Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
Consider the Lilies
Consider the Lilies | Iain Crichton Smith
5 posts | 3 read | 10 to read
Retrained, finely wrought ... Mr Crichton Smith shows us isolation, perplexity, loneliness, a combination of blindness and indifference' - New Statesman 'Mr Crichton Smith has an acute feeling for places and atmosphere. The wind-blown heaths, the grey skies, the black dwellings, the narrow lives, the poverty - are all vividly depicted ... one can linger over the sheer beauty of his phrases' - Observer The eviction of the crofters from their homes between 1792 and the 1850s was one of the cruellest episodes in Scotland's history. In this novel Iain Crichton Smith captures the impact of the Highland Clearances through the thoughts and memories of an old woman who has lived all her life within the narrow confines of her community. Alone and bewildered by the demands of the factor, Mrs Scott approaches the minister for help, only to have her faith shattered by his hypocrisy. She finds comfort, however, from a surprising source: Donald Macleod, an imaginative and self-educated man who has been ostracised by his neighbours, not least by Mrs Scott herself, on account of his atheism. Through him and through the circumstances forced upon her, the old woman achieves new strength.
Amazon Indiebound Barnes and Noble WorldCat Goodreads LibraryThing
Pick icon
100%
review
Twocougs
Consider the Lilies | Iain Crichton Smith
post image
Pickpick

A beautifully written story of the heart wrenching history of the Highland Clearances in Scotland. The story is written from a lonely old woman‘s point of view.

30 likes2 stack adds
blurb
Ms.Story
Consider the Lilies | Iain Crichton Smith
post image

#7Days7Covers #Day4 #TBR metallic letters ❤️

megnews Beautiful 5y
vamp Beautiful cover 5y
100 likes1 stack add2 comments
review
Bookwomble
Consider the Lilies | Iain Crichton Smith
post image
Pickpick

While set during the Highland Clearances, this isn't really about them, rather it's a character portrait of 70 year-old Mary Scott, and the family and cultural influences that lead her to be living a lonely, embittered existence. The Clearances are a shock, causing Mary to confront her assumptions about social and religious authority, to re-evaluate her life relationships, and her moral judgements about her neighbours. A resounding 5/5 🌟

LeahBergen Great review! 5y
21 likes1 stack add2 comments
quote
Bookwomble
Consider the Lilies | Iain Crichton Smith
post image

"The truth? What's that? Don't you know that the day has come when the truth is what we care to make it?"

The quote is from the tagged book, written in 1968 about events in the 1820s, which resonate with a book written in 1948 about the 1980s, all of which feels relevant to 2019 ☹

AmyG 😪 5y
GingerAntics It‘s shocking how many people don‘t take this seriously. 5y
Leftcoastzen It is absolutely horrifying every day.Make Orwell Fiction Again. 5y
See All 7 Comments
Weaponxgirl @Leftcoastzen right?! How are we even st the point that needs to be said? 5y
Bookwomble @GingerAntics @Leftcoastzen @Weaponxgirl Once you erode somebody's critical faculty, undermine their confidence in other sources of information, stultifying their ability to assess nuance and complexity, how (apparently) easy it is to sell them on your dogma and 'certainty', the more simplistic the better. 5y
CarolynM Saying you disagree with a fact just shows that you don't understand what the word "fact" means. Simple lack of intelligence. 5y
GingerAntics True. The attacks came hard and heavy and this is where we ended up. Some of these people were probably destined to vote for him anyway, but in some cases these are otherwise intelligent human beings who just seemingly went off the deep end. 5y
17 likes1 stack add7 comments
blurb
Bookwomble
Consider the Lilies | Iain Crichton Smith
post image

Next up - elderly Scottish woman reminisces about her life as she struggles to understand the cruel eviction of the crofters from their homes and livelihoods during the Highland Clearances of the early nineteenth century. According to the introduction, Smith denied it is an historical novel as he knowingly takes liberties with what actually happened in order to serve his poetic vision. Something to keep in mind as I read.