Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
All Fours
All Fours | Miranda July
144 posts | 117 read | 32 to read
A 2024 BOOK OF THE YEAR PICK FOR BBC R4 OPEN BOOK, THE OBSERVER, GQ, GRAZIA, HERO, I-D, NYLON A semi-famous artist announces her plan to drive cross-country from LA to NY. Thirty minutes after leaving her husband and child at home, she spontaneously exits the freeway, beds down in a nondescript motel and immerses herself in a temporary reinvention that turns out to be the start of an entirely different journey. Miranda Julys second novel confirms the brilliance of her unique approach to fiction. With Julys wry voice, perfect comic timing, unabashed curiosity about human intimacy and palpable delight in pushing boundaries, All Fours tells the story of one womans quest for a new kind of freedom. Part absurd entertainment, part tender reinvention of the sexual, romantic and domestic life of a 45-year-old female artist, All Fours transcends expectations while excavating our beliefs about life lived as a woman. Once again, July hijacks the familiar and turns it into something new and thrillingly, profoundly alive.
Amazon Indiebound Barnes and Noble WorldCat Goodreads LibraryThing
Pick icon
100%
review
LapReader
All Fours | Miranda July
post image
Pickpick

Did well at the Salvos in Dubbo over the festive season. Grand total = $27.45 as I used my credit. The skirt has shorts attached for me to wear to ballet. I love an enamel dish to cook in. The bag of toiletries includes Elemais products which I love to use. The necklace appears to be made using a tea towel. I was very happy to score both books as I had been hoping to find them for a while.

review
Gissy
All Fours | Miranda July
post image
Panpan

June 2025 Book#2

This one is going #offmyshelf @wanderglynn It didn‘t work for me. I found it so exaggerated and even histrionic in the way situations were managed or explained. What about menstruation it was like the topic is something out of this world🙄I still don‘t know why this book was in so many awards lists. I know mine is an unpopular opinion🤷🏽‍♀️2⭐️Almost bailed it.

BarbaraBB This is such a dividing book. People either hate or love it! 1w
CarolynM Not an unpopular opinion, as many people hated it as loved it, me included. Pretentious twaddle. 1w
See All 14 Comments
Gissy @CarolynM I tried but the book is going to another home☺️ 1w
Gissy @BarbaraBB Agree 1w
DieAReader Off the shelf👋🏻 1w
Gissy #LitsyAToZ2025 (letter J last name) @Texreader 1w
Texreader I did bail. Ugh. I didn't even make it past a few pages. So I'm impressed. 1w
Gissy @DieAReader Yes! 🙌 1w
Gissy @Texreader I should bail it too but I was trying to understand why so many people like it, why this book was in so many awards consideration lists. Maybe I was doing a reading choices research 😂🤣🤣🤣 1w
Texreader @Gissy I really wanted to do the same, and hoping for a gem. There had to be a reason why it hit all the lists. But I couldn't stomach it. 1w
Tamra Love the word “histrionic” - big turn off! 1w
TheAromaofBooks At least it's off the list!! 1w
41 likes14 comments
review
monalyisha
All Fours | Miranda July
post image
Pickpick

I‘m supposed to have strong feelings about this, right? But, I guess…sometimes I liked it a whole lot (eg, “I stood holding the note with that funny little abandoned feeling one gets a million times a day in a domestic setting. I could have cried, but why?”) and sometimes I felt like rolling my eyes — HARD (eg, “The future itself was another lover, reaching backward in time to cup my balls”). I bet Miranda July gets that a lot. 👇🏻

monalyisha 1/6: I neither loved it nor hated it — or…maybe, I loved AND hated it. But “love” feels too strong a word for a reaction to isolated sentences or thoughts and not to a whole. To love well, you‘ve got to love a person (or a book) in their wholeness. 1mo
monalyisha 2/6: You can‘t make them excise pieces of themselves to earn your love. You have to just figure out a way to embrace them and let them be — or at least find the “them” that you love *inside of* the thing you don‘t like; each trait has a negative and a positive expression. But I don‘t really want to let certain things in this novel just “be.” I‘d rather they weren‘t there. 1mo
monalyisha 3/6: And actually, I know July lost a lot of people with the tampon scene…but she lost me (and then roped me back in, and then lost me again, ad infinitum) when the narrator was preparing for “the dance.” I kept thinking, “This is *still* happening? All of this? Really?” I want to use the term “self-indulgent” but it feels bad. 1mo
See All 11 Comments
monalyisha 4/6: Usually, I feel like women aren‘t allowed to indulge themselves often enough; that‘s a huge part of July‘s whole point (and one that I agree with)! But in the particular case of this novel, I was definitely left wondering if short stories would be a better format for her. And then I remembered that she‘d published a (?) collection already, which has been languishing on my shelf for the better part of a decade. 1mo
monalyisha 5/6: So, I‘m sorry for thinking that July is “too much” and for trying to make her smaller…but maybe I should stop apologizing? And also stop ending my sentences with questions? Unapologetic confidence! Let the (book review) world *beg* to cup my balls! 1mo
monalyisha 6/6: I know, for certain, that I found this compulsively readable. And I appreciate that the MC neither drives nor flies (nor parks) at the end. She walks. That feels like the character growth we all needed. 1mo
ChaoticMissAdventures The Barnes and Noble in my MI's picked this for their October book club and her and I talked about it a lot - a lot about this "too much" idea and what women are "allowed" to do. She was so excited, 7 or 8 people had signed up with her and she wanted to talk about her evolution in thinking about the book. When she got there every single other person bailed and it was just her and the B&N manager! She said they still had a good talk. 1mo
Sparklemn The tampon scene was unbearable but I was dying to learn how it all turned out. Glad I finished it. (edited) 1mo
monalyisha @ChaoticMissAdventures I picked it for my book club (back at the end of last year; we plan a whole year out). I foresee the rest of the book club members/my friends being mad at me about it — and saying “Nope” a lot. 😅 But maybe they‘ll surprise me! What sorts of things did your MIL have to say? (edited) 1mo
monalyisha @Sparklemn I understood the intimacy she was/they were after (and the boundaries that were being intentionally transgressed; didn‘t Fifty Shades notoriously do something similar?). I think it was once she was back at home and still obsessing, with no end in sight, that I became the most uncomfortable and frustrated as a reader. 1mo
ChaoticMissAdventures @monalyisha she was really glad she pushed herself! This is not the type of book she would normally read but she is trying to not be in a rut since retiring. She had a lot of the same feelings as you, the thought of what women are allowed to do, even in fiction, also the comparison of male mid life crisis vs perimenopause. She was also super interested in the sexual aspect, how the MC and the guy have a sensual relationship w/o actual sex. 1mo
58 likes1 stack add11 comments
review
Gadolby
All Fours | Miranda July
Pickpick

This is a wild story. Bizarre, unique, totally worth the read. Sometimes cringey, but also revelatory. It has an unabashedly earnest and honest voice about what it is like to lose yourself in middle age as a woman—sexuality, madness—all of it

review
Billypar
All Fours | Miranda July
post image
Pickpick

How much you like All Fours may depend on whether you see a hidden thesis statement about relationships in middle age. But I don't think July wrote any lessons - in fact, it probably took a concerted effort to avoid them. The strange journey the main character takes, if not objectively realistic, felt true to people's struggles to reconcile sexual and relationship needs when they diverge. And way more interesting than the usual cheating narrative.

TheKidUpstairs Great review. I read this one with Camp Litsy last summer, and was fully prepared to hate it - instead I loved it. It was definitely a marmite book, people had VERY strong opinions! 4mo
TheBookHippie @TheKidUpstairs me 😝🎯 I HATED it. 🤦🏻‍♀️ It was a love or hate reaction from readers, I think too. 4mo
BarbaraBB Great review. I loved it too! 4mo
See All 8 Comments
AmyG Yes. Well said. I enjoyed it, too. It was wild. 4mo
Billypar @TheKidUpstairs Yeah, this one definitely fits into what you mentioned about Bunny. I expected to like it but not as much as I did. Polarizing books are always interesting to me. I know the main character was a dealbreaker for a lot of the bad reviews - not sure if that was true in your case @TheBookHippie ? 4mo
TheBookHippie @Billypar I think it was an insult to women, and a dangerous premise to say this is what women are at this stage. I abhorred the main character yes, but advertising this and publicizing it as how and what women want and are at this stage of life in the climate we are living in is both dangerous and an insult. That was my bigger issue. I found it distasteful on all levels. (edited) 4mo
rebcamuse I was trying to get through all the #TOB2025 shortlist, but put this at the end of the pile and never got to it (largely because a person I know who seems to share similar reading tastes suggested I deprioritize it). Such wide-ranging reviews! 2d
Billypar @rebcamuse I was aware of people talking about it, but I avoided specifics, so I went in pretty free of expectations. Even though it never breaks the laws of reality, I never felt like July was trying for realism, so I think that helped me enjoy the ride, instead of questioning 'who would ever do this?' if that makes sense. Definitely not for everyone! 2d
45 likes8 comments
review
Julsmarshall
All Fours | Miranda July
post image
Mehso-so

This was strange, thought provoking, and honest(maybe more than I would have liked). I understand the discussion around it and suspect I‘ll be thinking about it for awhile.

review
Lizwarnerpdx
All Fours | Miranda July
Panpan

I hate read this because I couldn‘t figure it out. Not my style at all. Turns out it‘s about perimenopause and the emotional, mental, physical changes. I‘m ok with the marriage, relationships, parenting styles etc but did not need the sex/fetishes/fantasies and the chaotic mental vomit that felt like a personality disorder.

review
vonnie862
All Fours | Miranda July
post image
Panpan

Ummmm...I was really close in DNFing this book, but I was curious to see if the MC would find closure and/or made some growth. Did she? I'm not so sure.

I did appreciate how the book touched on topics regarding sexuality (especially as we age), motherhood, gender, menopause, postpartum/trauma, and identity. However, I was not expecting to read how horny the MC was or about all her masturbation and sex escapades. ⬇️

vonnie862 Her treatment of her husband saddened me and kept wanting to shake her to be honest with him. I simply did not like her.

This book was not for me.
5mo
vonnie862 2 ⭐️ 5mo
Daisey I felt very much the same about this one. 5mo
CarolynM I think you‘re being generous. I hated her. 5mo
33 likes1 stack add4 comments
blurb
Floresj
All Fours | Miranda July
post image

As a 49 yo woman, I felt that parts of this book were so well written and hilarious, and other parts were so “WTF?”. Like a raunchy comedian who is so funny…and then tells a joke that makes you think “ok, that‘s too far.” I‘m not sure who or if I‘d recommend this, but I flew through it in 24 hours, and am both confused by and understand completely what I just read.

review
TamTracy
All Fours | Miranda July
post image
Panpan

There were a few things about this book that I just could get past. Not for me. ⭐️⭐️

CarolynM Nor me😩 7mo
59 likes1 comment
blurb
RaeLovesToRead
All Fours | Miranda July
post image

https://youtu.be/YOYkqdVEbXk?feature=shared

Who will win the Women's Prize today????

AmyG I loved The Safekeep. So 🤞🏻 7mo
BarbaraBB Echoing @AmyG 🤞🏽 7mo
Deblovestoread Adding my vote to 7mo
51 likes3 comments
blurb
RaeLovesToRead
All Fours | Miranda July
post image

I JUST RECORDED FOR 50 MINUTES. THEN WHEN I WATCHED THE VIDEO BACK MY MIC HAD SWITCHED OFF 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭

So I had to do it all over again but EVEN MORE TIRED.

And now it's 2am and I need to edit them so can post on time before Women's Prize announcement.

On the plus side I think I was a lot less rude about some of the books the second time 🤣🤣

TheBookHippie 🫣😩 I‘m pretty petty and salty about All Fours hatred 🤣 still.. 7mo
Prairiegirl_reading Oh no!! That sucks! 7mo
kspenmoll I am with you @TheBookHippie I didn‘t finish it. 7mo
See All 9 Comments
kspenmoll Sorry you had to redo- I have enjoyed your book talks. 7mo
Roary47 Oh no! 7mo
IriDas :( 7mo
RaeLovesToRead @TheBookHippie You may enjoy the All Fours part of my prediction video when it drops tomorrow morning 😅😅 I was in a bit of a salty mood full stop 😅 7mo
RaeLovesToRead @Prairiegirl_reading @Roary47 @IriDas Thank you 💕 I have re-recorded, edited and uploaded my video to launch this morning. It's now 5am 😵😵😵 (I also re-recorded my review of Fundamentally but I was so tired by that point that it was just nonsensical burbling. Will have to redo if I'm gonna post it 🥴🫠) 7mo
RaeLovesToRead @kspenmoll Awww thanks! 🥰🥰 Version 2 (only slightly less salty than version 1) will be live in 4 hours 🤣 I'm going to sleep haha 7mo
64 likes9 comments
review
andrew61
All Fours | Miranda July
post image
Pickpick

A book I finished last weekend as I try and read the women's prize shortlist. Interesting to be in the head of a 45 year old artist who hits a mid life crisis as she goes on a cross country drive to NY but stops halfway where she renovates a motel room + has a non consummated sexual encounter with a ynger man. What follows is the exploration of her sexual encounters as she rationalises her life. Its taken me a week to process, + still not sure.

BarbaraBB It‘s such an impactful read, whether you like it or not. Glad that you did! 7mo
49 likes1 comment
review
JillR
All Fours | Miranda July
post image
Pickpick

Nearly didn‘t read it, glad I did. This is not *the* mid-life novel; the protagonist‘s life bears no resemblance to mine, nor that of any other woman I know. She is the most self-absorbed, self-indulgent person you‘ll probably ever hear from yet despite that I found this utterly compelling, with a knowingness I suspect you‘ll recognise if you too are mid-40s. I also found the absurdity quite good fun in a way I didn‘t expect.

BarbaraBB Great review! 8mo
Cathythoughts Yes, great review. I havnt been drawn to it , but your review is tempting me. 👍🏻❤️ 8mo
JillR @Cathythoughts I was exactly the same, I only read it because it was on the WP short list and I could get it from the library. Nice to be surprised! 8mo
JillR Thank you @BarbaraBB ! 8mo
31 likes4 comments
review
CSeydel
All Fours | Miranda July
post image
Mehso-so

I had a lot of issues with this book but as you can see I also marked a LOT of sentences/passages for future reference. I ran out of book darts and had to start using Post-it flags! I‘m still not completely sure this wasn‘t satire - the MC was so comically pretentious and self-absorbed that I think she may have been intended as a sly parody of a certain type of artsy hipster grappling with middle age. In that light it almost worked.
#shelfsweeper

CSeydel I just couldn‘t relate a woman feeling the way she did with a child as young as hers - 7 years old. It‘s one thing when your kids are grown and you turn 50 and suddenly realize that not only are you no longer “mom” but it‘s also too late to go back to the sexual image you had of yourself before becoming mom/wife. But she has her child‘s whole life ahead of her and she‘s not at all interested - she‘s solely fixated on her sexual identity. 8mo
CSeydel I also found it off-putting the way she milked the drama of her child‘s traumatic birth. She has this whole thing about not knowing whether the baby would live or die, and in that moment reality split and she had two babies, one alive and one dead, and she “refused to play favorites” between them. But her child didn‘t die. She doesn‘t seem to care about the actual child, just the attendant trauma as a formative thing that happened to *her*. 8mo
CSeydel In other words - she‘s shockingly ungrateful for all the blessings and privileges she has had in her life. This is common of course, we all take so much for granted, but someone as navel-gazing as this unnamed protag should at least recognize all these good things, even if she can‘t emotionally connect with gratitude. 8mo
See All 17 Comments
RaeLovesToRead It's difficult to tell with autofiction how much of the writing is a caricature and an outlet for the unpalatable aspects of their character, how much is self-aware satire, and how much is in earnest. This one felt like all the awful crap that society tells women (voiced concisely and depressingly in Susan Sontag's On Women, for example) came to life in an explosion of awfulness. Which I found mesmerising and despair-inducing. 8mo
TrishB Well done on finishing for all the reasons outlined. 8mo
RaeLovesToRead If you want to torture yourself further with a narcissistic, sex-obsessed MC whose antics make you feel grotty, I recommend The Pisces by Melissa Broder. You won't thank me 🤣🤣 8mo
CSeydel @RaeLovesToRead Oh, I like how you put that! It is rather hard to pin down and that‘s an interesting lens through which to view it. I‘ll be pondering it, certainly, even though I can‘t say I enjoyed it. It was at least well-written. And I‘ll keep The Pisces in my back pocket for now - I‘m in need of a palate cleanser next, but who knows? Maybe I‘ll read it later, just to see 👀 8mo
CSeydel Thanks @TrishB ! I couldn‘t help myself - I had to find out where it was going 8mo
TrishB I can‘t remember at what point I bailed- I just knew wherever it was going I wasn‘t going! 8mo
charl08 I'm about two chapters in and got distracted by other shiny new books. Nor sure if I'll pick it up again before it's due back at the library... 8mo
BarbaraBB Kudos for finishing it and all the notes taken. Great review. I totally agree on the mc being selfish and unlikable yet I was also strangely intrigued by her. I think Miranda July has been able to write a book that affects everyone who read it in one way or another and I admire her for that 8mo
RaeLovesToRead Hahaha I was joking... do NOT read the Pisces haha. It will make you feel even WORSE than All Fours. NO PALATES WILL BE CLEANSED! 8mo
CSeydel @BarbaraBB Absolutely! It was certainly well-written, and thought-provoking. (edited) 8mo
Lesliereadsalot I really liked this one, crazy as the story was. Great review! 8mo
CSeydel @Lesliereadsalot Certainly a lot to think about! 8mo
Sparklemn @cseydel As much as I despised the character for the many of the reasons you stated, I found that I liked the version of her after the time jump at the end of the book. Time and distance had helped her grow to some degree. Not much. Just a little. 😁 7mo
55 likes17 comments
blurb
CSeydel
All Fours | Miranda July
post image

#whereareyoumonday

Still in Monrovia with the sociopath narrator of this tedious nonsense

bookandbedandtea "Tedious nonsense" ? 8mo
CSeydel @bookandbedandtea I keep waiting for her to realize that her unhappiness is because she‘s pathologically self-absorbed, but she hasn‘t yet 8mo
dabbe I bailed on this one during Camp Litsy last year for reasons you just described so well. 🤣 8mo
See All 33 Comments
CSeydel @dabbe I‘m so tempted to bail but my book club is discussing it Thursday night and I want to be able to defend my low opinion of it. And … maybe? .:. it gets better? My husband wisely bailed after 50 pages 8mo
CBee @CSeydel I bailed during #camplitsy last year too. It was making me feel physically ill 😂 8mo
5feet.of.fury 😂😂 8mo
TheBookHippie I‘ve never hated a book as much as this one.. 😵‍💫 8mo
fredthemoose @CSeydel it does not get better 8mo
dabbe @CSeydel Life's too short! I bet you already have enough to defend your position. Sometimes a bail sends a powerful message, too! #hailthebail! 😍 8mo
willaful yet another camp bail here! 8mo
DGRachel Adding my vote for “save yourself and bail”. I am another Camp Litsy bail. 8mo
BarbaraBB Lol, I loved it! 8mo
CSeydel @TheBookHippie It‘s truly terrible. The MC seems to think she‘s the only person in the world who has ever had an original thought. The rest of humanity exists only as either her audience, support staff, or pawns in whatever emotional games she‘s playing with herself. 8mo
CSeydel @CBee @5feet.of.fury @fredthemoose @dabbe @willaful @DGRachel Thank you all for your support! I was happy to have read far enough that she acknowledges that “there is something very wrong with me” and starts to take accountability for some of the bullshit she‘s making up in her head and attributing to everyone around her. That she‘s been ridiculously unfair about older women. But it‘s just so boring listening to her natter on. 8mo
TheBookHippie @CSeydel It was such an insult to women as a whole, let alone the immense privilege it shows ad nauseam and insult to my intelligence. I think it‘s an extremely harmful book. It shows why I don‘t like most women that‘s for sure. Just YUK. (edited) 8mo
CSeydel @BarbaraBB A lot of people do! When I‘m done I‘ll check out your review and look forward to seeing it from a different perspective 🤞🏻 8mo
CSeydel @TheBookHippie I hope most women aren‘t as full of themselves as this one. Somehow she manages to be completely absorbed by her own inner fantasy world - “mind-rooted,” as she calls it - living entirely in her mind yet shockingly un-self-aware somehow. She views her entire life as a piece of performance art and everyone else is her supporting cast, and can‘t understand why they don‘t also see themselves that way 8mo
FashionableObserver I tried so hard to get into this book. I really did. I think I made it a few chapters in before bailing. I usually hold onto my books with a death grip, but I swear I try to pawn that thing off on people all of the time. 🤣 8mo
CSeydel @FashionableObserver I hear you. It‘s a slog for sure. 8mo
5feet.of.fury @CSeydel is this the same book club that picked Lost Apothecary? 😅 8mo
TheBookHippie @CSeydel I always have that hope. 8mo
FashionableObserver @CSeydel I don‘t understand the rave reviews. It flew off of the shelves—I picked up the last copy my tiny bookstore had. All of the ladies in the store were raving about it, too… 8mo
Ruthiella If it‘s worth anything, I am enjoying your complaints! 😂 So thank you for reading! 8mo
RaeLovesToRead 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 8mo
RaeLovesToRead I thought the book was brilliant, but I also agree with everything you say 🤣🤣🤣🤣 8mo
CSeydel @5feet.of.fury haha - No! Can you believe it? Two book club meetings happen to fall in the same week and they both picked loser books 😩 8mo
5feet.of.fury @CSeydel 😩🤪 8mo
CSeydel @Ruthiella Thank you! That‘s one good thing! I had seen some bad reviews and I hoped even if it wasn‘t good, it would at least be “fun to hate.” But it‘s mostly tedious listening to someone go through all these emotional calisthenics to rid themselves of a stupid misconception that I don‘t share (that sexuality is everything, and women are worthless after menopause). Like: I just don‘t care, and I‘m not learning anything 💀 8mo
CSeydel @RaeLovesToRead LOL!! 😂 8mo
BarbaraBB I also love the controversy surrounding this book 😂 8mo
CSeydel @BarbaraBB Absolutely! At least we have that 😆 8mo
CarolynM You comments sum up my feelings exactly. She‘s appalling. 8mo
CSeydel @CarolynM Glad I‘m not the only one 😬 8mo
63 likes33 comments
blurb
CSeydel
All Fours | Miranda July
post image

Far too hot for a warm beverage tonight, and I had ice cream earlier, so I‘m just kicking back without refreshments for tonight‘s #HyggeHourReadathon

TheBookHippie It‘s almost lemonade weather time here - can‘t wait! 8mo
CSeydel @TheBookHippie 💛🍹 8mo
AllDebooks Lovely x 8mo
Chrissyreadit ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️ 8mo
56 likes5 comments
blurb
CSeydel
All Fours | Miranda July
post image

I‘ve got a bad feeling about this…

So I know this book is polarizing. I went in expecting shock, expecting transgressive attitudes about sex, gender, and aging, expecting discomfort in the name of probing implicit attitudes and assumptions about propriety and morality. But so far it‘s just exhausting. It‘s like listening to your most neurotic friend monologue about her chaotic and obsessive thoughts, which are entirely self-oriented

CSeydel She‘s kind of pretentious and while she thinks she‘s studying and interpreting the world around her, she actually living in a fantasy world constructed in her mind and projecting it onto the people around her. 8mo
Leniverse Yes, you're spot on. You will get some of the transgressive stuff you were expecting. And the second half of the books is better than the first half. Overall though, I found her ridiculous and privileged, and I really wished for the story to be about someone less unlikeable. There are some decent themes in there, and I wanted to be able to identify with the struggle but that was impossible. 8mo
CSeydel @Leniverse Oh, gosh. I was hoping it would get better in that respect. I have found a lot of interesting lines, like aphorisms peppering her incessant over-analyzing and rationalizing, that I think are pithy and incisive and capture some truth about human existence. But on the whole, yes, she‘s ridiculous. Which would be fine! Except that I think we‘re supposed to take her as seriously as she takes herself. 8mo
See All 7 Comments
Tamra Hmmmm 🤔I haven‘t been compelled to stack this one and you are making a good case against it. Doesn‘t sound like I‘d fair any better. (edited) 8mo
CSeydel @Tamra No, I don‘t think this would be up your alley at all. The MC is over-privileged, chronically discontent, and rationalizes her extreme self-absorption with tortuous philosophical justifications. About 50 pages in, I started to suspect that the book might actually be satire, and now I can‘t help but read it in that light. Whether I‘m right or wrong, it‘s much more entertaining that way. (So far.) 8mo
Tamra @CSeydel excellent plan B that might actually prove to be entertaining. You could be right! 8mo
CarolynM I think she was probably aiming for satire, but it was a big miss for me for the reasons you have given. 8mo
47 likes7 comments
review
vlwelser
All Fours | Miranda July
post image
Mehso-so

I found this protagonist super annoying and probably should have given up at the halfway mark but it does get somewhat better.

#BookSpinBingo @TheAromaofBooks

TheAromaofBooks Great progress!! 9mo
44 likes1 comment
review
britt_brooke
All Fours | Miranda July
post image
Pickpick

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Mostly loved the beautiful, smoothly flowing writing, but this story made me feel a bit icky. A relatable recurring theme was fitting people into boxes, and that was very thoughtfully handled. I‘m torn. Almost brilliant. Docking a star for the several foul bodily descriptions for shock value which kinda stole the show. Not in a good way. The writing was so freaking good, that shit was not needed.

RaeLovesToRead I both loved and hated this book 10mo
BarbaraBB Fab review! 10mo
britt_brooke @RaeLovesToRead Yes!! That‘s a good way to put it. Same. 10mo
britt_brooke @BarbaraBB Thank you! 🩷🩷 10mo
70 likes2 stack adds4 comments
review
marleed
All Fours | Miranda July
post image
Mehso-so

I was not rooting for this MC - her need for discovery was almost insufferable and she lost me with the tampon episode. The writing is quite good though.

ChaoticMissAdventures This one is so controversial! And on so many lists, hard not to pick it up. 10mo
marleed @ChaoticMissAdventures My thoughts exactly, and I was curious which side of the fence I‘d land on. I guess I‘m sitting on the fence🤣 10mo
ChaoticMissAdventures @marleed me too! I feel like I can appreciate her writing and bravery to just go there, I had it as a pick I think because I liked it more than most, but it really isn't my thing, I will not really recommend it and will not pick it up again. 10mo
GidgetsTreasures75 I liked it in some ways but it was definitely difficult to like the MC. 10mo
68 likes1 stack add4 comments
blurb
bio_chem06
All Fours | Miranda July
post image

I know this was a big book that everyone was talking about but when I really looked into the reviews, it was all over the place, so I don‘t feel bad for hate reading it right now. I think I‘ll finish it because it‘s a quick read, but I just don‘t care about the narrator. Being so self aware and self assured in my 40s makes the midlife crisis hard for me to understand. Not a humble brag, just an observation.

Hooked_on_books It hated this book 10mo
bio_chem06 Thanks for sharing @Hooked_on_books. It was recommended by a friend, but I am hating it too. I think it‘s going to the DNF pile. Life is too short to force myself to read something awful when I have a TBR pile just staring me in the face. 10mo
Hooked_on_books Amen to that! 10mo
9 likes3 comments
review
GidgetsTreasures75
All Fours | Miranda July
post image
Pickpick

3-8-25: My 17th finished book of 2025! I think I really got into this story because I went through menopause so early in life,37,and while the main character is suffering through perimenopause, I felt a connection of sorts.Beyond that, this story was a raw telling of one woman‘s journey through marriage and motherhood and everything that can happen when you let your guard down and start being real with yourself and your desires.⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️📖#️⃣1️⃣7️⃣

review
Bec_lectic
All Fours | Miranda July
post image
Mehso-so

So this is not a story for everyone. It went to places I don‘t normally seek when reading. It was graphic in parts that were just plain out there & gross at times. But, this book took me out of my comfort zone and put me into a mind that is very unlike mine. That‘s the great thing about reading though, it transports you into another world or life. I gave this a so-so because I don‘t feel like I walked away with anything profound from it. Just eh

review
Abailliekaras
All Fours | Miranda July
post image
Pickpick

A frank and funny novel that veers into the bonkers. I really enjoyed the on point writing and humour. July manages to walk a line between ‘artiste‘ on a complete flight of fancy and enough self-awareness to keep it grounded. Still, her narrator is self-absorbed which stopped me from loving the book (that & her obsession with sex & menopause - but many have loved this part). A provocative, interesting read and great fodder for a book club.

30 likes1 stack add
blurb
Sparklemn
All Fours | Miranda July
post image

I can‘t remember ever rooting so hard AGAINST the main character. She is dreadful. That being said, I‘m enjoying the book (about 70% complete) and looking forward to seeing how the story ends. Did anyone else feel this way about her?

Ruthiella I didn‘t find any character particularly likable. But I was curious to see where it would all end up. I also wondered how much of this was culled from the author‘s life. 11mo
TheBookHippie LOATHED her. LOATHED and I bailed. 😵‍💫😂😝🤪🤷🏻‍♀️ 11mo
fredthemoose Also completely loathed her, so much that when a friend read it we spent a 5 day trip having one long book club conversation about what a self absorbed jerk she was. 11mo
See All 14 Comments
Sparklemn @Ruthiella I hadn't even thought about that. I'll have to research the author when I've finished. 11mo
Sparklemn @TheBookHippie I almost bailed, too, but stubbornly pushed on. Not sure why. Hopefully it be worth it. 11mo
Sparklemn @fredthemoose Now that sounds like fun! I'm looking forward to reading reviews when I'm done. I'm not sure I can convince any of my friends to read this one. 11mo
TheBookHippie @fredthemoose was 5 days long enough????? 😝😂😩😵‍💫🤷🏻‍♀️😅 11mo
TheBookHippie @Sparklemn 😝😵‍💫😅 11mo
fredthemoose @TheBookHippie 😂😂😂 No! But it was as long as we had so we had to make do! 11mo
TheBookHippie @fredthemoose 😂😂😂 11mo
CarolynM Loathed her 11mo
BarbaraBB I enjoyed the book so much! I didn‘t particularly like the narrator but loved what the author did. I now follow Miranda July on IG and she‘s so fun. 11mo
Sparklemn @CarolynM yes! 😖 11mo
Sparklemn @BarbaraBB Can‘t wait to finish! 11mo
47 likes14 comments
review
HettyG
All Fours | Miranda July
post image
Pickpick

A middle aged female artist facing a midlife crisis writes about a middle aged female artist facing a midlife crisis with all the credulity of a teenager who has just figured out how to have an orgasm, certain the rest of the world must not be clued in to the experience.

I still really liked it though, there were moments of real insight and while the main character remains insufferable from beginning to end, I still liked her. 💜

BkClubCare Nice review. 11mo
CarolynM Great review. I didn‘t like her. At all. 11mo
HettyG @CarolynM she's a complicated character for sure and the book is really not for everyone, I wasn't sure I liked it or her until towards the end. And she is unlikeable, maybe all of us, the perimenopausal, are tough to take in this phase of life? I know I am. 🤣 11mo
37 likes2 stack adds3 comments
quote
HettyG
All Fours | Miranda July
post image

"I'd thought the two paths were:

sex with Davey vs. a life of bitterness and regret

But maybe the road split between:

a life spent longing vs. a life that was continually surprising"

I'm still not sure about this book but I feel this quote deeply, and it's one of the few times I've felt any genuineness from the main character, who hides herself from everyone, including the reader.

quote
HettyG
All Fours | Miranda July
post image

"It took me two days to call Brian the neighbor because I was busy savoring my position, like when a crush finally texts back and you want to enjoy having the ball in your court for a while."

Y'all know I have a soft spot for unlikeable female main characters but it is only page five and I am really being tested on this one. Also this particular quote had me ??? I have no idea why it's not THAT funny

JuniperWilde I loved this one 📕 12mo
23 likes1 comment
review
fredthemoose
All Fours | Miranda July
post image
Mehso-so

⭐️⭐️⭐️ I didn‘t love this. The writing was engaging and I got through it quickly but I just did not connect with the MC. There were some interesting pieces of commentary about women‘s sexuality and relationship structures and menopause, but by the time they came around I wasn‘t willing to give the MC a pass for being a self-absorbed jerk. #ToB2025 #ToB25

CarolynM Yep. 12mo
TrishB Accurate description of said MC. 12mo
Larkken Haha, agreed 12mo
63 likes3 comments
review
ncsufoxes
All Fours | Miranda July
post image
Pickpick

Read in 2024. At first I was a little unsure when I started listening to this one. It dealt with many topics & areas that I know nothing about but I realized that it‘s important for people with all different experiences to be able to tell their story. The biggest thing that resonated with me is the f-in patriarchy. Just that realization of how much of our lives as women is directed by the patriarchy (especially as we get older). The societal

ncsufoxes expectations of women. There are some uncomfortable discussions in the book & at first I was ready to give up but definitely happy I stuck with it. It‘s really made me think about things I didn‘t expect to get from this story. 12mo
35 likes1 stack add1 comment
review
rmaclean4
All Fours | Miranda July
post image
Pickpick

Surprising at every turn. Some very explicit sex scenes in this novel about a woman facing change in her body. A story about family and how to be an individual within parenthood. Great first book of 2025. Not for the faint of heart. 4.5 🌟

review
Bevita
All Fours | Miranda July
post image
Mehso-so

I really do not get the fuss. The first 2/3 of this book was stupid. Is it possible that an educated woman has never heard of perimenopause? I trust the other books on all the “best of” lists will be an improvement.

blurb
squirrelbrain
All Fours | Miranda July
post image

https://amp.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2024/dec/24/this-book-is-my-bible-the-w...

Interesting read! A couple of comments here that made me 🤔 - eg ‘the author is older and cooler than me so that makes non-monogamy more legitimate.‘🤷‍♀️

What do you all think?!

CatMS I'm on the fence about reading this book, when I read books that have gotten rave reviews I am less than thrilled. May have to wait till the hype dies down. What is everyone thinking about this book now? 12mo
Ruthiella So interesting the way it has struck a chord with so many readers. I think on the whole, the reaction underscores how women are often asked to sublimate their needs in the Western traditional family setup. 12mo
squirrelbrain @CatMS - we buddy-read this on Litsy in the summer and it was very polarising - most Littens either loved it or hated it. I‘d give it a go, just don‘t expect it to be fabulous and you won‘t be disappointed - maybe even pleasantly surprised! 12mo
See All 17 Comments
squirrelbrain @Ruthiella - the woman who said that her husband expected his needs to be put first definitely needed to read this book! 12mo
TheBookHippie I still stand by my loathing of this book 🤣🤣🤣😅😬🫠😝 12mo
Flaneurette I appreciated this book for the inclusion of menopause and women‘s roles more than I enjoyed it- I don‘t really understand ppl who center their lives w sex- just not my thing. Thought Sandwich was a much better book on similar themes 12mo
squirrelbrain @Flaneurette - I completely agree about Sandwich and, in fact, thought of it to recommend to @CatMS just before you posted! 12mo
Cathythoughts I‘m shying away from this book. Even though I have no idea what it‘s really about. Not drawn to it though. 12mo
Tamra I‘m with @Cathythoughts. I am though intrigued by Sandwich. @Flaneurette 12mo
sarahbarnes I‘ll admit that I‘m a shameless fan of Miranda July - her writing and her films. She also puts a lot of really interesting artistic content on social media. I loved this book. 12mo
BarbaraBB I loved this too and wasn‘t a fan of Sandwich. It didn‘t change my personal ideas on monogamy though, I didn‘t relate to the narrator personally but I loved what July did and caused among people all over the world! 12mo
CarolynM I read this article the other day. I guess I can understand that menopause really messes with some women, and I should be grateful I wasn‘t one of them, but I just couldn‘t stand how utterly narcissistic she was. @Maggie4483 described July as a “self indulgent exhibitionist” in her review and I think that description is perfect for the MC of the book. 12mo
Hooked_on_books I hated this book so much that I really don‘t want to read about women who blew up their lives because of it. Some lives need to be blown up, so if that was the case for them, that‘s great. If not, I‘d rather not know. 12mo
squirrelbrain @CarolynM @Hooked_on_books - I agree with you Carolyn with how narcissistic she was, which is what worries me that women have used this book as an excuse to/ reason to blow up their lives. We don‘t all have her financial (and emotional) capability to not give a shit. Yes, if you need to change something, you need to do it, but not based on this self-obsessed version of real life. 12mo
tpixie @squirrelbrain this conversation thread has me intrigued! 12mo
squirrelbrain I thought this must have been where you saw Sandwich @tpixie but clearly not. 🤓 All Fours is much more OTT than Sandwich and people either loved it or hated it - I‘ll be interested to hear your thoughts if / when you get to it. 12mo
tpixie @squirrelbrain I‘ll keep you posted if I get to it! 12mo
54 likes1 stack add17 comments
review
cariashley
All Fours | Miranda July
post image
Mehso-so

Hmm. This was a little too out there for me. While it‘s full of great lines that will actually stick with me, the protagonist was just too over the top on the sex stuff and it felt incomprehensible to me. Not that there isn‘t a certain enjoyment in reading those kinds of characters. The parts about her birth trauma and perimenopause were far more interesting to me than the lust parts. #tob25

review
rachelk
All Fours | Miranda July
post image
Pickpick

My feelings about this one are complicated. The mid-life experience of a woman going a little crazy during perimenopause while dealing with child rearing, career, marriage and fidelity told in such an honest and intimate way was very well done. The narrator made me feel uncomfortable and maybe that is a good thing, but as I struggled with that feeling I realized that I really did not care for her or her cringey behavior. Light pick for me.

review
Maggie4483
All Fours | Miranda July
post image
Mehso-so

I absolutely hated the first 3/4 of this. Part of the problem was that I looked up July‘s Instagram before I started reading, and could not separate the author, who I found to be a self-indulgent exhibitionist, from her main character. However, it was very well-written (although it dragged in parts), and the stuff about aging resonated with me.

CarolynM “Self indulgent exhibitionist” is a perfect description of the MC of this book. I hated all of it😆 13mo
Maggie4483 @CarolynM oh, good. I‘m glad I‘m not the only one who felt that way. 13mo
22 likes2 comments
blurb
Lands
All Fours | Miranda July
post image

I guess I should read this one 😂.

quote
onionsforever
All Fours | Miranda July

And, of course, in a patriarchy your body is technically not your own until you pass the reproductive age.

4 likes1 stack add
review
Abailliekaras
All Fours | Miranda July
post image
Pickpick

Provocative and much talked about, I liked the on point writing and sense of humour, but didn‘t love the far-fetched & self-indulgent elements. Then again, I‘m all for more women telling their stories in a world that still seems to be dominated by men. The menopause side doesn‘t interest me that much but is resonating with many. Frank & intelligent, a good book club pick.

mcctrish There was a lot in this book that just made me go 😬 but I still think about it because it is a strong and provocative book 👏🏻👏🏻 13mo
Abailliekaras @mcctrish yes very strong 13mo
28 likes1 stack add2 comments
blurb
Augustdana
All Fours | Miranda July
post image

Had to sit directly in the sun today after work and read in my favourite park. It didn‘t help, but it also didn‘t hurt.

review
JuniperWilde
All Fours | Miranda July
post image
Pickpick

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ I couldn‘t put this down. The writing is crisp, honest, and funny. A book about love and relationships in all their forms. I‘m drawn to portrayals of midlife female MCs experiencing an awakening (and full expression) in their sexual, relational, and personal lives.

review
mjtwo
All Fours | Miranda July
post image
Mehso-so

1-7 Oct 2024
Not sure how I felt about this book. It was challenging - in that the main character‘s journey was far removed from my life, my preferences and my values. Her actions were totally incomprehensible to me; the sex made me cringe. There was no aspect of her experience I wanted for myself. Ultimately I related best to Harris - wondering wtf was going on. But it kept me reading, even if I did not really like it. I did love Jordi.

blurb
JuniperWilde
All Fours | Miranda July
post image

(Photo of author Miranda July holding her hit novel All Fours) I am loving this book. It‘s edgy and creative and liberating. I can‘t wait to see where it ends up.

review
Avanders
All Fours | Miranda July
post image
Pickpick

It‘s weird reading about a 45 yo woman w a 7 yo who sets out to transform herself on a long solo road trip… while being a 45 yo woman w a 7 yo about to take off on a long solo road trip (tho mine was planned months ago…😜).The book is bizarre, well-written, intense, a little crazy, & quite good. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Also, showing off our holiday pillows as the correct seasons settle in…

And sending #AllHallowsReadSwap #ahrs pkg tmrw! (Early bc of road trip)

AmyG Safe travels! 1y
BethM Drive safe! 1y
TheBookHippie Safe journeys friend!!! I did one at 23 and 49. Itching to do it again!!! 1y
See All 14 Comments
Ruthiella Just stay clear of Monrovia, CA and you should probably be OK. 😅 1y
dabbe Be safe and have the trip of a lifetime! 🧡🤎💛 1y
MaleficentBookDragon Sounds exciting, where are you going? 1y
Avanders @AmyG @BethM @dabbe Thanks!! 🍁🚗♥️ @TheBookHippie thanks!! I‘m a bit of a roadtrip junkie and I definitely haven‘t had my fill in the years-post-buggy. Very much looking forward to this fall trip!! 🍁🍁🚗🍁🍁 @Ruthiella 😂😳😅 excellent advice! 😎 @MaleficentBookDragon “back home” in a variety of ways — last year, I promised myself a midwestern fall trip - visiting family in Gb, Eagle River, and Chicago, and then *alone* in beautiful Missouri… ♥️ 1y
BethM You know there‘s -ahem- a certain Litten that lives on the way to GB 😂 1y
BarbaraBB This sounds so good. Have a fab time and like @Ruthiella says, avoid Monrovia 😀 1y
Anna40 Have a safe trip filled with wonderful adventures 🏕️🚙 1y
Avanders @BethM lol you know I wasn‘t sure exactly how “on the way” it was - I‘ll email you and we can see if something is possible! 😉 @BarbaraBB @Anna40 thanks!! 🍁🚗🍂 (and lol Monrovia will be avoided 😁) 1y
mabell Oh what a crazy coincidence!! Have a fabulous time! 1y
CatMS I hope you actually did a solo road trip and had an adventurous time. Not stopping in one place with no view🤪 12mo
Avanders @CatMS I did!! lol, no lollygaggin‘ 30 mins away from home for me… 😁😁😁 12mo
76 likes14 comments
blurb
Avanders
All Fours | Miranda July
post image

Progress! 🤓

Finished Bulletproof ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ I think they‘ve found their old spark again, or maybe it was the heavy nod to Only Murders 🤔☺️

Murderous Christmas ⭐️⭐️⭐️💫 A cozy cozy! I‘ll definitely go back to read the 1st!

Listening to Mad Love on audio - a relatively quick murder mystery w a full cast. Def recommend so far!

Bubba & I are listening to the Zoo on road trips 🤩♥️

The tagged is for #reallifebookgroup… interesting so far! 🫢

blurb
BkClubCare
All Fours | Miranda July
post image

I have Grace on loan from a friend, All Fours Libby/eBook came off hold (of course 🙄), picked up the Heyer yesterday from the library, and have had Untamed on my shelves for awhile - something made me grab it today 🤷🏻‍♀️

I STARTED EACH TODAY! I am supposed to read Atwood‘s The Robber Bride for a club meeting next Wednesday and Kaleidoscope is my current audiobook. #OhDear #WhereToFocus #Overwhelmed #Distracted

* Had a job interview a.m. 😢

BkClubCare Thanks for asking; nah, not sure but I think I presented as a desperate inarticulate loser. #ohwell 1y
BkClubCare #Oct2024 Book89 Ended up skimming thru to read the end and … I am ambivalent. 1y
33 likes1 stack add2 comments
blurb
Avanders
All Fours | Miranda July
post image

Books update 🤓

Still finishing Sept‘s #cbbc, but up next is the tagged (a 2nd‘ary choice for #reallifebookclub) then the Cleo Coyle, my Sept #SeasonalCozies selection. I‘ve been meaning to check out their other work for a long time & I‘m finally doing it!

I also happen to be listening to their 20th (!) in the Coffeehouse Mystery series - definitely one of the better ones! ☕️🩸

Also rec‘d my #fffs package! Thank you @PatriciaU -I‘m so excited!!

Chrissyreadit i do not know the coffeehouse series! sounds like it‘s fun! 1y
PatriciaU Yay! Hey, that Cleo Coyle series looks good! 1y
julieclair The Cleo Coyles look like fun! 1y
See All 6 Comments
Avanders @Chrissyreadit @PatriciaU @julieclair they are fun! They‘re set in Manhattan, in a break from the usual cozy model, but they‘re still in a coffee shop, don‘t worry 😁 The early ones are a little dated, but they catch up pretty quickly. ☺️ 1y
BethM Ohhh I haven‘t read the Cleo series in a long time. 1y
Avanders @BethM for me, it kinda sagged a smidge, but I always enjoy going back to the Village Blend and the recent books seem to be picking back up ☺️ 1y
50 likes6 comments