Watson's Choice

It's been a while since I've done a #192025 update. These are the years I covered in the past couple of months. I've completed 65 of the 106 prompts so far.
@Librarybelle

Librarybelle Such great progress!! 13mo

35 likes1 comment

batsy

Watson's Choice | Gladys Mitchell

pick

This was my first Mrs. Bradley mystery, & I wasn't really expecting anything in particular so I liked it. Light, witty, & nothing to be taken seriously. It's best to simply surrender to the Sherlockian theme & try not to think too much about continuity or realism. I can imagine that these were written for holidays or train rides; nothing too taxing. Props to the "Hound of the Baskervilles" in this; can't go wrong with that! Lol #GoldenAgeCrimeClub

Bookwomble Sounds interesting, and chimes with my own reading today 😊 1y

sarahbarnes This sounds lovely actually. 1y

batsy @Bookwomble Nice! I had to read a Sherlock Holmes story today too after this book 😁 1y

batsy @sarahbarnes Perfect for a vacation read, I think! Or when your mind is on vacation mode 😆 1y

sarahbarnes Which is me a lot of the time. 😂 1y

80 likes5 comments

kwmg40

Watson's Choice | Gladys Mitchell

pick

The plot was so-so and the pace was quite slow, but overall, I enjoyed this mystery, the first I've read from this author. I liked the main characters and would be happy to read more in this series. I also enjoyed all the Sherlock Holmes references.

#goldenagecrimeclub @Mitch
#BookSpinBingo #DoubleSpin @TheAromaofBooks
#RushAthon @DieAReader @Andrew65 @GHABI4ROSES
#192025 #1955 @Librarybelle

Librarybelle I‘m really behind on this group. I have my copy ready to read - hope to get to it soon! 1y

DieAReader 🥳🥳👋🏻 1y

TheAromaofBooks Woohoo!!! 1y

kwmg40 @Librarybelle I really love the #goldenagecrimeclub and it's helped me fill in a number of slots in the #192025 challenge! 1y

kwmg40 @DieAReader @TheAromaofBooks Thanks for stopping by! 1y

35 likes1 stack add5 comments

quietjenn

Watson's Choice | Gladys Mitchell

Didn't read this #goldenagecrimeclub pick until today, so will be peeking late into the discussion. It was ... fine? I always want to like Mitchell's books/Mrs. Bradley more than I do, but I've read worse. Faint praise, perhaps, but there you go.

53 likes1 stack add

jlhammar

Watson's Choice | Gladys Mitchell

pick

Light and mostly amusing mystery. I enjoyed our sleuth, Mrs Bradley, and the Sherlock Holmes references. I did not appreciate the disparaging comments about redheads! Okay, now heading over to our #GoldenAgeCrimeClub discussion.

Mitch

67 likes

Mitch

Watson's Choice | Gladys Mitchell

Anything we‘ve not touched on you want to add….. are you off to seek out more Mrs Bradley or to watch the adaptations????

#goldenagecrimeclub

AmyG Not a fan. Ijust found this book to be a struggle to get through. 1y

lauraisntwilder I'd try another one, but I'm not in a hurry. 1y

Ruthiella Like @AmyG I‘m not going back for more , though I would definitely try the television adaptations. They might be more palatable. I‘m also not a huge fan of Sherlock Holmes either. 1y

See All 9 Comments

jlhammar I'd be interested in trying another sometime, see how it compares, but not in any rush to do so. My library has dvds of the complete series (BBC starring Diana Rigg) so might have to give those a watch at some point. 1y

kwmg40 I definitely want to read more in this series, as I liked the main characters, but with so many to choose from, I'll probably go with the ones rated/ranked higher at LibraryThing and other sites. 1y

quietjenn I just checked my Goodreads, and this is the 4th Mitchell I've read, all of which I've found pretty middling (or worse). I know she has enthusiastic fans, so have picked up a few others on Kindle when they've been on sale for like a dollar, so I may someday make it to some more, if only because I want to like them. 1y

quietjenn Also, I highly recommend the tv adaptations, all of which I've seen and loved! My understanding is that they are *very lose* adaptations and Diana Rigg's Mrs. Bradley is terrific - very proto-Phryne Fisher. In fact, I always think that the people behind Miss Fisher must have watched and loved them too. Maybe some of my dissatisfaction from the Mrs. Bradley books come from the fact that they aren't at all like the tv version. 1y

Ruthiella @quietjenn Ooh! Good to know the TV series is good! 1y

batsy I don't mind giving a few other Mrs. Bradley mysteries a try, but like others said, I'm in no rush! Glad to hear that the TV series is fun @quietjenn sadly I seem to have no way of accessing it here. 1y

39 likes9 comments

Mitch

Watson's Choice | Gladys Mitchell

Gladys Mitchell created a vast array of side characters in this one- any stand out favourites that you‘d love to go on more adventures with??
#goldenagecrimeclub

AmyG The “Hound of the Baskervilles”. 🤣 1y

Mitch @AmyG 🤣🤣🤣Yep the hound won the prize for me too! 1y

Ruthiella Yes, the dog was the most sympathetic character! 🤣 1y

See All 8 Comments

jlhammar Yes to the hound! Not the most likable bunch, but I found Laura somewhat endearing. 1y

kwmg40 Yes, I liked Laura and Gavin, and the hound, of course! 1y

quietjenn Agree about the Hound and I'm good with Laura and Gavin as well. And I liked the old friend on the farm and the boys when they were living there. That said, there were way too many characters for me, many of whom seemed unnecessary. 1y

batsy @AmyG Definitely! This book needed more "Hound" ?? 1y

Mitch @batsy That‘s the best one liner book review I‘ve ever read! 🤣🤣🤣🤣 1y

32 likes8 comments

Mitch

Watson's Choice | Gladys Mitchell

Our sleuth - Mrs Bradley - is no Miss Marple! From what I‘ve read she‘s a divisive character! How did you find our sleuth?
#goldenagecrimeclub

AmyG Of everyone, I liked her the most but that‘s not saying much. 1y

Mitch @AmyG That‘s a shame Amy - as there are literally 65 more Mrs Bradley books. Thought maybe we should read them for our 2024 Reading Goal 🤣🤣🤣 (edited) 1y

AmyG Ha…NO THANKS. 🤣 1y

See All 13 Comments

lauraisntwilder I thought she wasn't in it enough. She's figured it out, but then we go through the police investigation anyway. 1y

Mitch @lauraisntwilder This is the 28th of 65 books for Mrs Bradley. If I‘d of read the other 27 - I think I‘d of felt a bit peeved she didn‘t appear more! 1y

lauraisntwilder @Mitch Right?? lol 1y

Ruthiella I didn‘t really like her, though we‘re not really given much background on her. I thought it was weird how she was described as “grimacing” or “leering” instead of smiling. And at one point her hand was described as a claw. The author was certainly setting her apart, but why so grotesquely? 1y

jlhammar I quite liked Mrs Bradley - can't believe there are 66 in this series! I was looking at this Gladys Mitchell tribute site that ranks and reviews them all. Looks like Watson's Choice falls in the middle of the pack for most:
https://www.gladysmitchell.com/the-best-and-the-worst 1y

kwmg40 I liked Mrs. Bradley, but I I especially liked Laura and Gavin and hope they show up in other books in the series. 1y

quietjenn She wasn't much of a presence and she didn't seem very distinctive and interesting in this one. I also am super irked by characters (and books) where the sleuth knows the answer but refuses to reveal it because it can't yet be proven. I know that lots of others - including Christie! - do it as well, but in those cases, I like the detective enough to let it go. Not so with Mrs. Bradley. 1y

batsy I liked her, but she wasn't very much involved! This should have been called a Laura Menzies mystery. But yeah I enjoyed Laura and Gavin too (there should have been more of them interacting I think!) I'm still keen to read the early Mrs Bradley mysteries... I'm guessing somewhere around it being the 28th book Gladys Mitchell lost some steam 😆 I'm not sure how the later ones fare! Thanks for the link @jlhammar that will be useful. 1y

Mitch @jlhammar great resource - thanks for sharing. I might re evaluate my earlier opinion and try one near the top of that list 👍🏼 1y

Mitch My vote also goes to a Laura and Gavin series! 👏🏼👏🏼 1y

34 likes13 comments

Mitch

Watson's Choice | Gladys Mitchell

Did the mystery in this one satisfy you #goldenagecrimeclub readers??

AmyG Oh my, I don‘t have many good things to say. From the beginning zi kept thinking it would be Manoel…as I disliked him. I kept thinking he was out to get his Dad‘s money. The only character I liked was Mrs. Bradley. (edited) 1y

Mitch @AmyG im so sorry to have chosen this one! I was just very thankful it was short. I just didn‘t care what happened I was that not invested! 1y

AmyG Ha, I feel validated. I just said to my daughter how I didn‘t like this one and feel horrible as I have nothing nice to say. 🤣 1y

See All 9 Comments

lauraisntwilder I didn't care who did it, partly because the crime happens so far into the book. There were so many extraneous storylines! They didn't feel like red herrings though, just extra plot? 1y

kwmg40 @Mitch Don't apologize. I too found the plot somewhat tedious but I did like the book overall and am very happy to have discovered Gladys Mitchell. 1y

Ruthiella Not really. It was all too clever and the resolution and motivation came out of nowhere. None of the characters seemed like real people to me. They were too cartoonish. 1y

jlhammar I found the mystery itself somewhat lackluster. I think it could have been more exciting or maybe I was wanting more of a twist/reveal? I did really enjoy the chapter titles though paired with the epigraphs. 1y

quietjenn Not especially satisfying. I didn't particularly care and the resolution pretty ho-hum. 1y

batsy I agree that it wasn't a particularly satisfying ending, especially since the multiple characters and the subplots didn't factor too much into it in a good way. It was a bit of a damp squib of an ending. 1y

34 likes9 comments

Mitch

Watson's Choice | Gladys Mitchell

As with lots of #goldenagecrimefiction we need to wrestle with how to deal with reading work with historically acceptable ( be some!) but contemporary repugnant language and views. There‘s lots of ways to deal with this - and some interesting current debates around it. Any thoughts…….

AmyG I think it was just the times that the book was written. I am always taken aback, though. 1y

Mitch @AmyG it really jars on the page and floods me with disappointment an a level of guilt for ready and enjoying. I do appreciate the introductions to some of these reissued books that give context and opinion on these issues 1y

AmyG Yes, I appreciate that, too. But i am still amazed at the blatant racism of the “upper class”. 1y

See All 9 Comments

lauraisntwilder I got an old copy online, so no introduction. There was one line that literally made me say, "Whoah!" outloud. I think there's a truthfulness to the fact that the racist characters aren't seen as villains, as they would be in contemporary fiction. The fact that it was commonplace is part of what makes it so hard to read now. 1y

kwmg40 These aspects make me very uncomfortable too, but I accept them as commonplace for the times in which the books were written. What I find even more horrifying is rereading some of my Golden Age favourites and realizing that I myself didn't notice anything problematic when I'd first read the books decades ago! 1y

Ruthiella My book was a reprint from 1985 and had no introduction. I‘ve read a lot of Christie, however, and expect those attitudes when reading books like this. Still jarring-especially when the murder victim allegedly deserved their fate because their behavior was “immoral”. 🙄 1y

jlhammar Yeah, there were some real doozies in here! Can't escape without usual racism, classism, sexism, etc. I know to expect it, but still can't help but find it a little shocking that readers (& writers) at the time wouldn't have thought a thing of it. I think how the women were spoken about was particularly appalling. I mean, Linda Campbell didn't seem like a great person or anything, but the whole minx-who-had-it-coming thing was rather off-putting. 1y

quietjenn I pretty much go into these things kind of expecting that they'll be elements that I find jarring and objectionable, but were likely very realistic of their time. I think the most noteworthy things is just how common and casual it all was. 1y

batsy Agreed, so much of golden age detective fiction and even modernist literature are rife with these issues. Sometimes it's overt and sometimes it's more subtle. 1y

34 likes9 comments

Mitch

Watson's Choice | Gladys Mitchell

So my lovely #goldenagecrimeclub readers - let‘s jump straight in - did the plot live up to your expectations? How did you find the Sherlock Holmes elements of the story?

AmyG I found this part drawn out. I am not familiar with Holmes characters so was bored by that. 1y

Mitch @AmyG I only know a few really well and I always thought I was missing out on an injoke! 1y

lauraisntwilder I don't know Sherlock Holmes very well, but I didn't mind. I thought the dialogue was well written, and I was okay just going along for the ride, even if I was missing out on some references. 1y

See All 11 Comments

jlhammar I liked the Sherlock Holmes elements though I'm no expert so I'm sure I missed some! I was starting to find it all a bit tedious towards the end and was ready for things to wrap-up. 1y

kwmg40 I've read most of the Sherlock stories over my lifetime and watched many adaptations, but I still feel I would have done terribly at the competition! I found the plot rather slow-paced. 1y

Ruthiella I had no expectations, but the mystery itself was terribly convoluted. I also had to really hold myself back from reading ALL the Holmes stories first for context and background! 😂 (edited) 1y

quietjenn I liked the Holmes elements - only a few of which I “knew.“ I've read all of the stories but I'm not Sherlockian. It mostly made me want to revisit those stories though. 😏Beyond that, the actual plot was okay, but nothing great. 1y

batsy I liked the Sherlock elements but yes, I don't remember enough of the stories to get everything but was happy to just go along with it as @lauraisntwilder said. It was kind of silly and madcap and it suited my mood at the moment 😆 1y

Mitch @kwmg40 That competition was funny! It really helped me picture the rambling, old, grand mansion though 1y

Mitch @batsy getting the timing right for reading books, I‘m convinced, is the key to loving / hating books! 1y

Mitch @kwmg40 I thought it was slow too. Considering how slim a book it is I took me a while to get through it. 1y

32 likes11 comments

Mitch

Watson's Choice | Gladys Mitchell

Hey everyone - welcome to this months #goldenagecrimeclub buddy read. An potentially fun one this month that opens with guests receipt invitations to a country house party with a Sherlock Homes theme! Let‘s kick off with the usual - initial impressions, relationship with book / author, likes / dislikes!

AmyG I had a bit of trouble with this one. I was just basically bored. 1y

Mitch It‘s probably the ones I‘ve least enjoyed of what we‘ve read this year. I was really taken by the premise and loved the idea of a Sherlock Holmes party. But it never fulfilled on its promise for me! 1y

Mitch I was making my party costume in my head whilst reading chapter one ! 1y

See All 12 Comments

jlhammar This was a light pick for me. Happy to be introduced to Gladys Mitchell though. I had no idea she was so prolific! 1y

kwmg40 The mystery itself was just OK but I loved the characters and was very happy to be introduced to Gladys Mitchell's work. I'm planning to read more from this series. 1y

Ruthiella I wish my edition came with a cast of characters. I kept having to go back to previous pages to figure out who was who. I‘m also not that familiar with the Sherlock Holmes stories, so the party sounded like something I would definitely not enjoy. 😅 1y

quietjenn Definitely not the most compelling of mysteries. I agree that a) the premise is far better than the execution and b) a cast of characters would've been helpful! 1y

kspenmoll I am sorry I have not finished the book yet! Will join in when I finish. 1y

batsy I just finished! I agree with the rest about the execution and confusion of characters, but otherwise I quite liked it. It was also my intro to Mrs Bradley. Although this wasn't anything earth-shattering, it was light and pleasant and I enjoyed the "banter" lol. 1y

Mitch @batsy she was interesting wasn‘t she. I‘ve heard she‘s everything Miss Marple isn‘t! 1y

Mitch @Ruthiella a cast list would have been great - especially when people switch from real names to Nick names half way through! 1y

Mitch @kwmg40 @jlhammar She‘s written Sooooooo much! I can‘t imagine keeping a character going for 67 books! She‘s definitely a ‘Queen of Crime‘. 1y

31 likes12 comments

lauraisntwilder

Watson's Choice | Gladys Mitchell

pick

This was a quick read, with some really great dialogue. I read it for #GoldenAgeCrimeClub and I'm looking forward to everyone else's take on it. I really enjoyed it, but I actually didn't care who did it.

15 likes

kspenmoll

Watson's Choice | Gladys Mitchell

Just started this yesterday for the #goldenagecrimeclub
#buddyread @Mitch I am so enjoying your picks for us! Thank you for the work involved hosting!

Mitch You‘re most welcome. 1y

45 likes1 stack add1 comment

Mitch

Watson's Choice | Gladys Mitchell

Come join in the bookchat with the #goldenagecrimeclub. For August we‘re reading Watson‘s Choice which opens with a house party with everyone dressed as characters from Sherlock Holmes. Our detective - Mrs Bradley - is on the case when things go very wrong!
We‘ll be chatting on the last Sunday of August - 8/27

AmyG Thanks for leading this, Mitch! 1y

kspenmoll Thanks!!! 1y

59 likes2 comments

Welcome to Litsy!

Trending Hashtags

Trending Books