Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
#Islandlife
review
Jas16
Whale Fall | ELIZABETH. O'CONNOR
post image
Pickpick

18 year old Manod lives on a small Welsh island whose population is steadily decreasing as people leave for easier lives on the mainland. She is smart and dreams of more than a life where her only future is marriage. When strangers arrive to study the island Manod is both drawn to them and dismayed at how wrong they are about her home. A quiet novel with a unique and complicated heroine, this was easy to finish quickly but left much to consider.

Tamra I suspect I‘m really going to like this one - anxious to get to it! 6d
Jas16 @Tamra i honestly think you will like it too. 6d
50 likes2 comments
review
JenP
Whale Fall | ELIZABETH. O'CONNOR
post image
Pickpick

Debut novel about a small Welsh island community right before World War II. This was one of the books I had predicted would make the booker last year (I was wrong). Quiet novel about island life that is beautifully written. Fairly similar to The Colony. Story follows 18-yo Manood who is conflicted between traditions of her community and desire for modernization on the mainland.

charl08 I loved this one so much. Looking forward to seeing what she writes next. 2w
BarbaraBB I loved The Colony so I guess I should try this one as well? 2w
JenP @BarbaraBB I think you‘ll like it 2w
JenP @charl08 I am too. 2w
37 likes2 stack adds4 comments
review
Chelsea.Poole
Whale Fall | ELIZABETH. O'CONNOR
post image
Pickpick

Reminiscent of a few books I‘ve enjoyed: The Colony by Audrey Magee and Clear by Carys Davies. It‘s a slim novel, set in 1938 off the coast of Wales on a tiny island with 20 inhabitants. We see the island from Manod‘s perspective, an 18 year old girl living with her father and younger sister, when two English researchers arrive. Seeing her existence through their eyes changes everything. Isolated community, heavy on the nature and scenery.

JenP I‘m reading this now and also liking it. 3w
Cathythoughts Nice photo 👍🏻 3w
squirrelbrain I felt it was very reminiscent of those two books as well, but suffered slightly in comparison. They were so great that this one didn‘t quite compare. 3w
TheKidUpstairs I liked this one, but I think I read it too close to Clear. Like @squirrelbrain I felt it just didn't quite measure up to the Davies, and definitely not to The Colony, which I still think about. I was glad to have borrowed it rather than buying, but a good read nonetheless. I just can't resist and isolated island setting! 3w
Chelsea.Poole @squirrelbrain @TheKidUpstairs I agree with you both—this didn‘t reach the other two in my opinion, but similar vibes to be sure. If I had read this first I may have had a different perspective of it. But still a worthy and quick read for me! 2w
89 likes3 stack adds5 comments
review
charl08
Whale Fall | ELIZABETH. O'CONNOR
post image
Pickpick

Just loved this! One of those books that I had completely the wrong idea about, and was only persuaded by another reader to give it a go.

Cathythoughts Stacking 👍🏻❤️ 2mo
Kitta Loved this too! 2mo
46 likes1 stack add2 comments
quote
charl08
Whale Fall | ELIZABETH. O'CONNOR
post image

'Your English is perfect,' Joan said, watching me thoughtfully. 'Edward was worried we wouldn't find someone.'
'I learnt at school. From Sister Mary and from reading Woman's Own.'
She laughed loudly, again. I laughed too. No one found me funny on the island.
'I see. Well, it's perfect. You could pass for an Englishwoman.'
Joan looked out at the sea.

'Greatest country in the world.'

[Sensing an authorial raised eyebrow here]

review
rachaich
Whale Fall | ELIZABETH. O'CONNOR
post image
Pickpick

Beautiful writing and a bleak island life. Whilst a little predictable in the romance element, still held its worth. I liked the portrayal of young life and the natural and harsh world. Also a good time of the year to read it.

review
ImperfectCJ
Whale Fall | ELIZABETH. O'CONNOR
post image
Pickpick

There are a surprising number of books with this title. This one is quiet with a pace both leisurely and conveying urgency, echoing the collision of the way time is reckoned on the mainland with the way it runs on the island. Overall, I enjoyed this novel and was glad to have the audiobook to help me with the Welsh pronunciations. In the end, it left me wanting, which is apt but unsatisfying.

review
Kazzie
Whale Fall | ELIZABETH. O'CONNOR
Pickpick

Wonderful. Sparse sensitive writing. Historical fiction at its best makes the characters real and come alive. The protagonist learns about the trickery of strangers. I can see the straightforward ease of rural life, not for the work, but for the familiarity of the people

review
rmaclean4
Whale Fall | ELIZABETH. O'CONNOR
post image
Pickpick

A quiet lyrical novel set on an island off the coast of Wales right before WWII. Beautiful writing. 3.5 🌟