Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
#watchmen
blurb
vivastory
post image

As the title says the events of this are a bit like origin stories for Nite Owl/Dr Manhattan. Nite Owl is a bit of a poor man's Batman. What is interesting in this volume is how he grows as a character with his interactions with Rorschach & others. The second half of this was absolutely fantastic, easily one of the best graphic novels I have read this year. Dealing with quantum realities, pocket universes, etc. There are times where you (CONT)

vivastory have to turn the book sideways/upside down (House of Leave style-minus the pages of footnotes). This was an immensely satisfying origin story on Dr. Manhattan. 7d
RamsFan1963 I've read the Before Watchman volume with The Comedian and Rorschach, I need to get around to reading the rest of them. 6d
vivastory @RamsFan1963 If you haven't read it, Tom King:s Rorschach is fantastic 5d
See All 6 Comments
RamsFan1963 @vivastory I've seen it at the library, but I haven't read it yet. Is it the original Rorschach or the replacement introduced in Doomsday Clock? 5d
vivastory @RamsFan1963 I haven't read Doomsday Clock but it's definitely not the original 5d
RamsFan1963 @vivastory I wouldn't waste my time on Doomsday Clock. It was a good idea, and could have been an interesting sequel to Watchmen, but DC blew it. There was big delays between issues, then events were happening in other DC comics that affected the plot of the miniseries. The only good thing about it was the artwork by Gary Frank. 5d
56 likes6 comments
review
WeAreLegion
post image
Pickpick

It‘s never easy to create a sequel (or in this case, ‘sidequel‘?) to a classic. Especially one as beloved and foundational as WATCHMEN. This is a really good attempt, recreating the framework, style and pacing of the original while telling a new story. Especially exciting is the merging of worlds seen here as the DCU encounters characters and events from Alan Moore‘s creation. Solid, even if it never reaches the highs of its predecessor.

blurb
JLaurenceCohen
post image

Got Absolute Watchmen on a whim from my library and the larger page scale makes such a difference. Gibbons' art absolutely soars from the bigger dimensions.

KathyWheeler I have the Absolute Sandman books and love them for that reason. I‘ve never seen the Absolute Watchmen before though. 2y
21 likes1 comment
review
JLaurenceCohen
Rorschach | Tom King
post image
Pickpick

This is a pretty intriguing political thriller that might honestly be better if it had no connection to Watchmen at all. It's very contemporary in its exploration of conspiracy thinking, even as it has a retro feel with landlines, tape recorders, and Columbo references.

Ruthiella I ❤️ Colombo! 🕵️‍♀️ “Just one more thing…” 2y
34 likes1 comment
blurb
JLaurenceCohen
Rorschach | Tom King
post image

Along with HBO's Watchmen and Doomsday Clock, Tom King's Rorschach is another entry in the genre of Watchmen sequel/spinoff. King uses the tropes of detective fiction to explore the nature of conspiracy thinking.

24 likes1 stack add
blurb
Skeebies05
post image

Bought this from Vintage Stock yesterday. Never read it. Just the movie (in which I hate most of the casting)

review
Nebklvr
post image
Panpan

A nihilistic plot, horrible characters, graphic violence, wavering timeline and misogyny. I would have bailed but I spent money on this.

Amiable I finally read this a few years ago at the urging of my husband and son. I totally agree with you. 😖 4y
Nebklvr @Amiable The only positive is it did capture the fear of nuclear catastrophe at the time. Any time women were in the scene....rage inducing. 4y
Amiable @Nebklvr I said the same thing to my husband and son while I was reading it— they didn‘t understand my disgust. 😖 4y
Nebklvr @Amiable Some colleges teach it so I hope they spend some time acknowledging it. 4y
28 likes4 comments
review
starlight97
V for Vendetta | Alan Moore
post image
Pickpick

#Watchmen was not bad either but I loved this one more. 🖤🎭
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

review
TieDyeDude
Doomsday Clock Part 1 | Geoff Johns
post image
Panpan

Ugh, what a slogging mess. Overly complicated and boring. I can't imagine reading the second half.

Bookwomble I'm sure Alan Moore was thrilled by this! 4y
RamsFan1963 Sadly, it just gets worse as it goes on. Gary Frank's artwork is outstanding but the story is a dumpster fire worthy of 2020. 4y
TieDyeDude @ramsfan1963 Yeah, I figured it wasn't much since I barely heard anyone talk about it. The art was excellent, though 4y
RamsFan1963 @TieDyeDude I expected better from Geoff John's, but from what I understand, there was quite a bit of interference from upper management. The whole idea of blending the Watchman universe with the mainline DC universe was just plain bad. 4y
TieDyeDude @RamsFan1963 The TV show was excellent, but even though capitalism won't allow it, they should leave it at one season and retire the Watchmen brand entirely. I don't see what they add to the DC universe... 4y
27 likes5 comments