Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
Who Gets In and Why
Who Gets In and Why: A Year Inside College Admissions | Jeffrey Selingo
1 post | 3 read | 3 to read
From award-winning higher education journalist and New York Times bestselling author Jeffrey Selingo comes a revealing look from inside the admissions officeone that identifies surprising strategies that will aid in the college search. Getting into a top-ranked college has never seemed more impossible, with acceptance rates at some elite universities dipping into the single digits. In Who Gets In and Why, journalist and higher education expert Jeffrey Selingo dispels entrenched notions of how to compete and win at the admissions game, and reveals that teenagers and parents have much to gain by broadening their notion of what qualifies as a good college. Hint: its not all about the sticker on the car window. Selingo, who was embedded in three different admissions officesa selective private university, a leading liberal arts college, and a flagship public campusclosely observed gatekeepers as they made their often agonizing and sometimes life-changing decisions. He also followed select students and their parents, and he traveled around the country meeting with high school counselors, marketers, behind-the-scenes consultants, and college rankers. While many have long believed that admissions is merit-based, rewarding the best students, Who Gets In and Why presents a more complicated truth, showing that who gets in is frequently more about the colleges agenda than the applicant. In a world where thousands of equally qualified students vie for a fixed number of spots at elite institutions, admissions officers often make split-second decisions based on a variety of factorslike diversity, money, and, ultimately, whether a student will enroll if accepted. One of the most insightful books ever about getting in and what higher education has become, Who Gets In and Why not only provides an usually intimate look at how admissions decisions get made, but guides prospective students on how to honestly assess their strengths and match with the schools that will best serve their interests.
Amazon Indiebound Barnes and Noble WorldCat Goodreads LibraryThing
Pick icon
100%
review
Megabooks
post image
Pickpick

I‘ve found the process of admissions fascinating ever since I met the admissions counselor that advocated for my admission to Duke. It was interesting to see inside the decisions from the perspective of the admissions committees at Emory, Davidson, and UWash (Seattle), but he also followed three students at very different high schools. He looked at how colleges market to teens and their parents, selectivity/rankings, and aid packages, too. ⬇️

Megabooks ⬆️ This book is written for parents who went to college in the 90s who are sending their kids to college now. I know that‘s a lot of Littens. What he reveals about what is important (senior grades/difficult classes) and what is not usually important (the essay) is really interesting! (edited) 4y
BarbaraBB Super interesting although it is completely different from the situation here. 4y
Megabooks @BarbaraBB I would totally read a book comparing university admissions around the world!! 🤓 4y
See All 24 Comments
MrT You‘ve seen the Netflix doc? Interesting. 4y
Cinfhen This was SUCH a stressful process that im not sure I‘m ready to re-visit it yet although I‘m fascinated by the insider‘s info. 4y
Megabooks @MrT no, I haven‘t. Which Netflix doc? Netflix crashes my tv, so I rarely use it. 4y
MrT Operation varsity blues: the college admissions scandal 4y
TrishB Completely different here too. 4y
Megabooks @MrT oh yeah, I read this book on it. I‘m generally more down for a 10 hour audiobook than a 2 hour documentary. Idk why. 4y
Megabooks @MrT however the book I just reviewed talks a bit about how athletics plays in, esp at D3 schools, but it‘s not focused on that nor the scandal. 4y
Megabooks @TrishB yes! If anyone ever finds a college admissions around the world book, I am so down! 4y
ImperfectCJ Based on your description, this one might be even more relevant to my family's current situation than the other one of his you reviewed more recently. Our situation as homeschoolers is a little different than the norm, but anything that can decode college admissions even a little would be welcome right now. 4y
Megabooks @ImperfectCJ yes, I think this would probably be the more relevant one. The only thing that would be nice in Unbound is that he gives a long list of colleges with innovative programs, why they‘re innovative, and who it might be right for. Overall in 10th grade, as far as admissions prep, I‘d recommend you read Who Gets in and Why. 4y
ImperfectCJ @Megabooks Thank you for the personalized review! ;-) I have this one on hold at the library now and will see about getting Unbound after. 4y
Megabooks @ImperfectCJ I‘m glad I could help!! The other thing both books do well is talk about the elephant in the room of paying for college and what to look for when comparing aid packages. It‘s not comprehensive about that, but you‘ll probably find that part of this book helpful too. 4y
ImperfectCJ @Megabooks That is very likely to be helpful information for us! Did you happen to see this piece in The Atlantic about (among other things) prep schools as funnels to some of the elite universities? I found it very interesting and since you're into higher ed, thought you might, too: https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2019/09/meritocracys-miserable-winn... 4y
Megabooks @ImperfectCJ I‘m going to read this more carefully after dinner, but I‘ve read a number of similar articles over the past several years. New Trier HS, which is a top performing north of Chicago on Lake Michigan public school, was found to have a direct feeder program to my college (Duke). I had two friends that went there. My BFF from college went to a private school in Dallas with a class size of about 50, and she was one of 8 to attend ⬇️ 4y
Megabooks @ImperfectCJ Duke just in her little class of 50. The author of this book talks about the relationships that top schools develop with prep, private and top performing public schools, which can be a mixed blessing from the students applying from those high schools. I think you‘ll find this book really interesting! 4y
ImperfectCJ @Megabooks I wondered about Duke undergrads. My spouse went to grad school there, and the undergrads seemed like an odd mix of privilege and activism. I could never quite figure them out. But I didn't have many interactions with them, either. My public high school in Virginia sent a lot of students to Virginia Tech, but I don't think that's quite the same thing. 4y
Megabooks @ImperfectCJ I‘d say that‘s pretty true. I worked at the student newspaper as my main activity, and we were pretty much a mix of that as well. Most of us were pretty upper middle class, but I did have a couple of super wealthy friends (e.g. an heir to the Iams dog food fortune, son of the British ambassador to Japan), but in the late 90s, it was still possible for upper middle class people to go with minimal assistance. 🤷🏻‍♀️ 4y
Centique Man I‘m glad I never faced the stress of this - it sounds like one heck of a process. We have just a few universities - almost all government owned and you just have to have good enough grades for entry to the course/school. So medicine is hard to get into but it‘s only based on exam scores. My kiwi friend in California is looking to send his daughter bk here for uni, the money he will save! It‘s so expensive isn‘t it? 4y
Megabooks @Centique very expensive!! Tuition was $32,000 a semester when I went over 20 years ago. Now it is $60,000 per semester. Just crazy!! 4y
Centique @Megabooks this will make your jaw drop. It costs between $6 - $10,000 a year here - and they just brought in a programme to make your first year free. 🤯 4y
Megabooks @Centique wow!! 🤯 4y
94 likes1 stack add24 comments