Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
The Monuments Men
The Monuments Men: Allied Heroes, Nazi Thieves, and the Greatest Treasure Hunt in History | Robert M. Edsel
47 posts | 67 read | 69 to read
At the same time Adolf Hitler was attempting to take over the western world, his armies were methodically seeking and hoarding the finest art treasures in Europe. The Fuehrer had begun cataloguing the art he planned to collect as well as the art he would destroy: "degenerate" works he despised. In a race against time, behind enemy lines, often unarmed, a special force of American and British museum directors, curators, art historians, and others, called the Momuments Men, risked their lives scouring Europe to prevent the destruction of thousands of years of culture. Focusing on the eleven-month period between D-Day and V-E Day, this fascinating account follows six Monuments Men and their impossible mission to save the world's great art from the Nazis.
Amazon Indiebound Barnes and Noble WorldCat Goodreads LibraryThing
Pick icon
100%
review
Robotswithpersonality
post image
Pickpick

An ambitious project. It becomes clear as the book goes on why the narrative focuses more on certain individuals, but that does make the cast of 'main characters' line up in the beginning of the book a little confusing. I'll admit to investigating this work based on the notion of art conversation/reclamation history rather than World War 2 history, which means I had less interest in the sections of the book that acted as introductory context 1/?

Robotswithpersonality 2/? for the latest priorities/movements of the Monuments Men than their actual actions taken to discover and return/protect the art. Maintaining sense of tension without allowing the action to drag is difficult with a work of this length, even if it's clear that the muddle of war and the inevitable bureaucracy were just facts of history, not anything the authors ginned up. 4mo
Robotswithpersonality 3/? I appreciate that the authors gave time to consider the German-Jewish-American soldier perspective as well as the contributions of a woman to the French resistance and the recovery of artwork as well as to the art world of France, even though Ettlinger and Valland are not presented as the main characters in the bulk of the work. While the acknowledgement of an eventual force of men and women, especially post-action in the European theatre, 4mo
Robotswithpersonality 4/? in the MFAA, it remains The Monuments 'Men' throughout. 🤷🏼‍♂️ It matters that the authors took moments to acknowledge when even the Allies were destructive or unwise in their choices and art was lost as a result. I don't know if the fact that the authors are American or that the larger number of the original MFAA group were American explains why the focus seems to be on American MFAA people even if it was a joint British and American 4mo
See All 7 Comments
Robotswithpersonality 5/? operation. One situation related does make it appear that depending on which American army section the Monuments Man was attached to determined where they'd be able to work/help, to the exclusion of any British force which might be nearby.
The horrors of war are briefly touched on, but not the focus of the story, beyond the lamentation for history, culture, art which was stolen, destroyed, lost.
4mo
Robotswithpersonality 6/ I was glad to read about the nascent field of modern art conservation coming into being in the person of George Stout, the love letters from sculptor Walker Hancock home to his new wife and “great love“ Saima. The window into the ambition and frustration of men who were successful in their secular lives coming up against forces so much greater and grinding problems so much slower to solve primarily in the persons of James Rorimer and Lincoln 4mo
Robotswithpersonality 7/? Kirstein was humanizing. I can see why and how you could make this into a film, but I don't think I could watch a dramatization of it having been somewhat acquainted with the real people involved. I'm glad the authors chose to emphasize the importance of this type of work in modern warfare, and mentioned that the recovery of work from the historical time period is still ongoing. It's inspiring to remember people care about saving a little 4mo
Robotswithpersonality 8/8 beauty alongside the other priorities amidst the ugliness of conflict.

⚠️suicide, details of the Holocaust, SA
(edited) 4mo
6 likes7 comments
quote
Robotswithpersonality
post image

War: Destruction: Everyone loses.

quote
Robotswithpersonality
post image

Got their steps in, damn! 🚶🏻‍♂️

quote
Robotswithpersonality
post image

💣🫣

quote
Robotswithpersonality
post image

What a perennially, painfully relevant question. 😖

9 likes1 stack add
review
Shannon_McKinney
Pickpick

Incredible unsung hero‘s of World War 2! It‘s amazing that I‘ve never heard of this operation before. 4/5 ⭐️

review
Morr_Books
post image
Pickpick

Finished my 4th book of the readathons and have now been reading for almost 22 hours, so I've completed the #20in4 and am close to completing #deweysapril. Just two more hours and then I will sleep and sleep. I really enjoyed this book, though sometimes I got confused with the timeline. Also, this was my #100 pick for #Roll100. @PuddleJumper #readathon @DeweysReadathon @Andrew65

Andrew65 Doing brilliantly 👏👏👏 3y
PuddleJumper Brilliant! 3y
45 likes2 comments
review
shaynarae
post image
Pickpick

Despite scholarly issues and not the greatest writing, I was pleasantly surprised by not how bored I was by this book. Having an MA in art history and a career in museums, this story is a familiar one to me, and WWII books are very much not my jam. So I did go into it with pretty low expectations, making it an easy bar to raise.

MsMelissa I started this one a couple of years back, but thought the writing very weak and put it down. I want to get back to it though, since the subject matter is so interesting. 4y
shaynarae @Book_Fiend_Melissa I‘ve been told that the Rape of Europa (tagged here) is a far superior book on the topic. I hope that one works out better for you! 4y
26 likes2 comments
review
Mshookquilts
post image
Pickpick

Excellent book on a “fun” part of WWII‘s history. Good information that read well.

review
Bookwormjillk
post image
Pickpick

A bit dry in parts, but overall interesting. I liked the afterword the best. #NFNov

Clwojick 6 pts. 5y
40 likes1 comment
blurb
Bookwormjillk
post image

#TIL I had a very good public education, but it seemed like aside from reading Anne Frank‘s Diary we never learned much about World War II in history class. We always seemed to stop just after the Civil War. It wasn‘t until I visited England and Europe in college that I began to fully appreciate the horrors of that war. And now I‘m starting to appreciate what all the art went through and what a miracle it is to still have it. #NFNov

rsteve388 4 pts 5y
LauraJ I feel like history stopped with the invention of the car in my education. 5y
38 likes2 comments
blurb
Bookwormjillk
post image

#TIL During WWII MOMA would take their paintings down, and store them in sandbags. Each morning they would put them back up again. #NFNov

coffees this sounds interesting! stacking 5y
Bookwormjillk @Crimson613 I‘m enjoying it so far 5y
rsteve388 4 pts 5y
42 likes3 stack adds3 comments
blurb
Hestapleton
post image

This won‘t be upsetting AT ALL. Nonfiction can be hard for me to make time for when I‘m reading after work (I find it requires a level of mental engagement I can‘t always give) so audiobook version at work it is! Ready to rage at my desk this week. #nonfictionnovember #booked2019 #soldiersstory

Cinfhen I‘ve seen the film and was really consumed 5y
51 likes1 comment
blurb
Librarybelle
post image

I gave this one 3.5 stars when I read it a few years ago - good, but it was dry in parts, and didn‘t fully capture my interest in others. Yet, I was completely unaware of this group of men who tracked down art that the Nazis, in true #theraidersmarch fashion, confiscated. It‘s good to highlight the group and to show the trials they went through, and learn of the exquisite pieces and landmarks lost forever. The film was just okay. #SoaringScores

Cinfhen I liked the film / fascinating topic 5y
TrishB I was just thinking about doing this one 👍🏻 thinking cap back on. 5y
Librarybelle @TrishB Great minds think alike! 5y
See All 6 Comments
Librarybelle @Cinfhen It is a fascinating topic! 5y
CrowCAH It is very fascinating that there was this group to recover the lost art. 5y
67 likes6 comments
blurb
TrishB
post image

Thank you Kay - such a lovely surprise, this book looks really interesting 😁 😘
Thanks Jenny for the lovely postcard which seems to have taken a few weeks to get here 👍🏻😘

Crazeedi Good story! 5y
TrishB @Crazeedi it looks it 👍🏻 5y
Caroline2 I haven‘t read the book but I remember seeing the film years ago. Really interesting story. 👍🏻 5y
See All 10 Comments
TrishB @Caroline2 not seen the film 👍🏻 5y
kaysworld1 I'm glad you like it. I'm looking at finding it in large print now 🤦 5y
TrishB @kaysworld1 a kindle is great for large fonts 👍🏻 5y
kaysworld1 @TrishB I'm going to have to learn to love kindle and audio books because the fonts in most of these books are terrible. I've got my glasses and my magnifying glass 🕵️‍♀️😆 5y
TrishB @kaysworld1 you can set very big font sizes on the kindle (prob on all e-readers) and you can get some real bargains! 5y
kaysworld1 @TrishB I'm going to pick my new hoover up from Argos tomorrow so I'll have a look then even if it's just for when I'm home, thanks Hun x 5y
TrishB @kaysworld1 👍🏻 5y
101 likes1 stack add10 comments
blurb
OrangeMooseReads
post image

Came across this article this morning it is very interesting and something I guess I never thought about. I always assumed they just burned all the books like this.
https://www.nytimes.com/2019/01/14/arts/nazi-loot-on-library-shelves.html?fbclid...

Crazeedi This hurts my heart 6y
Lcsmcat Thanks for sharing this powerful article! 6y
Soubhiville What a great article. Thanks for posting. 6y
See All 6 Comments
DivineDiana I had not heard of this. It is good to see that some of the books are finding their rightful families. 6y
OrangeMooseReads @DivineDiana I hadn‘t either. Like I wrote I just assumed they burned or destroyed books of Jewish origin. It is great that there are people working hard to find and return those stolen books to the rightful families. 6y
OrangeMooseReads @Crazeedi it is heartbreaking, but encouraging too that there are people working incredibly hard to return these stolen items to their rightful owns. 6y
49 likes1 stack add6 comments
blurb
Samary

The book above is what I‘m currently reading. This year I am challenging myself to read only books I already own!
The only exceptions are audiobooks from my library app (which my BF thinks is cheating but c‘mon. I‘ve already listened to all the audiobooks I owned but 1!!)
And buying for my book review club.
Gotta thin out that bookshelf!!!

blurb
CMCurtis77
post image

Ready to read a little non-fiction about my favorite era in history!!

KTOHARA Hi! I'm new! I did a search about the SS book because I want to read it. So I looked at this book and you said it is your fave topic or time. Anyway, I want to recommend a terrific book to you. 6y
KTOHARA It's on my iPad, I think, and I am on my ipod. Please message me because I may not find you so easily. I'd give it a top rating! I've also read a lot from WWII. I minored in History and LOVED it! 6y
CMCurtis77 I followed you so I should be on your list... I love to get any recommendations 🙂 6y
1 like1 stack add3 comments
blurb
lauraodom
post image

Day 12: Backlist
Just a few I own that are on the evergrowing TBR pile.
#Ampersand2018

review
calicodreamin
Pickpick

A very educational and I hope historically accurate book. You really get transported to the time and the atmosphere. It‘s a very technical and complex read. I would expect to pick it up and breeze through (unless your that kind of reader!) however, sometimes I like to take the time to fully understand a book. Especially when it‘s concept is steeped in such truth and grief. But as always, the glimmer of hope.

blurb
Aims42
post image

My next read with the birthday gift I bought myself, this gorgeous bookmark! New gift idea for birthdays; the recipient‘s favorite book with one of these bookmarks from @Babiesandbooks 💖💕💖💕💖

Bookartbookmarks ❤️❤️❤️ 7y
Aims42 @Babiesandbooks I‘ll be sure to leave a review on your Etsy store too, I can‘t until the 31st 😕 I love this bookmark, I‘ll definitely be ordering more! 7y
20 likes2 comments
blurb
Aims42
post image

Today was great day! The books are my a result of a very successful trip to Half Price Books with my parents (Love getting gift cards for Christmas 🤗) and my mom sewed the pillows for me from some unused cloth napkins ❤️

Mdargusch I love the pillows and the books! 7y
Aims42 @Mdargusch Thank you!!! I‘m excited to read the books and the pillows are a comfy addition to the couch 🤗 7y
22 likes2 comments
blurb
A.mart
post image

Been reading this book probably all year.... it‘s a great book and an even more amazing story that I‘m thrilled to read about. It‘s just so long; I‘m almost there though

review
Oblomov26
post image
Pickpick

Have not seen the movie, but the concept grabbed me and it was cheap. A good story in a dark time, about a group of men and women who were tasked with protecting and recovering the artistic and cultural heritage of Europe during 1944-45. Not a story of traditional heroes but of dedicated and passionate people who were willing to risk (and in some case lose) their life for a greater human good, a good so often perverted during times of war

Texreader Loved the book. The movie is not very good 7y
Laura317 I loved the book, too. I‘ve not seen the movie. 7y
46 likes2 comments
review
Kristy_K
post image
Pickpick

I liked this in depth look at how art shaped part of WWII. There were some interesting facts and details that I never knew.

#history #WWII

Laura317 I was amazed at all the art that was saved and lost. 7y
Kristy_K @Laura317 Me too! I always took for granted all of the art in museums, but their survival through wars has given me a new appreciation. 7y
54 likes2 comments
blurb
StephanieMarie
post image

Audiobooks are best with this #readingbuddy since if I stop petting her for too long she meows at me 😸 #catsoflitsy

CareBear 😻😻😻😻what a beautiful kitty! 7y
Zelma What a cutie! 😻 7y
14 likes2 comments
blurb
Sarah83
post image

Ich hab bei dem Thema nicht direkt an die Kriegshandlungen gedacht, sondern an das, was neben dem Krieg noch passiert. Den Film habe ich schon gesehen, das Buch steht noch aus..

I thought about this subject not directly about the war itself, but instead some things that also happened during war time. I saw the movie, but I have to read the book. ..

#War #maybookflowers @RealLifeReading

Readingrobin Inspired photo! I wasn't crazy about the movie but interesting. 7y
TNbookworm The book is excellent! 7y
RealBooks4ever That's a great photo! 💜😀 7y
41 likes3 comments
review
Kangaj1
Pickpick

#MOREORLESS Probably my fave nonfiction lately...

Laura317 I agree! I kept stopping to google things as I read it. I hope there are still Monuments people out there... 8y
20 likes1 stack add1 comment
review
Laura317
post image
Pickpick

I loved this book! If you like WW2, art, intrigue, and fact-heavy books, this is for you! It took me forever to read because i was always stopping to Google an art piece, town or person of interest. Fascinating look at what these brave souls endured to save and reclaim Europe's cultural masterpieces from the Nazis. I heartily recommend.

Cinfhen I was thinking of suggesting this for my nonfiction bookclub choice, what do u think? Bookclub worthy??? 8y
Laura317 @Cinfhen I think it could be. It took me a good 2 weeks to read - but I slowed down a lot because of all the information. Several good discussion topics in this book. You might Google to see if there is a discussion guide to help you decide. 😀 8y
Cinfhen Great idea, thanks! 8y
See All 7 Comments
Laura317 You're welcome! 8y
Laura317 I meant to add that this is #13 for my #LRC2017. 8y
Reviewsbylola Great picture, I love it! 8y
kspenmoll That picture...! Book sounds fascinating! 8y
45 likes2 stack adds7 comments
blurb
Laura317
post image

Laura317 Back to my slog through this book. It's good, but my goodness is it slow going for me. 🐌🐌🐌 8y
46 likes1 comment
blurb
Laura317
post image

Gosh what a slog! I've been reading this book for 6,438 days and an only 111 pages in. I suppose this is what I'd grab if aliens beamed me up. Good book, but slow going. #aliens 👽📚

drbethandherkindle Completely agree with you about it being a slog! 8y
45 likes1 stack add2 comments
blurb
Laura317
post image

blurb
Laura317
post image

I may have gone a bit sticker crazy, but this quote inside the first pages of the book gives me chill bumps of the best kind.

Libby1 ❤❤❤ 8y
38 likes1 comment
blurb
Laura317
post image

I decided to go ahead and start this now. I have as my bookmark the Israeli one a friend brought back to me. It seemed fitting. I love to read anything about adventure, art, and WWII. This book hits all three.

TrishB This looks interesting 😀 8y
46 likes2 stack adds1 comment
blurb
Laura317
post image

I'm watching Woman in Gold, a movie about a painting stolen by the Nazis. I remembered that I had this book. Going to dive into this soon - but not until I'm done with some other heavy reads.

CocoReads @Laura317 this movie came up at family dinner on Sunday because at some point there's a shot of Vienna and my niece saw a building with my maiden name "Scherer" on it. Turns out it's a restaurant in the Jewish district of Vienna. Which begs the question, was our family Jewish at some point? 8y
melrailey I loved Woman in Gold. It came out right after I had visited Austria and saw Klimpt's work in Vienna. 8y
Jgotham This book is great:) 8y
See All 8 Comments
Laura317 @CocoReads You should try to find out! @melrailey That is such a good movie! I'd love to see Klimt's work. 8y
Laura317 @JHgotham I might have to move it to the top of my tbr then. 8y
CocoReads I asked my grandpa. He says he doesnt know but then he also said if his mom and aunt Esther had stayed in Germany (they went over for the olympics in 34) they probably wouldn't have made it out alive. 8y
Laura317 @CocoReads Wow! 😱 8y
CocoReads It was interesting for sure. He says he's got a journal or something that Esther wrote that he wants my dad to see so I'm hoping to get a peek at it as well. 8y
44 likes8 comments
blurb
brennahawleycraig
post image

This is a recent #bookhaul. It was bonus time at work, so I bought hard copies of a bunch of books I read as library books and e-books. Loved all of these, except for Pirate Hunters, but it's the only one I haven't read yet! Happy to put these on my shelves. Cosmo doesn't like when I pay attention to anything that isn't him. #catsoflitsy

blurb
Songbird918
post image

Loved the movie, so now I'm listening to the audiobook.

blurb
Tsubame
post image

A "little" bit of non-fiction in between ? At school I've been taught for years about all the crimes and cruelties the Nazis committed, so much that at the end I was getting fed up with it, but that's better than playing down what happened back then. About the Monuments Men I had never heard before the movie though and I found this book among my fathers books in Berlin and was happy that he said I could have it.

Sarah83 Have you already seen the film? 8y
Lynnsoprano Loved the film, and the book is TBR. 8y
Tsubame @Sarah83 No, I didn't, which I'm glad about because the movies hardly ever are as good as the books. 8y
Sarah83 I saw the movie first because I didn't know that there is also a book. Now I don't start the book because I think I know all about it. 😐 8y
47 likes3 stack adds4 comments
review
thefictionalreader
Pickpick

I FINISHED IT 🙌 Okay, that sounded really negative. It took me about a month to read this, but not because it is a slow read or boring. I just didn't have time for it.

This was a fascinating read. I never really thought about the artwork during WWII. How the bombardments could have easily destroyed hundreds of years of European culture. How Jewish families lost every possession, especially the art. I think this is such an important read!! 👌

3 likes1 stack add
review
Lauren_reading
post image
Pickpick

This book was so good! I saw the movie and once again the book was so much better!! I loved learning more about the men and women that protected art during WWII.

Texreader It is a fantastic book!!! 8y
TNbookworm Great book, really enjoyed it! 8y
102 likes7 stack adds2 comments
review
Nitpickyabouttrains
post image
Pickpick

I loved this story about art and humanity. A good non fiction which has a story and a plot and characters.

PatriciaU One of the real Monuments Men, Leslie Poste, lived in western NY and operated an antiquarian book shop in Geneseo for years. When he passed away, he left the contents of his shop to my library. What an honor and amazing experience it was to sift through the years of his life through his books. 8y
7 likes1 comment
blurb
Kristy_K
post image

Yet another book that's been on my #tbr for too long. The story of the men who saved a hoard of art (and culture) from the Nazis.
#seasonsreadings2016 - #artrelatedbooks

24 likes2 stack adds
blurb
Lauren_reading
post image

I didn't enjoy the movie all that much, but I love the story - have any of you read this? On my TBR. #artrelatedbooks #seasonsreadings2016

Emiller On my TBR list too. Fascinating story 8y
PurpleyPumpkin Yes, I read this and it was really interesting! Great story. 👌🏼 8y
itsbrb Great story! Gave it to my dad for Christmas last year so he could enjoy it, too! 8y
See All 7 Comments
Pinkmeghan This is on my Kindle! I keep meaning to read it and somehow it never seems the right time! One day!!! 8y
lauralovesbooks1 I listened to the audio and thought it was fascinating. 8y
Lauren_reading @lauralovesbooks1 ooh audio - I'm going to do that! 8y
MamaGina I urge you to read this! In another life I was a tour guide at an art museum and Robert Edsel gave a lecture during training for an exhibit we had on reclaimed art. He is a leader in this important work and a talented writer as well.🤓(P.S. That movie was ridiculous👎🏼) 8y
79 likes5 stack adds7 comments
blurb
Texreader
post image

If you saw the highly touted movie with big names before reading the book then you'd probably think the book was going to be just as bad. I think this five star book was sadly #ruinedbythemovie. Not sure if that's the intent of today's #octphotochallenge but that's how I read it. This is really an excellently written book that I couldn't put down. Highly recommended!!

Larkken I found the movie pretty blah, too, though I had high hopes given the actors! At least it's been a while, so I can check out the book without the movie shadowing it by now... 8y
Erynecki You might want to check out the documentary film: Rape of Europa. 8y
MamaGina When I lived in TX I worked at a modern art museum as a tour guide. Robert Edsel gave an amazing talk in conjunction with a special exhibit we had on reclaimed art. I have several of his books and they are all excellent. I agree, the movie was awful. 8y
See All 15 Comments
ValerieAndBooks Yep, saw the movie, have the book in my TBR. I don't usually do it backwards like that but the movie was a compromise between my hubby (war movie) and me (art history)! 8y
LibrarianRyan Dang. You make me feel bad. I loved this movie. But I know I will never read the book. 8y
britt_brooke Good to know! Hubby and I watched the movie a few months backs and it was really disappointing. 8y
Texreader @LibrarianRyan I'm so sorry! I didn't intend to! This was one of those situations where the events in the book were so much more complex and intense and the movie just couldn't convey it. Maybe if I hadn't read the book first... 8y
Texreader @britt_brooke I do recommend you read the book anyway. I could barely out it down. 8y
Texreader @ValerieAndBooks I hope you'll still read the book. It is so good!! 8y
Texreader @MamaGina After I read the book I saw Edsel speak on TV about the topic. He was amazing!! I'm so jealous you got to hear him in person!! 8y
Texreader @Larkken Good point. I remember I was so disappointed but you are right. It's been enough time that it shouldn't affect how you feel about the book. I hope you like it. 8y
ValerieAndBooks @Texreader I definitely plan to read the book but don't know when (so many books so little time)! 8y
Erynecki @Texreader and Josh Peterson is the editor. Josh is the consulting editor on my documentary. 8y
Texreader @Erynecki That is awesome. I'll want to check it out!! 8y
72 likes2 stack adds15 comments
review
jessberk13
post image
Pickpick

I loved loved LOVED this book!!! On sale for Kindle today! #ebookdeal

That-Bookish-Hiker I've seen the movie but I didn't know it was a book! 8y
Carissa-Green-Reads For people who like this topic, I recommend "The Rape of Europa" by Lynn Nichols. Just as good with more breadth. 8y
61 likes7 stack adds2 comments
blurb
Texreader
post image

Part 2 of the #nonfictionlove. I also love really well written nonfiction historical accounts like these brilliant novels. I didn't realize I had an affinity for World War II until I put these together. I highly recommend all of these books.

PurpleyPumpkin The Monuments Men was great! I haven't read the others though. More for my tbr! 8y
Texreader @PurpleyPumpkin We Die Alone and Unbroken are impossible to put down. But beware there are some very difficult parts to read that these guys had to endure. 8y
PurpleyPumpkin Thanks for the tags, much appreciated! 8y
Texreader @PurpleyPumpkin I am happy to oblige! 8y
59 likes1 stack add5 comments
blurb
KennethTolesJr
post image

My wife bought me this book yesterday. I can't lie, I'm excited and can't wait to get into it! It's going to be an awesome read! And I'll be using my Bookish Impulses bookmark in this one (the first one I will have used it in).

3 likes2 stack adds