Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
The Jewish Problem
The Jewish Problem | Louis Golding
7 posts | 1 read | 3 to read
LibraryThing
Pick icon
100%
review
Bookwomble
The Jewish Problem | Louis Golding
post image
Pickpick

This had an enlightening summary of anti-Semitism in Europe up to the mid-20th century, followed by a sociopolitical analysis of the then contemporary (1938) position of Jews globally, increasingly overshadowed by Naziism and the far right, a sadly over-optimistic section on the possibility of peaceful coexistence of Jews and "Arabs" in Palestine, and a sadly prescient warning of what might be in the immediate future if Hitler remained in power.⬇️

Bookwomble And, very, very sadly, so many current parallels not only with what is happening in Israel/Palestine, but also with the global rise of the far right, authoritarianism, persecution of refugees and immigrants, racist rhetoric, and general shitness.
Golding comes across as a thoughtful, balanced, and compassionate human being. 4.5 ✡️
5mo
TrishB I totally agree with the review of general shitness…..can the news get any worse? (Not a challenge!) 5mo
AlaMich @TrishB It always seems to. 5mo
See All 8 Comments
Bookwomble @TrishB Yeah, don't give it ideas! 😳 5mo
bibliothecarivs I love Penguins. Is that a reprint? Incredible condition for being 85 years old. 5mo
Bookwomble @bibliothecarivs It is a remarkably preserved first edition ☺️ 5mo
batsy Sounds like something I should read. (The news gets worse and worse.) 5mo
Bookwomble @batsy I found it very interesting, and it definitely cast some light for me on the roots of the current situation. I'd recommend it 🙂 I recently heard an historian asked about the seeming avalanche of awful world events say that we should remember the news is a selectively curated presentation of the worst bits of randomly occurring historical events, and that much good remains unreported. 5mo
33 likes1 stack add8 comments
quote
Bookwomble
The Jewish Problem | Louis Golding
post image

"The addition to any country of a body of young, strong, active and industrious immigrants with the probability of a long life before them (as the [Jewish] refugees from Germany and Austria in the main are) is clearly an asset, particularly to a land which, like England, is faced with an imminent fall in population. As workers and consumers, moreover, they must add to its economic activity, rather than compete (as is generally imagined) in... ⬇️

Bookwomble ...the labour market. Moreover, this class would constitute an addition of the most valuable age-groups, whose adolescence and education would have cost the receiving country nothing."
- Written 1938. Also in this chapter, the Nazi policy of expelling Jews without any means of subsistence to destabilise neighbouring countries, like Putin's Russia, & the French & USA proposals to deport refugees to Madagascar & Cuba, like Sunak's UK Rwanda policy.
5mo
26 likes1 comment
quote
Bookwomble
The Jewish Problem | Louis Golding
post image

"In the long run, persecution must harm its perpetrators more than it does its victims."

I'm really feeling Golding's compassion & humanity in his examination of anti-Semitism and fascism. I'm up to the section in which, having summarised the history of European anti-Semitism, Golding has turned to the burning issue of '38 Nazi Germany. Interesting to see his use of "Holocaust" to describe the wave of Jewish suicides caused by pre-War oppression.

batsy That quote is applicable for how things are playing out in the present, as well. Seems to be an unending cycle. Dark times. 6mo
Bookwomble @batsy So much of this book reflects on current effects that it's scary, and upsetting to think that so few lessons have been learned and that the killing goes on. 6mo
32 likes2 comments
quote
Bookwomble
The Jewish Problem | Louis Golding
post image

"In entitling the first chapter of this book "The Gentile Problem," let me state at once that in my view this would have been a more accurate title for the whole book than the one it bears."

#FirstLineFridays @ShyBookOwl

quote
Bookwomble
The Jewish Problem | Louis Golding
post image

"Poor immigrants, be they eighteenth-century Huguenots or nineteenth-century Irish, are always accused of overcrowding, disease-breeding, and competing against the native-born workman in the labour-market; and, of course, this was the case at the time of the Jewish influx in the early years of the twentieth century."

And, in the early twenty-first century...

Bookwomble #BooksAndMusic "I Pity the Poor Immigrant" by Bob Dylan from his 1967 album, "John Wesley Harding" https://youtu.be/0RJ_HsMfBfE?si=7aPvTf-L1zqZopxe 6mo
24 likes1 comment
blurb
Bookwomble
The Jewish Problem | Louis Golding
post image

Ok, I'm five pages in and Golding has introduced ideas currently criticized by the right-wing as being modern "Wokerati" concepts:
- It's not the responsibility of oppressed people to stop oppression; oppressors must take responsibility for that;
- Intersectionality (he doesn't use the word) makes oppression worse;
- Ethnic minorities (he uses the term) exist, but the term "race" has a "non-existent scientific authenticity" (direct quote).
⬇️

Bookwomble I think this is important as it gives the lie to conservative revisionist views that "well, people back then didn't know/understand so you can't judge them by modern standards", and "concepts of multiculturalism, and equality and oppression are recent, faddish ideas with no tradition or historical foundations".
I will try not to quote-spam!
6mo
Dilara @Bookwomble This is one of my pet peeves! Please quote-spam! 😁 6mo
TrishB I‘ve read a lot of stuff on Sylvia Pankhurst- she‘s obvs known for her feminist views- but she fought for all equalities and this was in the 1920s. She fought for ethnic minority groups of workers in the east end docks. So it‘s not new. 6mo
See All 6 Comments
Bookwomble @TrishB Exactly, Trish! It's utter bollocks that human rights and the struggle for emancipation is some "new-fangled, metropolitan elite, liberal lefty" agenda. 6mo
Bookwomble @Dilara Ha, ha! Well, on the other hand I'm unlikely to be silent, to be honest 😄 6mo
bibliothecarivs Go, Bookwomble, go! 6mo
33 likes6 comments
blurb
Bookwomble
The Jewish Problem | Louis Golding
post image

It seems a sadly opportune time to read this book I bought in January. As I did then I'll clarify that Golding was a British Jew writing in '38 to highlight the history of European anti-Semitism that was being murderously re-enacted by Hitler's nazi state.
"The Problem" of the title is an inversion of the racist ideology that led to the fascist Final Solution (still in Golding's future), Golding stating it as the problem Jews have with persecution

julesG I remember reading excerpts of this book for a university class. 6mo
Bookwomble @julesG That's interesting that it was relevant text after so many years - at least I assume that was the case. 6mo
tpixie Interesting that he was writing this in real time, surrounding the lead up to WWII. I bet it‘s a profound read. 6mo
See All 8 Comments
Bookwomble @tpixie I've only read five pages and Golding is already blowing my mind! 🤯 6mo
julesG Yes, my professor used excerpts as introduction to some topics that we then did a deep dive into. Meaning we then looked at relevant sources if they were available. It was definitely interesting and I honestly learned a lot about antisemitism and research methods. 6mo
tpixie @julesG what a great professor and experience! 6mo
tpixie @Bookwomble 🩷🇮🇱🩷 (edited) 6mo
Bookwomble @julesG It sounds like it was a fascinating course ☺️ 6mo
35 likes2 stack adds8 comments