Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
#ReadTheUSA2024
review
TheAromaofBooks
post image
Pickpick

Wow, reading the GR synopsis made me realize that my 1931 edition is LITERALLY an entirely different story from the later version! Maybe that's because this one didn't have a super cohesive mystery. It's mostly Nancy and her friends riding around mountains getting almost eaten by wild animals 😂 I was cracking up at the way some of the situations resolved themselves at the end (wife of husband with amnesia perfectly happy he's coming home with a ⬇

TheAromaofBooks (cont'd) random little girl he adopted who is also an heiress and is going to have no complications or difficulty establishing who she is and I guess they'll just hand over the kid and all her money to this couple?!?!!? LOL)

BUT it's still great fun, even if I apparently missed out on a great phantom horse mystery in the later edition!!

@Librarybelle
(edited) 2mo
TheSpineView Awesome! 2mo
See All 6 Comments
Librarybelle That sounds so different from the 1960s version! 😮 2mo
bookandbedandtea I've been thinking the same thing! Others have mentioned aspects of the story that bear no relation to what I'm reading! I'm hoping to finish this today and then read the 60s version real quick. 🤞🏻 @Librarybelle 2mo
BarkingMadRead Oh wow! I have the 60s version, that‘s crazy! 2mo
68 likes6 comments
review
julieclair
Irish Parade Murder | Leslie Meier
post image
Pickpick

The Lucy Stone books always make me feel like I‘ve plopped right down into the middle of her life. This one centers around the town‘s upcoming St. Patrick‘s Day Parade, and includes work problems, a death in the family, possible corruption, a potential long-lost relative, and of course, a murder. Very entertaining!
#SeasonalCozies #ReadTheUSA2024 @aperfectmjk

review
TheAromaofBooks
post image
Pickpick

Not the tagged book, but by the same author. This horse story has languished on my shelves for decades, and I'm not sure why I've never read it. Published (and set) during the Korean War, a young man leaves for the armed forces. His younger brother, who has a club foot and is ineligible to fight, stays behind and raises the colt they're convinced can be a champion harness racer. While fairly typical horse book fare, I still really enjoyed this ⬇

TheAromaofBooks (cont'd) this one and was rooting for Star the whole way.

#Roll100 @PuddleJumper
#100YearsofBooks
#ReadtheUSA2024 - Florida
#BookChain
#BookSpinBingo
2mo
48 likes1 comment
review
TheAromaofBooks
post image
Panpan

I complained about this book at length on Goodreads, and on my blog. Short version: Emma Gatewood was amazing. Ben Montgomery's writing sucked, and the entire rhythm of this book made no sense. What I actually need are Emma's diaries.

#BookSpin - February
#ReadtheUSA2024 - Maine
#GottaCatchEmAll - Nature Featured Prominently @PuddleJumper
#BookSpinBingo

Librarybelle Thank you!!! I completely agree with you on this, and honestly, people thought I was horrible for not thinking it the best book in the world. 2mo
TheAromaofBooks @Librarybelle - He just sounded so condescending and smug the entire time. I hated the parts where he talked about “following in her footsteps“ and all about HIS feelings blah blah blah. Like I care haha It just felt like he didn't actually like or respect Gatewood and was just here to make a buck on her accomplishments. And I couldn't stand the way he handled the sections about her husband abusing her - the way he would always end it on a ⬇ 2mo
TheAromaofBooks (cont'd) “cliffhanger“ - like “her husband beat her ten times that month“ CUT SCENE - Now we're in Maine, back on the hike! Ugh. He also had unlimited access to her diaries, and barely quotes them at all?? The format jumping all over the place in time was hard to follow and didn't really make sense. I just. Ugh. It made me mad because I am genuinely interested in Gatewood as a person - I'm from Ohio and have hiked the Buckeye Trail section ⬇ 2mo
See All 8 Comments
TheAromaofBooks (cont'd) named for her many times. There was a lot of potential here, but his sneering attitude just grated on me on every page. /end rant 😂 2mo
Lcsmcat Good to know. I‘m interested in her, but maybe I‘ll look for another source. 2mo
Librarybelle I was on a committee with individuals who thought his work was so good, and I was just flummoxed. I kept thinking I must be missing something - the writing was not engaging, & you bring up several of the points I thought. I also saw a shift in the writing style where I felt he almost went a little over the top with “fanboying” and the tone went very weird. Not a chronicle, per se, but something else. I‘m glad to find someone else who found issue! 2mo
ImperfectCJ Just popping in to say that I'm really enjoying reading this exchange. I haven't read this book, but it sounds like it hits one of my pet peeves---an author who centers their own experience while they're supposedly writing someone else's story. I will have to hike the Buckeye Trail section named for Gatewood next time I'm in the heart of it all. 2mo
dabbe #fanofthepan! 💚💙💚 2mo
47 likes8 comments
review
TheAromaofBooks
Celine: A novel | Peter Heller
post image
Pickpick

I had some trouble rating this book because the book itself can't quite seem to decide what it wants to be. It‘s also not exactly a novel, but somewhere in between. A novel with some thriller aspects. A slow-paced suspense with a lot of backstory. A spy story not about the spy at all. A missing person case with a long explanation as to why the detective takes on missing person cases. Something like that. The point is, I really enjoyed it. But⬇

TheAromaofBooks (cont'd) I'm also not sure exactly why 😂

Great #LMPBC pick @bookandbedandtea !! @Jerdencon @robinb
#ReadtheUSA2024 - Wyoming
#WickedWords - Couple @AsYouWish
#100YearsofBooks (2017)
#BookSpinBingo
2mo
Susanita My book club liked it more than I did, but I want to try the Dusty Miller sundae. 2mo
bookandbedandtea I like your analysis, Sarah. I can't properly describe the book, and couldn't nail down a genre for it, but I really enjoyed it. 🤷‍♀️ 2mo
robinb I enjoyed it as well, but it was definitely different. And I get what you say about the genre thing. At times it felt like a cozy, at times a book more about the mysterious Celine than a thriller/mystery. Celine was the focus, all else took a backseat. 😂 2mo
52 likes4 comments
review
TheAromaofBooks
Escape Into the Night | Lois Walfrid Johnson
post image
Pickpick

I originally read these back in the early 90s when they were being published and I was close to the same age as the middle grade protagonists. Libby has been living with her aunt and uncle since her mother passed away, but now her dad, a steamboat captain on the Mississippi in 1857, thinks she is old enough to come live with him again. Libby learns about the evils of slavery (a topic she's never thought deeply about) and finds out that the cabin ⬇

TheAromaofBooks (cont'd) boy is a conductor for the Underground Railroad. This is the first book in the series - they'll spend the books helping a young slave their age rescue his mother and siblings from slavery, all while eluding his exceptionally evil owner. While not groundbreaking, these are good “starter“ books to introduce some concepts. I remember enjoying them as a kid, although they're pretty predictable as an adult haha Soft pick. 2mo
TheSpineView Well done! 2mo
sblbooks This looks good! You should join us for #middlegrademarch. 2mo
49 likes4 comments
review
julieclair
post image
Pickpick

This was a sweet YA romance, lots of high school angst and drama, and a bit cheesy at times, but still a fun read. The main character, Mim, has a super-elevated sense of smell, and can actually smell people‘s emotions. She and her mother come from a long line of aromateurs - “love witches” who make elixirs that can open the path to love. Listening to Mim describe the scent various emotions was interesting!
A fun #SundayBuddyRead selection!

julieclair #Pantone2024 (Horizon Blue) @BarbaraBB #ISpyBingo (“Secret”, Grass, Pink Font, Purple Font) @TheAromaofBooks @Clwojick #ReadTheUSA2024 (California) @aperfectmjk 2mo
TheAromaofBooks Woohoo!!! 2mo
31 likes2 comments
review
TheAromaofBooks
Upgrade: A Novel | Blake Crouch
post image
Pickpick

I had mixed feelings about this one. Overall, it was engaging and interesting, but the pacing felt off sometimes. I also didn't care for the ending exactly (spoiler below). The author also seemed to feel like he had to mention that climate change is killing everyone on basically every page. Okay, I get it already. Sheesh. Still a fun thriller and I can see myself trying Crouch again sometime. Soft pick.

TheAromaofBooks Literally the entire book is telling us about how genetic engineering is sketchy and has unintended results, yet his solution was... genetic engineering?! Releasing a “virus“ out into the world without telling anyone or giving them option?? “it's a good virus that makes everyone a better person!!!“ ... a good option you've known about for like 2 seconds have no idea what the long-term results are?? It just felt SO hypocritical! 2mo
Zuhkeeyah @TheAromaofBooks I had a similar issue with the ending. After decrying all the manipulation mankind is doing…he goes and does he same. It was still a fun read though. 2mo
See All 6 Comments
julieclair Yay! Glad you have read it, and are now sending out into the world to find a new owner. 😆 2mo
bookandbedandtea I had the exact same thoughts at the end! How hypocritical and irresponsible! 2mo
MatchlessMarie 💯❤️ 2mo
65 likes6 comments
review
TheAromaofBooks
Past Perfect Life | Elizabeth Eulberg
post image
Pickpick

Sometimes the problem with a book is your expectations going into it. The blurb made this book sound thriller-y. It's not. Ally DOES find out that her whole past is different from what she thought, but we know right away why, who, and how. This is really a book about her adjusting to that and working through the complications of knowing she's been lied to for so long. I liked Ally and felt like she was realistic. Her mom, however. Oof. Soft pick.

51 likes1 comment
review
TheAromaofBooks
Wolf Gone Wild | Juliette Cross
post image
Pickpick

100% stacked this book originally because of that fabulous cover. Gifted to me back in 2022 for a Swoonathon Swap by @Nessavamusic it only took me two years to read it, so not bad! 😂 I really liked the characters and world-building in this one, the group of badass magical sisters - great fun. I did read the next few books in the series, but didn't like them quite as well. It felt like they got more focused on the spice and less focused on ⬇

TheAromaofBooks (cont'd) on story. Plus, I believe demons are real and evil, so whenever paranormal world-building decides to throw in “demons are actually sweet and misunderstood“... I'm pretty much out lol

But this first book was just great fun if you're looking for sexy paranormal nonsense.

#SeriesLove2024 @TheSpineView @Andrew65
#ReadtheUSA2024 - Louisiana
#ISpyBingo - Moon, Paw Prints, Cat
#GottaCatchEmAll - Guilty Pleasure @PuddleJumper
#BookSpinBingo
2mo
TheSpineView Fabulous! 2mo
Traci1 Love that cover 2mo
Nessavamusic A very fun book. So glad you enjoyed it @TheAromaofBooks ! 2mo
60 likes1 stack add4 comments