Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
Celebrated Cases of Judge Dee
Celebrated Cases of Judge Dee: An Authentic Eighteenth-century Chinese Detective Novel | Robert Hans van Gulik
5 posts | 3 read | 3 to read
Tells of a celebrated seventh-century Chinese magistrate's investigation of a double murder among traveling merchants, the fatal poisoning of a bride on her wedding night, and a murder in a small town
Amazon Indiebound Barnes and Noble WorldCat Goodreads LibraryThing
Pick icon
100%
review
Bookwomble
post image
Pickpick

A fascinating glimpse into life in 7th century CE China, translated in the 1940s from a 19th century Chinese manuscript that appears to preserve a genuine account of investigations undertaken by the magistrate of a small city.
Judge Dee is insightful, ethically scrupulous and morally strict, slightly softened by compassion. However, in the context of his culture, the use of torture, graphically described, is a legitimate judicial tool. I found ⬇️

Bookwomble ... these sections uncomfortable reading, but I guess that readers who enjoy "torture porn" movies might get a kick from these sections.
The current Netflix series excludes torture, but includes a few fight scenes, which I had thought was pandering to the modern vogue for adding martial arts to spice up the action, and was pleasantly surprised to read a few examples of Judge Dee's lieutenants exhibiting their "Chinese boxing and wrestling".
⬇️
7mo
Bookwomble I really enjoyed this, and will continue with van Gulik's self-penned sequels. 4.5⭐ 7mo
The_Book_Ninja Add martial arts to The Great British Bake Off and they got a whole new demographic. Prue Leith using nunchucks on Paul Hollywood?…who doesn‘t wanna see that!? 🥷 7mo
Bookwomble @The_Book_Ninja Yeah, I'd like to see Prue knock Paul right on his soggy bottom! 🍰 7mo
41 likes1 stack add4 comments
quote
Bookwomble
post image

“They say that reading will attract the spirit of sleep. Let me read a while, perhaps this book will help me pass the time, or else bore me to such an extent that I shall fall asleep.”

quote
Bookwomble
post image

"In the end, as a general rule, no criminal escapes the laws of the land."

If only this were true!
Judge Dee has a number of legal recourses not available to the modern judiciary. Were he presiding over the trial of D. Trump, that fellow would certainly have had 100 stokes of the heavy bamboo for lack of respect, and probably the thumb screws for lying!
#FirstLineFridays @ShyBookOwl

Ruthiella From Judge Dread to Judge Dee! 😃 7mo
Bookwomble @Ruthiella Ha! Yes! 😄 I suspect each would approve of the other. 7mo
The_Book_Ninja I fear the great orange demon is made of Teflon 7mo
Bookwomble @The_Book_Ninja He's certainly a slippery customer! 7mo
39 likes1 stack add4 comments
blurb
Bookwomble
post image

Is one book a #BookHaul ? ?

I've been really enjoying the Netflix series "Judge Dee's Mystery" and decided to get the source material.

Judge Dee was a Tang Dynasty magistrate, three of whose historical cases are translated here, the success of which led van Gulik to write his own stories in a continuing series.

In his introduction, van Gulik comments on the centuries old Chinese tradition of detective novels, considerably predating ⬇️

Bookwomble ... Poe and Doyle in the West.

The looming plate in the foreground is my lunch of garlic mushrooms on toast, washed down with dandelion and burdock, finished off with a cappuccino 😋
7mo
TieDyeDude I love the Judge Dee series by Lavie Tidhar about a vampire judge, but I always see this come up in results when I search. I've been interested in checking out his stories. I hadn't heard of the Netflix series.
Dandelion and burdock sounds good! I've never heard of it.
7mo
Bookwomble @TieDyeDude The series is good - it's a Chinese production, so it feels authentic, as far as I can tell. As well as the detection aspect, it has some good fight choreography, decent SFX, and interesting supporting characters. I've only read the books introduction, but that in itself is really interesting. I don't think I'm going to keep my intention of finishing another book before starting this one! 😄 7mo
See All 6 Comments
Bookwomble @TieDyeDude D&B is a traditionally Northern drink, fairly unknown in southern England (when I lived there it was like finding hens' teeth coming across a can!). The nearest I can describe it in North American terms would be similar to root beer or sarsaparilla. 7mo
rwmg I've got van Gulik's Judge Dee on my wishlist. Maybe next month. I didn't know about the Netflix series. 7mo
Bookwomble @rwmg I'm enjoying the book so far. The TV show is probably best described as "inspired by" the book, but I'm loving it on its own terms ? 7mo
38 likes6 comments
blurb
erzascarletbookgasm
post image

Robert Hans van Gulik was a diplomat & writer, best known for the Judge Dee historical mysteries. He first translated the 18th-century detective novel ‘Dee Goong An‘ into English under the tagged title. The main character, Judge Dee, was based on a real statesman & detective who lived in the 7th century, during the Tang Dynasty.
I have read a few of the books & enjoyed them. Sadly, he & the books are not so well known & #underrated.
#newyearreads

Ole Looks interesting. I found several translated to Danish available as ebooks. Will try them. Thanks for sharing 😊 7y
Alwaysbeenaloverofbooks Looks interesting to me too!!! 7y
72 likes1 stack add3 comments