Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
We Had To Remove This Post
We Had To Remove This Post | Hanna Bervoets
'[A] superbly poised, psychologically astute and subtle novel of mental unravelling.' Ian McEwan, author of Atonement 'Fast paced and thrilling, violent and nightmarish and grief-stricken, but also tender and wildly moving.' Kristen Arnett, author of Mostly Dead Things 'This novel gives us an acid glimpse into a new form of labor existing today . . . Fascinating and disturbing.' Ling Ma, author of Severance To be a content moderator is to see humanity at its worst but Kayleigh needs money. Thats why she takes a job working for a social media platform whose name she isnt allowed to mention. Her job: reviewing offensive videos and pictures, rants and conspiracy theories, and deciding which need to be removed. Its gruelling work. Kayleigh and her colleagues spend all day watching horrors and hate on their screens, evaluating them with the platforms ever-changing moderating guidelines. Yet Kayleigh is good at her job, and in her colleagues she finds a group of friends, even a new girlfriend and for the first time in her life, Kayleighs future seems bright. But soon the job seems to change them all, shifting their worlds in alarming ways. How long before the moderators own morals bend and flex under the weight of what they see? We Had To Remove This Post by Hanna Bervoets is a chilling, powerful and gripping story about who or what determines our world view. Examining the toxic world of content moderation, the novel forces us to ask: what is right? What is real? What is normal? And who gets to decide? Translated by Emma Rault.
Amazon Indiebound Barnes and Noble WorldCat Goodreads LibraryThing
Pick icon
100%
review
Gleefulreader
post image
Pickpick

A rather bleak novella about a group of people working at a firm where they moderate online content for a significant, unnamed client. In only a handful of pages, it demonstrates the bureaucratic, corporate-speak nonsense the determines what remains online and what goes. It also shows, rather than tells, in incredibly detrimental nature of such work, and its impact and insidious effect on those who work in the industry. Depressing but important.

review
rachelsbrittain
post image
Pickpick

This is a tough little novella to get through because it follows the dire reality of content moderators who sort through the worst of the worst of online content for work. Kayleigh's devolving relationship with her girlfriend and coworker, Sigrid, paints a picture of how the employees mental health is upended by their job. Lots of TWs but the topics are rarely explored in more than passing detail.

review
Itchyfeetreader
post image
Pickpick

This was short and quite difficult - it explores the impact of content moderation on a meta style tech giant. It‘s a novella with an abrupt ending but in it builds a sense of dread as folks react in different ways to what they see - from numbness to believing. Great example of an unreliable narrator

53 likes1 stack add
review
Rachiiebookdragon
Mehso-so

This is an odd one that didn‘t really go anywhere…

Read for reading prompts

3.75/5

Library book 📖

review
starlight97
post image
Pickpick

Kayleigh works at a social media platform as a moderator, reviewing uploaded content and deciding what can stay up and what has to be removed – she watches hundreds of videos depicting violence, child abuse, animal abuse, self harm and acts of terrorism every day. It's an interesting premise and I really liked the way this book was written, but it ended so abruptly and without any real closure. 😔
⭐⭐⭐⭐☆
#dutch #dutchauthor 🇳🇱

dabbe Hello there, sweet kitty! 🖤🐾 11mo
26 likes1 comment
review
JennO1
post image
Pickpick

Grabbed this novella today without knowing much about it. Upon finish I was surprised by the extremes of opinions. If you‘re looking for gore, you won‘t find it, although there isn‘t a lack of disturbing events, they just aren‘t the focus. Instead this is a slow psychological exploration of how internet trauma can warp good people. Or, maybe they weren‘t really such good to begin with. Some say the ending is abrupt, I felt it was an epiphany.

blurb
ju.ca.no
post image

Just finished this audiobook, but it wasn‘t really what I expected and I‘m glad I didn‘t buy the book. I thought it was about MORE. I expected it to be deeper. But it wasn‘t. The idea was interesting but the story ended up being mainly about one side of a probably toxic relationship. Also the ending was super random I felt.
2/5⭐️

51 likes3 stack adds
review
BookishTrish
post image
Pickpick

Definitely a disturbing novella about a fascinating, dark topic. Didn‘t ‘get‘ the ending so it felt abrupt, but will be thinking about it for days.

Reggie Love the pic! 2y
IndianBookworm How creepily cute!😍 2y
59 likes1 stack add2 comments
review
Addison_Reads
post image
Mehso-so

I may have rated this a so-so, but it's a quick read I'd still suggest reading.

This book does a great job of bringing up the darker side of society's social media consumption. For me, I was more disturbed at how the book points out how quickly we "normalize" occurrences due to our constant exposure through social media.

Although overall it didn't work for me, it still has left me thinking about it weeks after finishing it.

review
Robotswithpersonality
post image
Mehso-so

That was nauseatingly uncomfortable on purpose. I think I would recommend reading the non-fiction articles cited at the end, over this book and its unreliable and progressively more traumatized and traumatizing characters, if you want to investigate what being a content moderator on the internet does to a human. Excuse me while I go find something fluffy with pretty pictures.

Dilara “Nauseatingly uncomfortable“? I'll just focus on the Tunisian crochet pieces... (very nice!) 2y
Robotswithpersonality @Dilara Thanks! I'm still a beginner at crochet, but I love experimenting with new stitches and new colour combos. ☺️ 2y
4 likes2 comments
review
TheEllieMo
post image
Mehso-so

This one has an interesting premise but missed the mark for me. My main takeaway was it might explain why moderation on some social media sites is so lacking.

ju.ca.no I just finished it and had the same thought 100% 2y
20 likes1 comment
review
psalva
post image
Pickpick

This was brutal. It was, to me, a study in the extremes of PTSD from work environments. It was twisted, dark, and haunting, but grounded in the reality of social media moderators. Trigger warnings for just about everything. The writing was intense but this was a page turner, so I will be looking for the author‘s other work to be translated into English.

12 likes1 stack add
review
keithmalek
post image
Panpan

I've never read a novel that fell so far short of its description. The only "good" thing about this book is that it doesn't take long to read.

Terrible.

Suet624 Hmmm… I was just about to start this book but your review and others have helped me to decide to just return it to the library. 2y
keithmalek @Suet624 That's a wise decision. 2y
7 likes2 comments
blurb
psalva
post image

This is my library haul for today. I was also hoping to get my hands on the new Thursday Murder Club book, but I need to put a hold as it was checked out already. I‘ll be watching 42nd Street this evening and enjoying the closest thing to fall weather we‘ve had in SC so far this year.

review
ElleMNOpe
post image
Mehso-so

An examination of social media & the mental strain of being a moderator. An interesting psychological exploration delivered in a tight clip. Some great observations & provokes thought, but doesn't really go anywhere. Starts off strong, but then spirals into repetition. A lot of telling vs. showing & resulting lack of intensity. A left field ending that wasn't conclusive. Good thought piece with decent writing, but an incomplete execution.

review
KarenUK
post image
Pickpick

A pick but only just….. I found the premise of this short novella intriguing and unsettling, and tore through it… BUT although I usually don‘t mind an ambiguous ending, this one felt unfinished. A young woman takes a job with questionable working conditions, that‘s also kinda secret, deciding which horrific/offensive/dangerous etc, social media posts, should be taken down, and which remain for our scrolling ‘pleasure‘…. (Continued in comments)⬇️

KarenUK Told from her POV once no longer in the job, and hinting to some ‘incident‘, the story seems to build towards a crescendo that never really happens. The story feels sharp and relevant and a bit icky, but petered out at its conclusion. Still an interesting read. 2y
BarbaraBB So true. I completely agree with your review 2y
50 likes2 stack adds2 comments
review
squirrelbrain
post image
Pickpick

This novella is only just a pick for me. The MC is a moderator in a call-centre, looking at distressing internet videos. I liked the in-depth look at how this can cause trauma and reverberations throughout the lives of the protagonists, but I‘m afraid I just didn‘t understand the ending.

Maybe, Mr McEwan, it was just too subtle or maybe I‘m just not psychologically astute enough, but it was very 🤔 and almost spoiled the book for me.

BarbaraBB I don‘t remember the ending anymore 🤦🏻‍♀️ 2y
squirrelbrain @barbarabb - she went to the house of the girl in the video, someone came in downstairs and then it just ended…. 2y
Megabooks I thought about reading this, but ultimately it didn‘t seem that…idk striking. I‘m glad I said no. 2y
56 likes1 stack add3 comments
review
natashalb
post image
Mehso-so

Only 130 odd pages and easily devoured in a day. Kayleigh takes a job as a content moderator for a social media platform whose name she can't mention. All day she and her colleagues review offensive and violent content and decide which to remove and which can remain accordingly to the platform's strict guidelines. How does viewing such content day in day out affect a person?

quote
she_she
post image

15

review
MinnieTimperley
post image
Pickpick

This novella made me consider a side to social media that I had not given much thought to previously: the psychological effects on the content moderators that are employed by these organisations.

Protagonist Kayleigh is vulnerable to the manipulations of others in her personal life. Through her eyes, we witness the insipid effects of the content and judgements that she and her workmates engage in daily.

Thank you Netgallery for the opportunity

40 likes1 stack add1 comment
review
BarbaraBB
Wat wij zagen | Hanna Marleen Bervoets
post image
Pickpick

Kayleigh works for an online platform as a content moderator. She has to watch shocking content for hours a day and decide what should be removed. Not surprisingly she and her co-workers cling together somewhat desperately in their spare time. They drink and play tough but can‘t avoid being influenced by what they are watching all day. Conspiracy theories take over their conversations. An okay read.

Megabooks I know this is a Dutch book, but I read a short story with a similar plot set in Indonesia…but I can‘t remember the book! 3y
CarolynM That sounds interesting! I think it would be hard to stay sane in that situation. 3y
BarbaraBB @Megabooks This is a short story too. How weird! Let me know if you remember! (That‘s for reading as much as you do 😉) 3y
BarbaraBB @CarolynM Yes It sounds quite convincing! 3y
63 likes4 comments