Overall, it was enjoyable. If you‘re a Star Wars fan. As with any anthology, there were hits and misses. For me the hits outnumbered the misses, the the quality of the hits far outweighed any negatives from the misses. It was quite interesting to see where an author would go with ancillary characters, such as the dianoga in the Death Star trash compactor. Four stars and I hope the other two can be just as good.