LordPeterWhimsey

Robotswithpersonality

Clouds of Witness | Dorothy L. Sayers

“facts...nasty, hard things, all knobs.“ ☺️

8 likes

Robotswithpersonality

Clouds of Witness | Dorothy L. Sayers

so-so

I do treasure a cheeky last line.
I'll admit to being a bit surprised that this one felt so much more like a court drama than a classic mystery, it was technically following the beats of looking for clues, discovering evidence, but Wimsey seems to play a smaller role in figuring things out, we get less fun or incisive character moments with him and Bunter, less cozy or outrageous about town moments, and there were large swathes 1/?

Robotswithpersonality 2/? of news coverage and deposition.
Classism plays a major role, because I had no idea (and hope it's not still the practice) that peers of the realm were given an entirely different process within the justice system after initial charges are brought, and it's clear that the Lords and Duchesses are given every consideration during the investigation while the common folk and the less well off minglers in a certain echelon of society, 2w

Robotswithpersonality 3/? are often depicted with less intelligence, less manners, and more readily suspicious motives.
It doesn't appear that the central male characters of the story are treating the female characters with much more consideration than in the first novel of this series, but you do get a broader range and a clearer picture of what the womenfolk have in the way of restricted options in the time period of the novel. 2w

Robotswithpersonality 4/? Mary Wimsey, who couldn't pursue her original love interest because the family wouldn't allow it and she had no funds without their approval, who could only reconsider once the man found a job that could also offer her a modest salary as a secretary alongside, who alternatively planned to marry a man who guaranteed her a certain level of indifferent independence and an approved match that would secure her inheritance; 2w

See All 6 Comments

Robotswithpersonality 5/? Mrs Grimethorpe, suffering an appalling amount of physical violence from her husband, which no one in her immediate circle has worked to put a stop to, who feared for her life if she tried to leave, attempting to find solace with another man who didn't bother to try to lift her out of her circumstances, as men of his station are so used to having a wife and entitled to whomever else as well; 2w

Robotswithpersonality 6/? Simone Vonderaa, a mistress whom everyone understands has to look out for her own interests, going where the money is even if it devastates a former lover/supporter, because she needs a source of income that again, necessarily comes from a man. Pretty grim. 2w

Robotswithpersonality 7/7 As with many other series, I'll let the third book help me decide to continue or not based on whether it offers the same kind of promise as the first, or suggests it's not a series to wallow in if it drags about like certain portions of the second.
⚠️Domestic abuse, suicide 2w

7 likes6 comments

Robotswithpersonality

Clouds of Witness | Dorothy L. Sayers

The ultimate physical form of a detective? 🕵🏼‍♂️🤔

10 likes1 stack add

kspenmoll

Have His Carcase | Dorothy L. Sayers

so-so

This dragged on for me. Too much talk: blah blah blah from Lord Peter Wimsey. Harriet Vane, the voice of reason, sighted a dead body by the shore when she was picnicking. The plot that unfolds due to their investigation, although convoluted, did reach a resolution in the end. #readyourkindle

CBee

willaful I remember finding this one pretty dull. Gaudy Night is wonderful! 6mo

57 likes1 comment

kspenmoll

Have His Carcase | Dorothy L. Sayers

Top row: Just started Man in the Brown Suit today-thoroughly enjoying Anne Beddingfield as she creates her own adventures! A Summer of Hummingbirds, Have His Carcase #ChristieCapers #nonfiction #HarrietVane

Bottom row: took me most of the month to listen to The Queens of Crime, #audiobook #DCIBanks #poetry

Librarybelle

Librarybelle Yay!! 7mo

49 likes1 comment

kspenmoll

Have His Carcase | Dorothy L. Sayers

#bookreport
Top Row: #sundaybuddyread Trying to catch up this week; #Audiobook #QueensofCrime; #nonfiction #hummingbirds #readyourkindle #DorothySayers
Middle Row: #poetry
Bottom Row: finished books #memoir #DCIBanks #GideonOliver #forensicanthropology

wanderinglynn, TheBookHippie, CBee

wanderinglynn 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻 7mo

47 likes1 stack add1 comment

kspenmoll

Have His Carcase | Dorothy L. Sayers

1) we filed in March & got both federal & state taxes back within a week.
2) Grit

TheSpineView

TheSpineView Thanks for playing! 7mo

44 likes1 comment

Amie

Strong Poison | Dorothy L. Sayers

pick

Lord Peter Wimsey book 6. Very good! I think Miss Climpson and Miss Murcheson deserve the credit for solving this one - they did all the work! I wish Sayers had written a spinoff series about Miss Climpson and the “Cattery.“

34 likes

Mpcacher

Whose Body? | Dorothy Sayers

so-so

After reading “The Queens of Crime“ in which Sayer is a main character, I felt I should read one of her books. Perhaps I should not have started with her first as I expected more. I think part of my issue was the dated upper crust ways of talking, that was sometimes difficult to understand. I have read that the series gets better, so perhaps I will try another one. The mystery itself in this one was quite clever and certainly unique. 3.25/5

15 likes

CatLass007

Whose Body? | Dorothy Sayers

bailed

#AuthorAMonth I tried to listen to this but I just couldn‘t. Things I liked about this book are that Lord Peter is a book lover, his mother doesn‘t think his hobby is inappropriate, he has a “Jeeves”-type character who helps him. Things I didn‘t like are that he behaves like solving crimes is all a lark, cheerfully going to the house where the body was found and joyfully disturbing the crime scene. And he rhymes, rhymes about murder. As I (cont)⬇️

Soubhiville, dabbe

CatLass007 began writing this review I considered that if he were on the Spectrum, rhyming might be a coping mechanism. But I didn‘t get a Spectrum vibe, although I‘m no expert. #HailTheBail (edited) 10mo

dabbe The anti-semitism was awful, too. #hailthebail! #betterbooksahead 🤩 10mo

charl08 Wow, that is the worst Wimsey cover I've seen. So wrong! 10mo

See All 6 Comments

Soubhiville Ha, this is the first I‘m hearing about the rhyming. That would turn me off too. 10mo

CatLass007 @dabbe Yes, it was. I forgot to mention that. It really, really was. 10mo

CatLass007 @charl08 I like to read a series in order but it wasn‘t available on LIBBY for weeks, so I bought it from Audible for $1.37. Never having read any of the series before, I didn‘t really know anything about what the cover should look like. But we all know never to judge a book by its cover.😊😜 10mo

46 likes6 comments

Welcome to Litsy!

Trending Hashtags

Trending Books