Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
Irish Travellers
Irish Travellers: The Unsettled Life | Sharon Bohn Gmelch, George Gmelch
8 posts | 1 read | 4 to read
"Anthrogologists George and Sharon Gmelch have lived among the itinerant people known as Travelers since their first fieldwork in the early 1970s. In 2011 they returned to seek out families they had knows decades before--shadowed by a film crew and taking with them hundreds of old photographs that they shared with Traveller friends and acquaintances. Many of those black-and-white photos are included in this book, alongside more recent photos and personal narratives that reveal how Travelers lives have changed and what it means to be a Traveler today"--
Amazon Indiebound Barnes and Noble WorldCat Goodreads LibraryThing
Pick icon
100%
review
Lindy
Irish Travellers: The Unsettled Life | Sharon Bohn Gmelch, George Gmelch
post image
Pickpick

Two American anthropologists lived with groups of Irish Travellers in the early 70s, and then revisited the same families 40 years later. Photos and interviews from both periods document a vastly different way of life for this once nomadic community. It‘s fascinating and insightful. Thank you to Donal Ryan and his novel All We Shall Know for leading me to research Travellers. #Ireland ☘️

GatheringBooks gorgeous photos! 6y
Lindy @GatheringBooks Yes, indeed. The photos from their original fieldwork were a great icebreaker when they returned later. 6y
52 likes1 stack add2 comments
quote
Lindy
Irish Travellers: The Unsettled Life | Sharon Bohn Gmelch, George Gmelch
post image

Travelling men old enough to have experienced a life on the road miss their horses, the frequent change & daily activities associated with nomadism, the camaraderie of roadside camps, the open air & the romanticized sense of personal freedom they once possessed. It is also difficult for men to find work. The unique trades they once performed are obsolete & significant barriers to mainstream employment exist. As a result, many feel redundant, 👇

Lindy [cont.] their despair contributing to a high rate of suicide. In other cultures as well, immobility has placed great strains on once nomadic peoples […] including the Canadian Inuit and Cree. 6y
39 likes1 comment
quote
Lindy
Irish Travellers: The Unsettled Life | Sharon Bohn Gmelch, George Gmelch
post image

“There‘s not a shadow of doubt in my mind that Travellers constitute a distinct ethnic group. Sure, there are some dissenting opinions from within the Traveller community. But these are people who don‘t understand the situation. They believe that the more you claim ethnicity, the more you diminish your Irishness. I say bullshit. They‘re not mutually exclusive. There‘s no conflict between nationality and ethnicity.”
-Martin Collins ☘️

quote
Lindy
Irish Travellers: The Unsettled Life | Sharon Bohn Gmelch, George Gmelch
post image

“The DNA on my father‘s line relates all the way back to Niall of the Nine Hostages, one of the first kings of Ireland. Traveller DNA is Irish DNA, and it hasn‘t changed a lot in a 1,000 years. So how can they argue that we are a separate ethnic group? The current Taoiseach [prime minister] Enda Kenny had his DNA done and his line is the same as mine.”
-Martin Ward

quote
Lindy
Irish Travellers: The Unsettled Life | Sharon Bohn Gmelch, George Gmelch
post image

“I might be minding my own business at home when, say, two Travellers would go up to town & get drunk & break something or start fighting. Well, I‘d be blamed just as if I‘d been there myself. But if two settled lads went up to town & caused the same trouble, nobody would blame all settled people. It was very discriminatory. People today are starting to understand that.”
-Martin Ward, born in a roadside camp, and Ireland‘s first Traveller mayor

Mdargusch Sounds so interesting 6y
LeahBergen Have you read this one? 👇🏻 I quite enjoyed it. 6y
LeahBergen The author is Romany from England, though. 6y
Lindy @LeahBergen Looks interesting, thanks. Until very recently, I wrongly thought that Irish Travellers were actually Romany people. 6y
LeahBergen I did, too! 6y
39 likes5 comments
quote
Lindy
Irish Travellers: The Unsettled Life | Sharon Bohn Gmelch, George Gmelch
post image

“I have always been interested in people‘s stories. I often find them intensely dramatic and moving. If anyone starts talking to me about their life, I‘m immediately all ears, I suppose like you anthropologists.” -Paddy Houlahan (above), who has been involved in community work with Travellers for decades. ☘️

[I was struck by this passage because I feel a similar interest in other people‘s lives.]

quote
Lindy
Irish Travellers: The Unsettled Life | Sharon Bohn Gmelch, George Gmelch
post image

Legislation passed in 2002 now makes it a criminal offence to camp on public or private land, punishable by a month in jail, a 3,000 euro fine & the confiscation of property. As a result, it is no longer possible for Travelling People living in Ireland to pursue a life “on the road.” ☘️

Captivatedbybooks Can an owner camp on it‘s own land or is that illegal too? 6y
Lindy @Captivatedbybooks I don‘t know, but I would guess owners can do as they like. 6y
41 likes2 comments
quote
Lindy
Irish Travellers: The Unsettled Life | Sharon Bohn Gmelch, George Gmelch
post image

Attitudes towards birth control have changed. While Lance had 29 pregnancies & 16 surviving children, & Josey had given birth 14 times & has 12 surviving children, Josey‘s daughters said they want no more than 5. Yet some resistance to birth control remains. A Travelling woman described her birth control use to me & whispered, ‘If my husband knew, it‘d be THWACK [punching her fist into the palm of her hand].‘

Reggie Yikes. 6y
Suet624 Oh those poor Irish women. 6y
Lindy @Reggie @Suet624 Indeed. ☹️ 6y
47 likes3 stack adds3 comments