A Study in Scarlet (Sherlock Holmes Series)

pick

7 Jul-27 Nov 24 (audiobook)
Finally finished this first story after Trix hijacked my account to listen to the whole series (which I wanted to encourage!) A good introduction to the characters and to Holmes‘ methodology but not the most riveting case. I did read them as a teen but looking forward to listening to Fry‘s narration of the entire series. Having piqued Trixie‘s interest, we have all been watching Sherlock, which is fantastic.

14 likes

kelli7990

A Study In Scarlet: Sherlock Holmes Collections | A. Conan Doyle

I was looking at Netgalley‘s Read Now books to see if any new ones were added and I saw this one. It‘s being released on January 1, 2025. If you like graphic novels and have a Netgalley account then check it out. I‘m tempted to check it out myself. It wouldn‘t take me very long to read. Graphic novels are fast reads for me. It‘s interesting that this came up on Netgalley since I‘m participating in the #noplacelikeholmes readalong.

15 likes

Eggs

A Study in Scarlet | Arthur Conan Doyle

pick

This is considered the debut of the Sherlock Holmes/Dr. Watson relationship and truly solidifies Holmes as unequalled in his deductive and investigative powers.

#ReadAway2024
#seriesLove2024
#Pantone2024

@DieAReader @TheSpineView @GHABI4ROSES @BarbaraBB @Andrew65

BarbaraBB 😍 4mo

DieAReader 🥳🥳🥳 4mo

TheSpineView Great job 🤩📖📚 4mo

See All 6 Comments

Eggs @BarbaraBB 💕 4mo

Eggs @DieAReader 🥳🥰 4mo

Eggs @TheSpineView 🥰😊🥳 4mo

63 likes6 comments

TracyReadsBooks

A Study in Scarlet | Arthur Conan Doyle

pick

Loved this Gris Grimly illustrated edition of the tagged book! Of course the story is fantastic—it‘s Sherlock Holmes. No question it stands on its own (even though there are definitely some archaic and out-dated references/descriptions) but it‘s equally true that the black and white as well as full color illustrations add an exciting, visual dimension. Love Grimly‘s work and it‘s well suited to this type of story. Loved it!

wanderinglynn What a cool edition! 5mo

Cuilin Beautiful edition @dabbe have you seen this? 5mo

dabbe @Cuilin @TracyReadsBooks #completelygobsmacked 🤩🤩🤩 5mo

26 likes3 comments

TracyReadsBooks

A Study in Scarlet | Arthur Conan Doyle

…and my Gris Grimly collection grows a little bigger…

19 likes

Mollyanna

A Study in Scarlet | Arthur Conan Doyle

pick

The first Sherlock Holmes (#SeriesLive2024) and how can you go wrong. Doyle does an excellent job setting up the relationship between Holmes and Watson (and subsequently their relationship with Scotland Yard), as well as giving us an intriguing mystery. The second half of the book doesn‘t work quite as well, but it serves its purpose. Looking forward to reading the canon with #NoPlaceLikeHolmes

Cuilin, Andrew65, TheSpineView, dabbe

TheSpineView Fantastic! 7mo

Cuilin Wonderful 🫶 7mo

dabbe Yay! 🤩🤩🤩 7mo

33 likes3 comments

Gissy

A Study In Scarlet: Sherlock Holmes Collections | A. Conan Doyle

pick

I think that this story focused more in the introduction of each characters, their personalities, background, and to be familiar with Holmes‘ methodology than the mystery per se. Maybe that‘s why the conclusion of the mystery was like something rehearsed not spontaneous, like telling us, “this is the way Holmes will resolve his cases”🤷🏽‍♀️I still enjoyed it. 3.5/3.75 ⭐️

Gissy March 2024
#ReadAway2024 @DieAReader @Andrew65 @Ghani4Roses
#BookSpinBingo #4 (late reading) @TheAromaOfBooks
#ISpyBingo (notebook)
#NoPlaceLineHolmes @dabbe @Cuilin
#ItTakesAllKinds Day 19 9mo

dabbe I agree. It does prepare us well for the relationship between Watson & Holmes and the methodology of how Holmes will solve most of his cases. 🤩 9mo

DieAReader 🥳Awesome!! 9mo

TheAromaofBooks Yay!!! 9mo

Cuilin Agree, it‘s sets up the rest of the canon for us. 😊 9mo

42 likes5 comments

Gissy

A Study in Scarlet | Sir Arthur Conan Doyle

#ItTakesAllKinds Day 18 #WithPhysician

@Eggs @Alwaysbeenaloverofbooks

Alwaysbeenaloverofbooks Perfect 🩺 9mo

dabbe #greatminds 🤩😍😃 9mo

Eggs Popular choice 👏🏻👏🏻 9mo

38 likes3 comments

dabbe

A Study in Scarlet | Arthur Conan Doyle

#bookbracket2024
@CSeydel

CSeydel Great book! 11mo

dabbe @CSeydel 🩶🖤🩶 P.S. Notice I put your name on the photo. You deserve credit for your hard work, m'dear! 🤩 11mo

51 likes2 comments

dabbe

A Study in Scarlet | Arthur Conan Doyle

#Two4Tuesday
@TheSpineView

Thanks for the tag, Lisa and @The_Penniless_Author! 🤩
1. A STUDY IN SCARLET, not because it's my favorite Holmes story (it isn't) but because this is the month that I began my revisit of the SH canon, and this time it's with some stupendous Sherlockians! #NoPlaceLikeHolmes
2. I'm digging Nancy Drew and Sherlock. #serieslove2024 #NancyDrewBR

Play? @Cuilin @TheLudicReader @PageShifter 🖤🩶🖤

TheSpineView You're welcome and thanks for playing! 11mo

dabbe @TheSpineView 🩶🖤🩶 11mo

54 likes2 comments

TheAromaofBooks

A Study in Scarlet | Arthur Conan Doyle

pick

A soft pick. I enjoyed, but didn't love, this one. This was my first time reading a Sherlock Holmes book, and it was super fun to see how he and Watson met, get Watson's backstory, and see how things unwound. I'm really looking forward to continuing through the series.

Thanks for hosting @dabbe @Cuilin - I've been meaning to read these books for years, so this was a great nudge!!

TheAromaofBooks #NoPlaceLikeHolmes
#ISpyBingo - Polka Dots @Clwojick
#ReadtheUSA2024 - Utah
#BookSpinBingo 11mo

Gissy Pretty edition😍 11mo

dabbe IMHO, SCARLET is not his best. Even Doyle doesn't pick it as one of his favorites. More great ones are coming! 🤩😍🤗 11mo

77 likes3 comments

dabbe

A Study in Scarlet | Arthur Conan Doyle

#NoPlaceLikeHolmes @Cuilin
#JumboPuzzle

Hello, Sherlockians~
If interested, here's a fun little puzzle for you! We'll be doing these throughout the reading of the canon, and some will even be for prizes, so stay tuned and have fun! 🤩

The link to the puzzle is below:
https://bit.ly/3UifGS3

erzascarletbookgasm, CogsOfEncouragement, AnneCecilie, Aimeesue, Librarybelle, mom2bugnbee, Read4life, StayCurious, CatLass007, Mollyanna, eeclayton, dabbe, IndoorDame, kelli7990, TheAromaofBooks, 5feet.of.fury, Tineke, Pageturner1, PageShifter, AllDebooks, AnnR, kimrenee, aroyse

CrystalE02 Can you tag me for the #noplacelikeholmes I am enjoying the discussion and fellow Sherlockians. 11mo

Read4life I enjoyed the puzzle. Thanks @dabbe 💙 11mo

dabbe Absolutely! We‘ll add you to the list and are glad to have you aboard! 🤩 11mo

See All 7 Comments

IndoorDame Fun! That was tough (or else I‘m super brain dead today which is always possible 😆💙) 11mo

dabbe @IndoorDame Glad you liked it! I'm braindead, too, so you're not alone! I kept screwing up on what letters to include or not include in the message at the bottom! 🤪 11mo

CogsOfEncouragement I finally came back to this link to try the puzzle. Fun! Thank you for sharing it. 11mo

dabbe @CogsOfEncouragement 🩶🖤🩶 11mo

47 likes7 comments

AnneCecilie

A Study in Scarlet | Arthur Conan Doyle

#BookReport

I‘m very happy about my reading this week.

I finished several books:
📚 A Study in Scarlet
📚 The Running Grave
📚 Skogen (The Forest)

After finally finishing the chunkster that is RG I wanted to read something shorter and faster so I read:
📚 The Heartstopper volume 5
📚 Oxygen Mask

This means that for the first time in a long while, I‘m currently only reading one book and that is Beyond Black

54 likes

dabbe

A Study in Scarlet | Arthur Conan Doyle

#NoPlaceLikeHolmes
#SherlockianDiscussion
QUESTION #1

Hello, Sherlockians~
Time for a little discussion about A STUDY IN SCARLET. I‘m not hiding the questions, so if you don‘t want to see them yet, don‘t look! 😃 There are 6 questions; respond whenever you wish! 🤩

erzascarletbookgasm, Cuilin, CogsOfEncouragement, AnneCecilie, Aimeesue, Librarybelle, mom2bugnbee, Read4life, StayCurious, CatLass007, Mollyanna, eeclayton, dabbe, IndoorDame, kelli7990, TheAromaofBooks, 5feet.of.fury, Tineke, Pageturner1, PageShifter, AllDebooks, AnnR, kimrenee, aroyse

Librarybelle I really liked the setup of the first part. It was good to hear the back story of how Watson met Holmes. The second half was a struggle - by the end, I understood why we had to know the beginning part of part two, but it took me awhile to get to that point. 11mo

Aimeesue The meeting was neat; it‘s been so long since I‘ve read this one, I‘d forgotten how they got together. I‘d also forgotten he worked in a chem lab, experimenting all over the place. 11mo

5feet.of.fury @Librarybelle same. 11mo

See All 38 Comments

Read4life It was great going back to the beginning. 11mo

IndoorDame I loved that this opened with Watson‘s whole backstory before we even meet Sherlock. And I enjoyed the first glimpses into Sherlock‘s persona and his relationship with Watson starting to build. 11mo

CatLass007 This is the first Holmes I‘ve ever read and I don‘t know why it took me so long to get here. I begin to understand why Holmes and Watson are so beloved to readers. 11mo

aroyse It‘s been years since I‘ve read a Holmes! I love that Watson isn‘t sure at first what to make of Holmes and even thinks he‘s a little full of himself. And Holmes‘ army of street boys - love them!! They are the eyes and ears of the streets. 11mo

kelli7990 I tried reading Sherlock Holmes a long time ago as an ebook and I didn‘t like it that way so I decided to listen to it on audio instead. I wasn‘t sure if I was going to like it at first but I decided to keep going with the story and I liked it. 11mo

TheAromaofBooks I've never read any of the Holmes stories before, so I wasn't sure what to expect. I ended up enjoying it (with some reservations). It was a fun, engaging read. Ironically, it was the mystery that I found to be a little lacking haha 11mo

AnneCecilie This was the first Sherlock I ever read, but I have had intentions to ever since I bought The Complete Sherlock Holmes back in 2017. I loved reading about how they met, it reminded me very much of the BBC production. I felt completely lost during the first half of the second part, even if it did make sense in the end. 11mo

erzascarletbookgasm I liked the beginning..introduction of Dr Watson, and how he got to meet Holmes. 11mo

Pageturner1 i liked this. enjoyed learning about the friendship. 11mo

eeclayton For me this was a re-read. I enjoyed the first part more than the second, but the switch wasn't as jarring as the first time around. @TheAromaofBooks I too felt that the character studies were way more entertaining than the mystery! 11mo

CogsOfEncouragement I read this nine years ago, I've seen the Sherlock episode, and I listened to the audiobook for this reread. I really enjoyed it. Part two seems to come out of nowhere, but I appreciate the unique way Doyle had the mystery unfold. 11mo

dabbe @Librarybelle Yeah, the 2nd part could probably have read as its own novel. Even the writing style and narrator were quite different and took some getting used to. 🤗 11mo

dabbe @Aimeesue Or that he'd hit corpses to see how the blood congealed. 😳 11mo

dabbe @5feet.of.fury 🤗 11mo

dabbe @Read4life 🤗 11mo

dabbe @IndoorDame I loved how they instantly shared their bad traits and seemed to have instant karma. 🤗 11mo

dabbe @CatLass007 Oh how they will grow on you the more we read! 🤗 11mo

dabbe @aroyse I love the list he makes of Holmes re: his good and bad traits. I also forgot that Holmes knows NOTHING about literature but EVERYTHING about sensational literature! 🤗 11mo

dabbe @kelli7990 #yahooyou! IMHO this is not the best of the stories/novels. So, hang in there because some really good ones are coming up! 🤗 11mo

dabbe @TheAromaofBooks It was pretty much a straight revenge story and arguably not his best. Greater stories are coming! 🤗 11mo

dabbe @AnneCecilie The 2nd part was such a turn from the 1st. It almost read like a history book, didn't it? 🤗 11mo

dabbe @erzascarletbookgasm 🤗 11mo

dabbe @Pageturner1 🤗 11mo

dabbe @eeclayton Agreed. That's what makes these characters so beloved; we will really get to know them as the canon unfolds. 🤗 11mo

dabbe @CogsOfEncouragement It's almost like each part were completely separate rivers that come together in the ocean at the end. 🤗 11mo

CatLass007 @dabbe Rivers coming to the ocean. I like that. It‘s very poetic. 11mo

CrystalE02 I loved the book!!! I felt like the first part was interesting and a great read, I did struggle with second part. I did enjoy the book and the characters. I enjoyed reading Sherlock's interaction with the cases and the other characters. 11mo

AllDebooks It's the first time I've read this one. I absolutely loved it, especially the second half. 11mo

dabbe @CatLass007 🤩🤗😍 11mo

dabbe @CrystalE02 It only gets better from here! 🤩 11mo

dabbe @AllDebooks That's great to hear! Do you enjoy historical fiction--because that's how the 2nd part unfolded for me. 🤗 11mo

mom2bugnbee I've read them before, but it's been some time, and since then I've become a HUGE fan of the Cumberbatch/Freeman BBC series. I loved comparing the two! 11mo

dabbe @mom2bugnbee I adore that series! So creative and, well, there's Benedict! 🤩 11mo

Mollyanna I am way behind on our readings and just finished this book a week or so ago. I really enjoyed it and loved seeing how Dr. Watson and Holmes originally connected. 9mo

dabbe @Mollyanna Absolutely no worries! Read when you can! It is fun to see how they originally met and basically sized each other up to see if they were fit to be roommates. The best roommate pairing in literature (IMHO). 🤩 9mo

55 likes38 comments

dabbe

A Study in Scarlet | Arthur Conan Doyle

#NoPlaceLikeHolmes
#SherlockianDiscussion
QUESTION #2

Hello, Sherlockians~
Time for a little discussion about A STUDY IN SCARLET. I‘m not hiding the questions, so if you don‘t want to see them yet, don‘t look! 😃 There are 6 questions; respond whenever you wish! 🤩

Librarybelle Maybe that‘s why I struggled with the second part - the change in narrator. I think, overall, it made sense to divide the two sections of the story. I just struggled with the execution of it. 🤷🏻‍♀️ 11mo

AnnR This was the second time I've read A Study In Scarlett. During the prior read, I was completely lost with part 2. (Initially, I thought there was some type of mistake in my kindle version.) Ultimately, I found the transition jarring and actually wish Doyle had rewritten it at some point. (Sorry, probably an unpopular answer.) The backstory served a purpose but I didn't like it. 11mo

Aimeesue The transition could have been smoother maybe, but I‘m not sure how, without making it a far longer book. I found the second part interesting, though - my mother is now a Mormon, and I just don‘t understand some parts of that religion at all. (edited) 11mo

See All 36 Comments

Read4life @AnnR I had completely blocked part 2 from my memory of reading this. It may be an unpopular answer but I agree with you. 11mo

IndoorDame This was my first time reading this one, and I was completely shocked by the turn it took in part 2. But I was kinda pleased by that. Stories rarely surprise me that thoroughly and tie it all together effectively in the end. 11mo

CatLass007 @IndoorDame I agree with you. The difference between “civilized” London and the American Wild West is a jarring comparison. But I believe it is an effective way of telling this story. I enjoyed the mystery and I find the second part heartbreaking. A murderer‘s motivation is, in this case, easy to empathize with. 11mo

kelli7990 I didn‘t like Part 2 that much. I liked Part 1 better. I think breaking it up into a second part worked because the way Part 2 was written is completely different than Part 1. I wasn‘t expecting to learn about the history of the Mormon Church. I‘m disappointed because I was thinking that it was going to be more of a murder mystery kind of like Part 1 was but it wasn‘t. 11mo

TheAromaofBooks I really could have used some kind of transition or notice that we were switching gears. I even flipped ahead to make sure we ended up back in London at some point because I thought there was some kind of misprint in my book, the switch was so jarring. It did make sense to divide the story in that way, but I think it would read better with notification that we were delving into backstory lol 11mo

AnneCecilie I felt completely lost at the beginning of the second part, and wondered what it did there and was a little sorry that I didn‘t get an explanation to how Sherlock solved. It comes nicely together in the end. But feeling lost for such a long time during a relatively short book, is never fun. 11mo

erzascarletbookgasm The first time I read the book, I was put off by part 2. This is my second time reading, I understand why the backstory is necessary but I feel it need not be so in-depth. Also, like the others said, the transition is jarring. 11mo

CogsOfEncouragement I adore Watson. I've read a few Sherlock books and just love these characters. I also love me a now-it-all narrator! I enjoyed my reread of this mystery. No complaints. 11mo

dabbe @Librarybelle Books with completely different narrators and even writing styles are challenging for me. It's like I'll get the hang of one of them, and then when it goes to another, I'm like 😳? Books with many different narrators drive me bonkers! 😂 11mo

dabbe @AnnR No need to ever be sorry! All viewpoints are valid! I agree that the switch was jarring--just like the craggy rocks in Utah! 😂 11mo

dabbe @Aimeesue That's interesting re: your mother. Did she know someone who was Mormon? I found it interesting, too, but the first time I ever read it, I was like 😳? 😂 11mo

dabbe @Read4life Your brain was trying to protect you from that part! 😂 11mo

dabbe @IndoorDame Especially when even the writing style was so different; the 2nd part read like a history book for me. 🤗 11mo

dabbe @CatLass007 I rooted for Jefferson Hope and “hoped“ he'd get his revenge. I also liked that he didn't have to suffer in jail that long. His and Lucy's story was indeed a heartbreaker. 🤗 11mo

dabbe @kelli7990 It was like a history lesson, wasn't it? Lots of good mysteries lie ahead! 😃 11mo

dabbe @TheAromaofBooks It's weird. I kind of liked the jarring because it reflected the harsh landscape of the wild and untamed west. You had to hang in there, though, for it to slowly start to make sense. Quite a way to start the FIRST Holmes story ever, isn't it? 🤗 11mo

dabbe @AnneCecilie You make an excellent point. You do kind of hang there for a while, thinking “What on earth is going on?“ As a reader, I like to know EVERYTHING as I'm reading, not necessarily at the very end. 🤗 11mo

dabbe @erzascarletbookgasm I've often wondered if Doyle wanted to impress us with his so-called learning of the wild west. He did want to write nonfiction and didn't like that Sherlock ended up being the writing he is remembered most for (besides that fairy thing). 🤗 11mo

dabbe @CogsOfEncouragement I love that: a #knowitallnarrator! 🤩 11mo

CatLass007 @dabbe Fairy thing? 11mo

CrystalE02 I think that is why I enjoyed the first part better than the second part. I enjoyed Watson's narrative better than the 3rd person narrative. 11mo

AllDebooks @CatLass007 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-leeds-55187973.amp 11mo

AllDebooks I was gripped by the second half more. The back story set in the wilderness of America added extra weight to the desolation to Lucy and Jefferson's plight. 11mo

CatLass007 @AllDebooks Thank you. I have heard about this hoax before but I didn‘t remember or didn‘t know that Conan Doyle was involved. 11mo

dabbe @CatLass007 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cottingley_Fairies 🤩 11mo

dabbe @CrystalE02 The 1st part was so much more personal, wasn't it? Watson even talks about his life and hardships, too. I feel like he's openly honest as well. 🤗 11mo

dabbe @AllDebooks Excellent choice of word: “weight“. You can almost feel the high crags looming over them when they almost died of starvation and lack of water. 11mo

CatLass007 @dabbe Thank you! 11mo

dabbe @CatLass007 🤩😍😃 11mo

aroyse Omigosh! Just like AnnR - I thought that my edition had a printing error 😂. I think Doyle‘s audiences might have been more appreciative of part 2 as the descriptions of the “Wild West” would have been more exciting for them. And the Mormon religion would have been completely foreign to more readers - I wonder how many thought he made up the whole religion…. 11mo

dabbe @aroyse I bet quite a few may have thought it was made up. It might even have seemed like a fantasy to them at the time. 11mo

Mollyanna I definitely enjoyed Part One more than Part Two. I felt Part two was disjointed and didn‘t fit with part one. Plus as others have said, Dr. Watson is the far superior narrator. His impressions, opinions and reactions definitely add to the story. 9mo

dabbe @Mollyanna It's always interesting when a person realizes that it's through Watson's eyes that we hear the tales. Before I read these, I always thought it was Sherlock. Most of us agreed that Doyle went a bit too far in Part 2; he seems to get his writing to be more concise in the short stories. 🤩 9mo

42 likes36 comments

dabbe

A Study In Scarlet: Sherlock Holmes Collections | A. Conan Doyle

#NoPlaceLikeHolmes
#SherlockianDiscussion
QUESTION #3

Hello, Sherlockians~
Time for a little discussion about A STUDY IN SCARLET. I‘m not hiding the questions, so if you don‘t want to see them yet, don‘t look! 😃 There are 6 questions; respond whenever you wish! 🤩

Librarybelle It‘s always jarring to see thoughts that are less politically correct by today‘s standards. I recently watched Lucy Worsley‘s Agatha Christie program on PBS, and she interviewed a professor who looks at biases in Christie‘s books. The professor stated poignantly that you can still appreciate the author and their talent but also acknowledge that they come with their own biases and their contemporary thoughts - she said it way better than I just did 11mo

AnnR I read this article in the Smithsonian Magazine, which tried to explain how the English Victorians were fascinated by the Mormons and why Doyle likely chose to include that subject his story. After viewing things in that context, I guess the strange choice by Doyle makes a little more sense.
https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/why-was-arthur-conan-doyle-fascinated-... (edited) 11mo

Aimeesue Having been exposed to a lot of Mormon history, Doyle wasn‘t that far off in many respects, especially in the early days of their settling in Utah. They‘d been run out of a lot of places, and did not get on well with, well, a lot of neighbors. They disguised themselves as Native Americans and murdered more than 100 people in a wagon train who were just passing through. The West really was wild, and the Mormons were all up in it. (edited) 11mo

See All 30 Comments

5feet.of.fury @AnnR thank you for sharing that, I was a bit perplexed 11mo

IndoorDame @Aimeesue I thought the same thing. The early Mormon church had a lot of abuses that aren‘t talked about that much anymore. But in some respects they were very different from modern LDS. 11mo

TheAromaofBooks I definitely do think the early Mormons were up to a lot of sketchy stuff, so while I'm sure he did use some creative license, I also think they were prime candidates for the setting of a kind of wild story haha As others have said, I also think it's possible to read and appreciate a story while understanding their biases - which holds just as true for modern authors as it does ones from the past. 11mo

AnneCecilie I don‘t know enough about Mormons to have any idea about how they were portrayed. 11mo

kelli7990 @AnneCecilie Same here 11mo

dabbe @Librarybelle You stated it brilliantly! That's why as a teacher and reader, I abhor the banning of books! And I abhor changing the words to make them nicer or most palatable. For ex., when I taught HUCK FINN, the n-word is used over 250 times for a reason. The reason is what the kids need to read and discuss and understand about our country at that time. BTW, do you know the original title of AND THEN THERE WERE NONE by Christie? 🤩 11mo

dabbe @AnnR Interesting article! Thanks for sharing. Preconceived notions can definitely muddy the waters, can't they? Those Victorians! 😃 11mo

dabbe @Aimeesue I wish I was more surprised by how cultish they became. I mean, they were “run out of a lot of places“ as you eloquently stated, so I would have expected them to be more open to other religions and viewpoints. But they weren't ... just like the Puritans who were persecuted and came over here, hoping to be the “beacon on the hill“ (Emerson Baker) for all to see, but then became persecutors themselves. 🤗 11mo

Librarybelle @dabbe Yes! Not only that, but the original US title. You‘re so right - the books are a teachable moment. 11mo

dabbe @IndoorDame These thoughts also bring up in my mind how many religions today are abusive and/or cultish. You'd think humans would have learned how to be more loving and open, especially in a so-called loving religion. 11mo

dabbe @TheAromaofBooks Couldn't have said that any better than you did. 🤩 11mo

dabbe @5feet.of.fury 🤗 11mo

dabbe @AnneCecilie I know more about modern Mormonism, having read UNDER THE BANNER OF HEAVEN, but not being part of the religion means none of us will ever truly know unless we join. It seems as if Doyle focused on mostly the bad aspects of the religion from his island across the pond because it fitted his plot for the evil Debber and Stangerson. 🤗 11mo

dabbe @kelli7990 🤩 11mo

dabbe @Librarybelle The US title: also a not-so-nice name, huh? 😃 11mo

IndoorDame @dabbe so true! And so sad! I have yet to learn about any religion today mainstream or otherwise, that doesn‘t have deeply abusive aspects or sects. Makes me think of the old saying about power corrupting. I know it was never about religion, but we hand over a lot of mental/financial/behavioral control to those institutions… 11mo

AllDebooks I agree with all of the above points, particularly on bias. I think all books/art,etc, should be viewed from the time period in which it was created. Context is everything. A knee-jerk reaction to something unsavoury or offensive, is not appropriate. Question it, read around it and educate yourself. Doing this can give a completely different viewpoint. 11mo

AllDebooks Or at least an understanding as to why certain words and statements are used. As for religion, I know very little of Mormon history, so there's a little research project for me. 11mo

dabbe @IndoorDame ... without a second thought. (I had to finish the ... that you ended with). People can be so reasonable when it comes to pretty much everything--except religion. And I agree. I can't even think of one war or one abuse towards another human being without religion being involved in some way. 😢 11mo

dabbe @AllDebooks And hopefully create tolerance--which is why I think a lot of authors choose to rip off the bandaids and force us to look at ourselves and how we treat one another. 11mo

dabbe @AllDebooks I found UNDER THE BANNER OF HEAVEN to be enlightening, but it's more concerned with one tragic incident in modern Mormonism. 11mo

mom2bugnbee @dabbe Andrew Garfield was astonishing in the mini-series. Highly recommend if you haven't seen it. 11mo

dabbe @mom2bugnbee I haven't seen it! It's on the TBW list! (to be watched! 😂) 11mo

aroyse I love the Baker street irregulars! For all of Holmes‘ and Watson‘s education, studies, and books smarts, they can‘t hang unnoticed in dark places and collect information. It takes all sorts to get the full picture. 11mo

dabbe @aroyse Ain't that the truth? The people one might most look down upon can be the “diamond in the rough.“ In fact, they're so beloved, that the #1 hardest “club“ to get into is called ... you guessed it! 🤩 I'm using Wikipedia this time, but I promise I won't use it for my essay, Ms. Royse! 😂🤗🤩
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Baker_Street_Irregulars 11mo

Mollyanna I agree with all the above, knowing the author, what the author may have been biased about and understating it is a way to move forward. Don‘t ban or change their works to make it more palatable, then we learn nothing. As the saying goes, those who don‘t study history are bound to repeat it. I too love the Baker Street Irregulars and their resourcefulness. 9mo

dabbe What an excellent reminder and so well written by you: “Don't ban or change their works to make it more palatable; then, we learn nothing.“ May I borrow this quote to share with my school district? 🤩😍😃 9mo

41 likes30 comments

dabbe

A Study In Scarlet: Sherlock Holmes Collections | A. Conan Doyle

#NoPlaceLikeHolmes
#SherlockianDiscussion
QUESTION #4

Hello, Sherlockians~
Time for a little discussion about A STUDY IN SCARLET. I‘m not hiding the questions, so if you don‘t want to see them yet, don‘t look! 😃 There are 6 questions; respond whenever you wish! 🤩

Librarybelle Holmes is such an unusual character…there‘s something about his snarkiness and dare I say snobbishness that also makes him endearing. I tend to gravitate towards the flawed characters in books. While Holmes is not necessarily flawed, he has his quirks. 11mo

CatLass007 It‘s probably a little of both. We like Watson and we like the portrait of Holmes that Watson paints. 11mo

AnnR We probably find Holmes interesting because he is eccentric and (in some respects) very intelligent. We put up with Holmes because Watson does. Well, Watson is his champion and probably paints a more endearing portrait of Holmes than he deserves. 11mo

See All 34 Comments

5feet.of.fury The way they play off eachother is the key to success, different people will relate to 1 or the other, the prickly cactus who sows chaos or the rational friend who is secretly doing most of the work. Unlikely Animal Friends. 11mo

Aimeesue I‘m just fascinated with the way his mind works, tbh 😋 11mo

Read4life I love Holmes‘ snark, intelligence & how he and Watson play off each other. 11mo

IndoorDame Love that Holmes is quirky and a little aloof! But I do think he gets more endearing with Watson around as his foil. 11mo

kelli7990 I think Holmes & Watson are very interesting. 11mo

TheAromaofBooks I think they make a good balance, but I have a hunch that Sherlock would really annoy me in real life 😂 11mo

AnneCecilie I loved the list that Watson gave us about what Sherlock what good at and not, and it emphasized that he‘s good at what he has an interest in. 11mo

erzascarletbookgasm Probably Watson is the only person who can put up with Holmes 😂 11mo

CogsOfEncouragement I like Sherlock's cocky confidence, especially since he can back it all up. I adore Watson, he is an honest, kind man with a healthy ego. Bless him that he can live with Holmes. As much as I like Sherlock, he would drive me insane as a flatmate. 11mo

dabbe @Librarybelle I like to think of him as gloriously flawed. 🤩 And he is such a neophyte when it comes to relating to people that you just want to hug him and show him how it's done. 11mo

dabbe @CatLass007 I agree. Because Watson likes him, we like him. 🤗 11mo

dabbe @AnnR Agree 💯. 11mo

dabbe @5feet.of.fury Interesting idea. 🤩 How do you think Holmes sows chaos? 11mo

dabbe @Aimeesue My favorite parts of the stories are usually when he's able to size up someone just by looking at them. And then when he explains how, it's just a wonder to behold! 🤩 11mo

dabbe @Read4life It is a sight to behold, isn't it? 🤩 11mo

dabbe @IndoorDame That's what will be so fun rereading this canon ... to see how Holmes and Watson change each other. 🤩 11mo

dabbe @kelli7990 Agree 💯. 11mo

dabbe @TheAromaofBooks It would take a truly unique character to put up with him. Watson has his baggage, too; that's why I love how perfect they are for each other. #dareievensaybromance 🤩 11mo

dabbe @AnneCecilie And isn't that true of all of us? Why are we such good readers? Because we're interested in reading of course! Every human has a passion for something they're good at, right? 🤩 11mo

dabbe @erzascarletbookgasm Amen! 😂 11mo

dabbe @CogsOfEncouragement Me, too! All of his chemistry equipment everywhere, tobacco in his Persian slipper, knives holding his notes on the wall ... 😂 11mo

CrystalE02 I think we find Holmes interesting is because Watson makes him that way but also Holmes interesting ways of solving the crimes. 11mo

AllDebooks I really like Holmes, he fascinates me. Although, I don't think he would be half the character he is, without Watson to even him out. 11mo

dabbe @CrystalE02 Now there's a good question for the future stories: does Watson “talk up“ Holmes, or is he realistically true? I'm going to hold that thought in my head as we read further. 🤗 11mo

dabbe @AllDebooks They both definitely help neutralize the other, don't they? 🤩 11mo

mom2bugnbee Benedict Cumberbatch's Sherlock describes himself as "a high-functioning sociopath". That is absolutely the perfect description of his character. 11mo

dabbe @mom2bugnbee For the character Dr. Gregory House as well (I just discovered this series; I'm always WAY behind everyone else). He is the EPITOME of Sherlock! 😍 11mo

mom2bugnbee @dabbe I've never watched House, either! 11mo

dabbe @mom2bugnbee It's addictive! Just like Holmes is! 🤩 11mo

Mollyanna House is definitely a modern day Holmes! With Wilson as his Dr. Watson.😏. I love the character of Holmes, eccentricities and everything. He is a complex character that invites speculation as to his motivations and actions. I think that‘s what makes him so intriguing. Is this his calling or is it motivation something more? Dr. Watson is the everyman and through him we see the human side of Holmes. 9mo

dabbe @Mollyanna Couldn't agree more. BTW, I just started watching HOUSE and absolutely LOVE it! 🤩😃😍 9mo

37 likes1 stack add34 comments

dabbe

A Study In Scarlet: Sherlock Holmes Collections | A. Conan Doyle

#NoPlaceLikeHolmes
#SherlockianDiscussion
QUESTION #5

Hello, Sherlockians~
Time for a little discussion about A STUDY IN SCARLET. I‘m not hiding the questions, so if you don‘t want to see them yet, don‘t look! 😃 There are 6 questions; respond whenever you wish! 🤩

Librarybelle It was so like Holmes! 😂 But, I think Watson needs someone like Holmes to heal. 11mo

CatLass007 This bromance started with a “meet cute.” Yes Watson needs someone like Holmes in his life. But Holmes also needs Watson to act as a buffer between him and the world. 11mo

Aimeesue Blood tests and a bar. Seems fitting. 11mo

See All 28 Comments

Read4life @CatLass007 well said! 11mo

IndoorDame It was completely charming how determined they both were to like one another when it was clear neither was naturally gregarious. 11mo

CatLass007 @Read4life Thank you. 11mo

AnneCecilie I loved how they met, and how they are both trying to make their best to make their living arrangement work. 11mo

CogsOfEncouragement @CatLass007 LOL Yes! They make a great bromance and a marvelous team. 11mo

CatLass007 @CogsOfEncouragement @Read4life I was just thinking. Are friendships between men so rare that we use this silly nickname? I‘ll own that I‘m the one who used the word in this context. But a day later I‘m wondering if I need to rethink my respect, or lack thereof, for friendships between men. 11mo

kelli7990 I think they work really well together. 11mo

CogsOfEncouragement @CatLass007 I think it is the closeness of the friendship. It is the equivalent of BFF, right? My husband has friends, of course. There is one friendship he, the kids and I all refer to as his bromance from time to time though. The other guy's wife agrees. They are just really close and ride bikes together most weekends, etc. 11mo

CatLass007 @CogsOfEncouragement Saying it‘s the same as a woman having a BFF makes sense. I had been thinking that we have a silly nickname for male friendships but no silly nickname for female friendships. But we do! Maybe I just don‘t use the term because it‘s a generational thing. 11mo

dabbe @Librarybelle I'm glad you said that. In rereading this, I forgot just how traumatic the war was for Watson, not only the physical pain, but he definitely has PTSD. Holmes gets Watson's mind off of his troubles by involving him in cases. 🤗 11mo

dabbe @CatLass007 Amen! Watson humanizes Holmes. 🤩 11mo

dabbe @Aimeesue 😂 11mo

dabbe @IndoorDame I love how they instantly shared what they perceived were their bad flaws, too! 😂 11mo

dabbe @AnneCecilie And their retorts with one another when they get on each other's nerves! 🤩 11mo

dabbe @CatLass007 I didn't take it that you were showing a lack of respect. And there are quite a few literary critics out there who believe that there was more of a friendship between these two. There are just as many who think there wasn't. Then I wonder if that really even matters. What matters most to me anyway is that they are absolute best friends, and bromance is a cute/silly way perhaps to show that. 🤗 11mo

dabbe @kelli7990 Agree! 🤗 11mo

dabbe @CogsOfEncouragement Could BAE be the term, too? Or is that related only to romantic relationships? I think it means Before Anyone Else, so that would be like a BFF, too, right? Oy--these terms! 😂 11mo

CrystalE02 I think they both needed each other. It is such a Holmes thing for him to do what he did. Watson also needed this in order to heal. I am hoping to continue with more of the books soon 11mo

AllDebooks H & W met at an opportune time for both of them, when they were both vulnerable. It's a very serendipitous friendship 11mo

dabbe @CrystalE02 Next up is THE SIGN OF FOUR. Get reading! 😂🤗😍 11mo

dabbe @AllDebooks And a symbiotic one, too. 😍 11mo

CogsOfEncouragement @dabbe BAE is not my generation‘s term, but I know from my kids that it used for romantic, dating relationships. lol 😄 11mo

dabbe @CogsOfEncouragement Not from my era either. Good to know it's for romance! 😍 11mo

Mollyanna It‘s kismet for both of them… The universe gave them both what they needed at the time. 9mo

dabbe @Mollyanna Absolute karma! 🤩🤩🤩 9mo

37 likes28 comments

dabbe

A Study in Scarlet | Arthur Conan Doyle

#NoPlaceLikeHolmes
#SherlockianDiscussion
QUESTION #6

Hello, Sherlockians~
Time for a little discussion about A STUDY IN SCARLET. I‘m not hiding the questions, so if you don‘t want to see them yet, don‘t look! 😃 There are 6 questions; respond whenever you wish! 🤩

Librarybelle As someone who rarely figures out the murderer in a book, despite the clues being presented, I did not feel cheated. Conan Doyle‘s development of Holmes‘ character is what I think makes readers keep coming back. It‘s such a character study, diving deep into thoughts and perceptions. 11mo

CatLass007 I agree with @Librarybelle. But not just about the character study of Holmes. In any genre, if the characters are well developed the reader will forgive a great deal. 11mo

5feet.of.fury I like when things are breadcrumbed throughout the story, this one felt very far removed, as we had to leave the main characters & the whole country. 11mo

See All 28 Comments

IndoorDame @Librarybelle I agree on both counts. I rarely try to solve the puzzles, (and never succeed when I do try) so that aspect doesn‘t bother me, and I think that‘s only a small part of what we‘re drawn to in these stories. 11mo

PageShifter I think it's pecualiar characters? 11mo

TheAromaofBooks While I didn't mind that aspect, I did feel like in the end Holmes was basically like “I telegraphed Ohio and they told me that the dead guy had a murderous stalker“ so... it also didn't feel like he had to make any big deductive jumps?? That felt rather anticlimactic to me 😂 11mo

AnneCecilie I so agree with you @Librarybelle I never manage to guess either, so I don‘t think it matters how many red herrings are laid out through the story. With no clues, I don‘t need to feel stupid for not getting it 😊 11mo

erzascarletbookgasm I do not mind letting Holmes reveal the whole story. I just enjoy the ride, and I find Holmes eccentricity entertaining. 11mo

CogsOfEncouragement I started reading Holmes about ten years ago. I remember being a little disappointed at not even having a chance to try to solve it. I started with one of the short story collections. I quickly enjoyed these for what they are though, and they are not Encyclopedia Brown books. lol 11mo

kelli7990 When I read this story, I was trying to see if I could solve it but then I realized that I can‘t because of the way the story was written. I still enjoyed this story even though I‘m used to trying to solve a murder mystery while I‘m reading a book. This was a different type of murder mystery. 11mo

dabbe @Librarybelle Well said. 👏 I rarely solve any either--even if given ALL of the clues! I guess that's what makes us the couch potatoes living vicariously through our detective heroes! 😂 11mo

dabbe @CatLass007 Especially because we're on that character's side 💯. 🤗 11mo

dabbe @5feet.of.fury You make a truly valid point. I can't recall another story in the canon that does this, so we'll be with our bros much more consistently in the next stories! 🤩 11mo

dabbe @IndoorDame We just love our detectives, don't we? That's the success of every detective series ever, right? 🤩 11mo

dabbe @PageShifter Which character do you think is more peculiar, Holmes or Watson? 🤗 11mo

dabbe @TheAromaofBooks That's another reason I love this canon so much. Sometimes Holmes does seem to just phone it in, some crimes he doesn't solve, some he lets the bad guy go free ... you never know what he's going to do in each story. 🤩 11mo

dabbe @AnneCecilie Love this! What I don't know won't hurt me, and I won't feel like a total nitwit in the process! 😂 11mo

dabbe @erzascarletbookgasm That's an excellent way of putting it--to just enjoy the ride. And every ride will be a wee bit different, which is what entertains us. 🤗 11mo

dabbe @CogsOfEncouragement You make me think of an interesting point. I can't really even think of one detective story where we are given every clue like the detective. Usually we do have the big ending where all is revealed and we can then feel like “Wow! You make is sound so easy, Holmes!“ ... which is why he tells Watson he doesn't like to share his ways because then everyone will think it's so boring and easy when it really isn't. 🤗 11mo

dabbe @kelli7990 This one is quite a bit different. I look forward to reading what you think when we read a more “normal“ one. 😃 11mo

CrystalE02 Nope!! I didn't feel cheated about not knowing the clues first. I found it entertaining to learn the clues as the story progressed. 11mo

AllDebooks Hmmmm 🤔 I've never really pondered that before. I just go with the flow of the story. I would, therefore, say I don't mind not having the clues up front. It lends to a more absorbing story because you're not distracted by trying to work it out. 11mo

dabbe @CrystalE02 I don't think I have ever solved one detective story along with the detective; I just like to cruise along for the ride and have it explained to me at the end. 🤩 11mo

dabbe @AllDebooks I didn't think of that as a reason, but you're absolutely right. Then we can go along and watch, observe, and maybe even learn from good ol' Sherlock. 11mo

PageShifter Holmes feels more peculiar, and Watson is trying to help communication between Sherlock and people :D 11mo

dabbe @PageShifter Excellent point. I often wonder how well Sherlock would connect with anyone without Watson. 🤗 11mo

Mollyanna I think Sherlock Holmes‘s stories have stood the test of time because they aren‘t viewed as just detective fiction, but rather the story of humans. It is about observation of facts and evidence for the criminal act, but also the motivations of those that committed the act making it a sociological study. It is also about the characters. We see Holmes and Watson grow and evolve as they move through each case. (edited) 9mo

dabbe How true! I think it's especially imperative that Holmes changes for us the readers. He's so arrogant and prickly at the beginning, but Watson softens him somewhat. And since Watson loves Sherlock, so do we--with all of his idiosyncrasies. 9mo

39 likes28 comments

Librarybelle

A Study in Scarlet | Arthur Conan Doyle

pick

A soft pick, because I was all levels confused by the second half - I even double checked to make sure my e-copy did not somehow morph into a different book!

I greatly appreciated Watson‘s intro of Holmes and watching Conan Doyle unveil Holmes‘ genius for deduction.

Looking forward to reading the rest of the books and stories! #NoPlaceLikeHolmes

Cuilin, dabbe

Cuilin Yeah, I think we‘re all a little confused by the second part. 11mo

5feet.of.fury 😂 I understand completely 11mo

dabbe @Cuilin 🤩😂😃 11mo

dabbe @5feet.of.fury 🤩😂😃 11mo

74 likes4 comments

AnneCecilie

A Study in Scarlet | Arthur Conan Doyle

pick

A soft pick

I loved the beginning of how Sherlock and Watson met. The. in the beginning of the second part, the book lost me a little bit. I had no idea what was going on, and that‘s never fun. But the solution to the murder was great

#NoPlaceLikeHolmes
@Cuilin @dabbe

dabbe Can't wait to chat about it on Saturday! 💜🩶💜 11mo

72 likes1 comment

dabbe

A Study in Scarlet | Arthur Conan Doyle

pick

Who can resist reading the original meet-cute between Holmes and Watson, probably the most famous detective duo in history? I sure couldn't and reread this for #NoPlaceLikeHolmes. Though not one of Doyle's most popular novels or stories, this one's famous for being the FIRST. Period. Some criticism is given for how Doyle portrays the Mormons in part 2 (with some even thinking that that part could/should have been eliminated); however, it ⬇️

dabbe remains one of the most classic revenge stories in detective fiction. Appearing in Beeton's 1887 Christmas Annual and noted as being “the most expensive magazine in the world“ by magazine experts, an original copy sold for $156,000 at Sotheby's in 2007. For me, it's always thrilling to revisit the one that started it all. #sherlocked 11mo

AnnCrystal 🤩Wow! That's amazing! 11mo

dabbe @AnnCrystal 🤩😍😃 11mo

70 likes3 comments

erzascarletbookgasm

A Study in Scarlet | Arthur Conan Doyle

pick

A reread for #NoPlaceLikeHolmes .
This first novel recounts the initial meeting of Sherlock Holmes and Dr. John Watson, which I liked. Just as in the first reading, I enjoyed it, although I think the backstory need not be so in-depth. I read from an illustrated copy, artwork by George Hutchinson.

Cuilin, dabbe

Cuilin Love the illustration 11mo

dabbe Very Sidney-Paget like! 💜🤍💜 11mo

66 likes2 comments

CogsOfEncouragement

A Study in Scarlet | Arthur Conan Doyle

pick

Enjoyed this the first time in 2015.
Did a reread via audiobook for the #NoPlaceLikeHolmes BR with @dabbe @cuilin this month. Definitely long enough in between to appreciate it again.

dabbe Can‘t wait to discuss! 💜🩶💜 11mo

Cuilin 👍🕵️‍♂️ 11mo

30 likes2 comments

LitsyEvents

A Study in Scarlet | Arthur Conan Doyle

Repost for @dabbe

#NoPlaceLikeHolmes
#ScarletInfographic

Hello, Sherlockians!
Above is an infographic that I created as an introduction to A STUDY IN SCARLET. Some sensitivity issues exist (those pesky Victorians!) that @Cuilin and I wanted you to be aware of--plus, there are just some interesting facts that will hopefully get you excited to read! Our discussion will begin on 1/27.

If anyone else wants to join, tag us! All are welcome!

LitsyEvents Original post https://litsy.com/p/TlBLUUpUaWk0 11mo

37 likes1 comment

AnneCecilie

A Study in Scarlet | Arthur Conan Doyle

#BookReport

I continued reading The Christmas Chronicles and A is for Arsenic

I finished Shrines of Gaiety and I read The Bungalow Mystery.

I‘ve started reading A Study in Scarlet a chapter a day and I‘ve started on The Running Grave

66 likes

AnneCecilie

A Study in Scarlet | Arthur Conan Doyle

No I have finally figured out why I will never be a Sherlock Holmes - I spend too much time on litterateur. I am glad I finally know 😉

#NoPlaceLikeHolmes
@dabbe and @Cuilin

AnnR 😂 11mo

dabbe At least we can feel superior to him in one area! 🤩😍😃 11mo

Cuilin This was such a funny list. 11mo

52 likes3 comments

5feet.of.fury

A Study in Scarlet | Arthur Conan Doyle

so-so

I liked the introduction between Holmes & Watson, part 2 was rough.

dabbe Can't wait until discussion day--especially for that 2nd part. 🤩 11mo

47 likes1 comment

AnneCecilie

A Study in Scarlet | Arthur Conan Doyle

#WeeklyForecast

I want to continue my reading of The Christmas Chronicles and A is for Arsenic

I want to finish Shrines of Gaiety, read The Bungalow Mystery and I hope to get a start on The Running Grave

I also want to start A Study in Scarlet

5feet.of.fury I have that same Sherlock Holmes anthology, I love the houndstooth print 12mo

Ruthiella You remind me that I bought Shrines of Gaiety in 2022 and still need to get to it! 🙈 12mo

CatMS Listened to "The Running Grave" 36+ hours long. Got into 24 hours when library took it back and had to request it again and wait a couple of weeks before I got it back to finish. As usual I love the audiobooks of the C.B. Strike and Robin adventures. 11mo

58 likes3 comments

IndoorDame

A Study In Scarlet: Sherlock Holmes Collections | A. Conan Doyle

pick

#NoPlaceLikeHolmes When I realized that the #JaneAdjacent gang was starting a retelling of this exact Sherlock story on Monday I pushed to finish this faster than I‘d initially planned, and I‘m glad I did because this is definitely NOT one I‘ve read before. It had a lot of fun little surprises, but mostly it was really cool to see where it all originated and watch Holmes and Watson getting to know each other. @dabbe @Cuilin

Cuilin Great timing!! Glad you enjoyed it. 12mo

dabbe #whereitallbegan 🖤💙🖤 12mo

IndoorDame @dabbe 💜💜💜 12mo

StayCurious I‘m reading it as well! 11mo

IndoorDame @StayCurious it‘ll be super fun to actually read an original and a retelling in the same month. I don‘t think I‘ve ever managed that before! 11mo

71 likes5 comments

dabbe

A Study in Scarlet | Arthur Conan Doyle

#NoPlaceLikeHolmes
@Cuilin

Hello, Sherlockians!
I was going through my teacher stuff, and I found this LitChart that I purchased for A STUDY IN SCARLET. You can go to litcharts.com and view some of the items (with a lot of annoying ads), or you can look at this pdf file (without any ads and ALL of the goodies). Here's the link:
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1gL9T6_gS7DGayNphvaubx0pBbwg9aUR7/view?usp=shari...

erzascarletbookgasm, AnneCecilie, Aimeesue, Librarybelle, mom2bugnbee, Read4life, StayCurious, Mollyanna, eeclayton, dabbe, IndoorDame, kelli7990, TheAromaofBooks, 5feet.of.fury, Tineke, Pageturner1, PageShifter, AnnR, kimrenee, aroyse

IndoorDame Teacher stuff is the best! Thanks! 🙏🤗 12mo

Librarybelle Thank you! 12mo

dabbe @IndoorDame 🤩😍😘 12mo

See All 16 Comments

dabbe @Librarybelle 🤩😍😘 12mo

Cuilin Fabulous, thank you 😊 12mo

Pageturner1 thanks @dabbe 12mo

AnnR Wonderfully informative .pdf. Thank you @dabbe. You rock. I feel like I'm getting the benefit of a lit class but for free. (edited) 12mo

Mollyanna Thank you so much. 😊 12mo

dabbe @Cuilin I didn't think you'd mind! 🤩😍😘 12mo

dabbe @Pageturner1 🤩😍😘 12mo

dabbe @AnnR Now THAT made my day! 😂😍😘 12mo

dabbe @Mollyanna 😍😍😘 12mo

Cuilin @dabbe of course not!! I love it!! 12mo

dabbe @Cuilin 🤩🤩🤩 12mo

Bklover This is awesome! Thanks so much!🩷 (edited) 11mo

dabbe @Bklover 🤩😍😘 11mo

52 likes1 stack add16 comments

Cuilin

A Study in Scarlet | Arthur Conan Doyle

The game‘s s afoot.

I grew up with A but G is quite delightful. #NoPlaceLikeHolmes

Who‘s your Sherlock?
@pageshifter @AnneCecilie @indoordame @librarybelle @theAromaOfBooks @Aimeesue @kelli7990 @5feet.of.fury @Read4Life @AnnR @mom2bugnbee @pageturner1 @eeclayton @erzascarletbookgasm @aroyse @dabbe @cuilin @mollyanna @Tineke @Larken @StayCurious @kimrenee @alldebooks

5feet.of.fury It‘s hard not to pick Henry, but gotta go with G. 12mo

PuddleJumper That's hard! A for classic Holmes and then D for some fun 12mo

Cuilin @5feet.of.fury G 👍😍 12mo

See All 46 Comments

Cuilin @PuddleJumper My sister would choose D too. 12mo

AnnR Gotta go with G. 🔎 12mo

dabbe Love them all! But … A (JB) was the most original Sherlock in the shows that most closely held to the canon, so my ultimate heart lies there. 🖤 12mo

DaveGreen7777 I might be one of the few leaning towards F… “Young Sherlock Holmes” was one of my favorite movies growing up! 😀 12mo

Cuilin @dabbe I agree Brett was the most authentic. 12mo

Cuilin @DaveGreen7777 such a great show!!!! 12mo

Cuilin @AnnR completely understandable. 😍 12mo

RaeLovesToRead A is my Holmes 😊 12mo

AllDebooks I love Henry in Enola Holmes but, ultimately I'd choose Benedict 🔍🎻 12mo

Cuilin @RaeLovesToRead smart choice 12mo

Cuilin @AllDebooks I understand, I mean 😍 12mo

AllDebooks @Cuilin lol, Ikr 😅👀😍 12mo

IndoorDame Apparently I need to watch more TV! I‘d choose G, but I feel like I‘m missing out on many good options here… 12mo

Bookwomble A all the way! 12mo

Pageturner1 i‘m not up on the Holmes characters. i haven‘t really watched any of the movies. i will have to rely on other‘s answers 12mo

Librarybelle I‘ll more familiar with G - really good Sherlock 12mo

Cuilin @IndoorDame You‘re safe with G!! 12mo

Cuilin @Bookwomble Brett was so good!!! 12mo

Cuilin @Pageturner1 oh to watch them all for the first time!!! 12mo

Cuilin @Librarybelle 😍😍😍 12mo

KadaGul @cuilin Sooo E😍 F😍G😍 12mo

Scochrane26 Definitely G 12mo

Read4life G most definitely 12mo

Daisey G! 12mo

erzascarletbookgasm For me Jeremy Brett played the best for the character. But B Cumberbatch has brought a fresh air to the character in modern London, and he‘s irresistible 😊 12mo

PageShifter G! 12mo

TheAromaofBooks You seem to be missing Wishbone 😂 12mo

Tineke I loved Benedict Cumberbatch's Sherlock but I'm also missing Johnny Lee Miller's Sherlock in Elementary. Although it was a bit of a loose imagining. 12mo

Cuilin @TheAromaofBooks 😂😂😂 there was a dog cartoon character too. 12mo

Cuilin @KadaGul why limit yourself 😍😆 12mo

Cuilin @PageShifter 💯 12mo

Cuilin @erzascarletbookgasm my thoughts exactly 12mo

Cuilin @Tineke oh need to check that one out. 12mo

Cuilin @Daisey 💯 12mo

Cuilin @Read4life 😍 12mo

Cuilin @Scochrane26 makes complete sense 12mo

CogsOfEncouragement D, G, & E I enjoyed each series with these. 12mo

Cuilin @CogsOfEncouragement all fabulous 12mo

CatLass007 I have to say that I didn‘t care for either of the movies with Robert Downey, Jr. and I don‘t have any opinion about the others because I haven‘t seen them. 11mo

mom2bugnbee I'm late here... No one will ever match Benedict Cumberbatch IMO. ♥ 11mo

Cuilin @mom2bugnbee noted! 😍 11mo

CrystalE02 G. Benedict Cumberbatch!!! Thanks to my brother for getting me into the show. My stepdad got me into the Sherlock Holmes books. He doesn't like Cumberbatch as Sherlock he like Jeremy Brett. 11mo

Cuilin @CrystalE02 two great choices 11mo

56 likes1 stack add46 comments

dabbe

A Study in Scarlet | Arthur Conan Doyle

“In the year 1878 I took my degree of Doctor of Medicine of the University of London, and proceeded to Netley to go through the course prescribed for surgeons in the army.“

#FirstLineFridays
@ShyBookOwl

46 likes

dabbe

A Study in Scarlet | Arthur Conan Doyle

#NoPlaceLikeHolmes
#ScarletInfographic

Hello, Sherlockians!
Above is an infographic that I created as an introduction to A STUDY IN SCARLET. Some sensitivity issues exist (those pesky Victorians!) that @Cuilin and I wanted you to be aware of--plus, there are just some interesting facts that will hopefully get you excited to read! Our discussion will begin on 1/27. Happy Near Year! 🤩

If anyone else wants to join, tag us! All are welcome! 🤗

erzascarletbookgasm, AnneCecilie, Aimeesue, Librarybelle, mom2bugnbee, Read4life, Mollyanna, eeclayton, dabbe, IndoorDame, kelli7990, TheAromaofBooks, 5feet.of.fury, Tineke, Pageturner1, PageShifter, AnnR, aroyse

StayCurious I‘d love to join. My #Pemberlittens group is reading the tagged book

A Study in Scarlet Women (Lady Sherlock, #1)

12mo

Librarybelle Thanks for the graphic! 12mo

AnnR Great graphic @dabbe. Thank you for taking the time to create that. Even for books that are primarily fiction, I really enjoy learning about the authors, characters, historical setting, etc. It helps me get more out of my reading and appreciate the author's writing too. 12mo

See All 12 Comments

Bookwomble I love the infographic! 😍 I'd ask to join the buddy read, but having reread the whole canon in 2023, it's a bit too soon! I will enjoy reading the discussion posts, though 😊 I am, however, planning to read my as yet unread Holmes pastiches as a 2034 project. 12mo

dabbe @StayCurious Yahoo! You're on the list! 🤗 Now I'll have to check out the Lady Sherlock series is your group reading all of them or just this one? 12mo

dabbe @Librarybelle 🤩🤗😍 12mo

dabbe @AnnR Sherlock is special. I'm sure you know that there are groups out there (like the Baker Street Irregulars) who treat each story as if Watson and Sherlock really did exist and Doyle was simply their biographer. I can't think of another series that takes it to that level! 🤩 12mo

dabbe @Bookwomble You could be leading this read! You're a Sherlock encyclopedia! 🤩 I hope you'll contribute to the discussions! 🤗 12mo

AnnR Actually, I'm pretty naive when it comes to all things Sherlock and Watson. Mystery novels didn't sound appealing to me until recently. Although I coincidentally read A Study in Scarlett a few months ago, I really didn't do much historical research on the subject. I'm sure I'll learn a lot from the buddy read. 12mo

dabbe @AnnR I'm sure we'll all learn something. Every time I come back to 221-B Baker St., I feel like I'm right there in that cozy room with them! 🤩 12mo

StayCurious @dabbe we‘re starting with the first book. If we really like it we might read more. 12mo

Liz_M @LitsyEvents 11mo

51 likes12 comments

LitsyEvents

A Study In Scarlet: Sherlock Holmes Collections | A. Conan Doyle

Repost for @Cuilin @dabbe

Denise and I are so excited to get this going, we have fun plans including games and merch!!!! This buddy read is open to all, tagging those who have expressed interest. Here‘s a link to find out more about the structure of Sherlock stories and Merch Info.

https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSec5bhalZ__UWdUs3T1zjiyZZEGteC7KLDWbtCo...

LitsyEvents Original post https://litsy.com/p/NVg0SDM4UnVK 12mo

39 likes1 comment

Cuilin

A Study in Scarlet | Arthur Conan Doyle

Denise and I are so excited to get this going, we have fun plans including games and merch!!!! This buddy read is open to all, tagging those who have expressed interest. Here‘s a link to find out more about the structure of Sherlock stories and Merch Info.

@LitsyEvents

https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSec5bhalZ__UWdUs3T1zjiyZZEGteC7KLDWbtCo...

Cuilin @pageshifter @AnneCecilie @indoordame @librarybelle @theAromaOfBooks @Aimeesue @kelli7990 @5feet.of.fury @Read4Life @AnnR @mom2bugnbee @pageturner1 @eeclayton @erzascarletbookgasm @aroyse @dabbe @cuilin
12mo

Librarybelle Looking forward to this! 12mo

IndoorDame I‘m psyched about this! And those stats from The Guardian are fabulous!!!! 12mo

See All 36 Comments

Cuilin @IndoorDame agree!!! 12mo

Read4life So excited for this! My pup, Sherlock, is ready to enjoy some Holmes on audio! 🐶 12mo

Cuilin @Read4life fabulous, I have the books but also tempted by the Stephen Fry audio. I may do a combination. 12mo

dabbe “Come, Watson, come. The game is afoot. Not a word! Into your clothes and come!” (The Adventure of the Abbey Grange).
🤩🤩🤩 12mo

Cuilin @dabbe 🩷 The game IS afoot!!!! 🩷 12mo

dabbe Think you might want to join us, @kimrenee? 12mo

dabbe @Cuilin 💙❄️💙 12mo

Mollyanna I‘d like to join! Started working my way through the Holmes stories a few years ago, but only managed a couple. This is just what I need… 12mo

eeclayton Yay! And I love the hashtag 😍 12mo

Cuilin @Mollyanna wonderful, you‘re on the tag list!!! 12mo

5feet.of.fury Oh good! I‘m excited for this! 12mo

Cuilin @eeclayton thanks, we had a list but liked this one most. 12mo

Cuilin @5feet.of.fury me too!!! 12mo

AnnR Great article. 👍 🔍 I'm going to print it out for future reference. 12mo

TheAromaofBooks Ooooo I literally forgot about this! 😂 I'm so excited!! I can't remember - are we reading this at a certain pace (chapter/day or whatever) or just completing the book in time for the discussion January 27? 12mo

Cuilin @TheAromaofBooks read at your own pace for discussion on 1/27. We‘ll probably check in weekly. 12mo

Cuilin @AnnR Agreed, I think we‘ll need it. 🕵️‍♀️ 12mo

TheAromaofBooks Sounds good!! Thank you!! 12mo

Pageturner1 excited for this 12mo

Cuilin @TheAromaofBooks 👍 12mo

Cuilin @Pageturner1 yay!! 🕵️‍♀️ 12mo

Aimeesue Looking forward to it! 12mo

kelli7990 Yay! 12mo

Daisey Oh, I would love to participate in this, but I think I‘m already overbooked for my beginning of the year plans. I read through The Valley of Fear with another group (#Sherlocked) several years ago, but we never got through the final stories. I do have the complete audio, so maybe I‘ll follow along listening to as I can and for sure join in towards the end. Could you go ahead and add me to your list, please? 12mo

mom2bugnbee I'd forgotten! Wonderful! So excited. 12mo

Cuilin @Daisey yes, join in when you can. 12mo

Cuilin @mom2bugnbee 🎉 12mo

Tineke Yes, I'd like to join too! I have a book with all the stories. 12mo

Cuilin @Tineke Welcome, I‘ll add you to the tag list. 12mo

kimrenee I'm excited to do something like this. I've never done this before 12mo

Cuilin @kimrenee yay, wonderful you‘re joining us. I‘ll add you to tag list. You know who to go to if you‘ve any questions. lol. 12mo

AllDebooks Please add me 😊 12mo

Cuilin @AllDebooks absolutely, delighted you‘re joining us. 12mo

45 likes36 comments

Susanita

A Study In Scarlet: Sherlock Holmes Collections | A. Conan Doyle

More from yesterday. I know the picture is probably too small to read, so here‘s part of the text. “What may look like your average summer reading list is actually made up of some of the most commonly challenged and censored books of all time…” Sherlock Holmes banned? 🤦🏻‍♀️

You can also see the wet walkway, except the little bit shielded by the height of the sign. At least today has very nice weather for everyone celebrating Mother‘s Day. 💐☀️

Susanita “…While only a snippet of the larger list that exists globally, it illustrates the magnitude of what some governments and organizations are willing to do to stifle expression, creativity, and many authors‘ unique viewpoints.” 2y

dabbe #grrtoinfinityandbeyond #banbanningbooks! #bcubedclub 2y

41 likes2 comments

RayHallucinogen

A Study in Scarlet | Arthur Conan Doyle

Just started listening to a shash of 100+ audiobooks I've been gathering for some time. First in line, alphabetically, Arthur Conan Doyle and A Study in Scarlet.

dabbe The first Holmes in the canon! LOVE it! 🕵️‍♂️🔍💜 2y

RayHallucinogen The second part of the book got my full attention. Already onto the next one, The Sign of the Four. 2y

bunneeboy GREAT book!…but definite articles don‘t count, alphabetically. ; ) 7mo

RayHallucinogen True. 🙂 7mo

36 likes4 comments

Infinite_Adnan

A Study in Scarlet | Arthur Conan Doyle

Finally got my hands on this...
Looking forward to reading this masterpiece...

2 likes1 stack add

5feet.of.fury

A Study in Scarlet | Arthur Conan Doyle

#roll100 selections
Excited for A Study in Scarlet. I have a really gorgeous Sherlock Holmes anthology & I haven‘t read much of it, well, I read Hounds of the Baskervilles twice.

PLL I don‘t really care about reading, which begs the question “why didn‘t I leave it at the library book sale?”

& a grandma who hiked the Appalachian Trail. My mental fantasy is to quit life & thru hike the AT so I‘m sure this will add to my ambition

PuddleJumper

26 likes

Goxai

Uno studio in rosso | Arthur Conan Doyle

pick

Love this book.

1 like1 stack add

Crystal83

Sherlock: A Study in Scarlet | Arthur Conan Doyle

pick

I give this book 5/5 stars!!! It is one of my favorite Sherlock Holmes books!!! This is a part of the 31 books mentioned in Criminal Minds or read by Dr. Spencer Reid list. This is the second book I have read on the list.

5 likes

erzascarletbookgasm

A Study in Scarlet | Arthur Conan Doyle

Scarves are good for cold days and nights (which we never require here). Besides, they give the literary character style. I‘ve not seen Sidney Paget‘s original illustrations of Sherlock Holmes wearing a #scarf but actors like Basil Rathbone and Benedict Cumberbatch don it well..look elegant and charismatic. 👀 👀 👍👍
#GratefulHarvest 🧣

Eggs, Alwaysbeenaloverofbooks

Eggs Great pics 🧣 🙌🏻 ❤️ 3y

56 likes1 comment

Zoe-h

A Study In Scarlet: Sherlock Holmes Collections | A. Conan Doyle

pick

I added this to my TBR after I started watching Sherlock a few months ago. I was a bit confused once it got to the Utah part. I do feel like I enjoyed the show‘s plot a little more, because of the pick a bottle scene. But all in all, a good read. 4⭐️

TiredLibrarian Love the card! 💗 3y

11 likes1 comment

Zoe-h

A Study In Scarlet: Sherlock Holmes Collections | A. Conan Doyle

#FirstLineFriday
This is the longest first sentence I have ever seen.

rwmg Can I draw your attention to

A Tale of Two Cities by Charles Dickens

Awk_Word_Smith @rwmg “It was the longest of sentences, it was the shortest; it was the most semi-colons used, it was the fewest…” And yet still the greatest opening line/ending line in literature. #arguably 3y

11 likes2 comments

ravenlee

A Study In Scarlet: Sherlock Holmes Collections | A. Conan Doyle

so-so

This novella introduces Sherlock Holmes, beginning with him meeting Dr Watson and Watson‘s first look at Holmes‘ deductive reasoning. That was all very good. Then, suddenly, that narrative is completely abandoned and for 30 pages we‘re in Utah with the Mormon settlers. Huh? So, I deducted one grade for narrative discontinuity.

31 likes

ravenlee

A Study In Scarlet: Sherlock Holmes Collections | A. Conan Doyle