Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
The Hearts of Men
The Hearts of Men: A Novel | Nickolas Butler
An epic novel of intertwining friendships and families set in the Northwoods of Wisconsin at a beloved Boy Scout summer campfrom the bestselling author of Shotgun Lovesongs Camp Chippewa, 1962. Nelson Doughty, age thirteen, social outcast and overachiever, is the Bugler, sounding the reveille proudly each morning. Yet this particular summer marks the beginning of an uncertain and tenuous friendship with a popular boy named Jonathan. Over the years, Nelson, irrevocably scarred from the Vietnam War, becomes Scoutmaster of Camp Chippewa, while Jonathan marries, divorces, and turns his fathers business into a highly profitable company. And when something unthinkable happens at a camp get-together with Nelson as Scoutmaster and Jonathans teenage grandson and daughter-in-law as campers, the aftermath demonstrates the depthsand the limitsof Nelsons selflessness and bravery. The Hearts of Men is a sweeping, panoramic novel about the slippery definitions of good and evil, family and fidelity, the challenges and rewards of lifelong friendships, the bounds of moralityand redemption.
Amazon Indiebound Barnes and Noble WorldCat Goodreads LibraryThing
Pick icon
100%
review
staci.reads
The Hearts of Men: A Novel | Nickolas Butler
post image
Pickpick

I told a bookseller that I loved Shotgun Lovesongs and asked for her recommendation for my next Nickolas Butler. She recommended this one, and she didn't steer me wrong! I love his writing. As a Midwesterner, I feel he captures the setting so vividly. It's dark and moments are hard to read, but it's beautifully written.

SRWCF Looks like a lovely place to read. Enjoy! 3y
staci.reads @SRWCF thank you! 2y
63 likes2 comments
review
Cinfhen
The Hearts of Men: A Novel | Nickolas Butler
post image
Panpan

I somehow forgot to post a review of this book....I read it probably end of May beginning of June. #ReadingUSA2020 #Wisconsin 🇺🇸 Having read and loved Shotgun Love Songs , I had high hopes for this one, sadly it wasn‘t a book I‘ll remember. Really unlikeable characters and a weak plot line. I think the cover art was the best thing about this book. It pains me but this gets a Pan.

erzascarletbookgasm Aww, I liked Shotgun Love Songs. 😕 5y
Cinfhen I LOVED shotgun Love Songs so this book was SUCH A BIG disappointment @erzascarletbookgasm 5y
Sace The flowers on both your recent posts are "picks" so there's that. The books may be "pan" but the flowers are not. Sorry you had those two meh books though. Hope your next read is awesome. 5y
See All 6 Comments
Cinfhen Thanks @Sace flowers don‘t disappoint 💚💜thanks for noticing and your good wishes! I‘m in middle of a fun book but I have a bit of a migraine so I‘m not doing much reading/ listening today 🤕 5y
TrishB Hope migraine goes soon 😘 5y
85 likes6 comments
review
Saari84
Die Herzen der Mnner: Roman | Nickolas Butler
post image
Pickpick

Eine berührende Geschichte über Männer und über die Zwickmühle, wie sie zu sein haben. Dies war mein erstes Buch von Butler und ich mochte es wirklich sehr ❤️

review
erinjohns
The Hearts of Men: A Novel | Nickolas Butler
Mehso-so

I choose this book because of the camp theme. I didn't expect it to be so dark and chalked with the ugly evilness of men. So sad.

review
DocBrown
The Hearts of Men: A Novel | Nickolas Butler
post image
Pickpick

Well written & propulsive, it nevertheless loses focus going along. In that respect it reminds me of Smiley‘s Last Hundred Years trilogy. On the bubble between Pick and So-So, it compares unfavorably with my last book, Home Fire, which uses a similar narrative device of shifting POV. Not sure what kind of comment on 20th-c masculinity it offers, through the lens of the now quaint seeming Boy Scouts. Except that men need virtue now more than ever?

blurb
peaKnit
The Hearts of Men: A Novel | Nickolas Butler
post image

I actually gasped when I saw this deal, I ❤️ this local author. A steal!

NeeSwee ⬆️⬆️⬆️me too!! 7y
peaKnit @Cinfhen I loved Shotgun Lovesongs too! and I have seen him a couple of times, almost feel like a creeper😂 I can‘t help it. He is kind of WI cute too.😳 7y
See All 6 Comments
Cinfhen I think he‘s super cute too @peaknit i own this book but it‘s not grabbing me like the way Shotgun did @NeeSwee 7y
Christine Yes! Love this/him, too! (Though how could they ever use another cover but the perfect original paper doll scout one?!) 6y
peaKnit @Christine I agree! This is lovely but not as relative to the story somehow. 6y
21 likes6 comments
blurb
DennisJacobRosenfeld
The Hearts of Men: A Novel | Nickolas Butler
post image

So, I started reading this one last night and I‘m already absolutely taken with it. Butler writes beautifully and takes the classic coming-of-age elements and transforms this into something new and fresh. I find myself writing down passage after passage in my quote notebook.

Cinfhen I have this one....need to get to it. I HIGHLY recommend 7y
DennisJacobRosenfeld @Cinfhen thanks for the tip! I‘ve added it to my pile 😊 7y
12 likes2 comments
review
TheRiehlDeal
The Hearts of Men: A Novel | Nickolas Butler
post image
Mehso-so

I thought this book was alright. The author made you feel sympathetic about some of the characters when they were young, but when they grew up into men, they just seemed flat. The ending was kind of a disappointment for me. The author chose to use a strong female protagonist at the end of the novel in a heavily male-dominated story. But this book did have its strengths, though. Like, the writing and when the characters were still young.

blurb
TheRiehlDeal
The Hearts of Men: A Novel | Nickolas Butler
post image

Currently listening to this audiobook on #libby. It's pretty good so far. It's about a boy named Nelson who is a boy scout and is trying to earn the honor of being Scoutmaster. He forms a friendship with another fellow boy scout named Jonathan. Years later, when both are adults, something unthinkable happens.

18 likes1 stack add
review
ErickaS_Flyleafunfurled
The Hearts of Men: A Novel | Nickolas Butler
post image
Pickpick

Pick ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ The author explores what affects how boys grow into men, and also what men think actually makes them men. Several different characters show how honor or lack of honor, worship of women or disdain of women, make a man. I enjoyed this story. All told with the backdrop of Scouting and its relevance to changing societal norms. Intriguing work of literary fiction.

37 likes1 stack add
blurb
ErickaS_Flyleafunfurled
The Hearts of Men: A Novel | Nickolas Butler
post image

What‘s the opposite of a reading slump? A book boom? That‘s what I‘m in! All three of these are so good! 💥

Lissa00 Yes! I love the term “book boom” !That‘s a perfect description😄👍 7y
emilyhaldi Oooohh I just got this one from Book Outlet 👏🏻👏🏻 7y
ErickaS_Flyleafunfurled @Lissa00 Ha! Right?! It‘s such a rare thing!!! 7y
Reviewsbylola Book booms are the best! 7y
59 likes4 comments
review
OffTheBeatenShelf.com
The Hearts of Men: A Novel | Nickolas Butler
Pickpick

Wow, wow, wow. The story lagged a little in the middle, but the ending is one of the best I've read in a long time. It's a bit of a sausage fest and doesn't pass the Bechtel Test at all, but I'm really glad I read it. It's a fascinating look at the follies of toxic masculinity.

blurb
Bks4Wrms
The Hearts of Men: A Novel | Nickolas Butler
post image

I guess I‘m going as a stripper this year! 😳 #letthebookdecide #halloweencostumes

britt_brooke 😆 7y
MrBook I'd have to dress up as a professor. 😁👍🏻👍🏻 7y
See All 11 Comments
JoeStalksBeck @Bks4Wrms oh lord!! Lmao! 7y
SilversReviews A professor is good. I am a freckle-faced motorboat. 7y
Bks4Wrms @MrBook I‘m confident you can totally pull off the professor costume! 👨🏻‍🏫 7y
Bks4Wrms @britt_brooke @JoeStalksBeck I‘ll be the hit of the neighborhood when I take my kids trick or treating this year! 😜😝😳 7y
JoeStalksBeck Lmao! *cat call*😙😉 7y
britt_brooke 😆😆😆 7y
LauraBrook Did you go to the Half Price sale this weekend? 7y
Bks4Wrms @LauraBrook I thought about it but was too lazy 😳 and didn‘t want to go out in the rain. I guess I could have gone today but I have enough clutter! 😖 7y
22 likes11 comments
review
LibraryReads
The Hearts of Men: A Novel | Nickolas Butler
post image
Pickpick

A book a book group will love makes the March 2017 list. “In the summer of 1962, popular Jonathan & social outcast, Nelson, are friends. The only thing they seem to have in common is they spend a few weeks of one summer at Camp Chippewa in Wisconsin. Over time, their lives & the lives of loved ones are fiercely intertwined. This wonderful novel reveals layers of male friendship & shows what loyalty, compassion, & selflessness looks like."

2 likes1 stack add
review
Tillie
The Hearts of Men: A Novel | Nickolas Butler
post image
Pickpick

"Rock on Wisconsin!"

review
Reita325
The Hearts of Men: A Novel | Nickolas Butler
Pickpick

Intense. I cringed at times but truth and people can be grotesque in their ugliness.

blurb
peaKnit
The Hearts of Men: A Novel | Nickolas Butler
post image

An all American book on Independence Day! Love this author, for 3 bucks, get it:) 🇺🇸

Kshakal Thanks for the heads up... That is awesome! 7y
peaKnit @Kshakal you bet! I ❤️ this author, he is from my home State - WI, I might be biased!:) 7y
Kshakal @peaknit I am from Wisconsin too!!! And you are right, he is a great author! 7y
13 likes3 comments
blurb
AMVP
The Hearts of Men: A Novel | Nickolas Butler
post image

#junetunz day 27 - #mandown

Another theme I would've done on the day, but I couldn't remember the title and couldn't find it in stores. Finally had to trawl the #allthebooks archives for the episode where they talk about it.

blurb
CherylDeFranceschi
The Hearts of Men: A Novel | Nickolas Butler
post image

This is a moving story of family, fathers and sons, and love and forgiveness. Plus, this man is a charmer! #catsinthecradle #rockinmay

Cinfhen Gotta read this one!!! 8y
CherylDeFranceschi @Cinfhen I loved Shotgun, too. 8y
Cinfhen His storytelling blew me away! 8y
76 likes2 stack adds4 comments
blurb
Autolycus
The Hearts of Men: A Novel | Nickolas Butler
post image

4 likes1 stack add
review
kristinshafel
The Hearts of Men: A Novel | Nickolas Butler
post image
Pickpick

Despite the one main female character needing more 3D development, I liked Butler's latest a lot. It's about boys becoming men, parents and children, bravery and decency, romantic and platonic relationships changing you, and being a flawed human. Butler has a sensitive boice and his storytelling is immersive.

JenReadsAlot I met him last week at a book signing! He's great! 8y
kristinshafel @JenReadsAlot Awesome! It's hard for me to resist books set in my beloved homestate, Wisconsin 💚💛 8y
16 likes1 stack add2 comments
review
lauraisntwilder
The Hearts of Men: A Novel | Nickolas Butler
post image
Pickpick

I was totally immersed in this story of Boy Scouts, young and old, and what it means to "be prepared" and to be decent.

4 likes1 stack add
blurb
AvidReader25
The Hearts of Men: A Novel | Nickolas Butler
post image

I loved Shotgun Lovesongs by this author and so I'm excited about this one!

Coleen Me too! 8y
23 likes1 stack add1 comment
blurb
JenReadsAlot
The Hearts of Men: A Novel | Nickolas Butler
post image

Wonderful author! Great evening with @peaknit

blurb
peaKnit
The Hearts of Men: A Novel | Nickolas Butler
post image

And the Cubs were in the book, so Holy Cow indeed! Thanks Nikolas Butler, you are a rock star writer.

Bks4Wrms Isn't he from Wisconsin? Shouldn't it say "Go Brew Crew!" ?? 8y
peaKnit @Bks4Wrms oh, say it ain't so;) the Cubs get a small part, i felt like it was just for me😊 8y
Bks4Wrms I'm just kidding! That's really nice that he took the time to personalize the books, I'm jealous! Where was he doing a meet and greet? 8y
peaKnit @Bks4Wrms he was at the library in Lake Mills, 20 mins south of Madison. He was fantastic! 8y
13 likes4 comments
blurb
peaKnit
The Hearts of Men: A Novel | Nickolas Butler
post image

I melted into a big gushy book dork, but I love this man's books! He is a cool, quintessentially Wisconsin dude and I can't pimp his books enough. ❤️ thanks @JenReadsAlot for suggesting this photo😊

Flaneurette As (former) fellow cheesehead I approve of this post👍🏻 8y
22 likes1 comment
blurb
Pandalibrarian
The Hearts of Men: A Novel | Nickolas Butler
post image

Had the opportunity to meet Nickolas Butler lat an event today. He signed a boom for my dad - such a nice man and a great storyteller. I was in full author groupie mode today!

review
Well-ReadNeck
The Hearts of Men: A Novel | Nickolas Butler
post image
Bailedbailed

Listening on audiobook and I'm just losing interest. The writing is gorgeous but the story is just frustrating to me. I think I'm too female to get it 😉 Very much a man book (if you liked The Touchdown Special, you would enjoy this one, I think)

[pic from my walk today]

CocoReads Pretty! Life's too short to waste on a book you aren't enjoying 8y
Alwaysbeenaloverofbooks Beautiful 🌺🌸🌷 8y
merelybookish I had this from the library but decided not to read it. Had just finished White Tears and figured I wasn't in the mood for white boy problems. 😶 8y
See All 8 Comments
RealLifeReading Lovely! 8y
Well-ReadNeck @merelybookish probably a good call on your part 😉 8y
Megabooks Beautiful! 8y
TNbookworm Beautiful foxgloves! 8y
KellieRusselburg I can‘t get into it either. I might give it another try later. 6y
102 likes8 comments
review
Skybariline
The Hearts of Men: A Novel | Nickolas Butler
post image
Pickpick

Excellent insight into the masculine experience. The characters' interactions with others and participation in institutions such as the Boy Scouts shape them and also reveal just how close to the surface both the best and the worst of them can be. I haven't read Nickolas Butler before this, but I am now interested in reading more of his work.

Cinfhen You gotta read 8y
Chelsea.Poole Love shotgun lovesongs❤️🎵 8y
12 likes2 comments
blurb
Well-ReadNeck
The Hearts of Men: A Novel | Nickolas Butler
post image

#LyricalApril #AmericanBoy

Using my current audiobook for today's prompt. What says American Boy more than an Eagle Scout?! 🇺🇸

Reviewsbylola That's definitely a fitting choice! 8y
Cinfhen Excellent choice! I've been wanting to try this read....How's the book? I LOVED the author's previous novel 8y
Well-ReadNeck @Cinfhen I'm really enjoying it. His writing is just amazeballs!!! 8y
Cinfhen Yay! I was worried I wouldn't like this one as much 8y
StacksNShelves I loved this book. Glad you're enjoying it. 8y
107 likes3 stack adds5 comments
blurb
Freefallinmissy
The Hearts of Men: A Novel | Nickolas Butler
post image

Finally got my hands on this !

blurb
Freefallinmissy
The Hearts of Men: A Novel | Nickolas Butler
post image

Best email ever ! My hold is available!

blurb
Freefallinmissy
The Hearts of Men: A Novel | Nickolas Butler
post image

I can't wait to read this book - I Love love loved Shotgun Lovesongs.

blurb
Hoopiefoot
The Hearts of Men: A Novel | Nickolas Butler
post image

I'm already up past my bedtime but this book is so good I can't put it down.

merelybookish I have this from the library and was debating whether to start it or take it back... 8y
Hoopiefoot I think it's worth keeping if you have it a few more days. It's a pretty quick read. 8y
79 likes2 stack adds2 comments
blurb
readswellwithothers
The Hearts of Men: A Novel | Nickolas Butler
post image

I dropped off my trembling and confused dogchild at the vet for knee surgery this morning and, you guys, I am wrecked. He is my constant, my confidant, the one thing in my life that does not put into question my confidence or qualifications. The surgery is "routine," they say. But my routine is taking a hit today, and so is my heart. So, with my coffee this story I sit next to a group of laughing elderly ladies and try to end the pity party.

TrishB Hope all goes ok💖 8y
Litlady Sending extra good dog karma your way. 🙏🐶❤️🐾 8y
16 likes1 stack add2 comments
blurb
readswellwithothers
The Hearts of Men: A Novel | Nickolas Butler
post image

I cannot remember a character that I wanted to hug this much. Only on page 57 and I am deeply invested in Nelson. So much so that I am considering slapping a few Boy Scouts. (Reason #4527 that I do not have children.)

11 likes1 stack add
blurb
BookNAround
The Hearts of Men: A Novel | Nickolas Butler
post image

I really loved Shotgun Lovesongs a lot so I'm delighted to read this latest novel from Butler. Gatsby intends to sleep through my reading.

9 likes1 stack add
quote
MLRio
The Hearts of Men: A Novel | Nickolas Butler

And anyway, isn‘t this the reality of today‘s America? No one‘s marriage lasts; no one is innocent; and the Boy Scouts, like every other code of morality, is just an antiquated set of stone tablets, the words melting into obscurity, acid-washed by rain and returning stone to sand, until it is all just so much tiny particulate, forever shifting beneath our feet.

review
MLRio
The Hearts of Men: A Novel | Nickolas Butler
post image
Pickpick

Butler has a tender and compelling voice, which is the reason this book works. The narrative is loose enough that it feels more like a collection of short stories about people who happen to know each other than a novel, but the consistency of the tone, tenor, and quality of prose holds it all together. (Though implied by the title, it's worth noting that women are unapologetically sidelined here, acting only as lovers and mothers.) ⭐️⭐️⭐️1/2

quote
MLRio
The Hearts of Men: A Novel | Nickolas Butler

He has no idea where the boy even finds these books, where or how he buys them. This whole world Trevor dwells in, where love is still a reality, where people say NO! to drugs (instead of THANK YOU!), where mothers and fathers love one another, and Boy Scout camp is something to be excited about.

review
Christine
The Hearts of Men: A Novel | Nickolas Butler
post image
Pickpick

This is the second Nickolas Butler I have read and the second I have loved. He just writes so beautifully. And being Wisconsin-bred, I can't get enough of his settings. In this book, just when I was getting a bit tired of the (sometimes self-imposed) dramas of the generations of male protagonists, he shifted focus to a female character who won me over completely. The ending felt a little rushed/contrived to me, but overall I really liked the book.

37 likes2 stack adds
review
Jas16
The Hearts of Men: A Novel | Nickolas Butler
post image
Pickpick

This has turned out to be a good reading weekend. I really liked this book about three generations of Boy Scout camp attendees. No character is even close to perfect but I still hurt for them. Guess I will be seeking out Butler's backlist.

45 likes2 stack adds
quote
MLRio
The Hearts of Men: A Novel | Nickolas Butler

You don‘t think I know how the others tease you? I told you in the mess hall and don‘t you forget it: they tease you because they‘re afraid of you.

quote
MLRio
The Hearts of Men: A Novel | Nickolas Butler
post image

Just bury me alive with my feelings, it's fine

blurb
MLRio
The Hearts of Men: A Novel | Nickolas Butler
post image

Not bad for mid-March. #books #beer #booksandbooze

blurb
Christine
The Hearts of Men: A Novel | Nickolas Butler
post image

After a long week of more househunting/two rejected offers (and next to no reading, waaah!! 😭), we're treating ourselves to a day of rest, a little lowbrow culinary indulgence, and an already-so-good book (I'm just a few chapters in). 🏝🍔📚

saresmoore Here's to a better week ahead! And it's been too long since I had anything "animal style"—this looks delicious! 8y
Beckys_Books Good luck househunting! 8y
Christine @saresmoore Aww thanks! And haha yes - sometimes animal style hits the spot. 😋 8y
See All 6 Comments
Christine @Beckys_Books Thanks so much! It will happen when it's meant to, we figure. 8y
rachellayown Enjoy the downtime! And good luck! 8y
Christine @rachellayown It's bliss. 😉 And thanks so much!! 8y
47 likes4 stack adds6 comments