Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
Temeraire
Temeraire | Naomi Novik
An historical fantasy with bite. This deliciously addictive debut novel from Naomi Novik captures the Napoleonic period perfectly and skillfully layers history with imagination by adding a Dragon Air Force to the battle for England.
Amazon Indiebound Barnes and Noble WorldCat Goodreads LibraryThing
Pick icon
100%
review
Smarkies
post image
Pickpick

Starting this series again as I stopped 2 books in the last time. Enjoyed this as much as I did the last time.

CrowCAH Temeraire is such a fun dragon 🐉!!! 8mo
Readergrrl You are reminding me about this series!! I read the first and always intended to continue. Maybe this is a sign? 8mo
Smarkies @Readergrrl I remembered it being fun and I am hoping to make it through the full series this time around. 😁 8mo
Smarkies @CrowCAH he is! The most lovable character! 8mo
28 likes4 comments
review
Bluebird
post image
Pickpick

This was the first book I got for kindle, back in 2009. It was free & languished on my TBR list until the Napoleonic prompt from #bookedintime. FINALLY read this. The Napoleonic Wars with dragons. Great world building and I‘m totally invested in finding out what‘s next for Temeraire. I‘m on a roll reading books with great dragon characters. Next up is Yarros‘s Iron Flame.

I hope #serieslove2023 goes to 2024. I keep adding new series! 🤦‍♀️

Cuilin Napoleon with dragons, love it!! ✅🎉 11mo
21 likes1 stack add1 comment
review
hissingpotatoes
post image
Mehso-so

2.5/5⭐ I liked the bond between Laurence and Temeraire, and the humor at the expense of Laurence's propriety. However, I could not get into the main plot of the war. #roll100

blurb
jenniferw88
post image

@BarbaraBB Here's my ATY progress! Screenshots are of prompts I've got left to do, with ideas.

BarbaraBB Thank you so much for sharing this. You‘re definitely going to complete it! I love your choice for a western 😂 I chose something similar 1y
45 likes1 comment
review
Irejay907
Pickpick

I have a really short attention span until a book hooks me, truly i do, but when i say following this book (and the rest!) i will never hear 'I have an Idea' the same. Perhaps the most accurate short i can give without spoiling the entire series is that that phrase and draconic independence and pride are the motivations for everything not done by their exasperated and loving caretakers. Read/listen with no one nearby to hear random cackles.

review
Clare-Dragonfly
post image
Pickpick

Definitely a good sick day read! This is a fun fantasy adventure, the Napoleonic Wars with dragons and a big helping of comedy of manners. Actually, something I notice in a lot of Novik‘s books is one or more characters totally missing the social rules and the main character seemingly helpless to explain them—it annoyed me in Laurence more than in El. But I certainly loved Temeraire and I‘m looking forward to the rest of the series!

blurb
Kristelh
post image

#bookspin#12 His Majesty‘s Dragon
#bookspinbingo 3 #April2023

TheAromaofBooks Woohoo!! Did you enjoy this one? I struggled a little to get into it, but really loved the concept. 2y
Kristelh @TheAromaofBooks, I liked it and I listened to the audio read by Simon Vance. 2y
5 likes1 stack add2 comments
blurb
TLuvs
post image

I lived her writing in the Scholomance Trilogy and want to give this series a shot!

12 likes1 stack add
blurb
Kylivi

Naomi Novik does it again. I laughed, I cried, I jumped for joy. I've never been particularly interested in the Napoleonic wars, but now I might have to put in a little research, even knowing Temeraire might not be mentioned... ;)

review
TheAromaofBooks
post image
Pickpick

Do you ever read a book that you actually enjoy, but then want to spend time whining about? 😂 This is one of those books for me. It's definitely a pick and I will definitely be reading the next book, but at the same time it had several things that irritated me. The biggest one was the lack of relevant dragon-related information. The little “excerpt“ from a book in the back was not enough to help me sort through literally at least 20 kinds of ⬇️

TheAromaofBooks (cont'd) dragons. Plus, there are terms for all the different crew members that I just had to kind of guess what each person did - this book needed at least one appendix listing the breeds of dragons in a way that I could actually reference instead of the rambly few paragraphs I got of muddled information lol

But on the whole, I really enjoyed the concept and I love Temeraire (Laurence... eh, he's okay, but seemed to spend a lot of time getting ⬇
2y
TheAromaofBooks (cont'd) offended about stuff that wasn't very well explained. He was very sensitive to ~how~ people said things to him). I'll be continuing this series (one of these days) and am interested to see where Novik takes the world-building.

This book has been on my shelf since January 2021, when @avanders gifted it to me in a swap box - so thank you!! I have finally gotten around to reading it less than 2 years later, which is pretty good for me! 😂
2y
See All 10 Comments
TheSpineView I loved this book. I need to read the rest of the series. 2y
Andrew65 Great 👏👏👏 One i keep meaning to read. 2y
PuddleJumper I never read the rest of this series. I enjoyed this book but never enough to find the second one. Might give it another go 2y
BookwormAHN I love this series. I agree about the appendix and Laurence does relax some later on in the series. 2y
TheAromaofBooks @BookwormAHN - I could tell even in this book that that relaxation is part of his character arc. However, the development is rather uneven. I could be wrong, but I think this was Novik's first book, and it does have that vibe about it. I'm really looking forward to continuing the series, though. 2y
Catsandbooks Awesome! 🧡 2y
Avanders Fun!! (And 2 years is really fast for me too! 🤣) 2y
72 likes1 stack add10 comments
blurb
TheAromaofBooks
post image

Is the #WeeklyForecast looking unrealistically optimistic? Of course it is! I love having the windowsill stuffed! 😂 October books are IN and that tiny bit of extra space I had is now but a memory. The post-it notes that you can't really read are my Kindle books on the left, and then three sheets that are my #Scarathlon #BookSpinBingo books that I'll be mixing in with my other stuff, but since I do actually want to be able to kind of see out this⬇

TheAromaofBooks (cont'd) window, I decided not to physically pull them out just yet!

My current plan is to read as many of these in October as I can, then in November I am going to focus completely on progressing/finishing series. I seem to be in the middle of about ten of them, which drives me crazy. If anyone is interested in a low-key November series-reading challenge, let me know!

For now, off to finish the tagged book!!

@Cinfhen
2y
TheSpineView Good luck! 2y
78 likes2 comments
blurb
TheAromaofBooks
post image

I've done quite a poor job posting my goals for readathons lately, so I'm going to try to do better this month!! Hoping to hit 1000 pages for this readathon, but we'll see what happens!! Work continues to be crazy, my sister is moving, and Grandma is still in rehab... however, I'm going to get my oil changed on Monday, so that should be some nice uninterrupted reading time. *fingers crossed they're running behind* 😂

@Andrew65

Texreader A very good reason to get an oil change! 2y
TheAromaofBooks @Texreader - Gotta take that quiet reading time wherever you can find it!! 2y
54 likes2 comments
review
Tonton
post image
Pickpick

Binge-read all 9 books in this series-mashed up Richard Sharpe, Hornblower, with dragons! Not just action adventures but also points made/ questions raised and integrated on colonialism, white privilege, racism, misogyny, sentience.

review
Addison_Reads
post image
Pickpick

#SeriesRead2022 @TheSpineView #AuthorAMonth2022 @Soubhiville

Dragons were apparently just what I needed this weekend. 😁 I really loved this one. I'll admit, some sections got a little repetitive, but the connections between the dragons and their Captains kept me engaged.

There's also lots of action and battle scenes. I'd love to learn more about the history of the dragons, so I'm excited to continue the series and see what develops.

TheSpineView 💜🐉 2y
49 likes1 stack add1 comment
blurb
Branwen
post image

#AlphabetGame #LetterT
@Alwaysbeenaloverofbooks

The Temeraire series features DRAGONS! 🐉❤️ And look how cool of a picture it makes when you line up the spines! 😍

Suet624 That‘s so cool! 2y
51 likes1 comment
review
Caroline2
post image
Bailedbailed

Nope! I‘ve been looking forward to getting into bed with a book all day & I just can‘t read any more. Disappointing!!! I loved the beginning. Dragons, the Napoleonic war, beautiful writing! Then the doldrums hit! How can dragon school be boring? When you spend too much time banging on about the dragon bathing, eating and having his harness on and off again! Arghhh! I kept waiting for something to happen?! #authoramonth

TrishB ☹️ awww hate when that happens! 2y
squirrelbrain Boo, rubbish! 2y
Soubhiville It does get to some action later on… I read it earlier this month. 2y
Caroline2 @Soubhiville I‘m really impatient with books lately, prob bad timing! 2y
78 likes4 comments
review
Soubhiville
post image
Pickpick

I wasn‘t sure how I‘d feel about His Majesty‘s Dragon since I‘ve had mixed feelings about Novik‘s past books.

I really liked this though! My favorite part was the bonds between the dragons and their human Captains.

I‘m glad I found this used volume that has the first three books in it, and I‘ll continue with the series.

Good call voting in Naomi Novik #authoramonth readers! (The Scholomance series is still my fave though.)

Soubhiville Venkman approves of dragons. 🐱🖤🐉 2y
LauraJ Happy to see you‘re still here…and your gorgeous kitty too. 2y
Librariana Good morning, Venkman 🥰 Glad you enjoyed this one, Soubhi 😊 Hope the rest of the series continues to entertain! 2y
Soubhiville @LauraJ always! 2y
62 likes1 stack add4 comments
blurb
Soubhiville
post image

Early morning cuddle-reading with Igor 💜.
#AuthorAMonth I‘m really glad I picked this up and that Novik was voted in as an author this year! I am about halfway through and totally in love with Temeraire and Captain Will Laurence. If the whole series is like this I‘ll read it all. 🐉🐲🖤

vlwelser Yay! Welcome to the dark side. 😂 There are only 9 full books. It's manageable. Besides you'll need something to do while we wait for the third book in her other series. 2y
Soubhiville @vlwelser I‘ll just add the other 8 to the stack of Robin Hobb books I haven‘t gotten to yet 🤣. In fact I‘ve been building next month‘s #bookspin list around my “next in the series” books on my shelves. (I can almost do my entire list like this, lol.) 2y
Soubhiville @vlwelser I‘m glad I got the first 3 in one volume, it‘ll encourage me to get to them sooner… maybe, in theory 😆. 2y
vlwelser I apparently read the first one in July 2019 so I'm not exactly setting a brisk pace. But I might read 7 soon. Since it's Naomi Novik month. 2y
51 likes1 stack add4 comments
blurb
HeyT
post image

I can‘t believe it‘s already that time of the month again. @TheAromaofBooks has posted the #BookSpin reminder so here‘s my list. New to the list this month are the tagged and Ship of Magic. I‘m excited to see what the draw will be.

BookmarkTavern Sabriel! Woo! ❤️ 2y
TheAromaofBooks Woohoo!!! 2y
bookandbedandtea I love your tagged book! 🐲 2y
14 likes3 comments
review
BacklistReader
post image
Mehso-so

This was my #doublespin pick for January. I also used it for my Legacy prompt for Orilium: Gear Up.

I‘m at least intrigued enough to continue but it wasn‘t the best book I‘ve read recently.

#bookspindoublespin #orilium #oriliumgearup

@TheAromaofBooks

TheAromaofBooks I've had this series on my list for a while! 3y
BacklistReader This first installment wasn‘t bad. Not a lot happened but I‘m hoping book 2 has a bit more action. 3y
9 likes2 comments
review
BookwormAHN
post image
Pickpick

I loved this book. Captain Laurence captures a French ship during the Napoleonic Wars. On board is a dragon egg that is ready to hatch. And when it does the dragon, Temeraire bonds to him and thus enlists them into His Majesty's Aerial Corps.
#BookSpinBingo @TheAromaofBooks
#BBRC #YeahBaby #DragonFantasy @LibrarianRyan
#WickedWords #Luck @AsYouWish
#TheSupernaturalYear #Moose/Squirrel @AkashaVampie
#Pantone2022 #Poinciana @Clwojick

CaitlinR Such a fun series! 3y
Smarkies Love this book. Need to get to the rest of the series soon. 😁 3y
See All 6 Comments
TheAromaofBooks Yay!! I've been meaning to read this series forever - I even own the first book!! 3y
Roary47 Yay! 3y
62 likes6 comments
review
Nessavamusic
post image
Pickpick

This was a delightful fantasy adventure story. A naval officer becomes linked to a newborn dragon and their military adventures. I think this is YA? It is very sweet and would be a great first fantasy read if you want to try the genre. 4⭐️
#ReadHarder - Recommended by a friend
#PopSugar - Book by author I read in 2021
#19822022 - 2006

45 likes2 stack adds
blurb
Nessavamusic
post image

#WeekendReading

My current reads:
🎧His Majesty‘s Dragon 80%
📖Amari & the Night Brothers - just starting
📖The Worst Guy - 63%

Andrew65 Loved Amari and the Night Brothers. 3y
42 likes1 comment
blurb
BacklistReader
post image

I didn‘t post my list this month but here‘s what I‘ll be reading for January‘s #bookspindoublespin

Bookspin: Anne of the Island by L. M. Montgomery

Doublespin: His Majesty‘s Dragon by Naomi Novik

@TheAromaofBooks

TheAromaofBooks Woohoo!! I love Anne of the Island, and His Majesty's Dragon has been on my TBR for sooo long!! 3y
9 likes1 comment
blurb
TurnerofPages
post image

Really cool covers with an amazing flowing spine design!

blurb
TheSpineView
post image

#Movie2BookRecs @Klou
Prompt: Dragonheart

SpeculativeFemale I love the Temeraire books! 3y
TheSpineView @SpeculativeFemale I read the first one a few months ago. I plan on reading the rest next year! 3y
Klou Perfect! 3y
68 likes1 stack add3 comments
review
TheSpineView
post image
Pickpick

A book loving dragon! What's not to love about that, I ask you. Yet there is so much more to love in this story. Great prose and awesome characters, action and of course dragons. Enjoyed it all and look forward to seeing where the next book will take Laurence and Temeraire. 4⭐

SpeculativeFemale I love this series! 3y
74 likes2 stack adds2 comments
blurb
TheSpineView
post image

#sundayfunday in Monday because I forgot yesterday. 🤦‍♀️@ozma.of.oz

🐉Tagged. This book has been on my TBR list for a long time.
🐉 What if Christopher Columbus found South America.
🐉I prefer a positive outcome.

BookmarkTavern Oh that two is a fascinating idea! Thanks for sharing! 3y
TheSpineView @ozma.of.oz 😊 3y
43 likes2 comments
review
CaitlinR
post image
Pickpick

Now this was a hoot! Imagine the Napoleonic War … with dragons! Add in Novik‘s prodigious writing talent, and you‘ve got a great read.

In a naval battle, the HMS Reliant captures a dragon egg. When it hatches, the young creature chooses Captain Laurence as his caretaker and handler. Together, they join the Aerial Corps, learning combat skills, and fighting battles with other dragons protect Britain.

I‘m hooked and will now read the series.

wordslinger42 I haven't finished the series, but loved book one, too! 3y
CaitlinR @wordslinger42 I put a hold on the 2nd at the Lib. Can‘t wait 3y
26 likes2 comments
review
llwheeler
post image
Pickpick

March #doublespin done! (I'm slowly catching up...)

I loved this! Napoleonic war + dragons = right in my wheelhouse. And I knew that all along, so why did I leave it sitting on my shelves for years?! Ah well, happy I've gotten to it now.

#seriesread2021
@TheAromaofBooks @TheSpineView

Readergrrl I enjoyed this book so much! 3y
TheSpineView Great job! 👍📖📚 3y
TheAromaofBooks This one is on my shelf as well!! I really need to get to it!! 3y
llwheeler @TheAromaofBooks I hope you enjoy it when you get to it! 3y
37 likes4 comments
review
Twainy
post image
Pickpick

🎧 An alternate reality where there‘s an “Air Force” of talking dragons fighting during the Napoleonic war … YESSS!

I‘ve only read a few dragon books & found them to be boring. This one is sweet.

Captain Laurence accidentally bonds with a newly hatched dragon liberated from a captured French war ship. He can no longer be a captain, he‘s now responsible for a dragon. A dragon that talks within days of being born. A special dragon.

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 👇🏻

Twainy The story revolves around these two with plenty of British military red tape, political posturing & war but mostly it‘s a story of a young dragon & sea captain forging a deep meaningful relationship.

I will continue with these books as this one kept me interested. A quick, easy, fun read! I like the author‘s writing style. The narrator was ok & kept the focus in the book. An enjoyable read.
3y
TheSpineView I have been meaning to read this. Stacked! 3y
Twainy @TheSpineView I liked Temeaire‘s frank childlike opinions 😁 there‘s a glossary type chapter at the end that lists the types of dragons but the last chapter before that and the interaction between T & Laurence made me want to read book 2 right away but I have some more library books to get through. Easy likable read. Hope you enjoy it. 🤗 3y
TheSpineView @Twainy 👍🤩🌞📚 3y
26 likes1 stack add4 comments
review
theClaySpeaks
Temeraire | Naomi Novik
Pickpick

I was on a long trip & this series turned into my beach read. I first I thought it was YA but even tho there are dragons the issues & conflicts are not simple or unsophisticated. I had not read fantasy lit since high school, so there...

blurb
Chrissyreadit
post image
TheAromaofBooks Yay!!! 3y
TheAromaofBooks Oh by the way, I mailed your #LMPBC book back to you yesterday!! Just a couple of little extras in there to thank you for being awesome!! ❤ 3y
Chrissyreadit @TheAromaofBooks thank you- you are awesome 😘🙌❤️ 3y
45 likes3 comments
blurb
imyril
post image

#WyrdAndWonder (belated) day 21 | fantasy in translation

Embarrassingly, I don‘t seem to have any fantasy translated into English on my shelf (SF? Sure. But it‘s not SciFiMonth)

Erm, have two fantasy books translated into Dutch that I bought to brush up my rusty language skills, and I‘ll go update my wishlist…

review
Laughterhp
post image
Panpan

Sigh, I didn‘t like this one. Maybe because it‘s so different from her other stuff. I just found this one really boring and dry. I keep trying to read dragon books and I keep not liking them.

#MarvelousMarch
Definitely won‘t be continuing this series.

RamsFan1963 I enjoyed the first 3books, and I think it should have stopped there, because I think the series got weaker as it went along. 4y
Andrew65 Oh dear. 🙈 4y
51 likes2 comments
blurb
TheAromaofBooks
post image

Oh my gosh @Avanders everything is awesome!!! Thank you so much for these happy books & goodies - I'm especially excited about the tagged book & am in love with these coasters! Also LOSING IT because we both swapped coasters & candles! 😂 Thanks for hosting this super fun #HappilyEverAfter swap @Chrissyreadit !!

AmyG The coasters are beautiful. What a lovely swap. 4y
Yuki_Onna @TheAromaofBooks Ohhhhh... How lovely! ❤ 4y
Chrissyreadit it looks amazing! I love those coasters! 4y
Avanders Yay!!! I know it‘s so awesome we both thought coasters and candles!! 🥰🥰 I‘m glad you like everything ♥️♥️♥️ 4y
74 likes1 stack add4 comments
blurb
jenniferw88
post image
TheAromaofBooks Woohoo!! I've been really wanting to read the series that goes with the book you tagged. 4y
56 likes1 comment
blurb
gilroyc
post image
2 likes1 stack add
blurb
Valhalla
post image

Loving this book, but I love dragons so it helps

3 likes1 stack add
blurb
BacklistReader
Temeraire | Naomi Novik
post image

I know next to nothing about this stack.

Any suggestions on where I should start?

#unreadandontheshelf

blurb
Deifio
post image

Day 8 #20days20series
Set during the Napoleonic wars, but with dragons!

blurb
bookandbedandtea
post image

The Napoleonic Wars WITH DRAGONS; it's also much more. A navy man well established in his career has to give it all up when he bonds w/ a newly hatched dragon & is forced into the British Aerial Corps. He must contend w/ many of society's rules being upended. (Some of the dragon riders are WOMEN! 😱 And that's not even the worst of it!) It's funny & thrilling & touching because most of all it's about a man & his dragon.
#20series20days @Andrew65

TheAromaofBooks I've been meaning to read these!!! 4y
Andrew65 This is also I series I keep meaning to read. @TheAromaofBooks 4y
Leftcoastzen Love the bottles! 4y
23 likes1 stack add3 comments
review
AllisonM89
post image
Pickpick

An enjoyable read. Was disappointed at the start because it just wasn't what i expected. Temeraire is a great character. Will eventually get around to the other books.

#jubilantjuly @Andrew65
Book 3 ✔️
#bookspinbingo @TheAromaofBooks
Square 17 ✔️

Andrew65 This is one I want to read. Well done 👏👏👏 4y
AllisonM89 @Andrew65 it is a good read, but for whatever reason, it just wasnt i what i expected at all 4y
TheAromaofBooks I've been meaning to read this one for a while!!! 4y
AllisonM89 @TheAromaofBooks it's good, but feels very different from Novik's other books 4y
13 likes4 comments
review
JoyBlue
post image
Mehso-so

The short of it: talking dragons—yay!

The long(er) of it: There was a lot of scene building, relationship forming, character building, etc. I suppose this is reasonable for the first in a series. I don't know if it was enticing enough for me to continue reading the series. There is some appealing humor.

annahenke I concur wholeheartedly 4y
47 likes2 comments
review
TracyReadsBooks
post image
Pickpick

There‘s a lot to like in Novik‘s debut (way back in the day). The worldbuilding—Napoleonic Wars WITH dragons—is fantastic, the dragons themselves are equally wonderful, & the writing is really very good, particularly in a debut. It is also true, however that really very little happens. This book, the first in a series, takes its time introducing the world, & the characters before launching into the first real action. A good start. I‘ll read more.

27 likes1 stack add
blurb
TracyReadsBooks
post image

If 2020 was going according to plan—😂😂😬😂😂—my son & I would be in transit (at this very moment) to Israel to spend the summer excavating a Roman period village. Of course, nothing is going to plan right now...In the spirit of reading only what I already have or can carry with me as I do when I excavate, I‘m going to focus on working my way through my TBR stack—starting with the tagged book. No new books except for preorders & comics. (Ha!)

GatheringBooks This looks like one of her earlier novels. Any good? 4y
TracyReadsBooks @GatheringBooks It is one of her earlier books—originally published in 2006. I‘ve just started it but so far so good—it‘s a retelling of the Napoleonic Wars...with dragons. Novik is a great writer so I‘m hoping for a great story. 4y
bookandbedandtea I really enjoyed this book and the way the dragons were depicted. 🐉 4y
See All 6 Comments
ravenlee I have this on my shelf but haven‘t gotten to it yet. Interested in your review! 4y
Godpants WEIRD! I just picked up this series from my buildings discard pile last week, and hadn‘t heard of it! 4y
Tracyantoon Excavating a Roman period village sounds like an amazing adventure. Especially with your son. Wow!! So cool. Hope you still get to go when it‘s safer. 4y
19 likes6 comments
review
alisonrose
Pickpick

Now I want my own sweet clever dragon friend! The friendship b/t Laurence & Temeraire is one of the loveliest I‘ve ever read. Really liked how they came to rely on & care deeply for each other. Temeraire was done quite well too. Glad he spoke like a regular person rather than baby talk or Scooby-Do “rut roh” talk. And he has a personality! Or a dragonality! Battle scenes were less interesting but I‘m super eager to continue the series! 4/5 ⭐️

quote
alisonrose

Temeraire has seemed in most respects mature straight out of the shell, and ever since hatching he had been drinking up knowledge of the world with such enthusiasm that the gaps in his understanding were vanishing with astonishing speed. Laurence no longer thought of him as a creature for whom he was responsible, but rather as an intimate friend, already the dearest in his life, and one to be depended upon without question.

💗💗💗💗💗

AllisonM89 Ok, do i need to make halt all other reading plans and jump into this now?? It's sitting on my shelf and i haven't gotten to it yet.. 4y
alisonrose @AllisonM89 I‘m really loving it! 4y
20 likes2 comments
quote
alisonrose

Carver, very pale, stepped towards the creature, holding out his hand, which trembled visibly. “Good dragon,” he said; the words sounded rather like a question. “Nice dragon.”

[Picturing this cracked me up 🤣🤣🤣]

blurb
alisonrose
post image

Not sure how I‘ll take to this one. I LOVED Uprooted, Spinning Silver was just okay, and this apparently involves a lot of aerial battle scenes which is not something that typically appeals to me. But it also involves a dragon who loves to read?? Which sounds awesome. 🐉📚 #nowreading

AllisonM89 Can't wait to hear what you think. I also loved Uprooted, but was less impressed by Spinning Silver (in it's defense, i had just finished reading Arden's Winternight Trilogy and i think NOTHING was going to compare to that...) 4y
30 likes1 stack add1 comment