Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
The Witching Year
The Witching Year: A Memoir of Earnest Fumbling Through Modern Witchcraft | Diana Helmuth
12 posts | 8 read | 1 reading | 19 to read
A skeptics year-long quest to find spiritual fulfillment through modern Witchcraft, perfect for fans of A.J. Jacobs and Mary Roach. Diana Helmuth, thirty-three, is skeptical of organized religion. She is also skeptical of disorganized religion. But, more than anything, she is tired of God being dead. So, she decides to try on the fastest growing, self-directed faith in America: Witchcraft. The result is 366 days of observation, trial, error, wit, and back spasms. Witches today are often presented as confident and finished, proud and powerful. Diana is eager to join them. She wants to follow all the rules, memorize all the incantations, and read all the liturgy. But theres one glaring problem: no Witch can agree on what the right rules, liturgy, and incantations are. As with life, Diana will have to define the craft for herself, looking past the fashionable and figuring out how to define the real. Along the way, she travels to Salem and Edinburgh (two very Crafty hubs) and attends a week-long (clothing optional) Witch camp in Northern California. Whether shes trying to perform a full moon ritual on a cardboard box, summon an ancient demon with scotch tape and a kitchen trivet, or just trying to become a calmer, happier person, her biggest question remains: Will any of this really work? The Witching Year follows in the footsteps of celebrated memoirs by journalists like A.J. Jacobs, Mary Roach, and Caitlin Doughty, who knit humor and reportage together in search of something worth believing.
Amazon Indiebound Barnes and Noble WorldCat Goodreads LibraryThing
Pick icon
100%
review
Lauram
post image
Pickpick

“The history will never be perfect, and we‘ll never know what really happened or how people really used to practice magic. No one will ever agree on these things. So I‘m trying not to see Witchcraft as a path home to the past. Not anymore. I think it might actually be a path to the future.”

Good stuff.

TheBookHippie I loved this book. 1d
32 likes3 stack adds1 comment
blurb
mcctrish
post image

A stay at home day for me and after I did all my buddy reading and word games, I started this and vacuumed, washed the kitchen floor, did laundry, made an apple cake and a big pot of chicken orzo soup for dinner. I‘m quite liking this so far

Darklunarose This looks mighty interesting! 2w
mcctrish @Darklunarose no idea where I read about this, it just finally came in from my library holds queue and I am so happy with past hold happy me 2w
Suet624 Um….you did a lot today! 2w
See All 6 Comments
Bookwormjillk Busy day! 2w
mcctrish @Suet624 @Bookwormjillk I semi regret my choices 🤣🤣 since I have to work the next 2 days but lunch is made for at least one of them 2w
Darklunarose @mcctrish I love library holds that come in when you least expect them! I seem to always have a full holds list! Our library doesn‘t have this one and I‘m not meant to be adding to my personal library currently! 2w
53 likes1 stack add6 comments
blurb
monalyisha
post image

Using these monthly graphics as another way to track my reading.

I read 9 books in January, which is high for me but January always skews high. I credit the motivation of a New Year and my commitment to #AuldLangSpine! Three of the books were fairly short, as well.

The Witching Year was my favorite. Hard to beat that premise in terms of my interests, and her writing is clear, fun, colloquial, and sometimes poetic. Fire Exit was also a stand-out!

monalyisha Don‘t mind my personal tag tracker: #AWreads2025 2w
TheBookHippie People keep telling me to read A WellTrained Wife… 😵‍💫😩🤷🏻‍♀️😝 2w
monalyisha @TheBookHippie It was certainly impactful! I‘m still thinking about it. Her writing is a little uneven, though, and it was far too heavy for my state of mind right now. 2w
See All 8 Comments
TheBookHippie @monalyisha I don‘t need to read what I‘m surround by. 😂 and certainly not now. 2w
monalyisha @TheBookHippie She intentionally published now, to make the threat abundantly clear to those who may not understand how real and pervasive it is (fundamentalists dedicating themselves to create a literal “army” to bring to the polls). I respect her purpose and her persistence, for sure. But yeah — it‘s such a balancing act between educating ourselves, motivating ourselves to act, and protecting (all the different aspects of) ourselves! 2w
TheBookHippie @monalyisha I‘ve been telling people since 1982 how this is. No one listened. Here we are. Mostly people want me to read it to see that I was right I already know I was right. 2w
monalyisha @TheBookHippie Sometimes, it really doesn‘t feel good to be right. ❤️‍🩹 2w
71 likes2 stack adds8 comments
review
monalyisha
post image
Pickpick

I usually read a novel alongside my nonfic. I became so singularly obsessed with reading this memoir, however, that I skipped the novel entirely. I even felt compelled to underline this baby. I bought a special pencil and everything. 😅

The author & I are definitely kindred. Despite being soul-twins, there‘s plenty we *don‘t* have in common. She hates water while my childhood nickname was Alyish the Feesh 🐟. 👇🏻

monalyisha 1/6: She can‘t sit still; I live to laze. She hates October while I feel much like Anne (glad to live in a world with them) — as long as I can put my thoughts about the approaching winter out of my head long enough to actually live in the moment. 4w
monalyisha 2/6: Still, we have the same spiritual drive and seem to experience the same discomfort about the earnestness of our longing. We deflect with skepticism and humor while continuing to yearn, and, occasionally, we manage to express that yearning when we‘re feeling especially honest and brave. We‘re also roughly the same age, so we share cultural touchstones (like Ferngully, Buffy, and Practical Magic). 4w
monalyisha 3/6: Weirdly, despite the lengthy bibliography, I don‘t feel like I learned much about witchcraft. I don‘t blame Helmuth for this, however. It‘s the same way I felt after completing my Religious Studies major in undergrad. There‘s just so much history, philosophy, and content. Even a year (or 4!) of concentrated study leaves you barely skimming the surface. (edited) 4w
See All 20 Comments
monalyisha 4/6: I‘ll leave you with one of my favorite quotes (and there are many): “If the Christian serenity prayer is ‘God grant me the serenity to accept the things I cannot change, courage to change the things I can, and the wisdom to know the difference,‘ the Witch‘s serenity prayer is probably… 4w
monalyisha 5/6: “Goddess grant me the serenity to accept the things I cannot change, courage to change the things I think I can‘t, and enough candles on hand to make a difference.” 4w
monalyisha 6/6: I can‘t say this is a *perfect* memoir but it‘s pretty damn good. And it‘s exactly my jam. 4w
TheBookHippie I read the ARC and loved it! 4w
monalyisha @TheBookHippie I was fascinated by her conversations with Oberon Zell-Ravenheart about story, and about identifying as “spiritual but not religious” vs. “religious but not spiritual” (and how the latter talk didn‘t go as expected). I definitely don‘t see myself becoming a convert or anything like that but I‘d love to read more about/by him. 4w
Sace Well you‘ve convinced me. I will be ordering this in the near future. 4w
TheBookHippie @Sace It‘s good. 4w
TheBookHippie @monalyisha I am spiritual and familial traditions of my grandma -and NOT RELIGIOUS(😝) So I enjoyed that part . I like it when books make you think. 4w
monalyisha @TheBookHippie Oh, I definitely always say the line, too (“spiritual but not religious”), so it was interesting that he framed it as spirit vs matter, and made “religion” more about ritual & the body. Flipped the script on us all a little bit! 4w
TheBookHippie @monalyisha Exactly because ritual is in my life . I really did enjoy this book! I think so many would like it but it seems not well known. @Chrissyreadit & @BookwormAHN would like it I think. And many more. 4w
Chrissyreadit @TheBookHippie @monalyisha It is on my shelf- i will dust it off and read it since both of you are recommending. Maybe @BookwormAHN would be interested in a “buddy read” with me. 4w
Chrissyreadit @monalyisha I don‘t know what I am anymore- but nature and ritual (with candles) are my guide these days. I def lean feminist pagan if it were defined. 4w
Clare-Dragonfly Wow, I‘m really intrigued by the conversation with Oberon Zell-Ravenheart. Even if the whole rest of the book is stuff I‘ve heard before (I‘ve been a witch for most of my life), that part is probably worth the price of admission. 4w
Christine I am adding this in spirit to your 2024 list bc I will want to get to it sooner than later! 😁 4w
BookwormAHN @Chrissyreadit Definitely, it sounds really interesting 4w
BookwormAHN @TheBookHippie Thanks, this sounds really good 4w
TheBookHippie @BookwormAHN I think you‘ll love it. 4w
75 likes5 stack adds20 comments
blurb
monalyisha
post image

When I picked this up, I didn‘t even realize it was blurbed by AJ Jacobs and partially inspired by his book, “The Year of Living Biblically,” which is my *favorite.*

I can‘t express how much this is all resonating. ✨

Currently reading in a coastal cabin while wind, rain, and waves rage in the darkest night outside my door. Getting the sparkly star-shaped ceiling light; fresh, aromatic wood; and the animal skull in the shot just felt right.

AnnCrystal I am loving your ceiling and star-light 🤩, beautiful!

Read somewhere that the starshape symbolized time travel, and formed in crystal, it could transport the holder across time. Don't know if that was something written in the Spirit of Fantasy or once believd by an ancient people, either way I fell in love with the shape ever since. I know, I'm wacky 😂.
(edited) 1mo
Cortg I have a light like that in my foyer by the front door. Never thought of it as spooky 👻 Enjoy your spooky/cozy evening! It sounds delightful. 1mo
monalyisha @Cortg Ha! You know, I didn‘t even think of my description as “spooky” but I suppose it might be interpreted that way! 1mo
TheBookHippie I read the ARC of this I enjoyed it very much. 1mo
Suet624 Sounds like a wonderful place to be. 1mo
75 likes1 stack add5 comments
review
Tara
post image
Pickpick

I am once again back after several months of not posting! Maybe this time I can maintain some sort of posting rhythm 🤥 Anyway this witchcraft memoir appealed to me because I too have dabbled in all things witchy on and off since tweenhood 🔮 What really worked for me is how Helmuth balanced her natural skepticism while also being open to experience.

AnnCrystal Welcome Back Litten 📚🥳👍. 6mo
13 likes1 comment
review
Twocougs
post image
Pickpick

A year to explore and learn about witchcraft. I appreciated her honesty with all she experienced. Certainly made me ponder things.

HettyG Did you find it to be a respectful look at the people who practice this faith? 11mo
Twocougs @HettyG she speaks about it often and being respectful to indigenous practices. 11mo
32 likes2 comments
blurb
Augustdana
post image

Got curious based on the tagline: a memoir of earnest fumbling through modern witchcraft. I borrowed from the library a little early for this one, so I don‘t have a ton of time with it. 🤞 I‘m disciplined to get through it. 8 people are waiting.

blurb
Chrissyreadit
post image

First- I loved the packaging- this was so much fun to open- and I need 2 posts for all this delight 🖤 A huge thank you to Melanie- I love all of it so much! And a huge thank you to Ashley for hosting this swap!!! #modernwitchswap #mws

BookwormAHN 🧡🐈‍⬛️💜 1y
60 likes1 comment
review
underground_bks
post image
Pickpick

An aspiring witch spends 366 days studying spell books, celebrating the Wheel of the Year, burning through colored candles, summoning demons to do her bidding—& having real epiphanies about grief, doubt, & love. I so appreciated Helmuth‘s hang-ups—ahistoricity, cultural appropriation, fear of doing it “wrong”—& the humor and care with which she handled them. Curious about witchcraft? You have an honest, smart, funny companion for the crooked path.

dabbe Da cute kitty looks curious! 🖤🐾🖤 2y
underground_bks @dabbe Peter‘s always stealing the show 🤩 2y
dabbe @underground_bks A perfect name. Our greyhound's name was Pete. 🤩😍🤗 2y
34 likes1 stack add3 comments