Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
The Sentimentalists
The Sentimentalists: A Novel | Johanna Skibsrud
7 posts | 8 read | 6 to read
"A hypnotic meditation on memory . . . reaffirms the potential for storytelling to offer clarity and redemption." New York Times Book Review In this riveting debut, a daughter attempts to discover the truth about the life of her father, a dying Vietnam veteran haunted by his wartime experiences. Powerful and assured, The Sentimentalists is a story of what lies beneath the surface of everyday life.
Amazon Indiebound Barnes and Noble WorldCat Goodreads LibraryThing
Pick icon
100%
review
Singout
The Sentimentalists: A Novel | Johanna Skibsrud
Pickpick

Thanks to @Lindy for welcoming me to this buddy read!
Beautifully written, a winner of Canada‘s Giller prize, but also challenging in its intentional lack of clarity. The nature of truth and memory, voice and silence, and past and present are explored through a narrator‘s relationship with her father, a Vietnam War vet, and the father of her dad‘s killed war buddy, living together in her dad‘s last years near an underwater childhood home.

Lindy Sarah, I really appreciate the insights you shared when we were discussing this book. It was a pleasure buddy reading with you and I hope to do so again. 1y
Singout Likewise, @Lindy! 1y
14 likes2 comments
review
Lindy
The Sentimentalists: A Novel | Johanna Skibsrud
post image
Pickpick

“I don‘t believe in ghosts. I just think about them sometimes.” This is a haunting, lyrical, fragmented novel about history and how trauma affects subsequent generations. Napoleon is a veteran of the Vietnam war. In the final year of his life, his daughter seeks to know him better, and what happened when he was a soldier. There are no clear answers, but the emotional resonance rang through me like a bell. #CanadianAuthor

merelybookish I read this years ago. Wasn't it a surprise Giller or GG winner? 1y
Lindy @merelybookish Margot, you are correct! Giller Prize in 2010. Original edition was 2,500 copies done on a letterpress by Gaspereau Press. I believe one of the judges called it in, rather than having the publisher submit it. And when it won, it was hard to purchase a copy until Douglas & McIntyre gave Gaspereau a hand and published a regular trade paperback edition (which is what I read). 1y
Penny_LiteraryHoarders I read this when it won the Giller. Didn‘t like it too much, but I do have her book Quartet for the End of Time on my shelf. I wonder how I would feel about The Sentimentalists if I read it now? 🤔 1y
Lindy @Penny_LiteraryHoarders I saw your review on Goodreads and I wondered if you might view the book differently now. I am ready to pick up anything else Skibsrud has written. 1y
41 likes3 stack adds5 comments
quote
Lindy
The Sentimentalists: A Novel | Johanna Skibsrud
post image

So that even in those after-years, when my father had disappeared completely beyond the line of our horizon, it seemed as though, on fine days, I could see him still — a faint outline, a trace of himself — buoyed by the stubbornness of my memory, walking tentatively along the endless and otherwise uninhabited waters of my childhood.

quote
Lindy
The Sentimentalists: A Novel | Johanna Skibsrud
post image

At the end of the corridor was the room my father referred to as the “second library”—the “first” having reached its limit years before. My father was a great reader and a great rememberer of things, though he never remembered anything in the right order, or entirely, and always had just little bits of all the books and poems he‘d ever read floating around in his mind.

marleed Oh, that‘s what I‘m going to call the books I change out from month to month to celebrate the season and display on my front room shelves by color (i just changed out from New Year‘s black spines to Valentines red spines) - my secondary library! 1y
Lindy @marleed Perfect! Somehow giving the shelves a name elevates the importance of their content in our lives. 1y
marleed I agree! 1y
26 likes1 stack add3 comments
blurb
shawnmooney
The Sentimentalists: A Novel | Johanna Skibsrud
post image

This one won the Giller here in Canada in 2010, but the ratings here and on Goodreads are extremely mediocre. Anybody care to disagree?

TheCanuckReader I bought it when it won.... still haven't read it! Lemme know...lol 7y
ReadingEnvy Honestly I would be unlikely to pick up a book with that cover unless a reading friend swore up and down it was amazing. 7y
becausetrains @ReadingEnvy have you read any Tim O'Brien? Been a while, but his Vietnam... autobiographical fiction? is excellent. That said, I recommend Viet Thanh Nguyen even more. 7y
See All 6 Comments
ReadingEnvy @becausetrains I read and loved The Sympathizer, even went to a reading by the author and had my copy signed... I've never read O'Brien although I've certainly heard about him. 7y
becausetrains @ReadingEnvy we saw him just recently at our library (I feel like I told you that in another comment?) Haven't actually read The Sympathizer 😩 but I own it and think Nguyen is a brutally funny speaker soooo ima go pick it up right now. As for O'Brien, I have a soft spot for him because he grew up a few miles from my mom's town in MN. He epitomizes the small-town kid who saw too much, but chose art as a release instead of drugs or violence. (edited) 7y
ReadingEnvy @becausetrains we can spread the love to other posts haha. I do plan to read obrien someday. 7y
40 likes6 comments
review
mcctrish
The Sentimentalists: A Novel | Johanna Skibsrud
Mehso-so

Took me a while to finish this small quiet book. It reminds me of a book I read ages ago that I can't remember the title of. I did like the ending. The whole book inched sooooo slowly towards this one accounting of something that happened during the war. What is the truth? You can't handle the truth

blurb
mcctrish
The Sentimentalists: A Novel | Johanna Skibsrud
post image

Still working on my #novemberreads stack ( I got hijacked by the Gilmore girls revival)

10 likes1 stack add