Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
#GillerLonglist
review
TheKidUpstairs
We Have Never Lived On Earth | Kasia Van Schaik
post image
Pickpick

A low pick. The things that didn't work for me were definitely a case of "blame the reader, not the book."

This is the story of Charlotte's life and her loneliness, at times melancholy, at others content. It travels through Canada, South Africa, and Europe. And it is told through interconnected short stories, most with a sense of almost cold realism, some with a beautiful surrealism.

Cont'd in comments

TheKidUpstairs I often have trouble connecting with short story-narrative, and I found my attention and interest waning. But Van Shaik's writing is wonderful, and some stories (especially the last two - the title story and 'An Ounce of Care') were fantastic. If you like short stories, especially interconnected stories, I'd definitely recommend this one from the #GillerLonglist. If it's not a style that works for you, I'm not sure it transcends the genre. 1y
49 likes1 comment
review
TheKidUpstairs
post image
Pickpick

A story of a Torontonian art professor, his life, love, and experiences in WW2. But also an examination of art itself, beauty, and colour. Brief vignettes hop between scenes from Henry's life, his memory palace, and non-fiction "diversions" that give added depth.

Unsurprisingly, this is beautifully written, impeccably crafted in Richardson's unique style (if you've never read his work, please treat yourself!).

Cont'd in comments...

TheKidUpstairs Absolutely adored it, love seeing him back on the #GillerLonglist 1y
58 likes1 comment
review
TheKidUpstairs
The Clarion | Nina Dunic
post image
Pickpick

So far, so great with this year's #GillerLonglist. After a few wild and crazy metafictional rides (Wait Softly Brother and The Double Life of Benson Yu), this one stands out for its quiet, contemplative style. In alternating chapters, we get a week in Peter's life and a few months in his sister Stasi's. Where Peter is content with a simple life, Stasi is ambitious.

Cont'd in comments

TheKidUpstairs In these glimpses into their lives, Dunic gives a beautifully crafted, engaging look at ideas of performance vs. connection, and the difference between solitude and loneliness. An impressive debut. 1y
BarbaraBB I‘m very intrigued by this Giller longlist, of which I hadn‘t heard until you mentioned it. You‘ve read some great ones so far! 1y
TheKidUpstairs @BarbaraBB I'm so impressed with the list so far. I've read 7 of 12, and I'd highly recommend 6 of those (Study for Obedience is on the list, it's the only one I haven't liked). It's a great variety of styles and stories, no to 1y
TheKidUpstairs @BarbaraBB sorry, that sent before I finished typing! That should say...no two books have been alike 😁 1y
BarbaraBB Wow. I am going to check them all out! 1y
60 likes5 comments