I'll be honest, I didn't care for the first one at all and didn't really remember it going into this one. But for some reason, this one really clicked with me. I was interested in the story the whole time and once it started getting toward the end I found myself unable to stop. I'm really interested in where this story is going next.

I got so impatient after the last volume ended basically in a cliffhanger that I went ahead and bought the next volume because I had to know what happened next. This one was just as cute as the first one. A lot of things were introduced in this volume, and hopefully, they will be touched upon more in later volumes. There were a few moments that made the pacing a little choppy, but nothing horrible.

This was a lot cuter than I expected. I started it right before bed and decided that I didn't need sleep, I needed to finish the whole volume. I am a little mad that I didn't wait to start this until the rest of the volumes were available at the library. Now I have to read the next part.

Henderson and Martha are such cuties. Their story really was the spotlight in this volume, and I really just want more of it. We also had some other great moments in this one. The snowed in mystery was so good. I wish it had been longer because I enjoyed it so much. It was a great volume, now I can't wait for the next one to come out.

Finished this in a day, I didn't want to stop it. I think Kasey Stockton has become one of my favorite authors, I've enjoyed every one of her books and this one was no different. It was so cute, but it did have some real moments that were really touching.

This was a cute one. I found myself invested in the storyline rather quickly. The grandma killed me, I love her so much. She might actually be the best part of the whole book. It was a fun story to mix up what I have been reading lately.

This was a nice conclusion to the series. It was wrapped up nice and neat. I did enjoy seeing some of the characters flashback. It added a lot to the story and I honestly would have loved some more of it.

This one was really good. Things really are building up and getting intense. This whole volume had a more serious tone to it that the first two volumes lacked. But it was done so well, we were given some backstory to help us understand some of the characters a bit better. The ending was a little bit of a cliffhanger, so I'm going to immediately start the next book, which is the conclusion.

I don't know why I read an autumn book in March, but I did. It was cute, had all of the fall vibes you would want. However, something was missing to make the book truly stand out. I would have loved a bit more romance to the story. The ending just didn't hit me as much as I would have liked. But, I did find the story enjoyable.

I feel like this one had a different vibe than the first volume. It was more relaxed, we got to see what this school is like a little bit. I still feel like there are a lot of unanswered questions, but we are starting to see some more about the characters. I really don't know where this story is going, but I like the world enough to stick around.

This was certainly something. There was some stuff about it I didn't like, but I found I did enjoy the overall premise of the story. I will probably read the next one to see if it gets any better.

I'd missed these characters. The last volume ended on a cliffhanger and we get to see how that all wrapped up. But after that it seemed like we got a lot of random stories that were fun, but didn't add much to the overall story plot. We did start to see some more character development though.

I was really enjoying the book, and then the ending kind of ruined it for me. Most of the book was spent building suspense, waiting for the killer to be revealed. There were a lot of little clues as to who it could be that kept you guessing. Then the ending happened, and a lot of stuff remained unanswered. Things just weren't wrapped up the way I would have liked. It could have been done so much better.

I started this book a long time ago and set it down without finishing it. I don't remember what was going on during that time to cause me to not finish it, but I don't think it had anything to do with the story itself. I decided to restart it today and can honestly say, I enjoyed every minute of it. I wish it had been longer, or even a second book following some of the characters.

I'm unsure about this one. It felt different from the other books in the series, but I don't know if that was a good thing or a bad thing. I do enjoy the fact that we are starting to see more development in the relationships.

Everything was wrapped up nice and neat. I enjoyed this last volume so much, and loved getting some updates on other characters we met throughout the series.

This was absolutely adorable. Usually, I find the twins separated at birth trope to be a little boring, but I was pleased with how this one was done. It is a cute middle grade story that explores both Hanukkah and Christmas.

I always enjoy a "Sarah's Scribbles" book. Of course, there were some I really enjoyed, others I didn't care for. I think this one was a little bit more personal to the author, which was nice to see.

Okay, I think I liked this one more than the first two. I'm still getting used to the series, but I like how this one ended.

This volume was so good. A lot of struggles are being wrapped up and these characters have grown so much. I also loved the little side stories checking in on some of the characters we had met previously.

I don't know how I feel about this volume. Not a lot happened in it, but it did show some of the struggles the characters have to face. It dealt honestly with a really emotional topic, which I appreciated. I just didn't feel very engaged with the story though.

Cute and short, but it had all the right Christmas vibes. The mystery was kind of boring, but it wasn't meant to be overly complex. The romance part of the series is feeling a little too drawn out, I wish something more would happen already.

Oh my gosh, this one hit me in my feels. I really felt like this volume had a lot of moments that have been building up from the very start. I honestly don't know where the series will be going from here, but I'm enjoying it.

This one was cute, but there were still some difficulties for the couple to work through.

Ah, this one might be my favorite so far. It was intense, dramatic, sweet, all mashed up together. Things are really starting to take a turn and get good.

That ending! The rest of the volume had some nice moments, we did experience some time jumps. Then the ending...it was a cliffhanger. I'm immediately going to start the next one.

Who gave this author permission to mess with my emotions like this? I'm frustrated with some of the decisions the characters are making, but I know things are going to eventually work out. I'm invested in all of their relationships.

This series plays with your heart. I want some of the conflict to be resolved, but it is getting more complicated as we go. It's still such a cute story though. I hope we start seeing certain things get resolved soon.

I was more invested in this volume. It brought up a lot of issues for the couple that I'm sure will be tackled in the next volumes. The ending was kind of a cliffhanger, but one that was expected.

I wanted to like this story, but it felt too sweet and perfect. It just didn't feel real or keep my attention. It also heavily built off of the first book of the series, so that one should definitely be read first. It wasn't a horrible story, but it could have been better. I probably won't even remember much about it in a day or two.

Things got a bit more serious in this volume than they were in the first one. There were some intense moments, especially toward the end.

This was cute, but very short. I liked the story, but it needed a few more scenes with the main characters together. I just felt like their romance was too instalovey. I also wanted just a touch more of a Christmas feel to the story.

The story felt a little bit scattered to me, it had quite a few time jumps in there that didn't have a smooth flow. But, overall, the story was really cute. I look forward to the rest of the series.

I really don't know how to feel about this series. It's kind of weird, but still entertaining. I'll continue with it and see how it goes from here.

The second one wasn't as good as the first one. I also didn't care for the art style this time around. The story is still interesting, but I was a little bored with it.

I really enjoyed this, so much so that I plan to read the novels it's adapted from. I had heard of them before now, but I never took the time to check them out. The graphic novel was done really well, I obviously don't know how it compares to the novel version, but the graphic novel had such a great flow to the story. I was drawn in almost immediately. It was incredibly well done.

This was cute, but it was lacking something to make it absolutely perfect for me. The problem is that I just don't know what that thing is. I liked that we got a lot of scenes that included family members. Maybe it could have used a few more scenes in the workplace, but I don't know if that would have made much difference.

One of my issues with novellas is that a lot of them seem to follow similar storylines. This one reminds me a lot of a different story I have read. It was basically a Hallmark movie, sweet and predictable.

I've always been interested in both of these writers and the way they worked together. Having a story like this truly made me happy and enjoyed every second of it. The story felt more like a discovery, it didn't shy away from teaching some things about stories in general, while still relating to the overall story of C. S. Lewis and J. R. R. Tolkien. It was beautifully done.

I loved this one. I've enjoyed all the books I've read in this series, but this one might be one of my favorites. I love when the story features an author or is about other books, and this one is. The couple just worked so well together. It was just so cute.

It was a little scattered, but I think that's because they were trying to shove a lot of story into the pages. It just didn't have as much development as it should have. However, it wasn't bad, I actually really enjoyed it. Now I need to read the novel it was based on to see if it has the development that I felt was missing here. I loved the art style, it was gorgeously done.

I don't remember what drew me to this book, I heard about it from somewhere and put it on a to read list, but didn't pick it up until recently. I was pleasantly surprised by it. It was well thought out and had a great story. I really can't wait for the next book to come out.

This was cute, but far too short. I would have loved for this to be slightly longer to give a little bit more development to the story. I also feel like some stuff wasn't wrapped up as neatly as I would have liked. But, other than that, it was a really good story.

I don't know if it was the book itself or the narrator, but my mind kept wandering. I liked the concept and was interested when I managed to pay attention, but I feel like I'm going to struggle to remember anything about the story. I do plan on reading the next book.

I loved the book, but the graphic novel adaption was tedious. Honestly, it took me a couple of days to get through it, which is sad considering it only should take at most an hour. However, I just was not enjoying it. The art style was terrible. To the point that I will take note of the artist and avoid them in the future. The storyline was basically the same as the book, but it just didn't translate well to a graphic novel.

It's sad to see this end, but I like the way it finished. We got a small peek at what the future holds for some of these characters. I'm not ready for it to be over. The series is just so cute. I loved every moment of it.

I don't know why I picked up this second book even though I didn't care for the first one. I think there is something wrong with me and that I'm the only one who doesn't love this series. This one may have been a bit better than the first one, but it still had incredibly cheesy moments that had me rolling my eyes. I still don't care for most of the characters, but now I feel like I have to find out what happens with them.

The conclusion of this series has left me kind of disappointed. Everything worked out the way I expected, hoped for even, but it wasn't done in a satisfying way. The ending is definitely more of a happy for now situation, of which I've never been a fan. I really feel like there should be more to the story, but there isn't.

Okay, so this was surprisingly very simple, but still really good. There was a lot of development about how certain people felt about each other, but nothing has been determined yet. I'm curious as to how this is all going to work out in the end.

I probably shouldn't have started this one until I had the next one, the last of the series, ready to go. And yet, I couldn't stop myself. I read this as quickly as I could and now I need volume 15. This one had all the feels, I loved every second of it. Most of it was intense, and I honestly don't know how the next volume will wrap everything up.