Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
#RelatedToMurder
review
ravenlee
post image
Panpan

Oh boy. All right, first, I saw almost all the twists coming, so that was frustrating. The story was middling. Here‘s the BIG problem, though: A.L. Herbert is a pseudonym for a writer who is neither Black nor female, yet presents as such. I don‘t believe that every writer writing from a different perspective is guilty of cultural appropriation (it depends on how they do so and how they present themselves in the attempt) BUT 👇🏻

ravenlee when the author hides behind a nom de plume and makes it look as if they share the ethnicity/cultural background if their MC, then it‘s a problem. Especially because Wavonne, the MC‘s obnoxious cousin, is such a stereotypical trashy Black female, which becomes truly problematic when written by a non-Black male. Now it‘s not an elbow nudge and using the stereotypes ironically, but profiling and perpetuating those stereotypes. 2y
ravenlee So, I felt very uncomfortable reading a lot of this once I discovered the author‘s identity. I wouldn‘t have continued the series anyway, as I don‘t care for cozies specifically but most mysteries generally, but now I definitely won‘t. I got a few prompts covered for my challenges, which is really what I needed anyway. 2y
See All 7 Comments
5feet.of.fury Yeah, I feel he intentionally misrepresented himself to appeal to a certain audience. Yuck. 2y
ravenlee @5feet.of.fury exactly - and in doing so, worked through some horribly offensive checklist of Black stereotypes. 2y
Amiable I love reading reviews of horrible books more than reviews of great books. So descriptive! Thanks for the warning. (edited) 2y
Clare-Dragonfly That‘s really gross. Thanks for the warning. 2y
38 likes7 comments
review
BarbaraBB
Broken River | J Robert Lennon
post image
Pickpick

This is such a cool book. A family moves to a deserted house where a murder took place years before. A sex obsessed father, a mother who tries to save their marriage and their smart lovely kid, who is intrigued by the murder. More characters are introduced as is the sleepy town of Broken River, almost ghost town like. The setting, the atmosphere, the characters, the plot, the genre bending: it‘s all so good!!

Pic: Rabat, Morocco

squirrelbrain You‘re loving your Lennon books! ❤️ 2y
See All 19 Comments
BarbaraBB @squirrelbrain Yes! I‘ve read three so far and loved each of them! 2y
jhod I also loved this one, I should seek more Lennon out... 2y
Cinfhen I was there too, in Rabat 😉cool picture 2y
Librarybelle Stacking! 2y
batsy I have this stacked, I see. Great review! 2y
BarbaraBB @batsy Thanks! He is such a good author. 2y
BarbaraBB @jhod You should! I‘ve been reading his backlist lately and he doesn‘t disappoint! 2y
BarbaraBB @Cinfhen Cool place, that square. I really liked Rabat! 2y
sarahbarnes Yay! So glad you enjoyed it. I need to figure out which book of his I want to read next. 2y
BarbaraBB @sarahbarnes I loved it! Have you read 2y
BarbaraBB Or were you the one recommending it to me 🤣🤦🏻‍♀️ @sarahbarnes (edited) 2y
sarahbarnes I think maybe I did! 😂 I did really like that one, too. I‘m thinking maybe I‘ll read Happyland or Castle next? 2y
BarbaraBB @sarahbarnes You definitely did, I checked it. Both your suggestions sound good too! I am having this one on my shelves 2y
sarahbarnes Oh, that one sounds really good too! 2y
Centique Stacked! Great review and amazing photo 😍 2y
79 likes6 stack adds19 comments
review
KarenUK
The Appeal | JANICE. HALLETT
post image
Pickpick

A fun epistolary murder mystery, that slowly reveals everything you need to solve the puzzle yourself. Told mostly through emails and whats app messages, ‘The Appeal‘ has a double meaning. Both as a fund raising effort for a poorly child, and for the efforts to release the wrongly convicted murderer of the late revealed victim. Clever and witty but takes commitment. It‘s not short, and there‘s a LOT of characters! But I found it worth the effort.

53 likes6 comments