Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
#ISPYbingo
review
TheAromaofBooks
Rilla of Ingleside | L.M. Montgomery
post image
Pickpick

This is one of my all-time favorite books and I have read it probably 25-30 times over my lifetime. The characters, the setting, the fact that a few of the moments in this book still make me choke up even after all these rereads - this book is close to perfect to me.

SO IT WAS A COMPLETE SHOCK to find out that in the 1940s random sentences/paragraphs were edited out!!! The edition I grew up reading, despite clearly saying it was “unabridged“ ⬇

TheAromaofBooks (cont'd) was, in fact, abridged! As was virtually every edition published from 1942-2010! But in 2010 a restored text was published. Since I didn't know it existed, I didn't seek it out, but I just so happened to purchase this edition a couple of years ago as my old faithful Bantam paperback is wearing out and I love this cover. Turns out, it's the 2010 text. So obviously I didn't read the two editions side by side noting every passage I could ⬇ 1d
TheAromaofBooks (cont'd) find that had been removed, because that would be ridiculous. But if I did, the note in the picture indicates how heavily each chapter was edited - ✔is unabridged, - is only a couple words or a sentence, + is several sentences, and ++ is multiple paragraphs.

I'm still completely befuddled as to why these passages were removed. It's true, nothing vital was taken out, but there are moments of humor, depth, and character, that were cut. ⬇
1d
TheAromaofBooks (cont'd) A lot of the editing were various speeches of Susan's, so maybe they just decided they didn't like her character...???? But other moments, like Rilla clinging to hope so as to not 'break faith' with Walter, Anne recounting the hair-dying episode of her youth, or more details of how Dog Monday settled in at the station, seemed so arbitrary to remove.

So it was kind of fun to do a little treasure hunt and discover that there is even more ⬇
1d
See All 14 Comments
TheAromaofBooks (cont'd) of a favorite book than I thought!!

#KindredSpiritsBuddyRead @BarbaraJean
#192025 - 1921 @Librarybelle (I only have 5 years left to find so I think I may actually complete this challenge!!!)
#100YearsofBooks
#ISpyBingo - Cake, Stars, Train, Silhouette, Heart
#BookSpinBingo
1d
swynn Ridiculous? I don't know, reading the two editions side by side noting every passage that had been removed or altered sounds perfectly reasonable to me. How else would you know? Thanks for sharing your research! (edited) 1d
Librarybelle That‘s incredible! 5 years left…way to go!!! 1d
rubyslippersreads My copy is from 1921, so I think I‘m safe. 😊 Have you heard of this book? 1d
Kristin_Reads That‘s amazing! I would have never guessed! 1d
CSeydel Wow! 1d
BooksandCoffee4Me I‘ve never heard of it, but I want to read it. Hope I can find a true version. 22h
BarbaraJean And obviously I'm not going to go through your handy notes and check out all the differences between the two versions... and I'm also not reading the original unaltered edition in the ebook with my print versions at hand so I can check anything that doesn't sound familiar... 😆

It absolutely IS like a treasure hunt!! I love your perspective that it's like finding out there's MORE to love. I've been feeling betrayed by my old faithful Bantams!!
17h
TheAromaofBooks @rubyslippersreads - OOoo a first edition, so fun!! I have a few Anne books from the 1930s, but not Rilla. I hadn't heard of that book, but definitely want to check it out!! 8h
TheAromaofBooks @BarbaraJean - You can let me know if you find anything in the chapters I thought were intact - sometimes it would just be even a word. For instance, one time Rilla is cuddling Jims and says something like “I hope your poor little mother knows you're safe.“ Except in the original it's “poor little white mother“ and they cut the word white - which I feel like in this instance is more a reference to her being frail/sick rather than her actual race?⬇ 8h
TheAromaofBooks (cont'd) But I have also felt rather betrayed by my old Bantams that I grew up reading!! So crazy!! 8h
56 likes2 stack adds14 comments
review
TheAromaofBooks
post image
Pickpick

The fourth Dolittle book is set back in England. As usual (because of his generous nature) Dolittle is broke, so the pushmi-pullyu agrees to travel with a circus to raise some funds. So the entire household sets off together. This book was a lot about the importance of animal comfort and care and was definitely ahead of its time in calling out circuses and the like for their treatment of animals. There were some fun moments (Dolittle getting ⬇

TheAromaofBooks (cont'd) arrested AGAIN 😂). The ending was quite abrupt, but it appears that book 5 is going to pick up right where this one left off.

#DolittleDiscussion @Roary47
#ISpyBingo - Horn/Antler, Feather, Boot
#GottaCatchEmAll - Character with Horns @PuddleJumper
#BookSpinBingo
2d
51 likes1 comment
blurb
willaful
Bad Reputation | Emma Barry
post image

A soft pick. I really enjoyed the details of intimacy coordination work and the characters reinventing themselves, but the slow burn romance fizzled out instead of blazing.

(Can't complain about three #ISpyBingo squares for my first book of the month though!)

blurb
Read4life
post image

I got 2 bingos on my April #ISpyBingo board.

TheAromaofBooks Woohoo!! Looking great!! 4d
47 likes1 comment
blurb
Julies_Bookshelf_Adventures
post image

Got bingo this month for #ispybingo ☺️
I‘m really enjoying this extra way to get some of my #mountTBR finished

TheAromaofBooks Woohoo!! Looking fabulous!! 1w
18 likes1 comment
blurb
Lauredhel
The Cartoonists Club: A Graphic Novel | Scott McCloud, Raina Telgemeier
post image

Another month down in #ISpyBingo #ISpy @TheAromaOfBooks

The Cartoonists Club was a fun read, part story of the formation of a new school club, part instructional book on making comics and zines, part Ms Frizzle style encouragement to budding artists and writers to “take chances! make mistakes! get messy!“

I love the librarian who facilitates the group meetings, she's great.

TheAromaofBooks Yay!! Looking great!! 1w
36 likes1 comment
blurb
Gissy
post image

January 2025
Read: 11 books (Knitt one kill two was a mistake😳 I just finished that book today)
Pages: 3,410
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️2 books
⭐️⭐️⭐️6 books
⭐️⭐️-2 books
Bingo- ✅just one line no bingo in #ISpyBingo I
#BookSpin
#DoubleSpin
Favorite Books: The Girl From the Grand Hotel and La Grieta Del Silencio

review
Gissy
Snow & Rose | Emily Winfield Martin
post image
Mehso-so

January 2025 Book #11
This retelling for me is poor integrating and even boring. I‘m not the target audience but didn‘t like it. However, the illustrations are beautiful made by the author. 2⭐️

Gissy #BookSpinBingo #20 (wanted to read it for a reading challenge) #ISpyBingo (leaves not in plant, here you see leaves in grass) @TheAromaOfBooks
#FairytaleReadingChallenge @Charityann
#ReadAThon #Read2025 @DieAReader
2w
DieAReader 👋🏻 #Next 2w
TheAromaofBooks Great progress!! 2w
48 likes3 comments
review
Gissy
post image
Pickpick

January 2025 Book #10
I know this one didn‘t work for everyone but it worked for me. I liked the idea of a novel within a novel. The drama in the novel aunt Addie wrote was so silly, maybe too long but I lol. It was like watching the movie Clue but without a murder. When you thought you had the answer another ridiculous situation appeared. It was fun but the ending also has nostalgic, sad moments for aunt Addie. I like these covers😍 3⭐️

LeahBergen Lovely review! I enjoyed it, too. 😊 2w
Ruthiella I‘m so glad you liked it! 😃 2w
See All 6 Comments
43 likes6 comments
review
Gissy
La grieta del silencio | Javier Castillo
post image
Pickpick

January 2025 Book #9
This is the conclusion (supposedly) of Mirren Triggs trilogy) I know first book is already translated (The Snow Girl) which is a Netflix series.
I liked the conclusion. At the end we see a mature Mirren who decides to make a choice in her relationship and life in general. The case in this story is so sad. A body was found with his “mouth sewn” and a father looking for his son who disappeared 30 years ago. 3.8/4⭐️

Gissy January 2025 Book #9 free title translation The Fissure of Silence

#BookSpinBingo #13 #Continuewithseries #ISpyBingo (author‘s name in black letters) @TheAromaOfBooks

#SeriesLove2025 @Andrew65 @TheSpineView

##ReadAThon #Read2025 @DieAReader
#GoodReadsAroundTheYear #ATY prompt #32 (mystery)
2w
Andrew65 Excellent 👏👏👏🎉 2w
See All 6 Comments
TheSpineView Fantastic! 2w
DieAReader 🥳🥳🥳 2w
TheAromaofBooks Woohoo!! 2w
44 likes6 comments