Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
The Drama of the Gifted Child
The Drama of the Gifted Child: The Search for the True Self | Alice Miller
Why are many of the most successful people plagued by feelings of emptiness and alienation? This wise and profound book has provided thousands of readers with an answer?and has helped them to apply it
Amazon Indiebound Barnes and Noble WorldCat Goodreads LibraryThing
Pick icon
100%
review
Shae_Purcell
post image
Pickpick

As children, our survival depends upon the love or rejection of our parents. We protect ourselves by conforming, by being “good“. The only way to break the cycle is to acknowledge and feel what we've been through.

I could relate to this as I was reading it, but I can't say there was any good advice that might help a former “gifted child“ navigate their world later as an adult.

Full review here - https://www.goodreads.com/review/show/4082454621.

Smartypants Thanks for sharing, I was and my son was a gifted child, I‘ll definitely be looking to read this! 3y
Shae_Purcell @Smartypants I didn't have enough room to add it here, but she uses the term gifted child in a different way.

“When I used the word 'gifted' in the title, I had in mind neither children who receive high grades in school nor children talented in a special way. I simply meant all of us who have survived an abusive childhood thanks to an ability to adapt even to unspeakable cruelty by becoming numb... Without this 'gift' offered us by nature.“
3y
Smartypants @Shae_Purcell that is definitely a different way to use the word gifted. In that sense, I suppose I‘m lucky that my son and I are not gifted as she has described. 3y
See All 6 Comments
Shae_Purcell @Smartypants I was also part of a “gifted“ program in school, not helpful at all, which is why I was originally drawn to this book. I realized before purchasing that this was a different book altogether but decided to buy it anyway since it still felt relevant to me. If you do find any great books that address giftedness, specifically for adults, please share!

Side note: Check out #giftedkidburnout on TikTok if you want to feel validated, lol.
3y
Smartypants @Shae_Purcell I totally relate. Of the kids in my gifted program, only half have been exceptionally successful and unfortunately about 25% have struggled as adults in life. Two books I‘ve read have made it make sense to me, Drive by Daniel Pink and Mindset by Carol Dweck. Both excellent books on how motivation and mindset are key to success. 3y
Shae_Purcell @Smartypants I'll add those to my list, thank you! 3y
42 likes1 stack add6 comments
quote
Shae_Purcell

“I so desperately wanted to be loved --- and that meant, of course, to comply, to be obedient.“ - Vera, age fifty-two

It seems to me that if there were ever to be any form of unconditional love, that it should come from one's parents. Those evolutionary inclinations to see an offspring reach adulthood and all that. Though I suppose that doesn't really require love, does it? When it doesn't, sometimes it's safer to obey than to risk all you know.

quote
Shae_Purcell
post image

"He must excel brilliantly in everything he undertakes, which he is surely capable of doing (otherwise he just does not attempt it)."

Emphasis on the "otherwise he just does not attempt it." Anyone else have this problem? It's so hard for me to start new things, even hobbies, because I feel like I have to know it perfectly before I can even begin. But who can do something perfectly if they've never done it before? Makes no sense, yet here I am.

julesG 🙋🏻‍♀️Fortunately, I have enough life experience by now that I research intensively and then attempt the new thing. Instead of not doing it at all. 3y
Shae_Purcell @julesG I'm a big researcher too, but that's usually as far as it goes. I never can learn quite enough to gain the confidence I need to actually do the thing. It's something I'm working on. By reading and researching, of course. 😁 3y
28 likes2 comments
quote
Shae_Purcell
post image

"In what is described as depression and experienced as emptiness, futility, fear of impoverishment, and loneliness can usually be recognized as the tragic loss of the self in childhood, manifested as the total alienation from the self in adulthood."

quote
Shae_Purcell
post image

"The tragedy is that the parents too have no defense against it, as long as they refuse to face their own history. If the repression stays unresolved, the parents' childhood tragedy is unconsciously continued on in their children."

No parent is perfect, as much as we might expect them to be. They are people, after all. Flawed and human and children once themselves. Generational trauma claims more victims, and so we break the cycle or continue on.

quote
Shae_Purcell
post image

"At first it will be mortifying to see that she is not always good, understanding, tolerant, controlled, and, above all, without needs, for these have been the basis of her self-respect."

As an adult questioning much of my childhood, I find myself not mortified but shaken. I wouldn't say I prided myself on being this person, though maybe in some way I did, but I do believe this mindset formed the core of my identity. If I am not her, who am I?

quote
Shae_Purcell
post image

"Does this mean that it was not really me you loved, but only what I pretended to be? The well-behaved, reliable, empathic, understanding, and convenient child, who in fact was never a child at all?"

quote
Shae_Purcell
post image

" . . . as if the roots of a whole life were not hidden and entwined in its childhood." ?

blurb
Shae_Purcell
post image

I've been reading this very slowly over the past several days - I'm only on page 16 - but I'm finding myself underlining words on nearly every page. As the author explains, her idea of a gifted child isn't one who does well in school or has some special talent; instead, it's a child who has adapted in order to survive. I'm very interested in inner child work, trauma and its effect on the nervous system, and how trauma is stored in the body.

arkei Interesting perspective on “gifted“. Looking forward to your overall review later! 3y
ncsufoxes I‘m looking forward to see what your review is. My thesis is on adverse trauma & self regulating behaviors in preschool aged children. I have been reading a lot on attachment. So it‘s interesting to hear other perspectives 3y
Shae_Purcell @ncsufoxes Very interesting! I'm reading this solely for personal reasons, so I can't promise my review will be helpful or even interesting, but I'll certainly give a genuine and honest opinion. So far, I'm identifying with much of what the author has written. 3y
Shae_Purcell @arkei I thought so too! Not what I expected when I first saw the title. I was mostly drawn to the subtitle - The Search for the True Self - and read more about the author's meaning later. 3y
26 likes4 comments
blurb
Peaceful_Reader
post image

Reading this to see if I‘m inspired or a bad parent? #thesearchfortrueself

9 likes2 stack adds
quote
lonelybluenights
post image

The true opposite of depression is neither gaiety nor absence of pain, but vitality - the freedom to experience spontaneous feelings.

1 like1 stack add
blurb
lonelybluenights
post image

Started reading tonight, and already hooked. #readingatwork

review
volatilestatic
post image
Panpan

It took me an ungodly amount of time to slog my way through this, and it wasn't worth it at all. Way too psychoanalytic for my taste and sorely lacking in evidence beyond the anecdotal. It's not the 19th century anymore.

Peaceful_Reader I agree! I‘m having trouble getting to the middle of the book. 7y
2 likes1 comment
blurb
Bibliogeekery
post image

#bookshelftourism At peer supervision - I can't stop drooling over people's bookshelves!! These shelves are mostly filled with therapy books!

BookishFeminist 😍😍 8y
bookishkai Are you a psychologist? My boss is getting her PhD in psych and it seems like her supervision and clients and field placement are their own full time job, never mind class hours. 8y
Bibliogeekery @bookishkris I'm a psychotherapist. Supervision takes up a lot of my time too! At least there are good bookshelves! 😀 8y
zombie_kitty1987 I'm a social worker and my husband is a forensic psychologist. I'm we had to build so many shelves to for the clinical books, oh and ditto on feelings of supervision 🐺 8y
80 likes2 stack adds4 comments