It was awesome, but a bit too much death in some parts. I didn't like how Jagged Peak's energy was destroyed by Clear Sky. In the battle between the forest cats and the moor cats, I hated that some of my favorite cats died. And I uncovered a dark secret about Fourtrees. The cats buried them in middle of Fourtrees after Starclan cats appeared. But why, Erin Hunter, why did you kill Turtle Tail?!? Noooooo Turtle Tail! And Thunder Rising is awesome!