Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
Broadmoor Inmates: True Crime Tales of Life and Death in the Asylum
Broadmoor Inmates: True Crime Tales of Life and Death in the Asylum | Nicola Sly
1 post | 1 read
Broadmoor Inmates: True Crime Tales of Life and Death in the Asylum brings together the histories of people who died in Broadmoor Criminal Lunatic Asylum, each having committed a crime that led to them being pronounced criminally insane, necessitating their confinement and containment for their own protection, as well as that of the public. Nowadays, staff have a wide range of therapeutic tools at their disposal but historically the only treatment offered to patients was work, leisure activities and abundant fresh air. All human life is here - the addicts, the mentally deranged, the delusional, the tragic and the chronically and postnatally depressed - men and women whose acts of madness led them to be reviled and feared, but who were often as much victims of their own internal demons as were those they harmed.As well as wife murderers James Potter and Peter Whittle, the characters within include Henry Dommett, James Senior and Mary Ann Parr, who each killed their own children and Christiana Edmunds, who poisoned several people in Brighton to divert suspicion from herself, after attempting to murder her love rival. Other vignettes include serial arsonist John Green, counterfeiter Emma Jackson and James Stevenson and Roderick Edward McClean, both of whom took exception to the accession of Her Majesty Queen Victoria to the throne, the latter attempting to assassinate her. Daniel McNaughten became so paranoid about the 'Tory' spies that he believed followed him constantly that he killed a civil servant in 1843, mistakenly believing his victim to be prime minister Sir Robert Peel. Such was McNaughten's derangement that his crime spawned a new standard for the legal definition of insanity.Generously illustrated throughout, this book will prove of interest to those with a fascination for historical true crime and the way its perpetrators were dealt with by society.
Amazon Indiebound Barnes and Noble WorldCat Goodreads LibraryThing
review
OutsmartYourShelf
post image
Mehso-so

A history of some of the people who were sent to Broadmoor Criminal Lunatic Asylum (as it was then known) which opened in 1863. People who were tried for committing a crime but found unfit to plead or not responsible for their actions due to insanity under the Trial of Lunatics Act (1883), were sent to places such as Broadmoor - often for the rest of their natural life. Later residents included Peter Sutcliffe (the Yorkshire Ripper) & Ronnie Kray,

OutsmartYourShelf but this book concentrates on the early & less well-known cases.

Although the true crime stories were interesting, they did start to become a bit samey after a while. Many of the women incarcerated seemed to have been suffering some kind of postpartum issue, i.e. psychosis, & almost all of these men & women were incarcerated for many years. What really stood out was the absolute dearth of even rudimentary knowledge around mental health, even from
3w
OutsmartYourShelf doctors who were often reluctant to send their patients to an asylum resulting in tragic loss of life. I think the book may have worked better if it had included a more thorough history of Broadmoor (now psychiatric hospital) including photos of the plan of the site as it changed over the years, & maybe some idea of daily life within the asylum walls. 3.25⭐

My thanks to #NetGalley & publishers, Pen & Sword, for the opportunity to read an ARC.
3w
DieAReader 🎉🎉Onto the #next 3w
33 likes4 comments