Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
#Middlegrade
review
Makyah
Mexikid | Pedro Martin
Mehso-so

I think if it weren‘t for the graphics I wouldn‘t have really enjoyed it at all. As the story continued I started to get a little disconnected because of the dialogue being so young. I can definitely see elementary students eating this story up especially Hispanic kids who can relate to Pedro‘s family dynamic. So, It‘s important to be willing to read about different cultures and their life experiences to have more broad perspective of life.

blurb
Makyah
Mexikid | Pedro Martin

I love how we are getting to see so of the unfortunate realities of the world through the eyes of a child. For, example when the family is crossing the border into Mexico and they get some of their stuff stolen by the guards and the dad is trying to talk their way through that tense situation. It got so real! To experience something like that as a kid had to of been very frustrating and confusing.

blurb
Makyah
Mexikid | Pedro Martin
post image

I had never heard of a graphic memoir before and I was so surprised that this isnt done more often! Actually being able to see the family and looking at how their personalities are shown through the images made it much more fun to read! This is a great way to get younger audiences more interested in reading and to stay engaged with the story.

haylee.roach10 I had never seen a graphic memoir either!! this was a fun experience to read and get immersed into non-fiction with the visual context. I love memoir so it was fun to explore. It also helped with the social political themes in the book for younger students to be able to see and get comedic relief about a story with a lot of meaning. 8h
1 comment
review
alaynaroper
Mexikid | Pedro Martin
post image
Pickpick

I really enjoyed this book! I loved the graphic novel approach the author took to write his memoir. This novel would be a great mentor text for students, as they could then create their own graphic novel/comic strip memoir and see that not all graphic novels have to be fictional! I think it would also be a great alternative for students who don‘t particularly like reading wordy books!

haylee.roach10 I love the idea about having students create their own comic strip to practice story telling. This would be a great mentor text for younger students. I agree that the book was not super wordy which made it easy to read. I also enjoyed that it was non-fiction but a graphic novel. That was unique as far as I'm aware. 8h
1 comment
blurb
alaynaroper
Mexikid | Pedro Martin
post image

I love the way Pedro thinks about his grandfather, and how their relationship is developing. From someone he was wary about getting to know, and sharing a room with, to his own personal superhero. I also love how his grandfather interacted with him and joined in his drawings. So cute!

review
jkmac9717
Mexikid | Pedro Martin
post image
Pickpick

From just the summary, this seemed uninteresting to me at first, but I was endeared by this rich story and the Martín family's mission and antics. The characters were so lovable and I felt that they were a very realistic representation of a complex family. There were silly moments but also down-to-earth ones which brought topics like family, identity, war, and loss into the spotlight to learn from. This would be a great graphic novel to teach!

blurb
jkmac9717
Mexikid | Pedro Martin
post image

I loved Abuelito's ever-present role. Pedro idolized him, putting his achievements and history (while still noteworthy!) on a pedestal and exaggerating Abuelito's reality. He is someone to look up to for Pedro, but it also created a separation of “hero“ vs. not. When Pedro is in a situation closer to one like Abuelito's past deeds, he suddenly realizes the role that humanity plays, which I think solidified their bond as people, not superheroes.

blurb
jkmac9717
Mexikid | Pedro Martin
post image

The Martín family's border experiences sat heavy on my chest as I read, especially considering what is going on in the world now. Even though they are innocent, their experience was still tainted by corruption, and this affected them all later even after learning and growing and enjoying themselves in Mexico. This is very eye-opening to families' worries and traumas as they cross borders today, and it would be good for students to sympathize.

blurb
alaynaroper
Mexikid | Pedro Martin
post image

I really like how there is a mixture of Spanish and English in the story. It keeps it accurate to his experiences in his own memoir, rather than having everything in English. It‘s something I don‘t often see and I appreciate it.

blurb
haylee.roach10
Answers in the Pages | David Levithan

Overall I enjoyed this book. I'm not sure I would teach it because I think I would personally get bored reading it multiple times over but I would definitely recommend it to students or teach it through small group settings where kids could pick from various books and read them in a book club. The ending was satisfying and had a feel-good aspect to it that gives kids closure when building reading stamina.

annagsears I agree with this! I think that working this book in through small group settings or individualized reading would be the way to go. While the content is highly engaging, I can see where you're coming from, where repeated use could cause burnout. I also like the point you've made on reading stamina. Because this book is relatively fast-paced and under 200 pages, it could be a great starting book for students who “dislike“ reading. 2d
1 like1 comment