Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
#essex
review
quietlycuriouskate
post image
Pickpick

Glad I persevered but sorry to use such a word where reading is concerned.
My FIL was a Baptist minister and I've good memories of comet Hale-Bopp (I was pregnant), so there's that.
I did enjoy it in the end but it's a qualified pick: the vibe was more 1897 than 1997, which was disorienting, and several minor characters, along with the whole Maria Vaduva story arc, didn't quite come into focus.
I did like Grace and Thomas's complex friendship.

review
youneverarrived
post image
Bailedbailed

Hate to bail on this as I really liked The Essex Serpent and Melmoth but I‘m just over 100 pages and I don‘t feel invested at all and I‘ve sort of been just putting off reading it.

squirrelbrain The right decision, I think. It didn‘t change much - just drifted along, feeling rather long! 🤪 3w
BarbaraBB I haven‘t even tried and probably won‘t now! 3w
quietlycuriouskate Oh dear, this is my next up, after I've finished Richard Powers. 😐 3w
See All 8 Comments
youneverarrived @squirrelbrain I‘m definitely glad I bailed then - that‘s what annoyed me about it, too drifty. 3w
youneverarrived @BarbaraBB so many other better books to be reading 😁 3w
youneverarrived @quietlycuriouskate I hope you have more luck with it than me! Look forward to seeing what you think. 3w
sarahbarnes I‘ve always been curious about Essex Serpent. Glad to know you liked it. (edited) 3w
youneverarrived @sarahbarnes it‘s got more to it than this novel, I think. Quite atmospheric which I like but with good characters and story to back it up 👍 3w
31 likes8 comments
review
rachaich
post image
Mehso-so

Have to say I'm relieved to have finished this book. The synopsis was just what appealed but I found much of the story quite dreary and struggled to keep motivated. I liked some of the characters driven sections but overall it didn't entice.

review
ImperfectCJ
post image
Pickpick

I seem to be in the middle of a bunch of titles that I would describe as "meditations." This one is relatively interesting, spanning the course of 20 years and dealing with events that happened well earlier, but it's also rather slow and kind of frustrating in the way that life is often frustrating...a whole lot of tedium punctuated by getting sort of what you want but not quite. So, a qualified pick for me.

review
Kazzie
Pickpick

Not as good as Essex Serpent (but the cross overs were enjoyable). But she writes beautifully, and lovingly about her characters flaws. One reviewer was annoyed about the closeted main character, but I found it believable in a strictly religious small town in the 90s

review
AllDebooks
Mehso-so

Hhhhmm, I found this quite irritating on a few levels. I didn't connect with any character, didn't feel the enlightenment. It was a disappointment as I adored her other 2 books.
However, the writing is good. I think this is a bit of a hit and miss with a lot of people.
#Booker #Longlist2024

review
AnneCecilie
post image
Mehso-so

A book mostly about unrequited love, but also about how choices effect your life, faith, being different, astronomy and friendship.

Thomas is an older journalist and writer who gets interested in astronomy and a female astronomer that supposedly hunting a house. Grace is several decades his junior falling in love for the first time.

Another #Booker book read

AnneCecilie My relatively low rating of this book is because of my previous experiences with Perry. After all the buzz and hype for The Essex Serpent I was a little disappointed, but my expectations might have been too high. I liked Melmoth well enough when I read it and even enjoyed it. But when it comes to both of these books I‘ve mainly forgotten what they‘re about, and I‘m used to remember books I like, and there‘s nothing about Enlightenment that makes (edited) 2mo
AnneCecilie me think it will be any different. (edited) 2mo
squirrelbrain Great review - I didn‘t love this one either. 2mo
See All 8 Comments
Leniverse I am still waiting for this one from the library, but if it doesn't make the shortlist I might just cancel my hold. 2mo
charl08 It's tricky when you have expectations of an author. I feel like that about Matar. 2mo
AnneCecilie @Leniverse There‘s a lot of people that love Perry and if you haven‘t read her before this is probably a good place to start 2mo
AnneCecilie @squirrelbrain Thank you 😊 2mo
AnneCecilie @charl08 I know, only now my expectations were extremely low and that usually means that I fall in love with there book, but that didn‘t happen here. I loved the Marar, but don‘t what to add extra expectations to it 2mo
53 likes2 stack adds8 comments
review
TheEllieMo
post image
Pickpick

I feel this is a Marmite book, people will either love it or hate it.

I‘m definitely in the “love” category.

After reading in fits and starts around work and other commitments during the week, I devoured the last 200 pages this afternoon. The writing style won‘t be too everyone‘s taste, but I loved the slightly old-fashioned vibe to it. I loved the characters, I felt their pain, their loss, their happiness.

My top read of ‘24 so far.

quote
TheEllieMo
post image

“It was the restless period between summer and autumn, when it was never possible to guess the weather, or dress correctly for it.”

Describing Britain right now!!

review
Graywacke
post image
Mehso-so

#booker #booker2024 #longlist

Just finished my 4th. I‘m of different minds. One is to take it as a tale on its own terms, slightly removed from reality. The other is to be annoyed at how it simplifies relevant concerns of reality. Another is just to acknowledge it was ok and be done with it. And another is to embrace Thomas and Grace, give them a pass, and a hug. I am not enlightened, not wowed. Not carried away. Maybe slightly provoked.

JenP Im hating this so much 😬. This author and I simply don‘t get along 2mo
Graywacke @JenP you‘re in it now? Well, don‘t expect it to change tone much. I think it‘s all laid out in 1997, and the rest is epilogue. 🙂 If it helps, give it leeway in reality and allow it its own simplified version. Or…just abandon the darn thing! 2mo
See All 9 Comments
JenP @Graywacke about 60 pages in. I have never abandoned a Booker nominee bc we review them for my blog but I have come closest to it this year. First with Strange eventful history and now with this one. I am struggling with the writing style. So much description 2mo
Graywacke @JenP Oh, i see. I didn‘t mind the prose. I wish you well. Maybe your reading brain will adapt to it. ?? 2mo
BarbaraBB I‘ll only read this one if it makes the shortlist. 2mo
AnneCecilie This is next up for me. I don‘t have the best experience with Perry so curious to find out how I find this. 2mo
squirrelbrain Great review! @JenP -I listened to this and I wonder if that might make it easier? It‘s the sort of book you can let drift past your ears - I think I‘d have really disliked it too had I read it in print. 2mo
51 likes9 comments