Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
The Colony of Lost Souls
The Colony of Lost Souls | Kelsey James
3 posts | 3 read | 1 reading | 1 to read
A young woman searching for her missing sister in 1930s California is drawn into a dark and dangerous cult in this intoxicating binge of sacrifice and obsession, strange rituals, alluring promises, and a beautiful prison for readers of Emma Clines The Girls, California Golden by Melanie Benjamin, and The Final Act of Juliette Willoughby by Ellery Lloyd. Born a year apart, May and June Anderson were once as close as twins. Time and a loveless marriage changed the once vibrant May into Junes timid counterpart. Now, two years after June abruptly disappeared, May receives a letter from her sister, inviting her to visit a mysterious colony in southern California. Eager to match Junes boldness for once, May doesnt hesitate. The Colony is located in a magnificent Spanish Revival-style mansion perched on a bluff overlooking the Pacific, and is presided over by the groups charismatic leader, Rex. Colony members believe in an afterlife where departed souls mingle, and that the truly enlightened can even summon back the spirits of lost loved ones. May is told that June has recently left on a mission, and shes intrigued enough to accept Rexs invitation to stay until her sisters return. Drawn deeper into the group, and under Rexs seductive spell, May undergoes their initiation ceremony. Yet her questions grow more urgent with Junes continued absenceand the warnings of a presumptuous but charming undercover investigator. May has longed for the daring, adventurous life her sister pursued, but her arrival has sparked a dangerous unraveling within the Colony, where nothing and no one is quite as it seems. Gripping and atmospheric, The Colony of Lost Souls immerses readers in a world of secrets, deception, and unexpected redemption.
LibraryThing
review
Librarybelle
post image
Mehso-so

Promising premise, but I think the audio made me less inclined to fully appreciate it.

May receives a letter from her missing sister June with a return address from the Kinima Theosophical Society. May rushes to the Society and becomes enamored with Rex, the leader of The Colony. What follows is a gothic-esque novel that takes May through the rituals of a cult as she tries to find out the whereabouts of her sister. Set in 1930s California. ⬇️⬇️⬇️

Librarybelle May‘s naivety and repetitive thoughts of helplessness made me want to roll my eyes. Sure, May is sheltered and has led a very careful life, but the reader can gather May is trying to find a solution. The voice actress for this reading also makes May sound a bit whiny at times, which I know helped me form this opinion. Rex is well-drawn multilayered character; the reader will loathe him by the end. The mansion and grounds are also well crafted, ⬇️ 2d
Librarybelle ⬆️ …making them a character in the book. Elements of the story felt rushed or a little hard to believe, and I‘m not talking about the supernatural bits. Lots of trigger warnings too (we are dealing with a cult, after all): miscarriage, stillbirth, sexual coercion, drugs, strangulation, child endangerment, animal cruelty…full list on the author‘s website. In the end, I think I would have preferred this in book form rather than audio. #NetGalley 2d
55 likes1 stack add2 comments
review
AmandaBlaze
post image
Pickpick

'The Colony of Lost Souls' is an interesting book that borders on Gothic. I think it fits the mystery/thriller category better. May receives a letter from her sister whom she thought might be dead. June asks her to visit her at the Kinima Theosophical Society. Once May arrives, she is told June is off on a secret mission. May decides to stay and wait for her sister's return. There are a lot of secrets an suspense within this novel. 4 stars

review
Reecaspieces
post image
Pickpick

💙📚BOOK REVIEW IS UP📚💙

⭐️⭐️THE COLONY OF LOST SOULS BY KELSEY JAMES⭐️⭐️

⭐️QUICK THOUGHTS⭐️

⭐️This story surprised me. Don‘t let this cover fool you!

⭐️fast paced, a little weird, and intense

https://reecaspieces.com/2025/06/26/the-colony-of-lost-souls-by-kelsey-james-boo...

Susanita It‘s a great cover in any case. 4d
Reecaspieces @Susanita true! 😂 3d
35 likes2 comments