Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
#culturalcriticism
review
quietlycuriouskate
Monsters: A Fan's Dilemma | Claire Dederer
post image
Pickpick

It's no spoiler to reveal that there's no handy graph with great art on the X axis and monstrosity on the Y axis. What it does have is an ample selection of ethical chew-toys. She discusses themes such as: who gets to be considered a genius? How do we ascribe monstrosity differently to male and female artists? Who the hell is included in "we" anyway? To what extent does "our" individual, subjective judgement have any meaning? I liked it a lot.

GingerAntics This sounds like an intriguing mental exercise. 4w
Caroline2 Oh I have this on my kindle. Sounds like I need to move it up the pile. 👍 3w
quietlycuriouskate @GingerAntics @Caroline2 It's good! Be warned, though: I was expecting the onslaught of male, predominantly sexual, violence. However I was struck by the references to Trump's previous presidency, in that we had little idea how that would prove to be just the warm-up act for his current monstrous behaviour. 3w
See All 6 Comments
GingerAntics @quietlycuriouskate how innocent we were, just 4 years ago. 3w
sarahbarnes Oof. Great review. 3w
43 likes1 stack add6 comments
review
Jas16
Monsters: A Fan's Dilemma | Claire Dederer
post image
Mehso-so

I put this on hold after looking at all the Gaiman on my shelves and thinking “here we go again.”There is much to discuss regarding the art vs the artist but this was not what I was looking for. I found the equivalencies of monsters troubling. Women wanting space from childcare to work given the same consideration as Polanski? To me, it had less real reflection on the potential responsibilities of consumers and more tangents and biographies.

TrishB My thoughts exactly! I wanted a serious consideration but this came across as the authors attempt to rationalise her admiration of Polanski. 1mo
Jas16 @TrishB So glad you agree and I went back and read your review which had me nodding in agreement as well. 1mo
53 likes2 comments
blurb
Night_Reader
post image

His current reads: all non-fiction.

blurb
keithmalek
post image

My 10 favorite books of 2024. Number 10.

#2024Top10

review
AnneCecilie
Monsters: A Fan's Dilemma | Claire Dederer
post image
Pickpick

Can you love art by a person who has done despicable things? This is what Dederer is looking into focusing on among others the movies by Polanski and Woody Alan, the novels by Hemingway and the art by Picasso. This also leads to a discussion on the genius. Who is defined as a genius? And what comes first the genius or the great art? And also looking into the biggest sin a female artist can make, abandoning her children even if male artists to it

AnneCecilie all the time and no one batters an eyelid 4mo
Megabooks This was really good! 4mo
51 likes2 comments
blurb
AnneCecilie
Monsters: A Fan's Dilemma | Claire Dederer
post image

I‘m just gonna leave that as it is

quote
AnneCecilie
Monsters: A Fan's Dilemma | Claire Dederer

Why does all this matter? Because genius informs our idea of who gets to do what. Who gets to have license. Who gets to give in to their impulses. Whom we choose to aid and abet when they do indulge in those impulses. When genius is tied to masculinity - a masculinity that continually reasserts itself - then someone is being left out.
All of which is to say, the genius is not you. Not me. The genius, as we understand it, is not the person who

AnneCecilie spends most of her time, and I mean that quite literally, thinking about childcare. 4mo
39 likes1 comment
blurb
AnneCecilie
Monsters: A Fan's Dilemma | Claire Dederer
post image

38 likes1 stack add
quote
Leniverse
Monsters: A Fan's Dilemma | Claire Dederer
post image

'We imagine we would've been that person, the one who would've written the letter, who would've spoken out, would've hidden the Jews, would've provided the stop on the Underground Railroad.
We say this to ourselves as the world literally burns, as militarized police forces murder citizens, as children are held in camps at our own borders.'

charl08 Such a thought-provoking book! 5mo
Leniverse @charl08 Yes, it's a lot more nuanced than I expected. Not that I'm sure what I expected 😂 But it's a really good discussion. 5mo
25 likes1 stack add2 comments
blurb
ElizaMarie
Monsters: A Fan's Dilemma | Claire Dederer
post image
TheSpineView Great choice! 5mo
Catsandbooks 👏🏼🐦‍⬛🧡 5mo
23 likes2 comments