Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
Still Life
Still Life | Sarah Winman
Amazon Indiebound Barnes and Noble WorldCat Goodreads LibraryThing
Pick icon
100%
review
CarolynM
Still Life | Sarah Winman
post image
Pickpick

A gentle meander over 30+ years from the tail end of WWII to 1979 in the lives of a group of East Londoners who relocate to Florence. The fact that I‘m not a fan of Florence, or Italian art, and the ambiguity of the relationships made this a like rather than love book for me but it made for an interesting discussion at my IRL book group last night. Sorry about the sticker - I should have removed it when I bought it, it‘s now well and truly stuck!

MrsMalaprop I like Sarah Winman, but haven‘t gotten to this one yet. 2w
LeahBergen Lovely review. 2w
squirrelbrain This was my favourite book of last year, which surprised me somewhat as it‘s not my usual kind of thing! 2w
Bookwomble Sticker Shame - I hear your pain 😄 2w
84 likes1 stack add4 comments
review
OutAndAbout
Still Life | Sarah Winman
Bailedbailed

The lack of quotations marks was just too confusing, and the characters didn‘t grab me enough to push through.

perfectsinner I hate books without quotes, also. I've not read Sally Rooney for that reason. I did read The Pull of Stars, which also didn't have quotes, but it bothered me once I noticed it and felt the book itself was just ok. I wish I had saved my $ and checked it from the library 3w
OutAndAbout @perfectsinner Sometime it‘s okay not to have quotes, but I think it takes an awfully good writer to pull off each character‘s voice well enough for the reader to follow. I‘m not sure what makes an author risk confusing their readers. I wish I was smart enough to understand that. 3w
28 likes2 comments
blurb
Kimbono
Still Life | Sarah Winman
post image

Started Still Life today and it is delightful! 😍🦜🇮🇹 I‘m not someone who uses words like delightful but that‘s the only word that comes to mind AND this record pairs very well for a delightful reading experience! 🥰 #readingsoundtrack

blurb
Teresereading
Still Life | Sarah Winman
post image
Eggs Pretty photo 🌿💚🪴 2mo
Alwaysbeenaloverofbooks So pretty 🌱 2mo
20 likes2 comments
blurb
Teresereading
Still Life | Sarah Winman
post image

#bookmoods
Set in another century, the story starts in WW2 Florence, one of my all time favourites
@Eggs @Alwaysbeenaloverofbooks

Eggs Beautiful 🐦💙👏🏻 3mo
16 likes1 comment
review
Julsmarshall
Still Life | Sarah Winman
post image
Pickpick

Amazing! The prose in this book is transforming, lyrical, and gorgeous. It paints a picture of the people, places, and moments in a way that makes you feel like you are part of the story and experiencing it along with the characters. I listened on #audio but want to read the hard copy I own too. Perfect for summer with all the travel bits, fabulous art references, and great #lgbtqia+ representation. #BookspinBingo #BOTM @TheAromaofBooks

TheAromaofBooks Lovely cover!! 3mo
53 likes1 stack add1 comment
quote
charl08
Still Life | Sarah Winman
post image

It's what we've always done. Left a mark on a cave, or on a page. Showing who we are, sharing our view of the world, the life we're made to bear. Our turmoil is revealed in those painted faces -- some times tenderly, sometimes grotesquely, but art becomes a mirror. All the symbolism and the paradox, ours to interpret. That's how it becomes part of us. And as counterpoint to our suffering, we have beauty.

63 likes1 stack add
review
Kazzie
Still Life | Sarah Winman
Pickpick

I liked it, but there was a lot going on. I wish the two story lines could have been intertwined better. Or separated? Especially as it was such a long book. There isn‘t a traditional bogging middle end but rather a narrative of a life. Many characters were very lovable. I‘m glad the queer characters and love were so richly drawn

blurb
RobinGustafson
Still Life | Sarah Winman
post image

Saturday reading. This novel is making me crave travel

13 likes1 stack add
review
Cathy_J
Still Life | Sarah Winman
post image
Pickpick

It took me a while to get into this one but I really enjoyed it when it got going. Interesting characters with genuine and heartwarming connections. The historical information and scenery descriptions were great also. ⭐⭐⭐.5

74 likes1 stack add
review
Cazxxx
Still Life | Sarah Winman
post image
Mehso-so

It‘s taken me so long to finish this one. Although it was beautifully written it just didn‘t resonate with me at all. I can see why others loved it but it wasn‘t for me. I‘m giving it a so so because the writing was so descriptive and lovely

blurb
BookNAround
Still Life | Sarah Winman
post image

Thank you so much to @Mitch for the lovely birthday book! Can‘t wait to read it. 😁

Mitch 🎂 Happy - belated - Birthday! 🎂 6mo
64 likes1 comment
blurb
Lissa00
Still Life | Sarah Winman
post image

On vacation and trying to make a dent in my #botm tbr. I am loving both of these books!

review
Jeg
Still Life | Sarah Winman
post image
Pickpick

Excellent, Beautiful. I‘ve loved all her books especially the first one and this book did not disappoint. The greatest descriptions and wonderful characters. Loved loved loved this story.

CarolynM I've been dragging my feet about reading this but it's my #Bookspin book this month so that and your review gives me some extra motivation to get on with it🙂 7mo
Centique I‘m excited to get to this one - and your review makes me even more sure I‘ll love it! 7mo
17 likes1 stack add2 comments
review
Booksnchill
Still Life | Sarah Winman
post image
Pickpick

Well, I fell in love with Florence in 2004 and have returned twice since then as it is a place that never leaves my soul. Like character Evelyn Skinner, I first spent a month in Florence studying art and exploring and that trip was a gift. Still Life is a beautifully quiet book with love and found family and the beauty that is enduring friendship, enduring love and Florence. Read it when you need to feel a connecting love and you will find it.5⭐️

56 likes2 stack adds
review
AnneCecilie
Still Life | Sarah Winman
post image
Pickpick

During WWII, Ulysses Temper meets Evelyn Skinner. After the war Ulysses goes back home to his friends in London. For the next 30 yrs we follow what happens to this group of friends.

About friendship and how friends becomes your family.

Cathythoughts Sounds so good! I have it stacked already😄 7mo
80 likes3 stack adds1 comment
blurb
Penny_LiteraryHoarders
Still Life | Sarah Winman
post image

I‘m putting this aside for now. It just wasn‘t grabbing a hold of me. It‘s probably not the right book at the right time. Now I‘m trying to figure out what to read. I just don‘t know!!

quote
AnneCecilie
Still Life | Sarah Winman
post image

They hadn‘t got far before a small child stopped in front of Evelyn and screamed, Pinocchio! […]
Not a fan? said Dotty as they moved away.
Not as a child, that‘s for certain, said Evelyn. I found him to be a maniac. And when he murdered the talking cricket, I was quite affected. For me it was the silencing of truth. Politically speaking, of course. […]

(It‘s funny when stories you just read, is analyzed in your current read).

review
JillR
Still Life | Sarah Winman
post image
Pickpick

Another one that got me! I didn‘t like this at first because, well, it isn‘t Tin Man. But then I started to like it, and then I started to love it, and then it had me hook, line and sinker. What a stunner. I‘m still carrying these characters around with me. A slow, meandering, heart warming story. Perfect.

squirrelbrain Perfect review! This is exactly how I felt about it too…. Took me while to get into but then it was one of my favourite books ever! ❤️🦜 8mo
Cathythoughts Lovely review! I must stack this one ❤️ 8mo
JillR @squirrelbrain it wasn‘t at all what I was expecting, but I had very high expectations so am so glad it lived up to them once I settled into it! 8mo
See All 10 Comments
JillR @Cathythoughts it‘s a lovely gentle read, hope you get to it x 8mo
TrishB I loved this ❤️ Winman is such a brilliant author. 8mo
emmaturi I really loved this one, and the images of Florence made me so want to go. And now I will go in May! 8mo
JillR @trishb she is, this was so different from her two other books it took me a good while to get into it, but so glad I stuck with it! 8mo
JillR @emmaturi how lovely, I hope you have an amazing time! 8mo
BarbaraBB I‘m glad you loved it. For me it didn‘t live up to Tin Man. And I love your picture 😍 8mo
JillR @barbarabb I think I might have loved Tin Man a little bit more. Such different books though, I should re read Tin Man as it‘s a while since I read it. I think I hit lucky with a burst of winter sunshine when I took the pic! 8mo
47 likes4 stack adds10 comments
review
nathandrake1997
Still Life | Sarah Winman
post image
Pickpick

Summer, an undisclosed time, sitting at a cafe sipping piping hot espresso, the aroma of freshly ground coffee permeating the air, lively chatter abound, whispers of a Fellini retrospective, time comes to a grinding halt, a few strokes of ink on a blank canvas, strokes coalescing into outlines, outlines being filled with colour, the colour being filled varying from the perspective of the subjective lens of the observer....

nathandrake1997 ....Once the colour has been filled, the scene comes to life and the coffee is sipped and the tickets for the Fellini retrospective have been booked and the beans have been ground for the next espresso.... 8mo
nathandrake1997 ....Life, when paused at a particular moment, doesn't feel too far removed from a Still Life composition waiting to be sketched by the strokes of fate. But, are these pauses something we often notice, or even allow? For most of us, the answer is probably no and hence the sketches get progressively messier.... 8mo
nathandrake1997 ....The colours and strokes jumble into an incoherent mess and before long, the painting is an incomprehensible jumble of a once visible still life.... 8mo
See All 8 Comments
nathandrake1997 ....The writing style echoes this phenomenon magnificently by describing every sequence in decadent detail before explaining its significance to the plot.... 8mo
nathandrake1997 ....The prose, when compared to TIN MAN, feels more indulgent, but in a good way. From films to food to wine to art, everything is rendered in decadent detail and the diorama of this decadence leaps off the page and envelopes the readers sense in a manner that feels surreal.This is a novel meant to be read, seen, heard, smelled and tasted.... 8mo
nathandrake1997 ....This is one of those books where every moment needs to be savoured and every detail needs to be soaked in for all the pieces of the puzzle to come together. This is a novel that requires patience and rewards it in spades.... 8mo
nathandrake1997 ....With this being my second Winman, she has already made it to my list of all-time favourite authors ❤️ There is so much to love here and so much to savour, this is a novel that feels rich and decadent in a manner novels seldom do ❤️ 8mo
TrishB I love her books ❤️ 8mo
22 likes1 stack add8 comments
blurb
Penny_LiteraryHoarders
Still Life | Sarah Winman
post image

Tea and Still Life by the fire.

blurb
Penny_LiteraryHoarders
Still Life | Sarah Winman
post image

I‘ll be finished the book I‘m reading now within the next hour. What should I go with next??

PurpleyPumpkin Ooh that looks like a tough choice!🤔 I‘m leaning towards The Lincoln Highway. It‘s on my tbr too! 8mo
Penny_LiteraryHoarders @PurpleyPumpkin my friend just said the audio is wonderful for The Lincoln Highway….do I wait for it or do I read my own copy of the book?? Such decisions! (edited) 8mo
PurpleyPumpkin Recently, I‘ve had the opportunity to read both the physical and audio versions of books in tandem. I have to say, it‘s a great way to experience a book! Ahhh, hard choices! 8mo
Penny_LiteraryHoarders @PurpleyPumpkin I‘ve been doing that a lot too!! 8mo
27 likes4 comments
blurb
Branwen
Still Life | Sarah Winman
post image

Hi friends! My new book rec videos are up for the week! Would be most grateful if you would give them a view and a like! 😌

Honorable Mentions for the best of 2021: YA!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f41Hd31D9qQ&t=1s

Honorable Mentions for the best of 2021: Adult Fiction!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F640cwbHm_E&t=7s

Next week I'm going to feature my FAVE Fantasy/SF books of 2021! 💕 📚

Dragon Just borrowed Olympus Texas from Libby - thanks for the review 👍 8mo
Branwen @Dragon Oh my goodness! YAY! I'm so glad! You'll have to let me know what you think of it! 8mo
Dragon 👍💚🐉 8mo
See All 7 Comments
kspenmoll You have a great presence on video! 8mo
Branwen @kspenmoll Oh my goodness, thank you so much for your kind words! I appreciate you! ❤ You really think so? I get nervous sometimes that I sound like a huge weirdo! 😂🤣 8mo
vivastory Looking forward to watching these. Also, this is one of my favorite bookish shirts. So comfortable! 8mo
Branwen @vivastory Thank you so much! 😃I totally agree! It's one of the most comfy shirts I own! 8mo
45 likes7 comments
review
Jbakesmcgee3
Still Life | Sarah Winman
post image
Pickpick

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ this was a heartwarming lovely book. Loved all of the art and the love for Florence. It was a little unbelievable at times but still a happy nice story

review
kellock
Still Life | Sarah Winman
post image
Pickpick

What a lovely book. I now want to go on holiday to Italy 🇮🇹 💗

blurb
Mitch
Still Life | Sarah Winman
post image

Well I‘m going to have a very cosy afternoon! Thank you so much @Magpiegem all the decorations have come down today and it feels sad! So this wonderful gift couldn‘t be better timed. Thank you 🙏 #littlechristmasswap

BiblioLitten I still kept one pair of fairy lights on after taking down the Christmas tree.🎄 9mo
Mitch @BiblioLitten I have kept one little battery operated set too. Just couldn‘t bear to be without twinkly lights for a year! 🤣 9mo
Magpiegem I‘m so pleased the added a little bit of cosy joy in to a decorationless day. My house feels so dull and empty without all the sparkles and shine of Christmas. It‘s a great idea to keep some lights up… I should of done that! Xx 9mo
87 likes3 comments
blurb
Christinak
Still Life | Sarah Winman
post image

Next up - I hope this lives up to the hype.

36 likes1 stack add
blurb
kellock
Still Life | Sarah Winman
post image

Starting this today from my sick bed 🤧

rockpools Get well soon! 9mo
Cathythoughts ❤️ 9mo
16 likes2 comments
blurb
Penny_LiteraryHoarders
Still Life | Sarah Winman
post image

Had to exchange something at Indigo today and of course, oops, bought two books. With Boxing Day savings and rewards I paid the same for the hardcover as I did the softcover! Glad I waited to buy The Magician.

AmyG The Magician is just fabulous. 9mo
Penny_LiteraryHoarders @AmyG Yes, my friend said it was her favourite book of 2021 so I‘m going off of that! Happy to hear your thoughts about it too Amy! Thank you. 9mo
AmyG Fyi-it started a little slow for me but hang in if that happens to you. So worth it. (edited) 9mo
38 likes4 comments
blurb
kellock
Still Life | Sarah Winman
post image

And a Merry Christmas to me 🎄🎁🎅 been wanting this for ages

review
Brimful
Still Life | Sarah Winman
post image
Pickpick

I loved this immersive and sensuous celebration of the lives and loves of an unconventional quasi family over the second half of the twentieth century. Food art Florence and the highs and lows of life. I particularly liked the way that the author rejects stereotypes of class gender and sexuality to create a world where anything is possible with the support of those you love. A perfect antidote to current times!

review
Breanne1
Still Life | Sarah Winman
post image
Pickpick

I absolutely loved this book and it‘s cast of characters. Especially Claude 🦜. The book starts slow but is well worth sticking with as you wind up falling in love with the setting and characters of this rich story. #botm

jlhammar Can‘t wait to read this! 9mo
Breanne1 Hope you enjoy it as much as I did @jlhammar 9mo
16 likes1 stack add2 comments
blurb
Brimful
Still Life | Sarah Winman

I have listened to a few audiobooks this year and enjoyed them but this is the first one I have found immersive and compelling. Really enjoying the listen

review
KristiAhlers
Still Life | Sarah Winman
post image
Mehso-so

I‘ve finally finished this one. Started it last month and put it down for a bit. I loved the characters and the historical details but the storyline itself was a slog at times. Really wanted to like it more than I did.

Jas16 I felt the same way about this one. 10mo
KristiAhlers @Jas16 yeah I really thought this one was going to be amazing. Could‘ve seriously been 100+ pages less. 10mo
32 likes2 comments
blurb
Julsmarshall
Still Life | Sarah Winman
post image

#BOTM book haul 😄

blurb
Branwen
Still Life | Sarah Winman
post image

For me, it was definitely Still Life by Sarah Winman which I finished over the weekend! It was so slow and soft and beautifully written! I'm still thinking about it! 😃❤

What about you?

See All 12 Comments
wanderinglynn A great finale to the amazing Hell‘s Library trilogy: 10mo
wanderinglynn @RamsFan1963 that sounds like a fascinating book! 👍🏻 10mo
BookBelle84 Loved this one 10mo
Nelnjali My most recent 5 star book was 10mo
marleed I just finished Will, still grading but I think it may be a 5* 10mo
Ddzmini I‘ve read so many and I‘m missing all of the fun here because school has me writing 20-30 pg. papers but the books I‘ve loved include “A man called Ove”, The new “Dune”… (because it‘s different for the old one I have), “the origin of consciousness in the break down of the mind” and the tagged book there are so many🤨📖 10mo
Ddzmini Yep that‘s what Litsyversary is all about recommending great books and making your tbr pile go crazy 😜 10mo
46 likes12 comments
blurb
Branwen
Still Life | Sarah Winman
post image

My littlest bookworm once again using my current book as a pillow! 😹❤📚 I'm hoping to finish this one up today, so far it's been BEAUTIFUL. The writing is absolutely hypnotic and mesmerizing! #catsoflitsy #littenkitten #rumpel

Mitch Stunning kitty ( and the book looks good too!) 🤣 10mo
squirrelbrain Loved this book, especially Claude! 🦜❤️ 10mo
Branwen @Mitch Thank you! 😹 @squirrelbrain CLAUDE! HE WAS SO CUTE! ❤🐦 10mo
54 likes3 comments
blurb
Branwen
Still Life | Sarah Winman
post image

The world seems like a very dark place today. I've been watching the news reports about the latest school shooting and am just heartbroken. Hiding out with my book and some hot chocolate tonight. Stay safe out there, my friends.📚💞

blurb
Julsmarshall
Still Life | Sarah Winman
post image

Chose these after a few days of consideration. I hear good things about both!

review
BarbaraBB
Still Life | Sarah Winman
post image
Mehso-so

#UnpopularOpinion Unfortunately I did not enjoy this book as much as I expected to. While I mostly enjoy character-driven novels, I do want some sort of plot too. Considering how many decades this story spans, I was expecting a bit more of that. Instead I was sidetracked by keeping track of all characters and all dialogues - without quotation marks. So I am afraid I didn‘t get as much out of the book as I had hoped, based on all reviews I read.

TrishB Aww, that‘s a shame! I loved it, but that‘s the way of books. (edited) 10mo
Jas16 I was so excited about this book but didn‘t love it either. 10mo
squirrelbrain Oh dear, I loved it too, like @TrishB but the world would be a boring place if we all liked the same books! 10mo
See All 6 Comments
catebutler Most of my book group had the same opinion. They really hated the format. I had to re-read about 100 pages at the beginning. And switch from an ebook to a physical book. For some reason, the second I did this, it just clicked. And I actually really enjoyed it. I do think I dug deeper and went down a few rabbits holes, when everyone else in my book club didn‘t. But the polarised discussion we had was so intriguing! Thank you for tagging me above! 10mo
Cinfhen I started the audio a few weeks ago and bailed!! 🤷🏼‍♀️ 10mo
rmaclean4 Such a shame, I loved this one. 10mo
76 likes2 stack adds6 comments
blurb
BarbaraBB
Still Life | Sarah Winman
post image

#weeklyforecast 47/21

I started Still Life and the beginning is gooood! I am also starting My Life in Doha for #ReadingAsia2021 and will be trying to read a book from the #ToB22 longlist each week until the shortlist is announced. Looking forward to all of these!

Cinfhen Ohhh, good idea regarding #ToB 💕💕 10mo
TrishB Enjoy ♥️ 10mo
squirrelbrain I thought the beginning of Still Life was a bit slow, then suddenly I was captivated so it‘s only going to get better! 10mo
See All 6 Comments
emmaturi I enjoyed Still Life very much 10mo
BarbaraBB @squirrelbrain @emmaturi Looking forward to It! 10mo
Vansa I absolutely loved Still Life.Beautiful and moving, and so heart warming 10mo
70 likes1 stack add6 comments
review
Hooked_on_books
Still Life | Sarah Winman
post image
Bailedbailed

I listened to the first 20% of this and I‘m just not at all engaged in it, so back it goes to the library! I really don‘t know if it‘s me or the book. 🤷🏼‍♀️

Soubhiville I didn‘t really connect with her last book so I think I‘ll pass this one by. 10mo
EvieBee I had a question about E. M. Forster in this one. Is he an actual ghost? (edited) 10mo
Hooked_on_books @EvieBee I‘m afraid I have no idea. It just didn‘t stick with me at all. 10mo
60 likes3 comments
blurb
catebutler
Still Life | Sarah Winman
post image

It‘s been moody & overcast all day, & just started raining. Perfect weather to work on a few to do‘s on my list, & of course sneaking in a chapter or two of my current read, during lunch. I chose this for my IRL bookclub, which meets next week. I can‘t wait to discuss its many themes: art, what constitutes art, humanity, simple pleasures, living in the moment, & a fabulous cast of memorable characters. Is this book on your radar?

BarbaraBB Yes it is. Just about to start it. 10mo
catebutler @BarbaraBB Love to hear your thoughts when you finish! We had such a stimulating convo about this book at book club earlier this week. So I‘d love to hear your opinion. ☺️ (edited) 10mo
BarbaraBB I‘ll tag you in my review! It seems like a good book club book! 10mo
See All 6 Comments
BookBabe Well, it‘s on my radar now! 😊 Beautiful photo as always ❤️ How are you? 9mo
catebutler @BookBabe It was so lovely to have your message pop up! How are you!? 👋🏼 We had an amazing discussion with this book. I wish it would have had more art but it was such a feel good book, and had incredible characters. I‘m doing well, I just finished my first semester, pre-requisites for a Master‘s program in Literature. It‘s been crazy returning to school after 10 years. But I love it! Love to hear how you‘ve been!! 🥰 9mo
BookBabe Wow, congratulations on going after your Master‘s in Literature! 😃🙌🏻 As for the book, feel-good with incredible characters sounds good to me. ☺️ I‘m doing well, enjoying my new life as a Mama! Definitely cut into my reading time 😂 but sooo worth it! 9mo
55 likes6 comments
blurb
Branwen
Still Life | Sarah Winman
post image

I think this is the fastest my Book of the Month box came in! November 2nd and it's here already!? 😲 I'm really hyped for all three of these books honestly, but I've been looking forward to the tagged book for a long while so I'll probably start with that one! 💕📚 #botm #bookmail

squirrelbrain Still life is amazing! ❤️ 🦜😢 11mo
vivastory I received mine yesterday. I was shocked 11mo
TrishB Tagged book is wonderful. 11mo
53 likes3 comments
blurb
rachaich
Still Life | Sarah Winman
post image

My books of October.
Stillife was definitely the best 😍🤗😍, though all were worth reading.

blurb
Branwen
Still Life | Sarah Winman
post image

OMG YAY! 🎉🎉🎉 The Book Of the Month picks are up super early! 🎉🎉🎉 I thought I had my choices all decided, but then I saw Still Life as an add on and had to rearrange things a bit! 😁 I'm excited for the main picks they had, but Still Life was such a great surprise! What us everyone else getting? 💕📚💕 #botm

BrittanyReads I picked Keeper of the Night as well! 11mo
54 likes1 comment
review
rachaich
Still Life | Sarah Winman
post image
Pickpick

Oh my, i adored this. Beautiful writing and an intriguing plot which meandered through mid 20th century London and Italy. Made me want to return to Italy. 😍😍☀️🌞.
I think I've read one of her others and now want to read more!

BarbaraBB Read this one, so so good: 12mo
rachaich @BarbaraBB thanks, it looks really good:) 12mo
Oryx I really want to go to Florence after reading this. 12mo
BarbaraBB That‘s my favorite so far and by far. But I haven‘t read Still Life yet! 12mo
Tamra Anxious to read! 12mo
22 likes5 comments
blurb
rachaich
Still Life | Sarah Winman
post image

Oh, this is good!
I heard bits of it on Radio 4a few weeks ago and then book club chose it to read.
Chunkster but really keeping my attention 😍😍😊😊😉

review
Teresereading
Still Life | Sarah Winman
post image
Pickpick

#FallTreasures Day 26 #BirdonCover
Still Life is an exceptional novel. Sublime.
@Alwaysbeenaloverofbooks @Eggs

MidnightBookGirl Your picture is also sublime! 12mo
Eggs Beautiful! 12mo
Alwaysbeenaloverofbooks Beautiful photo 📚🐦❤️ 12mo
20 likes1 stack add3 comments