Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
Pretty Girls
Pretty Girls | Karin Slaughter
Amazon Indiebound Barnes and Noble WorldCat Goodreads LibraryThing
Pick icon
100%
review
angel1
Pretty Girls: A Novel | Karin Slaughter
post image
Pickpick

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️/5
When your book matches your new reading chair!😍
This was intense and disturbing but also so good!!
Definitely check the trigger warnings before reading.

review
ToniSwinehart6
Pretty Girls: A Novel | Karin Slaughter
post image
Pickpick

This book was surprising. While you should heed the trigger warnings, I didn't find it as bad as some people were saying. I found that I couldn't put the book down; it was quite thrilling, and I was never sure where the next twist would be.

blurb
Lauranahe
Pretty Girls | Karin Slaughter
post image

This one took the top spot for June!

15 likes1 stack add
review
Lauranahe
Pretty Girls: A Novel | Karin Slaughter
post image
Pickpick

I was not expecting how dark this book got. It was a fast read, but I was invested in the characters and cared about what happened to them. Very well written with a satisfying ending. But damn it went to a dark place.

review
Cjbesh
Pretty Girls: A Novel | Karin Slaughter
Pickpick

Fast read for me. I kept feeling like I read this book before but pretty sure I hadn‘t. May just be very similar storyline in another book I have read.

review
SanjanaGhosh
Pretty Girls: A Novel | Karin Slaughter
post image
Pickpick

“Optimism is a sliver of glass in your heart.”

Spent the night and the whole day today finishing this horrific yet a real page turner.

P for A to Z challenge!

Also please recommend books to read starting with Q!!!

wanderinglynn I thought the story‘s organization was a disjointed but overall, an interesting story. 7mo
wanderinglynn Another one, also nonfiction, & I thought this one was well presented: 7mo
Cosmos_Moon_River @wanderinglynn I was going to mention Quiet, as well… went through my “read” list and this was my only Q. It was a good nonfiction about the power of introversion. 7mo
SanjanaGhosh @wanderinglynn @Cosmos_Moon Thank you, have decided to go with Quiet ♥️ 7mo
21 likes4 comments
blurb
Kshakal
Pretty Girls: A Novel | Karin Slaughter
post image
Alwaysbeenaloverofbooks Great choices 🔪🩸🙌🏻 8mo
Eggs Well done 👍🏼 🖤 💀 8mo
40 likes2 comments
review
PageShifter
Pretty Girls: A Novel | Karin Slaughter
post image
Pickpick

I loved characters so much! I rooted for them and hoped they would survive. Characters were well created and I loved how I couldn't know who were trustworthy and who weren't.

This had one brilliant twist and was super captivating.

Horrible but enjoyable thrilling to read!

review
BookBabe2018
Pretty Girls: A Novel | Karin Slaughter
post image
Pickpick

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ this book locked me in from very early on. I was not expecting it to be so graphic and triggering; but wow what a tale. At times it was hard to read, but I continued to grasp for more information and to learn what really happened. Definitely beware of graphic scenes, but if you like an intense thriller…give it a go!

review
alecia3dixie
Pretty Girls: A Novel | Karin Slaughter
post image
Pickpick

This book was really good! My jaw definitely dropped a few times! The middle started to really drag, though. Did not need to be this long of a book. Also, I would stay away from the audiobook. The way the author pronounced words that started with a wh.... kept reminding me of the episode of Family Guy when Stewie pronounced cool whip... 4/5

blurb
H_SQUARED
Pretty Girls: A Novel | Karin Slaughter
post image

This is my first Karin Slaughter book, and holy shit… I cannot unsee what I read in this book. Im going to have nightmares for weeks. Are they all like this? She‘s a fantastic writer, but I‘m kind of scared to start another one!!

BooksNBowls This is my next read 🥲 13mo
H_SQUARED It‘s a doozy! 11mo
5 likes2 comments
blurb
Alwaysbeenaloverofbooks
Pretty Girls: A Novel | Karin Slaughter
post image

I had to recycle a pic because I gave this one away! It was so #dark and creepy with so many trigger warnings! I just really wanted it out of my house 😫🤣

#AutumnPlease

Mimi28 Good news! It says your package has been delivered!! It‘s a medium sized gold padded envelope 13mo
dabbe Perfect nail matching! 🤩🤩🤩 13mo
AnnCrystal Oh, I've done that.... except I donate. 13mo
See All 7 Comments
Alwaysbeenaloverofbooks @AnnCrystal I have a home library so I keep most of them, but I share with Littens when I can 📚🤓 13mo
Eggs ‘Dark‘ can sometimes be ‘Too Dark‘ 13mo
53 likes7 comments
review
Traci1
Pretty Girls | Karin Slaughter
post image
Pickpick

⭐️⭐️⭐️1/2
Low pick mostly because while I felt compelled to keep reading, some of the content just felt like too much. Audio was well done. Her voices were very distinct and easy to identify.
2,581 points #scarathlon #spookyghostclub @Clwojick (11hours*6thons) 191 words
#rushathon #31by31 #bookspin #falling4books #listenlisten #popupsaturday @Andrew65 @GHABI4ROSES @DieAReader @Catsandbooks @TheAromaofBooks @Read4life @aperfectmjk @AmandaBlaze

AmandaBlaze Great job! 14mo
Catsandbooks 👍🏼🐈‍⬛💜 14mo
Read4life 🍁👻🎃 14mo
Clwojick Great job! 14mo
TheAromaofBooks Woohoo!! 14mo
52 likes5 comments
blurb
ladym30
Pretty Girls: A Novel | Karin Slaughter
post image

This book is really good!!!

Clwojick SO DARK. But SO GOOD! 🖤 14mo
26 likes1 stack add1 comment
review
Jgacreations
Pretty Girls: A Novel | Karin Slaughter
post image
Pickpick

This was fantastic. Dark and sad at times

review
ImperfectCJ
Pretty Girls: A Novel | Karin Slaughter
post image
Mehso-so

I can't quite figure out why I keep reading Karin Slaughter's novels. They're like cheap appetizers at a party...I don't really like them, but I keep picking them up. This is a particularly harsh book with a combination of predictable twists and twists that made me cock an eyebrow.

SamAnne I‘m no fan. 1y
49 likes1 comment
review
Bookish.SAM
Pretty Girls: A Novel | Karin Slaughter
post image
Pickpick

Well… that was all kinds of horrific, but definitely a page-turner.
I think I need to take a little breather from Karin Slaughter‘s mayhem.

KathyWheeler While I liked this book, I never recommend it to anyone without giving them all kinds of content warnings (and I honestly rarely think about warnings at all with other books). 1y
Bookish.SAM @KathyWheeler Agreed! Not sure this would be an easy recommendation for anyone 1y
KathyWheeler @Bookish.SAM I don‘t think so either! 1y
33 likes3 comments
review
HotMessJess
Pretty Girls: A Novel | Karin Slaughter
post image
Pickpick

Not sure what possessed me, but I‘ve powered through FOUR books in the last seven days and it felt good. Big trigger warning for my Litsy friends: This is gruesome to say the very least, but an excellent thriller that kept me on my seat (even if the twists were easily spotted). 4/5 ⭐️

TrishB If there‘s one thing you can rely on with Slaughter it‘s gruesome! 1y
HotMessJess @TrishB I verbal announced “what the f***” a few times. But yes, GRUESOME 1y
28 likes2 comments
review
Alwaysbeenaloverofbooks
Pretty Girls: A Novel | Karin Slaughter
post image
Pickpick

Check out this review on Fable
https://fable.co/review/12b8bc24-e76b-42b1-aaea-bfdcceeeecd3

This is in between a pick and so-so… I don‘t recommend it unless you have checked all of the trigger warnings ⚠️

#LitsyLoveReads

Octoberwoman The only book I‘ve read by Slaughter. I liked her writing style but it was a little horrifying. 2y
Alwaysbeenaloverofbooks @Octoberwoman I read The Good Daughter and it wasn‘t this bad! I almost feel a little traumatized 😱 2y
KathyWheeler Of all the books I‘ve read by her, this one was the most graphic. I generally don‘t think about content warnings, but I always warn people about this one. 2y
Alwaysbeenaloverofbooks @KathyWheeler yeah I‘m not going to recommend it to anyone! I‘m giving this one away, but I made sure she was ok with multiple trigger warnings! I want it out of my house 😵‍💫😵🤣 2y
KathyWheeler @Alwaysbeenaloverofbooks I completely understand! 2y
70 likes1 stack add5 comments
quote
Alwaysbeenaloverofbooks
Pretty Girls: A Novel | Karin Slaughter
post image

“Optimism is a sliver of glass in your heart.”

Dinner and a book 📚 🥗

Bklover Oooh what is that deliciousness! 2y
Alwaysbeenaloverofbooks @Bklover haha! It‘s salad 🥗 with too much ranch! I‘m trying to eat a little better 🥴 2y
Bklover I had a chef salad yesterday at a restaurant and when I asked for more ranch she said “oh, I put a shit ton of ranch on my salad too”. So I guess I‘m at the shit-ton level. No apologies though. It‘s magical stuff. ❤️ 2y
See All 7 Comments
Alwaysbeenaloverofbooks @Bklover 😂😂 I need a shit ton too!! 2y
MaureenMc At first glance, I thought it was a cinnamon roll. 😄 I love ranch dressing, too. 😁 2y
Alwaysbeenaloverofbooks @MaureenMc haha!! That would be better!! 2y
Bklover @MaureenMc I could certainly eat a cinnamon roll right now too!! 2y
65 likes7 comments
blurb
Alwaysbeenaloverofbooks
Pretty Girls | Karin Slaughter
post image

Happy Hump day!! This drink is so good! Sitting at therapy trying to read this creepy book!! 😱📚

This book should come with a trigger warning on the dust jacket! It‘s pretty graphic and violent 🥴

H_SQUARED Good thing you had therapy lined up right after. Holy crap. 13mo
Alwaysbeenaloverofbooks @H_SQUARED it was my husband‘s physical therapy 🤣 13mo
64 likes1 stack add2 comments
blurb
Alwaysbeenaloverofbooks
Pretty Girls: A Novel | Karin Slaughter
post image

The weather is fitting for this book! 🌧️

Reading this with a group on Fable 📚 I love being able to discuss it 🖤

#LitsyLoveReads

Check out Thriller Lovers Book Club on Fable! We‘re reading Pretty Girls. Join us!
https://fable.co/club/thriller-lovers-book-club-with-sydney-405036205025

HeatherBlue This book creeped me out so hard!! I listened to it and got so freaked out one night, I had my husband meet me in our parking garage and walk me inside 😂 2y
Alwaysbeenaloverofbooks @HeatherBlue oh my gosh!! I‘m only on chapter 4! The video on the husband‘s computer made my mouth drop 😳😵 2y
5feet.of.fury LOVE this book! 2y
Alwaysbeenaloverofbooks @5feet.of.fury I couldn‘t sleep last night and I think it was this book 😱 2y
69 likes1 stack add4 comments
blurb
Toasty_Applejack
Pretty Girls: A Novel | Karin Slaughter
post image

Alwaysbeenaloverofbooks Welcome to Litsy!!! 📚🎉🎊📚🎉🎊 2y
2 likes2 comments
quote
Toasty_Applejack
Pretty Girls: A Novel | Karin Slaughter
post image

“Optimism is a sliver of glass in your heart.”

review
LitStephanie
Pretty Girls: A Novel | Karin Slaughter
Bailedbailed

I just couldn't get into this one. A woman's husband is murdered and she discovers he was involved with videos of women being tortured and murdered. She and her sister, the other main character, are not very likeable, and the scenes seem too drawn out and slow. It is also pretty predictable (I checked at over halfway to confirm) Maybe if I were reading it instead of listening, I could have skimmed some and made it farther, but I bailed at 20%.

SamAnne Same with this one. 2y
10 likes1 comment
blurb
BoleyBooks
Pretty Girls: A Novel | Karin Slaughter
post image

Tackle the TBR 🤓📚 #boleybooks #prettygirls #karinslaughter #bookbeast #bookjoy #bookbuds #bookchat
What are you reading? 😊

ShelleyBooksie Good book but really dark. 2y
KathyWheeler I loved this book but I couldn‘t read it at night. It‘s quite dark and pretty graphic. 2y
BoleyBooks @ShelleyBooksie yes, I agree. She did not sugar coat the violence. 2y
See All 7 Comments
BoleyBooks @KathyWheeler yes. There were some pretty intense moments. It was a chilling read. 2y
KathyWheeler @BoleyBooks It‘s really been the only one of hers that I couldn‘t read at night. 2y
Alwaysbeenaloverofbooks @KathyWheeler I couldn‘t sleep last night and this book is probably to blame! 2y
35 likes1 stack add7 comments
quote
MatchlessMarie
Pretty Girls: A Novel | Karin Slaughter
post image

Tagged book is my February #BookSpin 🕵🏻‍♀️ #Investigate #ScaryFebruary

blurb
Maggie4483
Pretty Girls: A Novel | Karin Slaughter
post image

I‘m going to play this year! Thank you @chasjjlee for putting this together!

#2023ReadingBracket

review
Maggie4483
Pretty Girls: A Novel | Karin Slaughter
post image
Pickpick

This probably would have only been 4 stars - a little too twistED yet somehow not twistY enough, if that makes sense. But that last chapter/epilogue was so heartbreakingly beautiful that it earned a little extra credit.

review
anniebannanie
Pretty Girls: A Novel | Karin Slaughter
Pickpick

I was gasping the entire time!

review
BeckyWithTheGoodBooks
Pretty Girls: A Novel | Karin Slaughter
post image
Pickpick

Slaughter writes some of the darkest shit I‘ve ever read, and I‘ll read every word. This gripping thriller kept me on the edge of my seat, broke my heart, and sewed it back together again. The best thing about this was the badass female characters. Smart, capable, and relentless, these woman leapt off the page. Trigger warnings for everything, but the real story here is the pursuit of the truth. No matter how horrifying, it will set you free. 5⭐️

Kappadeemom I loved it! 2y
5feet.of.fury I loved this one too! 2y
BeckyWithTheGoodBooks @Kappadeemom @5feet.of.fury It‘s so good! 2y
20 likes3 comments
review
Gizmo86
Pretty Girls: A Novel | Karin Slaughter
Pickpick

Another amazing story, full of intrigue and good characters. Loved how twisted the story was. Some of the chapters written from the father's perspective were irritating but I just skipped them in the end. Loved the book overall.

review
MelKelsey
Pretty Girls: A Novel | Karin Slaughter
post image
Pickpick

Book 142

I listened to Pretty Girls, another dark and disturbing novel by Karin Slaughter about abduction and violent rape and murder. It's elaborate and lengthy, but, overall, it's a well-done suspense with some surprises. Enjoyable but not for the sensitive reader. 3.5

quote
Gizmo86
Pretty Girls: A Novel | Karin Slaughter
post image

blurb
Gizmo86
Pretty Girls: A Novel | Karin Slaughter
post image

My last inspired my next 😀🤓📚

5feet.of.fury Ooooh! I loved this one! 2y
18 likes1 comment
review
BookMaven9
Pretty Girls: A Novel | Karin Slaughter
post image
Pickpick

🌟🌟🌟🌟A solid dark and twisty thriller for sure. I almost gave it 5 stars but the ending sort of fell apart and ended fell towards typical tropes. Other than that it‘s a rapid fire Paige turner and not for the feint of heart..

blurb
Billie84
Pretty Girls: A Novel | Karin Slaughter
post image

Starting this today

review
Jennaree3
Pretty Girls: A Novel | Karin Slaughter
Panpan

This book was so gruesome. It actually made me feel physical revulsion enough to quit with about 20 pages left. I like murder mysteries as much as the next person but this was twisted. 3/10

blurb
BookLineNSinker
Pretty Girls: A Novel | Karin Slaughter
post image

I'm going through my Audible library and making a re- read/listen list and this is one I didn't know I had in my library. I actually didn't realize how many unread/listened to books I have. I have 167 books in my Audible library and many are due for a second go!

20 likes1 stack add
review
Bec_lectic
Pretty Girls: A Novel | Karin Slaughter
post image
Pickpick

Whoa this book was a little deep in the dark side of humanity. This is the first book by Slaughter that I‘ve read so not sure if she normally writes about such disturbing subjects? I felt the story started out a little slow but definitely picked up in the middle with a few good twists I didn‘t see coming. This one may not be for everyone but if you have a tolerance for disturbing subject matter, I recommend!

5feet.of.fury Yeah she‘s pretty twisted. Some of her other books/series get some relief in the form of romance or character interactions. But they are all graphic and dark. 3y
Bec_lectic @5feet.of.fury haha good to know! Not that I mind twisted but sometimes you have to be in the mood for such dark subjects. 3y
45 likes2 comments
review
5feet.of.fury
Pretty Girls: A Novel | Karin Slaughter
post image
Pickpick

This is dark. A story of a family who is utterly broken after the disappearance of their oldest daughter/sister decades ago. While a similar disappearance makes the news, The family is brought together unexpectedly when a tragedy befalls the youngest daughter. However nothing is as it appears, and they don‘t know who they can trust.

Impeccable writing, the characters, the conspiracy. The pacing had me unable to put it down. Horrifying. Wonderful

quote
5feet.of.fury
Pretty Girls: A Novel | Karin Slaughter
post image

🧛🏻‍♀️

kplovesbooks 🤣🤣🤣 3y
16 likes1 comment
blurb
5feet.of.fury
Pretty Girls: A Novel | Karin Slaughter
post image

Rainy day October vibes
#blackcat
#blanketfort
#murder

monalyisha Your tags. 😅🙈 3y
14 likes1 comment
review
Annie1215
Pretty Girls: A Novel | Karin Slaughter
post image
Pickpick

SO GOOD!

Despite my propensity for true crime, this is my first Karin Slaughter book and it totally delivered.

Such a great plot and character build out.

Checking this off my #bookspinbingo list

TheAromaofBooks Yay!!! 3y
GinaKButler I love her Will Trent series, too! 3y
71 likes1 stack add2 comments
review
TamTracy
Pretty Girls: A Novel | Karin Slaughter
post image
Pickpick

I was shocked by the gruesome details and dark nature of this book. I was warned and can understand that it might be graphic for some people. I happened to love the twists and turns and overall story. It kept me on my toes and wondering how it would end. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

CoverToCoverGirl This was my very first Slaughter novel.. It was/is the darkest book I‘ve read to date…. I have since gone to read all of her books. 3y
59 likes2 stack adds1 comment
review
Bubblebelle
Pretty Girls: A Novel | Karin Slaughter
Pickpick

This book explores some pretty bleak aspects of humanity. Its conspiracies sometimes were more complicated than I could be bothered to keep up with and it also occasionally suffered for being told from multiple perspectives, but overall it was a good read. Just be warned though that it does explore graphic depictions of sexual violence.

review
DarkMina
Pretty Girls: A Novel | Karin Slaughter
post image
Pickpick

125 of 2021. #awesomeaugust #readathon

Wow! This is pretty dark and the worst part is there are people like this in the world. A true look at the evil people are capable of. I thought the way the story unfolded was excellent. I couldn‘t put it down. Definitely some difficult topics in this book. Just a warning.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Andrew65 Well done 👏👏👏 3y
20 likes1 comment
review
Tracey3
Pretty Girls: A Novel | Karin Slaughter
post image
Pickpick

My first foray into audiobooks now that I have a longer commute to work. I was not disappointed. I had a little trouble keeping track of the characters at first, but it was short-lived. The characters are not necessarily the most likable and it takes awhile before you understand the way in which the characters‘ stories intersect. At times, Karin provides TMI with the crime and the goriness of the violence, but I was hooked!!

blurb
Laughterhp
Pretty Girls | Karin Slaughter
post image

**Book Giveaway**

Does anyone want some Karin Slaughter books? Her books are too dark and gritty for me. I‘m trying to clear out my shelves and I don‘t think all the books will fit in the LFL!

US only (sorry!)

#bookgiveaway

CaffeineAndCandy Yes! 🙌🏽 I had no idea she had so many books! 💜💜💜 4y
Drnkpnkprincess She is my favorite author! I‘ll buy them off you 🤣🤣 4y
HOTPock3tt I tried one and they are too dark and gritty for me as well 😅😅😅 4y
See All 16 Comments
Laughterhp @CaffeineAndCandy @Drnkpnkprincess You guys can fight over which ones you each want! I can send both of you 2 if you want. And you don‘t have to pay, they are all used, so not 100% best condition. 4y
CaffeineAndCandy Are you giving away the others as well? @Drnkpnkprincess is welcome to the Slaughter books. 4y
Laughterhp @CaffeineAndCandy Yes. The other 2 shown I am giving away as well. The Lost Man and Arsenic and Adobo. 4y
Drnkpnkprincess Ahahaha- no fighting from me! I‘ve read all of those Slaughters so anyone who hasn‘t is more than welcome to take first. I just wanted to add to my collection. Keep me posted! I‘m sure there will be other offers. 4y
CaffeineAndCandy If you want them for your collection I totally understand. I haven‘t read any of the Slaughters @Drnkpnkprincess I‘m happy with the others though. 4y
Pageturner1 Yes! Fan of hers. If you have any left. 😁 4y
LapReader What did you think of the Australian book? 4y
Laughterhp @LapReader I haven‘t read it yet. I just have 2 copies so I‘m giving one away. I love Jane Harper though, so I‘m hoping to love it. 4y
Laughterhp @CaffeineAndCandy Send me your address and let me know what books you want! It looks like I‘m sending you Arsenic and Adobo and The Lost Man. Laughterhp3@yahoo.com 4y
Laughterhp @Pageturner1 Yes let me know which one you want! 4y
Pageturner1 @Laughterhp Triptych if you still have it 4y
Laughterhp @Pageturner1 Yes! It‘s yours! 4y
Pageturner1 Thank you 😊 😁 4y
65 likes1 stack add16 comments
review
FelinesAndFelonies
Pretty Girls: A Novel | Karin Slaughter
post image
Pickpick

If you are going to read this book, then you need to be aware of the seriously disturbed nature of the violence depicted. Thankfully, @CoverToCoverGirl and @LazyLibrary gave me a warning prior to jumping into this novel. Based on their warnings, I was actually expecting it to be a lot worse. My stomach for twisted is a bit higher than most, I think.
When Julia goes missing, all of her family members find their own ways to cope with the unknown⬇️

FelinesAndFelonies Most of them in unhealthy ways. Each of them grieving in their own way and falling into their own darkness. Claire and Lydia are the daughters left behind and living with the ghost of a sister who's presence is there though she is not. The story was packed full of twists and action and suspense. I finished this book in just under 24 hours. I couldn't put it down. I had to know if Claire and Lydia were okay. Definitely a solid thriller. 4y
FelinesAndFelonies This book will not be for everyone. TRIGGER WARNINGS ⚠️Graphic sexual violence, rape, torture, suicide, drug use, violence. 4y
BooksCoffeeNurse @FelinesAndFelonies I found this book to be very graphic. But I did still love the storyline and writing style. 4y
See All 11 Comments
LazyLibrary Yesssss! Not for the feint of heart! But great read!!! 4y
FelinesAndFelonies @BooksCoffeeNurse I have seen some pretty terrible things and read the statement of facts for over 600+ offenders. I think it becomes harder to be shocked when you realize how close violence lurks. They say on average we will each walk past 36 murderers in our lifetimes. I have personally walked past hundreds and had regular contact with dozens convicted of multiple murderers. But for people without that history I think this book would be shocking. 4y
5feet.of.fury @FelinesAndFelonies “We walk by 36 murderers in our life” 😳 I‘m shook. I love Karin. Def adding this to the TBR 4y
CoverToCoverGirl It was everything you described and more. Glad you enjoyed it! The “we walk by 36 murderers” I believe. Alan Legere, Noel Winters and James Hutchison are known to me. The first. a serial killer, I knew through his daughter, they lived on our street. The second, also a serial killer, resided over the hill from our cottage and the third was a family friend, he executed two policemen. It still scares me to this day, whenever it comes to mind. (edited) 4y
CoverToCoverGirl And I‘ve always lived a very quite and boring life, so you just never know who can wander into your sphere. 4y
FelinesAndFelonies @CoverToCoverGirl "you just never know who can wander into your sphere" is exactly the part of this book that is the most terrifying. You can never know the motives of a "chance" encounter. 4y
CoverToCoverGirl @Reggie @Reggie Right! Life truly is stranger than fiction. Legere was actually up for parole this past January but was denied, our whole province was terrified at the mere thought of it. This is a link if you are interested, they don‘t get much scary than this... https://atlantic.ctvnews.ca/parole-board-refuses-release-of-killer-allan-legere-... 4y
63 likes11 comments