Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
Idlewild
Idlewild | James Frankie Thomas
21 posts | 18 read | 18 to read
A darkly funny story of two adults looking back on their intense teenage friendship, in a queer, trans, and early-Internet twist on the Manhattan prep school novel Idlewild is a tiny, artsy Quaker high school in lower Manhattan. Students call their teachers by their first names, there are no grades, and every day begins with 20 minutes of contemplative silence in the Meetinghouse. It is during one of those meetings that an airplane hits the Twin Towers. For two Idlewild outcasts, 9/11 serves as the first day of an intense, 18-month friendship. Fay is prickly, aloof, and obsessed with gay men; Nell is shy, sensitive, and obsessed with Fay. The two of them bond fiercely and spend all their waking hours giddily parsing their environment for homoerotic subtext. Then, during rehearsals for the fall play, they notice two sexually ambiguous boys who are potential candidates for their exclusive Invert Society. The pairs become mirrors of one another and drive each other to make choices that they'll regret for the rest of their lives. Looking back on these events as adults, the estranged Fay and Nell trace that fateful school year, recalling backstage theater department intrigue, antiwar demonstrations, smutty fanfic written over AIM and a shared dial-up connection--and the spectacular cascade of mistakes, miscommunications, and betrayals that would ultimately tear the two of them apart.
Amazon Indiebound Barnes and Noble WorldCat Goodreads LibraryThing
blurb
BarbaraBB
Idlewild | James Frankie Thomas
post image

It‘s our second zombie match and again the zombie is the winner! A close call again and test Idlewild beats Wellness. Who would have guessed? I know I didn‘t!
Idlewild is the book that has received the most zombie votes. Will it be enough to take away the 🦃 against Sinners?
Tomorrow we‘ll post the final match of our #LitsyToB24 and then you can all vote for your winner! One more day to go!

Bookwormjillk Zombie vs zombie wow! Idlewild was the first book I read off the list and I don‘t know if that‘s why it‘s so memorable to me. 8mo
See All 19 Comments
Megabooks We‘re not voting today? I‘m having tire problems. Stuck near home. 😭😭 8mo
BarbaraBB @Megabooks Oh no. Near home still. Any help coming? I can‘t believe your bad luck. My heart goes out to you! Tomorrow is the voting, below the final post. There won‘t be another form, because tomorrow is the end of the tournament! I hope that‘s okay!! X 8mo
Kitta Interesting! I wasn‘t a huge fan of Idlewild, it was good but not great for me. I gave it a so-so. Maybe I‘m the only one who disagreed here! 😂 8mo
BarbaraBB @Kitta I am sure you‘re not, many people rooted for Wellness! 8mo
kwmg40 Interesting to see the two zombies in the final! Looking forward to seeing how it plays out. 8mo
Ruthiella I really loved Idewild and voted for it as a zombie, so am totally glad to see it come back to life! 🧟‍♀️ 8mo
BkClubCare I will read Idlewild if it wins! 8mo
BarbaraBB @Ruthiella Me too and now I hope it‘ll win! 8mo
BarbaraBB @BkClubCare That‘s great and of course you can‘t go wrong with it if your Littens made it the winner 😀 8mo
BarbaraBB @kwmg40 Who would have thought, a zombie finals! I don‘t think that has ever happened before! 🧟 🧟‍♀️ 8mo
sarahbarnes Wow! I thought Wellness might take it all! I really liked Idlewild though. Loving the drama of this tournament! 8mo
fredthemoose Ooooh… the plot thickens! 8mo
Hooked_on_books Woohoo!!!!! 🥳 Idlewild was one of my best reads of 2023 and Wellness was just ok for me, so I‘m thrilled! I was sure it would go the other way. And now an all zombie final! Cool! 8mo
BarbaraBB @sarahbarnes @fredthemoose @Hooked_on_books Yes, the drama! Tomorrow the grande finale 😀 8mo
AmyG I would have thought Wellness would have won. Wow. (edited) 8mo
Chelsea.Poole What a surprise! 8mo
57 likes1 stack add19 comments
review
Kitta
Idlewild | James Frankie Thomas
post image
Mehso-so

⭐️⭐️⭐️

Interesting debut by a trans author!

Centred on an intense friendship in a New York City high school that begins on 9/11, this novel kinda slightly missed the mark for me.

I was interested in the fate of the characters but the chapters using AIM chat and livejournal blog posts were off putting to me.

Something about Nell and Fays blog really made me uncomfortable? I don‘t know how to articulate it.

#lgbtq2024 #lgbtqbookbingo @Kenyazero

Kitta Also a late read for #litsyToB #LitsyToB24 8mo
Ruthiella I think the journals were meant to be awkward and off putting. Teenagers are figuring things out. I can‘t read my diaries from my younger years. I cringe. 😬 (edited) 8mo
squirrelbrain Great review, although I loved this one! 8mo
See All 8 Comments
Kitta @Ruthiella that makes sense then, it was definitely awkward reading them! I stopped keeping a diary after my sister started writing responses to what I wrote in mine! I never thought anyone would read it never mind write their thoughts back! 😱 8mo
Kitta @squirrelbrain I don‘t usually read anything about teenagers because I‘m just not interested but I wanted to make an exception for this one! I think the second half was better than the first and most people seemed to enjoy it! I think I‘m the odd one out. It wasn‘t bad, just not for me. 8mo
dabbe 🖤🐾🖤 8mo
Kenyazero Sounds like an interesting concept, at the very least! Always disappointing when a book misses the mark. 8mo
Kitta @Kenyazero a lot of others really loved it! But at least I can check off disappointing read on my bingo card haha 8mo
25 likes8 comments
blurb
Kitta
Idlewild | James Frankie Thomas
post image

But late for this one for #litsyToB24 but I‘m going to start it today!

New happy lamp that looks like the moon 🌕 perfect for this rainy day.

#litsyToB #lgbtqbookbingo #lgbtq2024

BarbaraBB Love the 💡 and the book 🤍 8mo
squirrelbrain Enjoy the book! I love your light too. 8mo
Kitta @BarbaraBB @squirrelbrain thanks! I am enjoying the book so far but only read about 2 hours yesterday so more to read today!! 8mo
31 likes1 stack add3 comments
review
LiteraryinPA
Idlewild | James Frankie Thomas
post image
Pickpick

This was so much more than I expected it to be. It was a really immersive, absorbing look at the intertwining lives of a group of theater kids at a Manhattan Quaker high school in 2001-2002. Strong themes of queerness in many forms, sex, art, love, friendship, obsession, control, and more. I recommend it!

BarbaraBB Totally agree! 8mo
56 likes2 stack adds1 comment
review
fredthemoose
Idlewild | James Frankie Thomas
post image
Pickpick

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Coming of age/friendship story of queer friends at a Quaker school in NYC in the immediate aftermath of 9/11. I was initially a little put off by the obnoxiousness of the MCs, but grew more sympathetic to what they were dealing with in terms of friendship and identity, especially 20+ years ago. #LitsyToB24

squirrelbrain Weren‘t we all that obnoxious at that age?! 🤣 9mo
LiteraryinPA I‘m reading this now and I totally get what you mean! 9mo
Ruthiella @squirrelbrain I was so reminded of how awful I must have been as a teenager when I read this book! I was so disdainful of others who didn‘t share my worldview and so sure I was right…except for when I was totally insecure. 😂 9mo
53 likes3 comments
review
kwmg40
Idlewild | James Frankie Thomas
post image
Pickpick

I can't say I “enjoyed“ this novel, as it brought back memories of some of the aspects I hated the most about high school. However, it was a good coming-of-age story with a mix of light-heartedness and darkly satirical humour.

#gottacatchemall @PuddleJumper (prompt 6: “Thievul: Set in a city“)
#LitsyToB24 @squirrelbrain @Megabooks @BarbaraBB
#52bookclub24 (prompt 51: Related to the word “Wild“)

Librarybelle One of those rare 100% rating books on Litsy! 9mo
Megabooks There are definitely some painful coming of age moments in this one. 9mo
squirrelbrain This is one of my favourites from our list, but I can see why it might bring back bad memories. 9mo
See All 6 Comments
BarbaraBB I agree she writes very accurate about coming of age and high school time 9mo
Ruthiella I agree that the author got the pain of adolescence right, but also the joy of close friendships-how they develop their own vocabulary and mannerisms. 9mo
PuddleJumper 🦊🦊 9mo
50 likes6 comments
review
Ruthiella
Idlewild | James Frankie Thomas
post image
Pickpick

A compelling coming of age story which was both familiar and disturbing. Fay and Nell are best friends at a NYC private Quaker high school navigating teenage insecurity, solipsism, and queerness. Their friendship is insular and uneven, with Fay leading and Nell following. Seamlessly told in flashback by their adult selves, regretful and nostalgic.

Read for #LitsyToB24
#Pop24 Fiction by a trans author
#52Bookclub24 About finding identity

Hooked_on_books I really liked this one. I think it‘ll stick for a while. 10mo
Librarybelle Nice! 10mo
See All 19 Comments
Liz_M I was going to add this to my wishlist, based on your review, but it's already there. Now I know I really do want to read it. 😁 10mo
TheAromaofBooks Great progress!! 10mo
squirrelbrain Glad you liked it! 10mo
BarbaraBB Fab review! Such a good read. 10mo
Ruthiella @Hooked_on_books I think this will stick with me too. I am drawn to good portraits of adolescence and this was one. 10mo
Ruthiella @Liz_M I found it to be quite a page turner! 10mo
Ruthiella @squirrelbrain I thought of you when I managed to hit TWO reading prompts with one book. 😆 10mo
Ruthiella @BarbaraBB Thank you! I found it so compelling. 10mo
squirrelbrain Ooh, you clever thing! 🤣 And here‘s me, only doing *one* challenge this year, so no double-dipping (or more!) here. 10mo
Reggie Stacked. Wasn‘t gonna read this until now. Great review. Also credit to Tom Lake and looking back on one‘s life. 10mo
Ruthiella @Reggie It is rare when I can recommend you a book Reggie! I think, however you will like it. It has a lot of emotion and a little edge of fear. 10mo
Megabooks Love this review and this book, too!! 10mo
Megabooks @Reggie I agree with @Ruthiella definitely in your wheelhouse! 👍🏻👍🏻 10mo
Ruthiella Thanks! I‘m a real fan of good depictions of adolescence and this really felt right to me. 10mo
83 likes1 stack add19 comments
review
Deblovestoread
Idlewild | James Frankie Thomas
post image
Pickpick

#LitsyTOB. High schoolers trying to figure out who they are and looking for connection at a Quaker school. The friendship of the two MC‘s starts the day of 9/11 and grows through their Junior and Senior years. A good debut novel. #52Bookclub24 #RelatingtoWild 4🌟

BarbaraBB I really liked this one. 10mo
Megabooks Agree! I‘m excited to see what they write next! 10mo
Hooked_on_books I thought this one was lovely. I think it‘ll stick with me for a long time. 10mo
See All 7 Comments
TheAromaofBooks Woohoo!! 10mo
Librarybelle Sounds really good! 10mo
Crazeedi Sounds good 10mo
squirrelbrain Glad you enjoyed it! ❤️ 10mo
71 likes7 comments
review
sarahbarnes
Idlewild | James Frankie Thomas
post image
Pickpick

Last book of 2023. I really enjoyed this one. It had me laughing out loud at certain moments - Thomas captures the absurd world of teenagers so perfectly. At the same time Nell‘s and Faye‘s experiences into adulthood broke my heart. Thomas captures all of it so poignantly and the ending felt real in a way I appreciated. #LitsyTOB24

Megabooks Glad you enjoyed it! 11mo
BarbaraBB Great review, totally agree! 11mo
squirrelbrain I loved this one too. ❤️ 11mo
Reggie Happy New Year, Sarah! 11mo
sarahbarnes Happy New Year, @Reggie !! 11mo
29 likes1 stack add5 comments
review
Hooked_on_books
Idlewild | James Frankie Thomas
post image
Pickpick

I‘m so glad this one was on the #tob24 longlist and our LitsyTOB24, because it was not on my radar and I just loved it! I was fully drawn in to Nell and Fay‘s world and friendship as they each try to understand their own identities. My only quibble is it‘s sometimes unclear who‘s who on the audio. Terrific read.

TrishB Still really expensive here. Waiting for an offer 🤞🏻 as I‘m really intrigued. 11mo
Megabooks Yes! A really great tob choice! 11mo
32 likes2 comments
review
Well-ReadNeck
Idlewild | James Frankie Thomas
post image
Pickpick

This #LitsyToB24 title will likely be my final read of 2023. I plowed through this angsty high school drama and especially appreciate that the epilogue gives a “where are they now” for all of the characters.

review
Bookwormjillk
Idlewild | James Frankie Thomas
post image
Pickpick

Wow, what a ride. I usually avoid books about teenagers and/or 9/11, but my library had this one and it‘s on the #LitsyTOB24 list. I really enjoyed it after all, and kind of don‘t want to read anything else until Monday so I can end this year on a high note.

squirrelbrain So glad you loved it! ❤️ 11mo
BarbaraBB Great idea about the year‘s ending! 11mo
Megabooks I‘m still thinking about that ending!! 11mo
61 likes1 stack add4 comments
review
Addison_Reads
Idlewild | James Frankie Thomas
post image
Pickpick

#tob24 long list

Give me a story with well-developed characters that allow me to see and experience the world around them, and I am hooked. Idlewild was such an enjoyable read that made me think, made me feel, and even surprised me.

It's a great story about growing up and reflecting, and the 9/11 storyline was very well handled in it.

And, I loved the ending. 😁

squirrelbrain This seems to be a fave with many of us! 11mo
Megabooks The ending was spectacular! 11mo
38 likes2 comments
review
BarbaraBB
Idlewild | James Frankie Thomas
post image
Pickpick

Nell and Fay are delightfully weird, teenage friends, so inseparable that part of the book is narrated by their collective consciousness, the “F&N unit”. Inseparable for 18 months that is: we know from the start that the Unit will not last. Until that tragic moment I was lost in their growing op in NYC post 9/11, in search of their own identity and sexuality, mirroring themselves in two boys they are a bit obsessed with. A great debut! #LitsyToB24

Jas16 Great picture(and review)! (edited) 11mo
Librarybelle Awesome photo! 11mo
Ruthiella Looking forward to this one! 11mo
See All 14 Comments
Deblovestoread Amazing photo and great review. (edited) 11mo
squirrelbrain So glad you loved it too! Fabulous photo. ❤️ 11mo
TrishB Great pic. On my need to buy list! 11mo
sarahbarnes Can‘t wait for this one! 11mo
Hooked_on_books Great picture! But that‘s no surprise from you. This one sounds really interesting! It hadn‘t jumped out at me from the longlist, so I‘m glad we picked it, since it‘ll prompt me to read it. 11mo
BarbaraBB @Hooked_on_books It‘s another one about friendship. I am looking forward to what you‘ll think of this one in comparison to Em&Emily and Rachel&James! 11mo
Suet624 Oooh, sounds great! 11mo
Megabooks I thought the ending was spectacular. It‘s one that I‘m still reflecting on. 11mo
Megabooks Also very cool stuff going on in your neighborhood this Christmas! 11mo
batsy What a photo! 😍 And I wasn't quite interested in this one but you might have changed my mind. 11mo
BarbaraBB @batsy I‘d like you to: see above what I mentioned to @Hooked_on_books 😂 11mo
76 likes2 stack adds14 comments
review
Jas16
Idlewild | James Frankie Thomas
post image
Pickpick

On the morning of 9/11, Nell finally speaks to Faye, the subject of her huge crush. Although the attraction is not reciprocated, the two strike up an intense friendship. Faye is more fixated on gay boys and becomes curious about two male students at their school. The awkward teenage search for understanding about identity and relationships come through so viscerally, I was reminded of how much I would never want to revisit those years. #litsytob24

squirrelbrain So true about never wanting to revisit teenage years. 11mo
Megabooks Visceral is a great description of this novel. These were fantastically drawn characters. 11mo
Megabooks @squirrelbrain I loved my teenage years! 😂😂 I was a really awkward tween, but I actually enjoyed high school. 11mo
BarbaraBB Great review! I am starting this right now! 11mo
48 likes4 comments
review
Chelsea.Poole
Idlewild | James Frankie Thomas
post image
Pickpick

When your book matches your flowers from a friend 💐
Really enjoyed this NYC Quaker school-set coming of age novel from the #tob24 longlist. I‘m really grateful because I‘d never have picked this up otherwise. Nell and Faye are friends but using each other for different purposes in their post 9/11 year…finding themselves and defining their queerness in relation to each other and a cast of classmates. I was wrapped up in the drama! Pick for sure!

squirrelbrain This is one of my favourites from the list and I‘d never even heard of it before. Lovely flowers! 11mo
89 likes1 stack add1 comment
review
Megabooks
Idlewild | James Frankie Thomas
post image
Pickpick

I didn‘t love this as much as some other #tob24 readers did. Top half, but not top third. 🤷🏻‍♀️

Burgeoning lesbian Nell has a crush on high school classmate Faye. When 9/11 brings them together for a tumultuous 15 months, they navigate their different emerging queer identities. They obsess over a pair of boys who have their own odd sexual energy, and the foursome together is the definition of toxic friendships!

BarbaraBB This one just arrived today. I hope I‘ll like it too. 12mo
Megabooks @BarbaraBB me too! 12mo
66 likes2 comments
review
MicheleinPhilly
Idlewild | James Frankie Thomas
post image
Pickpick

I did NOT expect to enjoy this as much as I did seeing as I‘m almost 30 years out of high school. But I found it to be really witty and touching. My only quibble was wanting to spend more time with Fay and Nell in adulthood. #TOB24

Ruthiella This one is sounding more and more like a must read, regardless of whether it makes the shortlist or not! 12mo
See All 7 Comments
TrishB On my after Christmas buy list! 12mo
squirrelbrain Yay - I‘m glad you liked it too! Always a worry when you rave-review something first, in case everyone else hates it! 😮‍💨 12mo
BarbaraBB I have purchased a copy after @squirrelbrain ‘s review. Glad you loved it too. 12mo
BkClubCare 😎 12mo
59 likes1 stack add7 comments
review
squirrelbrain
Idlewild | James Frankie Thomas
post image
Pickpick

Another #ToB longlister that I loved and wouldn‘t ever have read otherwise.

Idlewild is a small Quaker school in Manhattan. Nell is gay and is obsessed with Fay who, in turn is obsessed with gay men. During rehearsals for the school play they notice two sexually ambiguous boys who they encourage to join their Invert Society.

If you love academia novels you‘ll love this, and if you read and liked Cyclorama, I think this is even better.

erzascarletbookgasm That‘s a lovely view! 12mo
Hooked_on_books Sounds good, plus, beautiful picture! 12mo
batsy This sounds interesting! And agreed, that's a lovely backdrop 😍 12mo
See All 13 Comments
charl08 Beautiful setting. 12mo
RebelReader My library only had the audiobook and it a 24 week wait! 😫 Hopefully it makes the shortlist! 😝 12mo
Megabooks Oh wow! So excited for this now!! 🤩🤩 Have a great holiday! 12mo
Chelsea.Poole I‘m intrigued! 12mo
sarahbarnes I‘m very interested in this one and even more so now! I love academia novels and really liked Cyclorama. 12mo
Suet624 Thanks for the recommendation. I have it on hold at the library. 12mo
MicheleinPhilly Just borrowed from the library! 🎉 12mo
Ruthiella That‘s a ringing endorsement! Stacked! 12mo
BarbaraBB That‘s quite the recommendation! My expectations are now sky high and I am going to look for a copy immediately 🤣 12mo
Well-ReadNeck Aaaaaaah! Must read now! 12mo
77 likes5 stack adds13 comments
blurb
Megabooks
Idlewild | James Frankie Thomas
post image

Always copying @squirrelbrain 🫶🏻 This is what I‘ve saved audible credits for all year: holidays and the Tournament of Books!! 🥂 #tob24

BarbaraBB Well deserved 💕 12mo
Megabooks @BarbaraBB 😘😘 such a fun time of year but bittersweet not sharing it with Cindy, too! 😢 12mo
BarbaraBB Absolutely, I‘ve been thinking about that too. I miss her very much! 12mo
See All 6 Comments
squirrelbrain Makes a change from me copying you! 🤣 12mo
Megabooks @squirrelbrain I listened to VC yesterday and today while I did stuff and ran errands (and for sanity/relaxation 🤣), and it‘s really good! I may finish today. It‘s one I‘m really glad the tob spurred me to buy. 12mo
squirrelbrain Oh that‘s good news! I have a print copy which I hope to get to next week whilst we‘re away…along with the other 5 books I‘m taking. 🤣 12mo
54 likes6 comments
blurb
squirrelbrain
Idlewild | James Frankie Thomas
post image

I promise I won‘t buy any more books from the ToB long list; I have enough already….oops! 🤣

These are two where I really liked the sound of them from the blurbs, plus I‘d never heard of them before. (Maybe American rather than UK?) They‘re used copies from Amazon but both in good condition. They‘re also quite chunky compared to many of the other longlisters.

Anyone else read these or planning on reading them?

JamieArc These both seem really interesting. 12mo
BarbaraBB I have them both on my to read list too! 12mo
Ruthiella Not heard of either. I‘ll be interested to hear what you think. 12mo
See All 15 Comments
Deblovestoread I plan to borrow Idlewood from the library but can‘t find the other from any of my free options … will be interested in your reviews. 12mo
Megabooks I‘ve been eyeing vintage contemporary! I still need to go through the list! I‘m having a crazy time catching up with online stuff now that I can look at screens. And replying to your email is on the list! 💜💜 12mo
TrishB As always with these lists I will await your reviews 😁 12mo
Hooked_on_books I‘m going to try to read as many as possible from the list. I have a digital copy of VC from the library now. 12mo
sarahbarnes I did read VC. I thought it was just alright, but I seem to be in the minority on that. 12mo
merelybookish I enjoyed Vintage Contemporaries. One of the few times I've differed from @sarahbarnes 12mo
squirrelbrain Interesting to get two different views on VC! @sarahbarnes @merelybookish I‘ll let you know which side I fall on! 😃 12mo
squirrelbrain @JamieArc @BarbaraBB @Ruthiella @Deblovestoread - I‘ll hopefully read both next week when we‘re away on holiday so I‘ll let you all know. 12mo
squirrelbrain @Megabooks - looking forward to hearing which books you‘ll choose once you‘ve had chance to go through the list. 12mo
Megabooks I‘m reading this one rn that I had already checked out from the library. It‘s surprisingly good. 12mo
squirrelbrain I can get that one on Audible @Megabooks but not much time to listen to books at the mo, so it might have to wait to see if it makes the shortlist. 12mo
jlhammar 😆 Those both sound promising! I'm just waiting until the tournament picks are announced before I really dive in. Might get to a longlist title or two that I already own before then if I'm lucky. 12mo
74 likes2 stack adds15 comments