Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
The Man from the Train
The Man from the Train: The Solving of a Century-Old Serial Killer Mystery | Bill James, Rachel McCarthy James
Using unprecedented, dramatically compelling sleuthing techniques, legendary statistician and baseball writer Bill James applies his analytical acumen to crack an unsolved century-old mystery surrounding one of the deadliest serial killers in American history. Between 1898 and 1912, families across the country were bludgeoned in their sleep with the blunt side of an axe. Jewelry and valuables were left in plain sight, bodies were piled together, faces covered with cloth. Some of these cases, like the infamous Villasca, Iowa, murders, received national attention. But few people believed the crimes were related. And fewer still would realize that all of these families lived within walking distance to a train station. When celebrated baseball statistician and true crime expert Bill James first learned about these horrors, he began to investigate others that might fit the same pattern. Applying the same know-how he brings to his legendary baseball analysis, he empirically determined which crimes were committed by the same person. Then after sifting through thousands of local newspapers, court transcripts, and public records, he and his daughter Rachel made an astonishing discovery: they learned the true identity of this monstrous criminal. In turn, they uncovered one of the deadliest serial killers in America. Riveting and immersive, with writing as sharp as the cold side of an axe, The Man from the Train paints a vivid, psychologically perceptive portrait of America at the dawn of the twentieth century, when crime was regarded as a local problem, and opportunistic private detectives exploited a dysfunctional judicial system. James shows how these cultural factors enabled such an unspeakable series of crimes to occur, and his groundbreaking approach to true crime will convince skeptics, amaze aficionados, and change the way we view criminal history.
Amazon Indiebound Barnes and Noble WorldCat Goodreads LibraryThing
review
LoverOfLearning
post image
Pickpick

I appreciate some good sleuthing and a fresh perspective on unsolved murders and on some likely wrongful convictions. An interesting yet troubling recap of murders that occurred in the 1900s. Combining fact and research Bill James possibly identifies The Man from the Train.

This was long and repetitive via audiobook so I give this a 3.5 stars. But I mean the effort and research that went into this I respect so i give this a thumbs up. 💯

blurb
LoverOfLearning
post image

Wanting to finish this audiobook on Libby..... but wow it is long. It's been on the back burner for months and I just picked it back up again. It is very interesting but a bit repetitive.

I appreciate the speculation especially when it's surrounding unsolved crimes. A discussion on how many murders the man from the train committed across the us and how many wrongful arrests were made. Eye opening really!

40 likes2 stack adds
review
MsRadioSilence
post image
Panpan

I have major problems with this book that outweighs the minor things I liked about it, which was really disappointing. I wanted to like it, but after a time it just became something I had to finish reading through to move on to something better. Another swing and a miss recommendation from MFM.

Read my full review at: https://www.rainyreader.com/single-post/the-man-from-the-train (SPOILERS)

#mfmrec #disappointed #truecrime

HeathHof I bailed on this one🥴 2y
MsRadioSilence @Mynameisacolour i really wish i had 😭😭 2y
26 likes2 comments
blurb
MsRadioSilence
post image

Turns out I have exactly 300 books, haha. Unfortunately a little over 200 of them remain on my tbr. 😬 I think I‘m on a book buying ban, lol.

21 likes1 stack add
blurb
BookishMadHatter
post image
review
SaraHasClass
post image
Pickpick

Growing up near Villisca, Iowa, I was aware of the sensational murder of the Moore family (1912) who were bludgeoned to death with the blunt end of an ax. Heck, I toured the house. Here, within these pages I discover that this unsolved crime was most likely the work of a serial killer. This book is one with exceptional research, logical arguments and an interesting history of criminal justice in the early 1900s. Nonfiction. True Crime. History.

review
DieAReader
post image
Pickpick

#Challenge2021

⚠️⚠️⚠️TW WARNING

5⭐️

Even though I might have been slowed down a bit by the back & forth telling of the murders & years. I very much think it benefitted the reader to lay things out the way they did.

IamIamIam 👀 Haaaaaay!!!! 3y
CoverToCoverGirl Thanks for increasing my TBR piles! 😉 3y
DieAReader @IamIamIam CoverToCoverGirl (I was hoping you‘d stack this one😏) I absolutely love the way the authors speak directly to the reader, quite often might I add. I found it refreshing tbh & couldn‘t put it down! 3y
40 likes2 stack adds3 comments
quote
DieAReader
This post contains spoilers
show me
post image

#Challenge2021

Having lived by🚂🛤 (It was on the other side of the two lane road just over the ditch a couple feet😳) I can agree! Mom‘s poor China cabinet was never the same😬🤣 The house always shook & everything rattled long before we saw or heard the 🚂😂 Gotta say though, I strangely missed the disruption while living in NB🤷🏻‍♀️🤪

CoverToCoverGirl Little mini earthquakes everyday, and never mind the dinging at the crossing. Dale lived close to a crossing too. 3y
DieAReader @CoverToCoverGirl 🥰Yup, mini earthquakes! Thankfully no dinging cross near but many roads so lots of whistles🙃 3y
10 likes2 comments
quote
BookishMadHatter
post image

Apparently #baconmakeseverythingbetter

Okay ... I can officially say that I will henceforth do my best not to say bacon makes everything better because this will be what pops into my head and I don't need that image lol. I will be changing it to bacon makes all foods better. Why would anyone even think to try that???? What a waste of bacon

quote
BookishMadHatter
post image

Words matter and at times it can be all too easy to dictate the narrative. Sometimes you're damned if you do and damned if you don't

quote
BookishMadHatter
post image

At least they're upfront about it lol

quote
BookishMadHatter
post image
review
KateD1
post image
Mehso-so

I really don‘t know what to rate this book.
The story is interesting; they put a lot of research and work into it, and eventually figure out who the man from the train might have been.
On the other hand, it isn‘t my favorite writing style, and with so many murders mentioned, it‘s really hard to keep track of who is who.
#historical #murder #serialkiller

blurb
KateD1
post image

I started a new book.
The story is interesting. The writing, and the way it‘s written, is a bit confusing and all around not my favorite.

5 likes1 stack add
quote
BookishMadHatter
post image

Skeptical?

This might possibly be my new favorite paragraph from a book lol

blurb
BookishMadHatter
post image

Going to start this book to keep in the car when it's school pickup time. Gotta love that quote

review
deirdrebeecher
post image
Pickpick

This book needs a TW for everything, but I feel the James took pains to avoid it becoming murder-porn.

They bring together a huge amount of information and lay it out with its historical context in a very clean way. They don't need drama, the crimes themselves are so horrible, the villain so monstrous and many of the aftermaths so chilling that you need their matter of fact tone to ground you. Its one of the best non-fics I've read in ages.

review
K.Wielechowski
post image
Pickpick

Fascinating!
The James‘ examine some of America‘s most gruesome family murders at the turn of the century, proposing that they were all done by the same person: the man from the train, a serial killer who road the rails, killing people across the country with an ax.
This series of family murders include the Moore family, victims in Villisca, Iowa.
Tone is fairly casual and entertaining, keeping the historic events from being bland.

blurb
HeathHof
post image

I've been wanting to join an IRL book club and today I finally did. Looking forward to this one!

ljuliel I really liked this book and the way it was written was quite unique. 4y
53 likes1 stack add1 comment
review
pigeonsandcrows
post image
Pickpick

It's been a long time since a book creeped me out enough to keep me up at night... and it's nonfiction! Yikes! Thankfully distant history. I have been interested in some of the cases discussed in here for a long time, and I couldn't put this down. I am also extremely impressed with the amount of research that the authors put into this, and their emphasis on understanding the impact of time and place on the crimes and investigations.

ljuliel I really liked this one, and liked how the author almost talks directly to the reader in parts. It was different, but very good. I‘ve read books on Villisca , and I think one of them mentioned there‘d been a few other axe killings around the same time frame. 4y
pigeonsandcrows @ljuliel The one by Troy Taylor, Murdered in Their Beds, talked about a lot of the “subsection“ murders that the Jameses discuss, but the addition of all the other cases they uncovered in their research was so impressive to me. I got interested in Villisca a while back, and kept thinking it had to be a stranger and he couldn't have only done something like this once. So I have been excited to see more books that connect the dots! 4y
56 likes1 stack add2 comments
blurb
pigeonsandcrows
post image

Coming to my spooky read for the fall a bit late!

veritysalter This looks interesting, I‘m stacking it📚x 4y
45 likes2 stack adds1 comment
quote
Pageturner2
post image

It has been taking me awhile to get through this book, it keeps jumping around and then veering off in a different direction.

StillLookingForCarmenSanDiego Welcome to Litsy 💚📚💚 4y
LauraJ Welcome! I hope you enjoy Litsy 🖤 4y
CoffeeNBooks Welcome to Litsy! 📚 4y
5 likes3 comments
blurb
Minimalgrl
post image

New audio book download from King County Library.... some true crime for an afternoon walk ....
#truecrime #audiobook #litsywalker #walk

review
Chelsea.Poole
post image
Bailedbailed

Started two #audiobook titles this morning that I have been waiting on from the library for months. It was a "no" to both of them. Returned one right after the other. ? hate it when that happens! At least I figured out they were not for me right off the bat. Thanks to the reviewers on Litsy who helped me make my decisions! On to the next one!

MallenNC I tried to read The Editor but didn‘t get too far. I wanted to like it so I may try it again sometime. 5y
cathysaid Happens to me as well. I‘ll check out a couple in a row that I don‘t like, then I‘ll start checking out other subpar books out of desperation to have one to listen to on my commute. Ten books later I usually land on one I like 😬 5y
68 likes2 comments
blurb
AutumnRLS
post image

Is it weird that my true crime and food writing ended up on the same shelf?

review
Tamra
post image
Panpan

I‘ve never felt like an author had such disdain for readers. 😧 There was one section with a childish diatribe against readers who might believe lives in bygone eras are boring. I was listening to the audio and was momentarily confused thinking the book got switched or something it so odd. Then there was the chapter for the skeptic midway, which came off hostile & defensive, like he was expecting a lot of push back. Weird audio experience.

Tamra It also got so incredibly detailed on each and every case in the middle that I skipped 5 chapters to get to the point where he started to pull them together. It was fine doing so because he outlines them in the beginning. This could have been much shorter and thus more cohesive. (edited) 5y
Texreader Ugh!! Thanks for an honest review!! 5y
Tamra @Texreader this was probably a really interesting article, but fleshed out for a book it just got bogged down. The end was interesting as the authors began to explain why they tied the cases to one identified person. But, still the tone was off putting as a whole. It could just be me! 🥴 (edited) 5y
See All 12 Comments
Crazeedi The title sounds like it'd be a great book, sad to hear it didn't live up to expectations . I hate when that happens 5y
Tamra @Crazeedi I think the subject is fascinating! I think it‘s probably worth checking out, just feel free to skip ahead. 5y
Kaye Oddly , I liked this book a lot. Even the way the guy tells the story. It was really different than normal true crime books. Maybe that‘s why I liked it. 😁 5y
Tamra @kaye you are right, it was quite different than other true crime tellings, from what I can tell. I haven‘t read a lot of them. It certainly is a fascinating and scary set of murders! 😱 Gruesome and so inhuman. I kept wondering how he could have put a sheet over them before bludgeoning them and get into so many unfamiliar homes w/o being detected. I‘m glad we have a dog! 5y
Hestapleton Yeah I had really similar feelings on this book. The tone was NOT working for me. 5y
Crazeedi @Tamra thanks! 5y
Crazeedi @kaye yes everyone has different tastes, that's what make life so interesting! I will check it out! 5y
Tamra @Hestapleton ok, I‘m glad it wasn‘t just me. 😅 5y
Tamra @Crazeedi 👍🏾 5y
94 likes1 stack add12 comments
review
Hestapleton
post image
Mehso-so

I really wanted to like this book, but unfortunately, it didn‘t work for me on a lot of levels. Check out the review on my blog for the full story! ⭐️⭐️⭐️
https://talkbookswithme.home.blog/2019/01/07/the-man-from-the-train-3-5/

review
Rissa1
post image
Bailedbailed

I wanted to love this book. I DID NOT love this book. I usually don't bail on books, but this was due back and for 2 days I would push this aside and read everything else.

blurb
Rissa1
post image

My husband is a brave man and took our children to the store, I am listening to this audiobook, and staring out the window at my light projector shining through the trees.

blurb
Rissa1
post image

I just started this while I was in the shower. I don't want to stop! John Bedford Lloyd's voice is perfection for this book.🎧📖

6 likes2 stack adds
review
Loralie
Mehso-so

Wow. I wish I had one tenth of the confidence this author had. If you disagree you are wrong & he is also pretty condescending. I also think that this could have benefited from at the very least a timeline listed somewhere. The sheer number of murders got confusing. That said, it was interesting how the authors connected murderers, whether they were right or not.

blurb
Blair_Reads
post image

Loving these puppy snuggles tonight with Miss Daisy. 💜

tammysue What a pretty girl! 💕 6y
65 likes1 comment
blurb
Blair_Reads
post image

Evening reading complete with 🛀

Grrlbrarian Ooh give us a review when you‘re done! 6y
Monica5 Yes please do. Looks interesting. 6y
68 likes4 stack adds2 comments
blurb
aprilpohren
post image

@nelehelen oh my goodness, I LOVE everything!! How fun! Thank you so very very much for everything...it is all so perfect! The hat is adorable and so fun! I can't wait to dive into everything!!
#itstrulycriminalswap @JenlovesJT47 thank you so much for putting this swap together!!

nelehelen Yay! I‘m so glad you like everything! I thought the hat would be useful for summer. It‘s all about sun protection! 😉 6y
JenlovesJT47 Awesome!!💚💚💚 6y
41 likes2 comments
review
Bookzombie
post image
Pickpick

Book 1 of #24in48 - I found this book fascinating. It‘s not only about a series of possibly connected murders (and some that aren‘t connected), but also about how the United States was changing during the period of time covered. I enjoyed that it often felt like the authors were having a conversation with you about the case they were building. #nonfictionchallenge2018

73 likes3 stack adds
blurb
Bookzombie
post image

Here is my #24in48 stack, plus I have two audiobooks in progress. The top two books are also in progress. I‘m sure I won‘t get to them all but I like options. I also might detour from the stack if the mood strikes. I‘m so excited to start! Just a little under 15 minutes to go! #tbr #readathon 💃🏼🎉📚⏱

vivastory Good choices! Happy readathon! 🎉🤘📚 6y
Bookzombie @vivastory Thank you! You too! 🎉📚 6y
TheLibrarian Meddling Kids is fun! 6y
61 likes3 comments
review
GoldenGirl
Mehso-so

This book kept me up late learning all these poor murdered families' names. I have to say, it gets a bit boring as the author walks you thru the history of DNA and fingerprinting, but the fact that they solved the crime is amazing!

blurb
GoldenGirl
post image

Man. I have had a slooowww reading month since about the end of May. I've hardly read at all this month. Still working thru book 4 of GoT and The Gunslinger. Just grabbed this one 👆 from the library, hoping it'll pull me out of my slump!

19 likes1 stack add
blurb
TheBookkeepersApprentice
post image

When your friend knows just the surprise present to send you to cheer you up 😄❤️ #murderino #truecrime #currentlyreading #nonfiction #mounttbrreadathon (I‘m planning to finish this book today so I promise I will stop taking pictures of it 😄)

blurb
TheBookkeepersApprentice
post image

A cozy comfy Saturday night-a great book, a peaceful-smelling candle, and warm milk with vanilla and honey in one of my favorite mugs 😊 #mounttbrreadathon

BookMaven407 Great mug! 6y
TheBookkeepersApprentice @BookMaven407 thanks! It was a present from my brother and my sister-in-law 😊 6y
mrozzz I have that saying on a hoodie!! 👌🏻 6y
See All 6 Comments
TheBookkeepersApprentice @mrozzz that is awesome! I would love to have it on a piece of clothing too! 6y
BibliophileMomma 😍 that mug. 6y
TheBookkeepersApprentice @Tiffy_Reads my amazing brother and sister-in-law surprised me with it for my birthday last year 🤗 6y
26 likes6 comments
blurb
TheBookkeepersApprentice
post image

This book is just so good I can‘t stop taking pictures of it! I love James‘ wry & really intelligent take on #truecrime (seriously, if you haven‘t read Popular Crime you need to). Don‘t be put off by the fact that he is a statistician by trade, I am not a math person and I love his books. He doesn‘t throw math formulas at you or anything like that, his background allows him to bring a really unique analytical nature to the way he looks at crimes.

blurb
TheBookkeepersApprentice
post image

Loving reading this on my train ride-if you love true crime, you should definitely check out Bill James! #truecrime #currentlyreading

EvieBee Is it creepy?! I do love that in true crime. (edited) 6y
TheBookkeepersApprentice @EvieBee it definitely is creepy 6y
12 likes1 stack add2 comments
blurb
TheBookkeepersApprentice
post image

Reading The Man on the Train while on the train 😉😊🚊 So excited to finally read this, I loved James‘ Popular Crime! #truecrime #currentlyreading

12 likes1 stack add
blurb
Leelee08
post image

Starting the year off with a little true crime.....

Mdargusch I‘m stacking! This sounds like the same person that killed in 6y
KimHM I‘m beyond excited to add this to my TBR 📚! I read his earlier compendium of true crime cases and really enjoyed it. I can‘t believe I missed this! Thanks for posting ⭐️⭐️⭐️ 6y
70 likes9 stack adds2 comments
blurb
bio_chem06
post image

It took me 18 months to find full time work since moving back to Ohio from Chicago, but I wouldn't say I didnt take advantage of my time. 📚🔖
#readersgonnaread #hereistofulltimeemployement #finally

rubyslippersreads 🎉📚🎉📚🎉🎉🎉 6y
9 likes1 comment
review
Jen2
post image
Pickpick

Fascinating!!!

106 likes8 stack adds
blurb
queerbookreader
post image

In today's WSJ book reviews: -The Man From the Train- by Bill and Rachel James. True Crime book basically about this string of murders along the railroad system around turn of the 20th century. The author theorized that this one murder of a family was connected to a bigger picture, thus his investigation was born. Sounds creepy af 😳 and he uses lots of stats cos he's a baseball stat guru. Yay. Suitable reading for October 👻 #truecrime

BekahB I saw this at Barnes and Noble yesterday and was so close to buying it! I'll have see if my library has it. 😀 7y
Dorianna This book is right up my alley. 7y
dylanisreading This is right up my alley, too. Thanks for sharing! 7y
46 likes4 stack adds3 comments