Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
American Sherlock: Murder, Forensics, and the Birth of American CSI
American Sherlock: Murder, Forensics, and the Birth of American CSI | Kate Winkler Dawson
44 posts | 38 read | 45 to read
Amazon Indiebound Barnes and Noble WorldCat Goodreads LibraryThing
blurb
jenniferw88
post image

5 🌟 reads of 2023

blurb
jenniferw88
post image

TieDyeDude 💪🎉 3mo
39 likes1 comment
review
rabbitprincess
Pickpick

An interesting look at the life and career of E. O. Heinrich, a pioneering multidisciplinary specialist who laid the foundations of modern forensic science. This book would pair nicely with 18 Tiny Deaths, Bruce Goldfarb‘s account of the story of another forensics pioneer, Frances Glessner Lee.

review
Pogue
post image
Pickpick

This was a great audiobook for my commute. I liked how the story was told in case files. It showed how each new method was used.

dabbe American Sherlock? Count me in! #sherlockfanatic 1y
19 likes1 stack add1 comment
review
jenniferw88
post image
Pickpick
Cinfhen Im very keen to read this one!! Thanks for putting it on my #ReadersRadar 😊 1y
Librarybelle I really need to get to this one! 1y
Bluebird Oooooh! Looks great! Right up my alley! Stacked! Thanks 1y
56 likes3 stack adds3 comments
blurb
jenniferw88
post image

That moment when you realise everything is from an independent bookshop 😂! The mug & bookmark is from Mr B's in Bath, and the book is from Gulliver's Bookshop in Wimborne (my local)!

Ruthiella Awesome! 👍 1y
dabbe If it has SHERLOCK in the title, it's gonna be stacked! 🤣 1y
69 likes1 stack add2 comments
blurb
jenniferw88
post image

@Cinfhen Here's the #propernouninthetitle list (without the #cityorcountryintitle prompt, as the list would have been huge). #52bookclub2023 #booked2023. Mrs Dalloway & My Friend Anna may not be of much help, however, as they are quite specific to me.

@alisiakae @BarbaraTheBibliophage @BarbaraBB @Librarybelle

Cinfhen I read and loved 1y
Cinfhen Im planning on reading this book and I‘d be happy to share it with you plus it‘s a second hand copy I bought so it could work for that prompt too and it works for Cuba and i think it involves an innocent c person being incarcerated 1y
Cinfhen Im gonna work on a post with some of my #TriplePlays and if any interest you lmk because I will mail them to you if they are physical books 😘 1y
BarbaraBB So much work! I love it!!! 1y
40 likes4 comments
review
jlhammar
post image
Pickpick

I enjoyed learning about Oscar Heinrich and the founding of modern forensic science. Interesting mix of biography and true crime. I prefer Dawson‘s Death in the Air, but this is still worth a read. Look forward to trying her newest, All That Is Wicked.

JackOBotts Have you checked out her podcasts? Tenfold More Wicked & Wicked Words…and also Buried Bones (w/Paul Holes). She has a great voice and is a terrific storyteller. 1y
jlhammar @JackOBotts Oh yeah, I've been meaning to try those. Thanks for the reminder! 1y
55 likes2 comments
review
SW-T
post image
Mehso-so

A few of these were free Hoopla borrows and others were off my TBR. The tagged was a TBR read and wasn‘t bad. While interesting, it wasn‘t quite what I expected. Funny, there was a lot of information provided, but at the end of the day, didn‘t feel like I learned much, if that makes sense. Felt like the author was doing a research dump. For all that, it was interesting to learn a bit about how crime scene investigations evolved.

#nonfiction

review
AvidReaderandGeekGirl
Pickpick

4 stars

This was a really good look at the birth of modern forensics. Heinrich was unlikable to me. I felt like he spoiled his sons too much. But the science part was interesting. As were the cases he helped to “solve“. I also loved the epilogue that pointed out the flaws in both his and some modern forensics and the parts throughout the book that did so. Full review: https://www.goodreads.com/review/show/4807854893

4 likes1 stack add
review
JackOBotts
Pickpick

If February were just a few days longer my #DoubleSpin would have happened in the selected month! 🤷🏻‍♀️ 3.5 ⭐️ I enjoyed this dive into E.O. Heinrich‘s legacy and contributions to criminal investigations. Amazing to think about the way this man‘s mind worked & the legacy of his efforts. I like Dawson‘s writing style, and look forward to reading her next publication (research from Season 1 of her podcast “Tenfold More Wicked”).

EvieBee I really enjoyed this one, too! 2y
TheAromaofBooks Woohoo!!! 2y
JackOBotts @EvieBee -yes! I was lucky to have both her books picked in this year‘s book spins(!)…now I have to wait patiently for #3 to hit stores… 😳 2y
EvieBee I didn‘t realize she has one coming out in October! Just preordered. (edited) 2y
JackOBotts @EvieBee 🙌🏼 - do you listen to her podcast? She‘s such a great storyteller. I‘ve enjoyed her 1st two seasons very much and def. recommend! 2y
29 likes5 comments
blurb
JackOBotts
post image

Happily moving on to my #doublespin pick for February.

EvieBee I really liked this one! 2y
39 likes1 stack add1 comment
review
bookwrm526
post image
Mehso-so

This wasn‘t as good as I wanted it to be, mostly because it was a bit uneven. It had some really interesting sections and it was a quick read, but I found my mind wandering a lot while I was reading. Speaking of wandering, the neighborhood stray that we feed has decided to try to sneak into my car any time the door is open!

JessClark78 🐱❤️ 2y
24 likes1 comment
review
RainyDayReading
post image
Panpan

While the subject matter of this book was fascinating (Oscar Henrich), I don‘t recommend this book at all. Repetitive writing, events are not in chronological order leading to a lot of confusion, some facts were not entirely accurate, and above all it was boring with slow pacing. The author would also leave little bits of foreshadowing or indicate a bit of a scandal and then when it was eventually explained several chapters later, it was 👇🏻

RainyDayReading Like...that‘s it? Essentially building up to nothing. We were reminded as to who people were often on the same page that we were introduced to them (fairly sure I‘ve got enough wherewithal to remember that his closest friend was a librarian, but thanks for telling me every other page). It just....it‘s not good. I can see what the author was trying to do, but it‘s a mess. I really hope someone else writes a book about Oscar in the future. 3y
23 likes1 comment
review
OutsmartYourShelf
post image
Pickpick

Biography of Edward Oscar Heinrich's role as one of the pioneers of forensic science in the US. This was a great read, the cases & techniques talked about here are fascinating. I would recommend this to anyone interested in the origin of forensic science. 4🌟

Thanks to NetGalley and publisher, Icon Books, for the opportunity to read an ARC.

29 likes1 stack add
review
OrangeMooseReads
post image
Pickpick

A look at the man called the American Sherlock Holmes and a father of modern CSI. E.O. ‘Oscar‘ Heinrich was an interesting man. Learning that the investigation techniques that we just expect to occur during an investigation have only been in use for a little more than a century was surprising. Like any science when introduced people didn‘t understand it and were skeptical of it. Heinrich made CSI common and understandable in court.

Darthdad Interesting. This sounds like something worth exploring 3y
38 likes1 stack add1 comment
blurb
OrangeMooseReads
post image

My next listen. It‘s interesting. I like learning the origins of things we just expect and to a point take for granted.

review
rsteve388
Pickpick

This was a well.laid out and well Narrated Audiobook. I enjoyed learning about the father of modern CSI and the techniques he developed to help law enforcement collect evidence and conclude crimes. Oscar Hemich was a fascinating person, meticulous, detailed and specific in his analysis, his work help shaped the analysis that are done in modern day forensic chemist today. Well done. Thoroughly enjoyed

blurb
rsteve388
post image

@Moonprismpower Your #LLFS is in the mail you should get it by Thursday! @Bookgoil

Moonprismpower Yay! I‘m so excited! I love mail. 4y
23 likes1 comment
blurb
rsteve388

My fall Swap boxes are ready to be shipped.out! I'll go to FedEx on Thursday after work to ship out my boxes. Very excited #LitsyLoveFallSwap

review
Hilary427
post image
Mehso-so

Well written, easy to read. A bit dry/bland, but being that it‘s a biography, it‘s to be expected (most people‘s lives are dry/bland 80% of them time 😂). Interesting history, just not a real page turner.

review
Honeybeebooks
post image
Pickpick

Just as Edward Oscar Heinrich had to let the science direct his investigations the author had to let the facts, both flattering and unflattering tell the amazing story of American Sherlock. It was fascinating to learn about EO Heinrich. His achievements in crime scene investigation are amazing yet I had never even heard his name before reading this work. It may be worth a closer look if you are interested in the development of the science in CSI.

review
Nitpickyabouttrains
post image
Pickpick

Non fiction about a scientist who made csi work in America popular. It went through his history and then a few of his more famous cases.

blurb
Julia Harris
post image

Genres: Biography, crime
July 8th- August 11th
Summary: In a lab filled with curiosities–beakers, magnifying lens, Bunsen burners, and hundreds upon hundreds of books–sat an agent who would split at slightest two thousand cases in his forty-year career. Known as the “American Sherlock Holmes,” with a mysterious talent for finding clues, building up proof, and driving answers with an ability that appeared nearly powerful.

marleed Oh my goodness, your photos are gorgeous! 3y
42 likes2 stack adds1 comment
review
Ephemera
post image
Pickpick

For fans of true crime and forensics this is a must-read book. Edward Oscar Heinrich was a brilliant man who devised approaches to crime solving that are still in use today. A graduate of the University of California at Berkeley, Heinrich lived and worked in Berkeley, and was called on for his expert testimony in thousands of cases over the years. A fascinating book. Five stars.

blurb
Bookishgal71
post image

“The forensic scientist who helped ruin Arbuckle‘s career had actually inspired him creatively.” #reesewitherspoonbookclub

13 likes2 stack adds
review
Battledoll
post image
Mehso-so

Finished this while lounging outside in a kiddie pool. It was fine. Some interesting cases but ultimately I think the book was plagued by the same problem Heinrich faced throughout his cases in his lifetime. Ultimately, he did interesting work but was not a very interesting person. His more subdued personality doesn‘t really sell a biography (or a court case!) and his exploits mostly consisted of lab work. It just wasn‘t very engaging.

quote
Battledoll
post image

I‘m about halfway through this book. It‘s interesting but I‘m not super into the writing. The book is a biography about a forensic scientist in the early 1900s. I like the bits about the cases but there is a lot of hero worship and I find the constant comparisons to Sherlock grating. In this bit, Oscar vows to solve a case because his reputation depends on it, but the same could probably be said about his oafish rivals. That‘s how jobs work.

review
thereadingowlvina
post image
Pickpick

🆃🆁🆄🅴 🅲🆁🅸🅼🅴 🆃🅷🆄🆁🆂🅳🅰🆈

A fascinating story about Edward Oscar Heinrich - America's greatest forensic scientist & the nation's first unique crime scene investigator, who helped solve many difficult & puzzling cases during the 1920s-1930s.

Rating: 5⭐

𝐹𝑜𝑟 𝑚𝑦 𝑓𝑢𝑙𝑙 𝑟𝑒𝑣𝑖𝑒𝑤 𝑝𝑙𝑒𝑎𝑠𝑒 𝑣𝑖𝑠𝑖𝑡 https://www.goodreads.com/review/show/3338722827?book_show_action=false&from_rev...

22 likes2 stack adds
review
night_shift
post image
Mehso-so

This took me way too long to read and I only was able to finish due to suddenly having the bright idea to get the audiobook from the library. I breezed through the second half then.
Overall, I found it interesting but dry at times and the details about his private life a bit tedious to read. I haven't decided if I'm going to write a longer review yet.

#arc

Crazeedi My daughter lent me this book, havent read it yet 4y
night_shift @Crazeedi don't get me wrong, it's interesting, but the man's personal life wasn't awfully interesting and there's so much of it included. 4y
61 likes2 comments
quote
NotCool
post image

“Police were preoccupied with enforcing strict anti-drinking laws, so the Bureau of Prohibition “deputized” Ku Klux Klan members.”...I‘m sorry, wtf?!

Smrloomis What?! 🤯 4y
NotCool Blew my mind that this was the first I was hearing about this, but there are sources https://tinyurl.com/y9w7kot7 4y
4 likes1 stack add2 comments
review
CoffeeK8
post image
Pickpick

This tells the story of the Edward Oscar Heinrich the first, and most famous criminal investigator of the 20th century. He was an innovator but also a proponent of some criminal science that has since been debunked.

Crazeedi My daughter just lent me this book, it sounds so good!! 4y
CoffeeK8 I really enjoyed it. It was really an interesting perspective on the development of CSI 4y
49 likes1 stack add2 comments
review
DGRachel
post image
Mehso-so

The development of modern forensics and the man who led the way, is a topic I find interesting. For that reason, this doesn‘t get a pan. But, the text itself was often dry, like listening to someone read a textbook, and there were sections that were repetitive. I agree with reviewers who questioned the necessity of Heinrich‘s personal details interspersed they way they were. I recommend audio over text, though. I‘d have bailed in print.

GingerAntics Duely noted on the print version. I think I‘m going to have to re-evaluate this being on my wish list. 4y
Cinfhen Ugh, I‘ve seen lots of meh reviews for this book and I really loved her previous book 👉🏽 4y
Cinfhen Thanks so much for the tag!!! I‘m going to #BorrowNotBuy 4y
DGRachel @Cinfhen I haven‘t read anything else by this author, but I think Borrow not Buy is a good plan! 4y
73 likes4 comments
blurb
DGRachel
post image

Currently sitting at just over 4 hours for the #24b4Monday readathon, thanks to starting American Sherlock on audio while I worked today. Hoping to read a few pages of Aru Shah before sleep claims me. I have to go into the office Sunday to pack up my desk for the office renovation. It‘s going to take forever, so I‘m hoping to have some solid reading time tomorrow, because I won‘t have it Sunday. 🤞🏻

Andrew65 A good start 👏👏👏 4y
61 likes1 stack add1 comment
review
Hooked_on_books
post image
Pickpick

American Sherlock is a biography of the man who pioneered many forensic techniques in the US, using several of the cases he worked on to illustrate his work. I thought it was fascinating and appreciated the author‘s inclusion of the fact that a number of these techniques have been discredited. My only complaint is the author/narrator‘s pronunciation of certain sounds annoyed me (“kimist” for chemist, etc).

46 likes4 stack adds
review
Chelsea.Poole
post image
Pickpick

Between a "pick" and a "so-so". 1930s #truecrime. A biographical #nonfiction about Edward Oscar Heinrich's personal life, but mainly his contributions to forensics. His brilliant, original ideas helped shape modern practices. He helped developed the study of ballistics, blood splatter patterns, and geological traces found on victims for evidence.

90 likes1 stack add
review
RamsFan1963
post image
Pickpick

I think the book is mistitled, but otherwise it's an interesting look at the birth of American forensic science. I found the cases, including the infamous Fatty Arbuckle trial, and the methodology far more interesting than the so-called American Sherlock, Oscar Heinrich. 3 💥💥💥 1/2

Book 3 for #EasterExtravangza @Andrew65

Andrew65 Well done 👏👏👏 4y
58 likes1 comment
blurb
RamsFan1963
post image

1. The Darkening Age, American Sherlock (which I'm almost finished), The Eyes of the Dragon, The Five and Crisis in The Red Zone.
2. Print, ebook and audiobook
3. The Last Emperox by John Scalzi

#weekendreads @rachelsbrittain

rachelsbrittain I really enjoyed The Collapsing Empire but I haven't read the rest of the series yet 4y
RamsFan1963 @rachelsbrittain I know a lot of people didn't like The Consuming Fire as much as the first book, mainly because it turned more to political intrigue than straight up action. I liked both books. I remember the same criticism of Scalzi's later books in the Old Man's War series. 4y
rachelsbrittain @RamsFan1963 mmmh yeah I can see that. Good to know going in though! 4y
43 likes1 stack add3 comments
blurb
Chelsea.Poole
post image

Easter dinner last night with my current read. a quite different Easter than normal, but not bad! Still spending lots of time with my family, just with more reading time, pjs and potato soup instead of dinner!

rabbitprincess Looks like an interesting book! Right now I am reading another early-forensics book, 4y
RamsFan1963 I just started this on audio, so far it's been very interesting. 4y
100 likes5 stack adds2 comments
review
bookandbedandtea
post image
Mehso-so

This was fascinating (mostly) but uneven. Heinrich was an incredibly intelligent and driven man who pioneered many of the forensics that are still used today in crime solving. The account of him developing his tests was very interesting. The descriptions of some of the trials he worked were also interesting. But the portions about his private life were repetitious & became dull ⬇️

bookandbedandtea esp as they were interspersed at random in chapters about his trials but didn't actually relate to the trial in question. It would have been better if those parts were chapters of their own. Short ones! 4y
night_shift Yeah, I'm trying to read this now and have been for over a month. Those personal life bits are a drag. 😩 4y
bookandbedandtea @UnidragonFrag Definitely! I enjoyed learning about his background and his family but that could have all been condensed to one chapter. Or a paragraph or two between forensics or trial based chapters. 4y
26 likes1 stack add3 comments
review
JeniReadABook
Mehso-so

🌟🌟🌟

blurb
Jess
post image

I joined Jenny Lawson‘s book club and just received my first box. Yes! I can‘t wait to start this book this weekend.

Suzze I‘m about halfway through and love it. Forensics is my jam. Last month‘s book was quirky but good! I think I‘m gonna love the choices. #fantasticstrangelings 4y
StellarDoc Oooh, I wish I'd joined in time for this! My college hosted the author last year, and she's so much fun! 4y
Linsy I haven‘t been able to join the physical book club, but I‘m following along! So far, I love Jenny‘s choices. I‘ll put the audio of this on hold! Looks fascinating 🖤 4y
Jess @Linsy she does have a good picker. I hope you enjoy this one! 4y
24 likes1 stack add4 comments
blurb
McGonagall
post image

Barnes & Noble sent me an email with these recommendations, and I want them all! Have any of you lovely Littens read these yet?

blurb
Mitch
post image

Yeah- the stars are aligned this month - I actually have my birth sign book on pre order!

https://lithub.com/the-astrology-book-club-what-to-read-this-month-based-on-your...

wanderinglynn Wow, the book for my birth sign is also spot on. It would‘ve been a perfect book for my undergrad studies. 4y
Mitch @wanderinglynn I look at them every month and think - we‘re....no! But not this month! Maybe 2020 will be the year of planetary alignment. 👍🏼 4y
wanderinglynn Maybe the stars have aligned. 😂 There are several others on the list, like American Sherlock, that I want to read too. 4y
See All 9 Comments
Bookwormjillk This is fun. My sign was assigned a baseball book which I immediately requested from the library 4y
Mitch @Bookwormjillk looking good for 2020!🥳 4y
DGRachel What‘s funny to me is that I‘m usually more interested in the book recommended to my rising sign rather than my sun sign. This time, I may have to add both to my TBR. 😆 4y
JamieArc My book seems to be spot-on as well! The Force of Non-Violence. As a Quaker, this really appeals to me. Thanks for sharing! 4y
Hooked_on_books Thanks for sharing. I‘m a Cancer and the book is so spot on! Stacked! 4y
ZoraNealeThurstin So cool. Thanks for sharing! 4y
67 likes9 comments