Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
Fish Swimming in Dappled Sunlight
Fish Swimming in Dappled Sunlight | Riku Onda
3 posts | 5 read | 6 to read
From the author of The Aosawa Murders, one of the NYT Notable Books of 2020. The WSJ commented: "Part psychological thriller, part murder mystery--it is audacious in conception and brilliant in execution." The Globe and Mail said the book was "emerging as one of the most praised novels of the year." This gripping psychological thriller takes place in a desolate apartment in a Japanese city. The protagonists, Aki and Hiro, fell in love at university before becoming convinced that they were brother and sister, separated when young after Aki was adopted. After living together platonically for some years they went on a trek in the mountains, where their guide--their estranged natural father--died inexplicably. Each believes the other to be the murderer and are determined to extract a confession. The suspicion has destroyed their relationship and so they have decided to go their separate ways. But first, they feel compelled to discuss what happened that day. In the ensuing psychological battle of wills during their last night together, they retrace events and come to a stunning conclusion. The thriller--buried in a literary whodunit--explores the mysteries of romantic love, memory and attaining self-knowledge. Like the best Japanese crime writing it is an unflinching foray into the darker recesses of the soul, quietly suspenseful and elegantly constructed.
Amazon Indiebound Barnes and Noble WorldCat Goodreads LibraryThing
review
Robotswithpersonality
post image
Panpan

Okay, you're getting the whole review I already splashed out elsewhere because I don't know how else to summarize my issues: 1/?
I think many would consider this too slow and contemplative to be considered a thriller, but lamentably it was thriller enough to not work for me. There were elements I liked, the descriptions of nature, the mentions of hiking, the unraveling of interpersonal tension over meandering discussion of a single night.

Robotswithpersonality 2/?∆But it played well into tropes I consider classic for the thriller genre: 1. not a single likeable character to be seen - by which I mean instead of being complex humans with flaws, they seemed to only be a showcase of negative traits; 2. the twists just made everything messier and uglier.

1y
Robotswithpersonality 3/? ∆ I hope to investigate the mystery (which is what I thought this might be) genre more, and see if I can find a niche where I am intrigued to see secrets gradually uncovered that are not designed just to shock and appal or baffle, but also/rather to illuminate. I can appreciate what this author was trying to do, but it felt unfinished rather than purposely unsatisfying. 1y
Robotswithpersonality 4/5 There was a bizarre preponderance of vague references to other scenarios that acted as a mirror of these characters' current or recalled circumstances, as if the author knew what she wanted the focus of the conversation to be, but couldn't think up a real world example, or even one that felt fully contextualized within the story. 1y
Robotswithpersonality 5/5 Also, not thrilled with the gender binary stereotypes near the beginning: general reflections of 'women are this' 'men are this'. On a shallower note, always bummed out when a pretty cover opens to a disappointing book. 1y
5 likes4 comments
quote
Robotswithpersonality
post image

"...sun-stabbed..."
I like it. Violently poetic. ☀️?

1 like1 stack add
review
TamTracy
post image
Panpan

The first few chapters kept me interested and I was all in. It very quickly took some turns that just didn‘t make sense and I ended up just wanting it to be over. Now I‘m just confused. ⭐️⭐️