Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
The People Have Spoken (and They Are Wrong)
The People Have Spoken (and They Are Wrong): The Case Against Democracy | David Harsanyi
22 posts | 1 read | 1 to read
Democracy may be one of the most admired ideas ever concocted, but what if it’s also one of the most harebrained? After many years of writing about democracy for a living, David Harsanyi has concluded that it’s the most overrated, overused, and misunderstood idea in political life. The less we have of it the better. “Democracy” is not synonymous with “freedom.” It is not the opposite of tyranny. In fact, the Founding Fathers knew that democracy can lead to tyranny. That’s why they built so many safeguards against it into the Constitution. Democracy, Harsanyi argues, has made our government irrational, irresponsible, and invasive. It has left the American people with only two options—domination by the majority or a government that can’t possibly work. The modern age has imbued democracy with the mystique of infallibility. But Harsanyi reminds us that the vast majority of political philosophers, including the founders, have thought that responsible, limited government based on direct majority rule over a large, let alone continental scale was a practical impossibility. In The People Have Spoken, you’ll learn: Why the Framers of our Constitution were intent on establishing a republic, not a “democracy” How democracy undermines self-government How shockingly out of touch with reality most voters really are Why democracy is an economic wrecking ball—and an invitation to a politics of envy and corruption How the great political philosophers from Plato and Aristotle to Burke and Tocqueville predicted with uncanny accuracy that democracy could lead to tyranny Harsanyi warns that if we don’t recover the Founders’ republican vision, “democracy” might very well spell the end of American liberty and prosperity.
Amazon Indiebound Barnes and Noble WorldCat Goodreads LibraryThing
Pick icon
100%
review
keithmalek
post image
Pickpick

Readers who enjoyed this book might also enjoy David van Raybrouck's "Against Elections." And even though I enjoyed this book more, van Raybrouck offers solutions while Harsanyi does nothing but complain.

#2024Book13

quote
keithmalek
post image

Suet624 Hmmm.. I keep thinking about this statistic. If the stat stated 50% I might agree, but 70% seems awfully high. is this number verified by studies? 1mo
keithmalek @Suet624 He doesn't cite sources on that, but I just googled it, and according to Forbes, it's 68 percent. So yes, it's pretty much accurate. 1mo
3 likes2 comments
quote
keithmalek
post image

quote
keithmalek
post image

keithmalek @Suet624 If that last quote sounded familiar, so will this one. 1mo
Suet624 It‘s just astonishing how history repeats itself. 1mo
5 likes2 comments
quote
keithmalek
post image

Suet624 Ugh. Sounds so familiar. 1mo
4 likes1 comment
quote
keithmalek
post image

Bertrand Russell

quote
keithmalek
post image

quote
keithmalek
post image

Freedom vs License (continued)

quote
keithmalek
post image

Freedom vs License (part 1 of 2)

quote
keithmalek
post image

quote
keithmalek
post image

(Continued)...is, the person who uses them has his own private definition, but allows his hearer to think that he means something quite different.
-- George Orwell, "Politics And The English Language: An Essay" (1947)

quote
keithmalek
post image

Kenneth Minogue

quote
keithmalek

Individuals join crowds because of a vague understanding of the original idea. Crowds accept the superficiality of their ideas because it is a prerequisite to conforming, which, quite often, is their real goal.

quote
keithmalek
post image

--Gustave Le Bon, The Crowd: A Study of the Popular Mind

quote
keithmalek
post image

quote
keithmalek
post image

(Continued)...protects the free exercise of religion, we shouldn't be surprised by some of the bitter debates that Washington faces.

RebL I'm pretty sure that we do have the first amendment right to own and raise pets and drive them to school where they can learn that not everything has to be enumerated. 🙃 1mo
keithmalek @RebL 😅 1mo
4 likes2 comments
quote
keithmalek
post image

(Continued)...had declared independence from--6 percent thought we had revolted from various other nations, among them France, China, Japan, Mexico, or Spain.

quote
keithmalek
post image

quote
keithmalek
post image

(Continued)...true.

quote
keithmalek
post image

quote
keithmalek
post image

This has always been one of my all-time favorite quotations.

quote
keithmalek

The majority is never right. Never, I tell you! That's one of these lies in society that no free and intelligent man can ever help rebelling against. Who are the people that make up the biggest proportion of the population--the intelligent ones or the fools? I think we can agree it's the fools, no matter where you go in this world, it's the fools that form the overwhelming majority.

--Henrik Ibsen, An Enemy of the People